Arrowverse: Every Season Ranked Worst To Best

9. Arrow Season 5

Arrow Season 5
The CW

Arrow went back to basics for its fifth season and the difference was clear from the offset.

Gone were the over-the-top theatrics that came with mysticism, and, mercifully, gone was the toxic romance that turned the show into a parody of itself. Instead, we got a narrative so refined that the whole season practically revolved around it and there were no melodramatic subplots.

One of the reasons it worked so well was down to the portrayal of its villain and his relationship with Oliver Queen. Prometheus was a terrifying avenger born out one of the Arrow's earliest sins, making the show's overarching narrative all the more intense because of how personal it was.


8. Black Lightning Season 3

Black Lightning Season 3 Episode 10 Jefferson Anissa
The CW

Black Lightning doesn't shy away from hard-hitting material, but it took that to the next level with its poignant third season.

Jefferson's battle against racial injustice was no longer exclusive to the streets of Freeland as he found himself in the midst of a corrupt government takeover and had to fight his way out from underneath the oppression that threatened those he loved. Furthermore, the writing was more timely than ever because it dealt with kids being ripped away from their families and unlawfully imprisoned.

Black Lightning doesn't just tackle these issues, it pulls them into the light for its viewers to see - starting conversations that really aren't being had enough. The third season reiterated that, giving it its most thought-provoking and compelling story yet.


7. Supergirl Season 1

Supergirl Kara Alex
CBS

Kara's journey into the Arrowverse began on CBS when the Girl of Steel rose to prominence in National City on an earth that hadn't even heard of heroes like The Flash and Green Arrow. That earth had heard of Superman, though, as his presence loomed large over the first season and it was up to her to step out of his shadow.

That mission was quickly accomplished in a season that felt much bigger than anything else on network television. A triumph of a debut, Supergirl felt like it was to Kara what the classic Christopher Reeve Superman movie was for her cousin: A nostalgic, ambitiously impressive and game-changing spectacle.

There were issues, yes, but the truth is that Supergirl never felt more spectacular, triumphant and super than it was here.


6. DC's Legends Of Tomorrow Season 2

Legends of Tomorrow CW
The CW

Following the mixed response to the first season, Legends’ creative team took a risk by drastically redesigning the show.

Suddenly, it became more reliant on humour and wacky plots ensued. But it's important to clarify that it never overpowered the narrative. There was still a reality-altering device at the heart of the story - one that many of the heroes and villains wanted for themselves - and this allowed us to continue to take it seriously in spite of its tongue-in-cheek tone.

It was unbelievably enjoyable, but it also knew how to tackle dramatic arcs and the Legion of Doom proved to be far greater antagonists than Vandal Savage ever was.

Walking the line between hilarity and heart, this was Legends at its bloody finest.


5. Arrow Season 8

Arrow Season 8 Oliver Queen John Diggle Laurel Lance Black Canary
The CW

Arrow's final season brought an end to the show by paying tribute to its past and it found its way back to its former glory in the process.

The shortened Season 8 was full of nostalgia, yes, but it also contained excellent standalone Crisis-centric episodes that reminded us what this great show was truly capable of.

What really worked was its specific focus on the three most important characters on the show as each episode was headlined by at least one of Oliver, Laurel and Diggle. And it was worth it alone just to see Green Arrow and Black Canary team up on a consistent basis.

It may have taken Arrow most of its run to find itself again, but its final season was worth the wait - allowing it to bow out on a well-earned high.


4. Stargirl Season 1

Stargirl finale
DC Universe/The CW

There were no ties to the Arrowverse or anything outside of Blue Valley in Stargirl’s debut season. There was just Courtney Whitmore, her family and the Injustice Society that threatened to harm those she loved. And because of that, this young woman evolved from troubled teenager to triumphant hero.

There's a brilliance in Stargirl that's hard to sum up. It's like the way you felt when you watched The Flash for the first time. The goosebumps that form on your arms; that smile that makes itself at home on your face - you know you're watching something special.

With a strong narrative, impressive performances, out-of-this-world special effects and a light-hearted tone that makes every episode a joy to watch, Stargirl feels like it belongs on the big screen - and it is easily the best superhero show in years.


3. Arrow Season 1

Arrow Season 1
The CW

The season that didn't just start a popular comic book show but an entire multiverse, Arrow's beginnings are every bit as compelling as you might remember. In fact, they're even better upon reflection because they end up setting a standard so high that the show only managed to match it twice.

But what is it that makes Arrow's debut offering so compelling? Is it the fact that it attempts to reinvigorate the superhero genre with a more grounded approach? Is the excellent use of all the major characters and the payoff it ultimately leads to? Is it the chemistry between leads Stephen Amell and Katie Cassidy? Is it the brilliant Dark Archer? The truth is that it's all of that and more.

A gripping saga of family, betrayal and redemption, Arrow hit the target right out of the gate and the Arrowverse could do with more grounded tales like this.


2. Arrow Season 2

Arrow Season 2
CW

Deciding against a random Green Arrow villain to take Dark Archer's place, the Arrow writers opted to tie the season's main narrative to the flashbacks, meaning that a large portion of the story’s foundation had already been laid. And this allowed for a much deeper story, as Oliver's thought-to-be-dead friend-turned-enemy Slade Wilson set his sights on destroying him.

It's hard to describe the quality of the second season because words couldn't do it justice. Every character had a purpose, every storyline a meaning as two years of storytelling came to a head in one of greatest second seasons in the history of television. This is the kind of vendetta-driven drama every dark superhero series should aspire to create.

Arrow was never better than it was here.


1. The Flash Season 1

The Flash Season 1
The CW

The Flash's debut season proved that it could follow in Arrow's footsteps, but it wasn't long before it started to outshine it.

Barry Allen's arrival enhanced things, imbuing viewers with a sense of hope that The Flash would use as a foundation moving forward. And the lighter tone, sense of family and super-powered showdowns were callbacks to the superhero TV golden age.

There's a reason many still consider The Flash's debut season to be the Arrowverse's greatest. Yes, there was an inherent newness about it that made each episode a genuine delight, but the 'Man In The Yellow' arc is the best piece of storytelling the shared universe ever accomplished, providing the light-hearted fun with a gripping core narrative and an incredible villain.


Watch Next


Arrow: You'll Never Get 100% On This Oliver Queen Quiz

Arrow Crossover Oliver Laurel Wedding
The CW

1. Who Was The First Love Of Oliver Queen's Life?

Contributor
Contributor

Michael Patterson is an experienced writer with an affinity for all things film and TV. He may or may not have spent his childhood obsessing over WWE.