Arrowverse: Every Season Ranked Worst To Best
19. DC's Legends Of Tomorrow Season 5
Legends of Tomorrow bounced back with a steadier fifth season that saw the gang try taking down a bunch of resurrected figures from the past, leading to battles with Rasputin, Marie Antoinette and Genghis Khan.
What really worked was the show’s pivot in a more dramatic direction. It was still inherently silly (we wouldn't want Legends any other way), but this maturer tone really heightened the stakes.
That said, there were still plenty of wonderfully ridiculous episodes in there (the TV parody one is a standout), making the 16-episode season a fun look at the otherwise heavy post-Crisis Arrowverse.
18. Arrow Season 7
The first half of Arrow's seventh season was an exhilarating status quo-changer that saw Oliver incarcerated for his years of crime-fighting, all while Team Arrow had to contribute to a society that outlawed vigilantes. This approach proved very effective and the hard-hitting prison narrative was a major success - giving Oliver a unique arc unlike anything the show had done before.
The second half was less successful as it struggled to articulate who the main villain was and the flash-forward 'twist' was predictable. On top of that, Emiko Adachi's arc was handled in very disappointing fashion and the rushed finale was a complete disservice to the season.
'Confessions' and 'Lost Canary' are fantastic episodes, but overall the ball was definitely dropped in the back half.
17. Black Lightning Season 2
Black Lightning is arguably the most consistent superhero show on television because it remains committed to telling realistic and personal stories, mixing in some genuinely great comic book material while it's at it.
Its second season carried on the mission of its predecessor to do all of that and it benefited from the new format that split the season into acts driven by specific themes. This allowed it to delve deep into the issues it was exploring and it once again started conversations about racism while also exploring the importance of mental health care.
However, it couldn't always juggle its larger cast of characters and it didn't all come together as seamlessly as it did the first time. Hardly a sophomore slump, but a slip nonetheless.
16. The Flash Season 6
The Flash bounced back last season with a sixth offering that reminded us why we fell in love with it in the first place.
With a specific focus on Barry and Iris as well as a better juggling of the overall ensemble, the show's streamlined plots allowed for more effective storytelling. You know what else was streamlined? The season's narrative, as the decision to split it into two separate storylines - woven together by Crisis - freed it from its previous tendency to drag.
With two great villains in Bloodwork and Mirror Master, The Flash found its groove again after nearly three years, delivering a season that was nearly as strong as its earlier offerings.
15. Batwoman Season 1
Batwoman had a lot to prove because of that infamous trailer that killed all of its momentum, but it was determined to pull it off when it hit screens. Needless to say it succeeded.
It did have something of a flat opening but it improved with each episode before the standard increased immensely following Crisis On Infinite Earths. Its greatest strength, however, is undoubtedly its ensemble cast - all of whom play their roles to perfection - but it would be remiss of this writer not to mention Rachel Skarsten who steals the show as Alice in a performance that gifts the Arrowverse with one of its finest villains.
Batwoman's reputation will tell you that the show isn't worth watching, but that's a lie. In spite of teething issues, it came together incredibly well over the first season and even outshone some Arrowverse vets.
14. Supergirl Season 2
Supergirl's CW reinvention provided it with the opportunity to introduce Superman and it wasted little time doing so, bringing him in as early as the premiere. His arrival kicked things off on perhaps the highest note it had ever seen, but the show couldn't maintain that standard throughout the season.
Though the addition of Lena Luthor livened things up, that wasn't enough to make up for the absence of Cat Grant because the moment that Calista Flockhart departed, it struggled.
That said, the season was still solid. There were a number of issues but the introduction of Mon-El provided it with some great storylines - particularly for Kara, who found some overdue happiness with him. Furthermore, James Olsen came into his own as Guardian and Alex Danvers stole the show with her emotional journey towards self-acceptance.
13. Black Lightning Season 1
Black Lightning wasted little time making it clear to audiences that this wasn't a typical catch-the-bad-guy-on-a-weekly-basis kind of superhero series. It was a character-driven story that used the titular hero to address wider issues - and this realism proved to be its greatest strength.
Furthermore, the family dynamic was incredibly authentic, and the whole season was built on an outstanding performance from Cress Williams.
Black Lightning was created without the notion of a wider shared universe in mind, and it thrived because of it. Everything about it feels unique and even though it's part of the Arrowverse now, it will always have its own original identity because of this brilliant debut.
12. The Flash Season 2
The Flash's first season opened up the Arrowverse by welcoming metahumans and time travel, but the second was pivotal in expanding its horizons by introducing the multiverse.
Even though he wasn't directly tied to Barry, Zoom's arrival spawned another character-driven arc for the Scarlet Speedster - who struggled to find happiness in the wake of Thawne's destruction - and thanks to an understated performance from Grant Gustin, it became a solid foundation for the season. Additionally, the mystery surrounding Zoom's identity was very well-executed, allowing the monstrous speedster to rival his predecessor in terms of how terrifying a villain he was.
Season 2 certainly revisited a number of the same beats as the first and it didn't hit all of them as smoothly, but The Flash's sophomore outing was a great follow-up that once again illustrated the depth of Barry Allen's story.
11. Supergirl Season 4
Supergirl has proven it can tackle important issues and its fourth installment highlighted that as the rise of Agent Liberty allowed the writers to delve into an aliens vs. humans narrative that unapologetically asked hard-hitting questions about racism and bigotry.
It's also notable for adapting the Superman: Red Son story through its Red Daughter arc and for being the season that finally introduced Lex Luthor. And thanks to a show-stealing turn from Jon Cryer, Lex's arrival was worth the wait.
Its serious approach did take a little of the light-hearted sheen off it, but it was a price worth paying because the writers outdid themselves here, putting Supergirl back on top where she belonged.
10. DC's Legends Of Tomorrow Season 3
Having found its groove with its second offering, Season 3 of Legends saw it continue to hit new heights as the gang took on a time-demon.
It also brought forth a huge shift in the show's dynamic as Mallus was used to write Rip Hunter out while introducing the Time Bureau - and Director Ava Sharpe - and, perhaps most important of all, reintroduce us to Matt Ryan's fantastic John Constantine.
While it was just shy of its predecessor's success, Legends' third season was a worthy follow-up that once again managed to walk the line between comedy and drama. In the process, it even offered us the chance to see a winged demon battle a giant plush doll.