Batwoman Season 1 Review: 9 Ups & 5 Downs
The Arrowverse show you SHOULD be watching...
The CW's Arrowverse had built itself a dominant family of superhero shows as Arrow, The Flash, Supergirl and DC's Legends of Tomorrow entertained millions of fans around the world for a number of years. Several months ago, that family grew.
The addition of Batwoman changed things up in a shared universe that leans on familiarity far too often, officially tying it to DC Comics' most famous superhero in the process. But Batwoman is about more than its references to The Dark Knight, and it sure wasn't afraid to let audiences know that right from the offset.
A show that rubbed people up the wrong way because of its admittedly awful debut trailer, it came out of the gate fighting like it had something to prove because it did. And here we are in the aftermath of the season finale, the aptly titled 'O, Mouse!', and we can safely say that it did just that.
Batwoman uses the familiarity of the Arrowverse to find its footing, but as soon as it does, it throws the rule book out the window, ramping up the drama, action and its compelling central narrative to produce something refreshingly different. It's more than the haters give it credit for, it's more than fans could have asked for, and it's certainly more than its initial trailer ever suggested it would be.
With the show's debut run having come to an end, let's reflect on what was an unforgettable first season.
First, the negatives...
Downs...
5. It's A Little Flat At The Beginning
Back when Batwoman's pilot episode first hit screens, this writer referred to it as a 'triumph' because it was so much better than the trailer ever gave it credit for. And it's true, because the first few episodes started it off in a way that set it up for success.
What this writer didn't expect, however, was for the show to improve so much in such a short space of time that it would ultimately leave its debut in the dust.
Yes, Batwoman's beginnings pale in comparison to the adventures that follow because it tries the familiar Arrowverse tropes without ever matching the standard of Arrow, The Flash or Supergirl's pilot episodes. It's not that it's slow or anything... it's just that it rushes through the predictable beats without offering much of substance in between. Once it drops its attempts to recreate that predictable format, however, it truly comes to life.
4. Patchy CGI
Batwoman's reliance on rooftop battles results in a troubling amount of poor CGI rather early-on. It doesn't always stick out like a sore thumb but once you spot it, it's hard to unsee.
Other Arrowverse shows have experienced their fair share of bad CGI throughout the course of their runs so it's not exactly off-putting - and given that Batwoman is also a TV series, we're not expecting cinematic-level sights all the time. That said, this show in particular should have adopted a more grounded visual approach in the early-going - like Arrow. After all, we certainly didn't see any poor CGI in its first two seasons.
Thankfully, the message sinks in throughout the season as the show relies on those CGI backdrops a lot less as it goes on.
3. Some Characters Are Underdeveloped
Batwoman does contain some of the best character development in recent TV memory (and we will get to that shortly), but that doesn't prevent it from giving us a few turkeys along the way.
While most of the main characters are fine, the show does struggle on occasion when it comes to presenting some of its less-regular characters as actual people.
Catherine Hamilton-Kane is billed as a regular character and barely surfaces to do anything other than be a socialite, and when she does, her characterisation leaves a little something to be desired. And the same can be said for the show's recurring reinvention of Tommy Elliot who just feels like he's evil for the sake of being evil. And though his eventual transition into Hush looks magnificent, his arc could have been so much stronger.
2. It's Not Immune To Plot Conveniences
Over the years, the Arrowverse hasn't been afraid of relying on a convenience or two in order to weave its plot together. Be it a costume suddenly becoming weaker than it was before or a villain always finding ways to escape against a supposedly 'game' team of heroes, plot armour tends to make itself comfortable on these shows, and unfortunately, Batwoman isn't entirely immune to that.
It doesn't happen as often as it does on its predecessors (yet), and if you're not looking for it, you probably won't find it. That said, there are moments in which characters behave out of character for no reason other than the requirements of the plot, and their overall lack of reason can become quite bothersome.
Again, not constant... but it is there.
1. It Doesn't End The Way It Was Supposed To
Though Batwoman's impromptu finale does indeed serve the show well, it's still hard not to feel a little disappointment for the creative team as they weren't able to tell the full story they wanted to tell before the season was cut short.
Of course, as with The Flash and Supergirl, they're going to get the chance to finish the story at the beginning of the next season, but as this was Batwoman's first offering, it deserved the chance to cap off its strong debut with the finale that the writers originally envisioned it having.
Now, for the positives...
Ups...
9. It's SO Much Better Than Its Trailer
Let's start with the one thing that quickly became a roadblock in Batwoman's journey to success before it had even hit screens: That infamous trailer. The moment it found its way onto the internet, the Batwoman character's triumphant debut in the Elseworlds crossover seemed but a distant memory; replaced by a montage of cringey music, unsatisfying effects and dialogue attempting to be so clever that it didn't even make sense.
Well, just as this writer assured you before, the show is so much better than that trailer as it maintains all of the elements that made Batwoman's Elseworlds appearance epic and infuses it with the most compelling narrative that the Arrowverse has seen in some time. It's epic, it's action-packed and its theatrical in its approach - everything that the trailer wasn't.
We'll not get caught up on that as it's best to leave the trailer in the rear-view mirror, but seriously don't let your opinion on the show be tainted by one serious promotion misstep. If you're still interested in starting it, you absolutely should.
8. The Tone
Each show within the Arrowverse has their own distinct tone. While Arrow was the dark parent that started it all, it spawned the delightfully cheery Supergirl and The Flash and also made room for the campy over-the-top goofiness of Legends of Tomorrow. As fun as all of those spin-offs are, Batwoman couldn't operate in the light... she needed to be more like the originator; she needed darkness.
The show may have a few issues to work out early on, but figuring out its identity is not one of them. It's pretty clear from the offset what the show wants to be, portraying Gotham City for the corrupt hellhole that it is, allowing it to tackle the harder-hitting - and more grounded - stories that we would have only seen unfold on Arrow.
Batwoman is darker than most of its predecessors and thrives because of it, and that is what ultimately allows this Dark Knight to rise.
7. A Gripping Central Narrative
If there's one thing we've learned from previous Arrowverse seasons - or just TV and film in general - it's that the best stories always center on family. The conflict is just that much richer because there are more emotional stakes for the characters involved, and this approach has carried the freshman seasons of Arrow, The Flash and Supergirl to greatness. It does the very same for Batwoman.
The narrative focus on the Kane family may have felt obvious given its titular hero, but it was the right choice because we don't know this character very well at the beginning of the series. And as the mysterious disappearance of Kate's twin sister Beth begins to unravel its way to the truth, it provides Batwoman with a story that is every bit as poignant as it is thrilling.
Kate and Alice are both examples of the monsters that Gotham City can turn its citizens into; it just so happens that one of the dark demons represents light while the other is surrounded by more than enough darkness for the both of them. And in order to truly understand both why and how, we need to see it unfold... and that's exactly what we get.
The notion of fighting for family can make for a great story, while fighting against family can make for great conflict. Batwoman has both... in bucket loads.
6. The Action Scenes

With Arrow's run having officially come to an end, the Arrowverse looks more 'super' than ever, so it's only fitting that there's a show set to carry on its grounded, gritty approach (at least until spin-off Green Arrow and The Canaries hopefully comes along). And, for the moment at least, Batwoman is definitely that show.
Part of what made Arrow both of those aforementioned things was its many action scenes which evolved over its eight-year run as Oliver Queen and his team got physical with some of Star City's worst, and it's safe to say that the latest entry in this shared universe has carried on that legacy.
With expertly-choreographed routines and some innovative camerawork - not-to-mention a number of impressive one-shots - Batwoman's fight scenes make for thoroughly entertaining moments whenever they pop up in the opening or closing moments of an episode, either giving us an idea of what we're in for or finishing out the adventure in style.
The Bat-Family are all about the fisticuffs and Kate can clearly throw punches with the best of them.
5. The Supporting Cast
While Batwoman is very much Kate Kane's story - or at the very least, the story of her family - it's like every show in that its success is very much the sum of its parts. Yes, Batwoman is the hero that rises up to stop the brewing new evil, but she can't do it alone, so it's a good thing that she's surrounded by a number of great characters who ultimately help her get there.
The show's supporting cast is unquestionably one of its strongest attributes as they bring out the best in Ruby Rose's Caped Crusader while offering up their own engaging narratives at the same time.
Dougray Scott functions well as the perpetually angry Jacob Kane and Meagan Tandy's portrayal of forbidden love interest Sophie Moore adds layers to Kate's characterisation while her own struggles with her sexuality gifts Batwoman with one of its multiple authentic character journeys. Furthermore, Christina Wolfe's crafty Julia Pennyworth provides so much more than a fun link to Batman's beloved butler as her history with Kate enhances the show midway through.
The real supporting stars, however, are Camrus Johnson and Nicole Kang, as both Luke Fox and Mary Hamilton infuse Batwoman with levity at times when it really needs some while also gifting the season with some of its most emotional moments.
As for the other major player not mentioned here, well, we'll get to her later...
4. The Post-Crisis Surge
Remember how we said Batwoman had a flat-but-fairly-decent opening? Well, barring one or two exceptions it does improve with each passing episode; adding layers upon layers to its central arcs. However, following the Crisis On Infinite Earths crossover, it experiences an incredible spike in quality as it surges ahead of anything it produced in its first half to deliver a tale that is genuinely gripping.
You would think that the Kane family drama used all of its trump cards too early on - and that is a genuine gripe with the first couple of episodes - but somehow, the writers find a way to build on that, using plot developments outside of the predictable ones, while also utilising some of the changes enforced by Crisis On Infinite Earths to complement the narrative.
Pre-Crisis Batwoman is flawed but it certainly has potential... Post-Crisis Batwoman not only lives up to that potential, it exceeds it, smashing expectations into pieces with an arc that is among the Arrowverse's finest.
3. A Great Villain
They say every great hero is only truly as great as the villain they defeat. In the past we've seen how a strong antagonist can indeed propel a superhero to greatness. The Arrow had the Dark Archer, The Flash had the Reverse-Flash and, of course, Batman always has his Joker. Whether it be in comic books or on television, overcoming a major threat is what ultimately shapes a legendary hero... and thankfully, Batwoman followed in those footsteps with Alice.
Described by comic book fans as Batwoman's answer to The Joker, Alice is the female Dark Knight's archnemesis in the comics, but there was always the fear that the unhinged woman of wonderland wouldn't translate all that well to television. Well, you can forget about those fears because our TV Alice is the show's strongest attribute.
The long-lost twin sister of Kate Kane, Alice's ties to the Batwoman-to-be make the story a personal one from the get-go, but as we've already discussed the strength of the overarching narrative, let's instead take a moment to look at the woman herself.
A relentless soul so tortured by the trauma of her childhood experiences that she was driven to the point of insanity, Alice is a chilling monstrosity that makes even the most trivial of elements highly unpredictable. And she is brought to life so effortlessly by the magnificent Rachel Skarsten that it's hard to do anything but watch her in awe.
Without a doubt, one of the best villains to ever grace the superhero medium, Batwoman is worth the watch for Alice alone. She's that damn good at being so damn bad.
2. Ruby Rose Is A Strong Lead
Yes, I said it... and yes I stand by it.
When Ruby Rose was initially cast as the iconic DC Comics character in the Elseworlds crossover, it caused division among fans who didn't think she was right for the part. While she certainly looked the part as Batwoman, it still begged the question as to whether or not she could bring the grit of Kate Kane to life. The answer to that question is: Yes.
As with any actor, she takes some time to settle into the role, finding out what works and what doesn't in the beginning, but by the time you're a few episodes in, Rose has no problem proving to you that she is, beyond a shadow of a doubt, Kate Kane.
The broodiness of the character is something she captures instantly and that lends itself nicely to her heroic alter-ego, allowing her to portray Batwoman as the larger-than-life vigilante that she is.
Some didn't want to give Rose a chance, but so far those of us who did have been very, very impressed. Yes, she is Batwoman.
1. A Strong Debut
With Batwoman's season finale in the books, the show's maiden voyage has officially come to an end. No, it never got the chance to end the way that we'd all hoped, but its post-Crisis surge resulted in a ton of episodes that were so edge-of-seat that any of them would have served as fitting season-closers.
With the first season officially in the rear-view mirror it gives us a chance to look back and appreciate just how far it has come in such a short space of time... which is pretty much one of the points of this review.
A strong first season is what ultimately positions a show as a force-to-be-reckoned with. Arrow's debut offering was one of the series' best, while The Flash's is still the Arrowverse's overall best outing. Batwoman followed in their footsteps, overcoming a number of teething issues to present itself as a worthy addition to a star-studded shared universe.
The truth that nobody wants to admit is that, when it was on the money, Batwoman's first season is an example of the very best that the Arrowverse has to offer. And that, more than anything, makes it a worthy TV debut for this legendary comic book heroine.
-
What did you make of Batwoman's debut season? Tell us in the comment section below.