Brooklyn Nine-Nine: Every Halloween Heist RANKED!

Grab your 'stumes and get ready for the spoOoOokiest list of the year!

Brooklyn Nine-Nine Halloween Jake Peralta Captain Holt
NBC

As October rolls in and the ghosts and ghouls of the world make their preparations for the 31st, it's the perfect time to take a look back at the 99th Precinct's spooktacular Halloween Heists. An annual tradition, Brooklyn Nine-Nine dedicates an episode to a Halloween-themed heist game every single season. They started off as Jake's personal ploy to get back at Captain Holt, but soon expanded to involve the entire squad.

The goal is simple: to sneak into a secure location within the precinct and steal an important object of sentimental and/or symbolic value. Whoever pulls it off is crowned the winner, and gets to laud it over the rest of the squad. Some, like Jake, are fiendishly competitive and spend all year planning out their path to victory. Others, like Terry, are reluctant to even participate ("heists are dumb!").

These heists are consistently praised as some of the best and most inventive of the show, and every fan looks forward to them for good reason. They're filled with hilarious jokes, memorable moments, and fiendishly complex plots filled with classic double-crosses, betrayals, and twists. But which heist offered the greatest thrills, spills, and scares? Who is the ultimate detective/genius? Read on to find out! You have until midnight...

7. Valloweaster (Season 7 Episode 11)

Brooklyn Nine-Nine Valloweaster
NBC

Season 7's heist episode is a valiant effort that sadly can't hope to live up to previous offerings, thanks to an over-reliance on gimmicks and a number of scenes that give off an unfortunate sense of deja-vu.

The first gimmick is that this heist takes place across three holidays (Halloween, Valentine's Day, and Easter) which is a neat idea in theory but sadly doesn't add much. The same is true of the second gimmick, which involves the squad being paired off and handcuffed together, a premise with tons of potential for slapstick comedy which is unfortunately not capitalised on.

The objective of this year's heist is to steal three gems from the Infinitude Gobbler, a knockoff of Thanos' Infinity Gauntlet that Jake bought from Russian eBay. While funny, this feels a bit random and impersonal compared to previous heist trophies.

This general sense of being underwhelmed continues throughout the episode, and while the twists and turns are clever enough, they're fairly predictable as many feel similar to past heists. The main problem with this heist is that it feels uninspired, and lacks the emphasis on character that previous Halloween Heists weaved into their intricate plots so expertly. It's still a fun watch for fans, but it deserves no higher than last place.


6. Halloween IV (Season 4 Episode 5)

Brooklyn Nine-Nine Halloween IV
NBC

One of the less memorable Halloween outings, Halloween IV is still a solid heist with plenty of ghoulish gags and spooky surprises, but doesn't quite match up to the plethora of twists and turns and memorable moments in other entries.

A triple tie-breaker between Jake, Amy, and Holt, the trio must compete to steal a fancy plaque that reads "The Ultimate Detective/Genius". Jake appears to win early on, publicly heisting the plaque having trapped the rest of the squad behind locked doors. But when his partner-in-crime Gina knocks her front teeth out when trying to rollerskate away from an angry Holt, the heist is reset.

As it turns out though, this was all part of Gina's plan to claim victory for herself, winning her appreciation from the squad and the modified title of Ultimate Human/Genius. It's a satisfying resolution, though somewhat predictable after the similar twist with Amy winning the heist in order to earn respect in the previous year's heist, making the episode feel slightly like a rehash.

If we were judging these episodes based purely on the quality of the Halloween decorations in the precinct, however, this one might just win. It's the perfect balance of spooky seasonal theming and cosy autumn aesthetic.


5. Cinco De Mayo (Season 6 Episode 16)

Brooklyn Nine-Nine Cinco de Mayo
NBC

You'd be forgiven for going into this episode thinking it would be a bit of a disappointment. It comes in the midst of Season 6, the most uneven season yet, and it moves the proceedings from the iconic Halloween setting to Cinco de Mayo, making it seem initially like more of an homage than a true heist. Surprisingly, however, this is an excellent episode with an intricately twisting plot, a bevy of laugh-out-loud moments, and some great character development.

Every character gets their time in the spotlight, and even Kevin gets involved. One particularly brilliant scene involves about a dozen double-crosses all playing out at once as every betrayal committed thus far is revealed. It's this sort of frenetic, fast-paced comedy that makes the Halloween Heists fan favourites, and this heist delivers that in spades.

But the real crown jewel in this year's heist is Terry's deserving double victory, which he achieves not only by winning the heist but also by passing his lieutenant's exam, transforming his nickname from "Sarge" to "Lieut" and giving viewers a surprising and uplifting piece of character development to top off all the chaos of the heist.


4. Halloween II (Season 2 Episode 4)

Brooklyn Nine-Nine Halloween II
NBC

Having been shamefully defeated in the first heist, Captain Raymond Holt vows to take vengeance upon Detective Peralta, hatching a devilish scheme to outplay Jake at his own game and prove that he is the more deserving holder of the prestigious title of Amazing Detective/Genius. He tasks Jake with stealing his watch from right off his wrist, a tricky task which sets up a whole host of spooky shenanigans.

Jake swaggering around in his cheap magician's outfit flying a drone through the precinct as Scully sings Carmina Burana is a sight to behold, as is Boyle pushing Jake in a shopping trolley as they desperately chase a truck that's towed his car (which happens to also contain the Captain's stolen watch).

It's somewhat tragic to see Jake, brimming with overconfidence at the start of the heist, have his plans go completely sideways like this after months of planning. But it's oh-so-satisfying when it's finally revealed that Captain Holt was behind everything, keeping one step ahead of Peralta all along thanks to a full year of planning.

Turns out Holt is in possession of both the real watch and the fake one, having employed the pickpocket who we all thought was working for Jake in advance, and instructed Amy to tow away his car. Holt celebrating his victory as he explains to Jake every detail of how he manipulated him is a fantastic final scene that proves this heist is a trick and a treat all in one.


3. Halloween III (Season 3 Episode 5)

Brooklyn Nine-Nine Halloween Part 3
NBC

This year, the stakes are heightened (heist-ened?) for the third and supposedly final heist, as Jake and Holt both compete to steal the same item, each assembling a team to assist them in their nefarious schemes. Amy is excluded from the heist due to her divided loyalties between Holt and Jake, and Hitchcock and Scully are excluded because, well... they're Hitchcock and Scully.

There are some great fake-outs, double-crosses, and betrayals throughout the episode, taking advantage of the higher stakes and expanded teams. The viewer is kept guessing throughout as to who exactly is on which team, and what everyone's true motives are. Plus, there are also plenty of loving digs at the heist genre ("Commence Operation Oh Crap, Wrong Vent!").

That said, it's the ending that really cements this episode as a top-tier Halloween heist. As the episode nears its conclusion, the viewer is still genuinely unsure whether Peralta or Holt will be crowned the winner, as it's been neck-and-neck so far.

So, it's a genuine shock when neither of them win, and Amy Santiago pulls off a surprise victory, having consistently outplayed both of them and proved herself to be her own person independent of her relationship with Jake and her bond with Holt. She's a deserving Queen of the Nine-Nine.


2. Halloween (Season 1 Episode 6)

Brooklyn Nine-Nine Halloween Costumes
NBC

Despite the increasing complexity and heightened stakes the Halloween Heists gained year or year, it's hard to beat the simple brilliance of the OG heist. It's a Season One highlight that cemented our love of these characters (particularly Jake and Holt) and still holds up as one of the best episodes of the entire show.

When Jake boasts to the squad that he'd make an excellent criminal and none of them could ever catch him, Captain Holt is determined to prove otherwise. He agrees to a challenge in which Peralta must steal Holt's Medal of Valor from his office without being seen, and he only has until midnight to do it. What follows is a series of side-splitting hijinks as Jake desperately tries to infiltrate Holt's office ("Are you in my ceiling, Peralta?" "...no?").

It's an eminently quotable episode with some fantastic visual gags (Jake rounding up pigeons being a personal highlight) and it makes great use of the Halloween theme. The payoff at the end is super satisfying as Jake brags about how he pulled off his victory, with help from every other member of the squad.

So what's stopping this creepy caper from taking the top spot? The surprise factor. Despite the neat resolution, it was pretty easy to guess that Jake was going to win since he was really the only competitor, so this classic doesn't quite reach the same level of twists and turns that certain other heists do.


1. HalloVeen (Season 5 Episode 4)

Brooklyn Nine-Nine HalloVeen
NBC

Five heists in, you might think things are starting to get stale and predictable, but that couldn't be further from the truth. On the contrary, this episode gave all of us the sweetest shock ever with the most seismic surprise of them all: the entire heist was carefully constructed by Jake to act as his proposal to Amy, and it's just the cutest.

Uniquely touching and moving, it's a perfect contrast to the chaos that came before, and it ranks as one of the greatest moments in the entire show, paying off a five-year will-they-won't-they relationship. You could hear shippers squealing with excitement all around the globe. VINDICATION!

But that's not all that makes HalloVeen the ultimate heist. It's packed with some of the most outrageous jokes of them all, from the hilarious opening scene of Holt waiting overnight in Jake and Amy's bedroom, to the brilliant wordplay ("it's one 'bund to none, son!") and the adorable antics with Holt's absolute chonker of a dog Cheddar. The heist movie spoof with Rosa, Terry, and Charles infiltrating the precinct's server room is another highlight.

This heist has it all: amazing character development, non-stop quotable dialogue and guffaw-inducing gags, and a lovably ludicrous plot with surprising twists that keeps you guessing right up until the downright iconic heart-warming ending.


Watch Next


Brooklyn Nine-Nine Quiz: How Well Do You Know The 99th Precinct?

Captain Holt - Jake Robot
Fox

1. Who Was The Commanding Officer At The 99th Precinct Prior To Raymond Holt?

Contributor

Patch is a pop culture enthusiast and purveyor of puns. He writes about media in a vague attempt to justify the alarming amount of time he spends consuming it. Nobody's convinced... but nobody's told him that yet. He spends his spare time working on Portal 2: Desolation, an ambitious fan-made sequel to Valve's beloved puzzle games.