Doctor Who: 10 Best Moments Of Series 8 So Far

So far so good for Capaldi.

The reason Doctor Who has lasted so long is not only due to the ability to recast its leading actor without breaking the story, it is also because that when the Doctor regenerates the show does too. Under a new face it can completely change its tone and style. And under the bottle-top-breaking eyebrows of Peter Capaldi the show has had one whopper of a regeneration. With Doctor Who coming up to ten years since it was brought back, there has been a conscious effort to do something different. Namely, to give the show a moodier, broodier outlook. However, too much seriousness does not a good Doctor Who make and, thankfully, this series is also aware that there needs to be light (Robot of Sherwood) alongside the shade (Into the Dalek) and heart (The Caretaker) as well as scares (Listen). With this in mind, it could be said that Series 8 has already provided us with some of the most interesting Doctor Who in years - taking us inside a Dalek, to the end of the universe and even to where the Doctor began. So even though this run of episodes has only just reached its halfway point, you would be hard-pressed to narrow down the best moments of this series so far €“ but we€™re going to try.

10. The Restaurant Scene - Deep Breath

Series 8 arrived with a bang (after it had been spat out by a dinosaur) with its feature-length opening episode, Deep Breath. As well as providing familiar Victorian hijinks with Vastra, Jenny and Strax and an adventure fit for the silver screen, it also turned out to be a model example of the new style of the series, with longer, talkier scenes and a new emphasis on Clara's character. One moment demonstrates this better than any other, however, and that is the scene where the Doctor and Clara reunite in a restaurant. After arguing among themselves, they realise that they are surrounded by clockwork robots - before being taken to a secret underground space to be harvested for 'spare parts.' Sweeney Todd, eat your heart out. At roughly five minutes in length, this is a fairly long scene for just two people sitting and talking - especially in a show where the principle characters are generally always running. If handled badly it's a moment that could soon outstay its welcome but as it is the scene is very entertaining. At first showcasing Capaldi and Coleman's chemistry as the newer, ruder Doctor and his put-upon companion, it then delivers a classic Moffat moment - the 'the horror's been here all along' gambit. The Doctor may have called Clara an egotist but, if you ask us, both of them are too self-involved if they didn't realise they were dining with a load of ticking robots.

9. Brain Soup - Time Heist

That age-old argument - 'is Doctor Who too scary for kids?' - reawakened this year in light of two episodes on the trot being deemed to feature scenes of an excessively horrific nature. One of these was from the otherwise snappy crime caper of an episode Time Heist. When the Bank of Karabraxos' security guard, the monstrous Teller, detects guilt in a customer he precedes to punish the criminal - by feeding off the man's brainwaves, leaving him a vegetable with a caved-in cranium. For one thing, this is the sort of grisly-but-not-really-too grisly scene that kids lap up and so is perfect for Doctor Who but also it is a great display of the nasty powers of the best monster this year, the Teller. With his fabulous design, the Teller proves once again that aliens trump robots and good ol'-fashioned monster suits are superior to CG creations. Overall, this might not be the most touching, funniest or dramatic entry on this list but it is a standout scene from its episode, making it one of the most memorable moments of the run so far. And, no, don't question why the man's head is concave when that would mean his skull was liquefied rather than his brain. Don't even think it. Or the Teller will come and do the same to you...

8. 'You Are A Good Dalek' - Into The Dalek

Every Doctor has to face the Daleks (unless you are Paul McGann, in which case you are fobbed off with unseen squeaky-voiced ones) so it was no surprise when Peter Capaldi came eyebrow to eyestalk with his oldest enemy in only his second episode. But it was perhaps a surprise to find out that the two opponents were more alike than the Time Lord cared to admit. Connecting his mind to damaged Dalek 'Rusty', the Doctor sought to alter the creature's mindset to make it good. However, the overriding emotion it got from the Doctor was not love or compassion but hatred. A hatred it unleashed on its invading fellow Daleks, yes, but the revelation was still a soulful blow to the Doctor. This was helped no end when Rusty proclaimed to him that, while the Dalek itself was no longer one, the Doctor was 'a good Dalek.' It's a shocking scene and one which brings to a head the running theme in the episode of the Doctor's newly-found murky morality. However, more impressively, it also acts as a counterpoint to a line from a previous Dalek episode from nearly ten years ago, when another 'corrupted' pepperpot told the Ninth Doctor 'you would make a good Dalek.' Now, it seems the Doctor's conversion is complete.

7. Boyfriend Error - The Caretaker

But it's not all doom and gloom this year as the most recent episode, The Caretaker, showed. While going undercover (or, rather, wearing a different overcoat) as the janitor of Coal Hill School to stop a deadly robot, the Doctor got the chance to find out about Clara's new beau. Rather than solider-cum-maths teacher Danny Pink, he assumed it was the floppy-haired, bowtie-wearing Adrian. Wonder why that was. The proud fatherly glint in the Doctor's eye as he thinks Clara has picked a man like himself (as the old-fashioned notion goes, 'women marry men like their Doctors') is just as funny as his later indignation that he got it wrong - the look on his face when Clara says Adrian is 'not her type' is priceless. This moment shows us Peter Capaldi's comic timing is as spot-on as his dramatic acting (although we should never have doubted that after several years of The Thick of It) but also demonstrates the new relationship between the Doctor and Clara. Rather than romantic as most of the 21st century Doctor-companion teams have been, this is more of a teacher-student pairing. Although which is which is hard to decide.

6. Whatever Happened To The Half-Face Man? - Deep Breath

There has certainly been an effort to emphasise the thematic content of the series this year with episodes so far focussing on such big ideas as heroism, morality and fear. Naturally, then, the Twelfth Doctor's first episode after his regeneration centred around the notion of change, even down to pitting the Doctor against an enemy who mirrored himself; the Half-Face Man, a robot who had repaired himself with human body parts over and over again across centuries. However, there was one important different between them: one was lying about their basic programming. To let his friends go safe, the Doctor knew that the Half-Face Man needed to die. But the cyborg refused to kill himself just as the Doctor did to murder him. Nevertheless, the next time we see the Half-Face Man he is impaled on the spire of Big Ben, as a brooding Doctor stands in his spaceship above. So... who killed the Half-Face Man? It's a debate that fans have been arguing over for weeks now and seeing as we - probably, but you never know - won't get an answer they could be doing so for a long time yet. That fans are contemplating whether that pacifist children's hero, the Doctor, could have murdered someone in this way is testament to the volatile nature of Peter Capaldi's new Doctor. What do you think happened?

5. The Doctor Vs Robin Hood - Robot Of Sherwood

The rip-roaring romp Robot of Sherwood came as greatly needed comic relief after the heavier first two episodes. Swapping the previous instalment's sterile spaceship trappings for sunny forests and medieval castles, it had a lightness of touch embellished by the rapport between one of the show's funniest ever double acts: the Twelfth Doctor and Robin Hood. Whereas other Doctors may have found the rambunctious Robin a laugh, the new Doctor had no time for either his guffawing or his green tights and constantly sparred with him. Whether they were locked in an archery contest or sword/spoonfighting, the Doctor and Robin were always trying to get one up on the other. After all the disagreements (and a script full of cracking lines from Mark Gatiss) the two came to a begrudging respect and accepted each other as good men. Here's hoping, then, that the two heroes meet once more as their hilarious first meeting made us all merry men (and women).

4. 'Top Layer, If You Want To Say A Few Words...' - Into The Dalek

Before the series started, showrunner Steven Moffat described Capaldi's version of the character as the 'kick-up-the-a**e' Doctor. A rendition of the Time Lord who could shock and surprise us, after two, generally nice, 'boyfriend Doctors' in Messrs Tennant and Smith. What with the death of the Half-Face Man, it didn't take long for Moffat to be proved right. And an even better example came in the very next episode. When the Doctor, Clara and a team of soldiers venture inside a Dalek, they are cornered by the metal meanie's antibodies. Taking hold of the situation, the Doctor throws one of the soldiers, Ross, a capsule and tells him to swallow it. Ross does and is immediately killed by the anti-bodies, allowing the others to escape. The pill, the Doctor claims, was not to save the apparently already-doomed Ross but to track the signal to the place where the Dalek stores the protein it has 'hoovered' up. While this is still pretty callous, it gets worse when the group find the refuse disposal and the Doctor answers the question of whether Ross is here with 'yeah, top layer, if you want to say a few words.' It's a snappy line, sure, but a very cold thing for the Doctor to say. It's certainly a far cry from David Tennant's decree of 'I'm sorry' to every person he failed to save. This new Doctor here showed himself thoroughly unpredictable - something that has made the show all the more interesting to watch.

3. The Creature Under The Covers - Listen

As previously said, episodes this year have been criticised by some quarters for being too scary, for instance in the 'brain soup' scene from Time Heist. However, that moment pales to nothing compared to a scene from serial chiller Listen when... something sits under a bedsheet? Is that it? Well, trust us, it works... The Doctor's latest mission is to prove the existence of the perfect hider, creatures that could be all around us but we don't know it. This search leads him to an orphanage where little Rupert Pink (Clara's boyfriend, Danny, as a child) is frightened of a figure sitting on his bed, silent and unmoving. Calming the child, the Doctor gets them to turn away as the creature leaves. It may not sound much but this scene is a tour-de-force of Doctor Who terror. The simple premise of the scene could come from any horror film but it is staged exceptionally well - with the lighting and direction deserving special notice - keeping us enraptured until the whole thing comes to a head when the figure removes the bedsheet in the background, revealing a fuzzy image. The episode may later suggest that there is no monster and that it was only a child but we task you to find a child creepy enough to do all this. Unless that child is you, of course, in which case, er, hello there. Please stay away.

2. The (Eleventh) Doctor Calls - Deep Breath

For the first time since she joined the series, Deep Breath is really Clara's episode as we see her adjust to her best friend changing his face and becoming a completely new man. Due to the new Doctor being so different from Matt Smith's silly professor, by the end of the episode she is still not sure of Doctor number Twelve (or thirteen. Or fourteen...). That is until the Eleventh Doctor himself gives her a ring. On one hand, this is a pure fan-pleasing moment and a hangover from the 50th anniversary year which featured surprise Doctors popping up left, right and centre, but on the other it is a valid 'handing-over-of-the-baton' moment between the show's leading men, done in a very original fashion. This scene features so highly on our list as it is a hugely poignant and important moment that tells Clara - and any wavering viewers - that this new, perhaps scarier, man is the same person underneath it all. 'Just see me,' the (Twelfth) Doctor tells Clara, and thanks to this phone call, we do and can properly start our adventures with this new man, the Doctor. The one and only.

1. 'He'll Never Make A Time Lord...' - Listen

The criteria for a 'classic' episode of Doctor Who is a hard one to define with some episodes growing in audience's estimations over time while others become instant favourites. For lots of viewers, the recent episode Listen features in the latter category. It impressed for many reasons, including its brave deviations from the show's norms, its look at the Doctor's psyche and also for a never-before-seen glimpse at the Doctor's childhood. Using the TARDIS' unstable telepathic circuits, Clara attempts to fly the TARDIS to astronaut Orson Pink's own time. However, she misses by quite some way and ends up in an old barn, where a small boy lies crying. This boy, she discovers, is the Doctor and the barn is the one to which he will one day return to end the Time War. To soothe the tiny Time Lord to sleep, Clara tells him to embrace his fears and to be kind and gives him an idol to look up to: a soldier who doesn't carry a gun. A jaw-dropping moment, it offers up something we were certainly did not expect to see but, like the best twists, serves the story first and foremost; it turns out that this episode hasn't been about a monster hunt rather the excising of the demons of a small boy who is still scared of the dark. It's the sort of brazen tinkering with Doctor Who lore that Steven Moffat has made one of his calling cards, considering The Day of the Doctor last year, although the scene does also show sensible restraint, satisfying our curiosities but leaving us wanting more (e.g. we never see the young Doctor's face). In all, it's an exciting, tantalising moment that personifies the brave new direction that this series is taking. A regained emphasis on character drama? Check. The most important companion the Doctor's ever had? Check. The best Doctor? Well, we'll have to wait and see but on the evidence of these first six episodes anything is possible. Were our own telepathic circuits working perfectly when we compiled this list? Or are these choices as dubious as the fate of the Half-Face Man? Leave your thoughts below!

Contributor
Contributor

Spewing words on the internet daily. You can also read my stuff at StarburstMagazine.Com, WeGotThisCovered and TheQuiz.Com.