Doctor Who: 10 Reasons Why We Need A War Doctor Spin-Off

We need more John Hurt! Or, pending budget restrictions, a guy who looks like him!

From K-9 to Torchwood to The Sarah Jane Adventures, Doctor Who has had its fair share of spin-offs over the years. Each spin-off has brought a new dimension to the Doctor Who franchise or has given us a better understanding of some of the Doctor's companions and allies. The 50th anniversary special, The Day of The Doctor, opened up a previously unexplored section of the Doctor's timeline - one that could possibly hold its own as a new mini-series or spin-off. This spin-off would be focused on the events of the Time War and the years where the 'War Doctor' piloted the Tardis. The Time War has been pegged as being the darkest time in the Doctor's life - a time filled with ruthless killing, apocalyptic warfare and some of the hardest decisions the Doctor has ever made. But other than this we know very little about what happened during those turbulent years. A War Doctor Spin-Off would answer many questions, fill a lot of gaps and create a darker branch of Doctor Who (a bit like Torchwood with more epic imagery and less sex). Here are the top reasons why the Doctor Who franchise could benefit from a War Doctor spin-off series.

10. The Doctor As A Warrior

John Hurt's incarnation of the Doctor did not identify himself as being worthy of using his own self-given pseudonym. The name 'Doctor' was supposed to symbolise hope and make people feel safe, but the War Doctor was born because the universe needed a warrior capable of turning the tides of war. As Paul McGann's Doctor said: "I don't suppose there's any need for a Doctor anymore. Make me a warrior now." John Hurt's character was truly a secret regeneration of the Doctor's, but he was not THE Doctor as we knew him, he was a weapon of war. The Doctor has always had his brash moments, and some brief moments of cruelty, but we have not seen the Doctor in such a dark light for a whole regeneration. A series showcasing a 'gloves-off' Doctor in a seemingly unending battle with the Daleks will show us exactly what the Doctor is really capable of. It would give context to the remorse and restrained anger shown by the older regenerations of the Doctor.. Doctor Who's increased funding over the years has proven that the show is capable of giving us more than just cheesy alien costumes and lacklustre imagery; the show is moving more towards showing off its action epic potential. A series dedicated to the Time War and the War Doctor would be the perfect setting for developing that potential further.

9. The Doctor's Inner Turmoil

Paul McGann's Doctor was ready to go against his own morals to try and put an end to the Time War, and the incarnations that came after the War Doctor couldn't help but regret that decision. The War Doctor himself was the man that had to make the best of the worst possible situation - he had to kill in order to protect in the vain hope that peace would come out of the destruction. Although the War Doctor knew that he had to fight in the Time War, he still held on to his strong beliefs in peace, justice and honour, which would have made fighting on the front lines that much harder. A spin-off series showing the battles fought by the War Doctor would show more than simple, merciless violence, it would also reveal the struggle of the War Doctor learning to deal with the consequences of his actions. When we finally met the War Doctor in The Day of The Doctor he was already at wits end about the part he played in the slaughter and destruction, so there would be great scope for the War Doctor to have some dramatic and emotional scenes in this kind of spin-off. What exactly made him get into that exhausted, fed-up state of mind?

8. Resurrection Of Rassilon

Rassilon has had mixed reviews in the annals of Time Lord history. Sometimes he is regarded as the heroic founder of Time Lord civilisation, whilst in other reports he is said to be a tyrannical megalomaniac. When he appeared in The End of Time he certainly seemed to be leaning more towards the latter of those two, but we saw very little of Rassilon's personality or his approach to warfare. All we really know is that he was desperate to ensure Time Lord survival. It's not entirely clear what Rassilon's role was in the Time War, or why/how he was brought back to life, but this could be explored in a War Doctor spin-off. Friend or foe, Rassilon would no doubt have a big part to play.

7. Time Lord Science At War

Time travel, black hole manipulation, parallel universe jumping, de-mat guns; these are just a few of the things that Time Lord science is capable of. In war, the Time Lords would have pulled out all the stops to protect themselves from the invading Daleks. We have seen snippets of their weaponry and technology in mini-episodes and flashbacks, but so much has been left to our imaginations. Would we see Tardises of all shapes and sizes, armed with Time Lord weaponry, defending the sky trenches against the onslaught of Dalek ships? Would wounded Time Lords be able to utilise their regeneration energy as an emergency weapon? I would like to think so! If The Day of The Doctor is anything to go by, the Time War would definitely have a lot to offer if it was made into a spin-off series. The series would be set in the heart of Time Lord civilisation and would show off everything that make Time Lords' one of the mightiest races in the universe.

6. The Fall Of Alien Civilisations

It may be tempting to assume that a War Doctor spin-off would exclusively feature Time Lords and Daleks in the heat of battle, but this would not be the case. Many, many more planets and races were affected by the Time War. The first creature the Doctor encountered in NuWho was the Nestene Consciousness, protected by its Autons. The Nestene Consciousness was quick to blame the Doctor for the loss of its home planet, Polymos. From then on, more and more creatures and planets have been shown as victims of the Time War - the Zygon and Gelth being some of the others. The buccaneering War Doctor would not be limited to fighting on Gallifrey in a series set during the Time War, he would still have a great deal of exposure to other planets and races who were unfortunate enough to cross paths with the fighting. Seeing the Doctor's involvement in the fall of other civilisations would add more weight to the modern Doctor's distaste for violence and fighting. The series would also bring some context to the struggles of war-damaged races that the Doctor has met since the TV series was revived in 2005.

5. The Master As A Soldier

Rassilon was not the only Time Lord to have been resurrected to fight in the Time War. When the Doctor encountered the Master in the episode Utopia, we learnt that the renegade Time Lord fought and fled from the war by using a Chameleon Arch to rewrite his biology. It's possible that the War Doctor may have fought shoulder-to-shoulder with the Master during the Time War. It would be brilliant to see a less restrained incarnation of the Doctor combining his genius with the cruel, calculated cunning of the Master in order to defeat a common foe. The same goes for the other renegade Time Lords that popped up on occasion in Classic Who.

4. Daleks In Their Prime

The Dalek Empire's full fleet has been pegged as being one of the most destructive armies in the Who Universe, able to break down even the mighty defences of the Time Lords. Classic Who and NuWho alike have shown the brutality of the Dalek race, but the full planet-destroying force of the Dalek fleet has never quite been fully explored. We have seen the fleet, several times. It has invaded planets, held people hostage, and caused a fair amount of damage to the surface of Earth on several occasions. But none of that compares to what they were supposedly capable of during the Time War. Now that Doctor Who has the budget and production team to tease us with the kind of mass warfare, epic scale imagery that we have seen in recent episodes, it makes sense to keep riding that wave and explore the full potential of Time Lord / Dalek warfare with a War Doctor spin-off.

3. The Omega Arsenal

The Omega Arsenal. The Time Lord vault of all things nasty and destructive. This is where The Moment was safely tucked away, out of sight and out of mind. The Time Lords exhausted all but one of their most deadly weapons whilst fighting the Daleks, so what made them use the others, when did they use them and what effect did each have in the war? The Doctor seemed to find his way into the Omega Arsenal with great ease, so maybe he had played a part in using the other weapons. The Doctor was present at the fall of Arcadia, he witnessed the destruction of the Dalek Crucible and was no doubt a key player in most of the other major landmarks of the Time War so it is possible that he also led some of the assaults and executed the weapons in the heat of battle. Christopher Eccleston's Doctor was quick to think of making a Delta Wave when trying to take down the Dalek Emperor on Satellite 5, so he is definitely capable of taking drastic measures to deal with Dalek threats, but that Doctor was supposedly much more restrained than the War Doctor. The War Doctor is probably capable of so much more!

2. Time Lord Corruption

David Tennant's Doctor feared what the Time Lords had become during the last days of the Time War - a race hellbent on ensuring their own survival by any means necessary. What was the turning point? What made the almighty and wise Time Lords become a dark and sinister race, capable of repulsing even the Doctor? This creates quite a significant story arc for the War Doctor spin-off to follow; the collapse and corruption of Time Lord civilisation. The Doctor's relationship with the Time Lords has been turbulent at best over the long years, but how would a darker incarnation of the Doctor deal with Time Lord treachery during the biggest in their history? I have my money on 'not very well'. Doctor Who series 8 may just see the Time Lords return, following on from the events of The Day of the Doctor and The Time of the Doctor. As of yet, we know very little about how these post-war Time Lords will behave. The War Doctor may have had confrontations with some of the Time Lords, particularly those close to Rassilon, and the grudge may have stuck. There is definitely scope for a War Doctor spin-off coming along to prepare us for the Gallifrey returning.

1. Completing the Doctor's Timeline

For any Whovian, knowing the Doctor's definitive, accurate timeline is a bit of an unachievable ideal. The Doctor's life and adventures have been shown on TV, radio and also in books, so its inevitable that there are going to be some discrepancies about the chronology of the Doctor. Inconsistencies aside, the time between the Doctor Who TV series being originally discontinued in 1989 and it being revived in 2005 created a big gap in the Doctor's life which was never properly documented; the Time War years. From the 2005 series to now, this time is still the only substantial gap in the Doctor's life that we have not seen, except the pre-'Doctor' years. If the War Doctor's adventures and struggles were given their own airtime, we would finally be able to properly bridge the gaps in the Doctor's life. There will still be gaps, that's unavoidable, but our understanding of the Doctor's timeline will look a lot more like the image above. We will then be able to watch the Doctor's adventures from the 1st Doctor all the way through to the current 14th Doctor (13th regeneration, 13th body, 14th life!). I would love to see a warmongering version of the Doctor - an incarnation of the Doctor that is darker, more vicious and less forgiving. Doctor Who is slowing shedding its reputation for having awful alien costumes and budget CGI by moving towards the kinds of cinematography and visual effects that are befitting for an accessible Sci-fi epic franchise. Feel free to share your views on a War Doctor/ Time War spin off in the comments below.

In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

My life is an odd blend of the real and surreal. By day I study law but by night I live my life vicariously through science fiction and fantasy, as a Whovian, gamer and writer.