Doctor Who: 5 Reasons Why We Need A New Showrunner
The internet has been infected and there are monsters in the wi-fi, but I'm not talking about aliens. Haters seem to have taken over Doctor Who's online fan base in every corner of the internet people are loud and proud about their hatred of that moment in this episode, and this character, and that plot point. Yet Who is to blame for these issues? Every finger seems to point to current Doctor Who show runner Steven Moffat. The writer, once applauded by fans for his gripping stories in the first few seasons of DW's revival, has had many Whovians turn against him. While there is a huge gap in the number of vehement haters of his work online and the actual number among viewers, the disgust towards Steven Moffat on the internet can be overwhelming. Let me say this: I like Steven Moffat. His plot twists are undeniably mind-blowing, he takes full advantage of the freedoms of time travel, and the fairy tale element he has brought to Eleven's run is truly beautiful. So let's put down the pitchforks, stop shaking our fists and talk about this civilly. Here's why it's time for Moffat to go.
5. New Mouth, New Rules
The main reason why Steven Moffat's smart choice would be to walk away now is simply because his Doctor is leaving. With Moffat's brain and Matt's heart(s), these two have created a whimsical, brilliant, angry, ageless man that is remarkably easy to love. At the moment, only half of Eleven is walking away, and while Moffat has proven he can handle writing for different Doctors, his continued presence could present a problem. Namely, if he leaves in the middle of 12's run we will hit a very uncomfortable snag in the fabric of the show as the style, language and dynamics change while the actors stick around. It would be more prudent for him to bow out now alongside Matt Smith and let someone else fly the TARDIS alongside Peter Capaldi.
4. Respect The Ladies
This is my big issue with the Moff. His episodes of Doctor Who are rampant with tropes that have been getting progressively less progressive. Amy Pond waiting at the window for her Raggedy Man may have been sweet, but it goes downhill from there. River regressing from archeologist who dated the Doctor to a woman whose entire life revolved around him, the awful disregard for the trauma that should have arisen from Amy and Rory's child being stolen, the fact that Clara is treated more as a mystery than as a real person; the list goes on and on. The "She Said He Said" prequel to the series 7 finale was the last straw. I'm surprised Jenna Coleman didn't toss her script away in disgust over the claims of Clara being the "perfect" girl and her constant struggle to keep herself from dropping her panties at the Doctor's feet. After all, he's a guy who condescends to you and has a really nice car: how can a girl resist? The issue boils down to what Steven Moffat constitutes as a strong female character: smart, hot, witty, sexually loose. "Strongly written" is not a list of adjectives, it simply means a fully developed person. Moffat has proven he can't handle his ladies. It's getting old, and it's time for us to get someone who can.
3. The Doctor Hates Repeats
It's impossible for a writer not to have tropes and tricks that they fall back on. Moffat may never admit it, but he does have quite a few of these plot points and character tics that repeat themselves. Take a look at River Song and compare her to the character Irene Adler in Moffat's other series, Sherlock: Sherlock may get better every time I watch it, but the femme fatale who grows to center herself around a man is one of many tropes that Moffat falls back on when he's not paying careful attention. When he's focused on one script, Steven Moffat is capable of writing brilliant stories that feel original, but after a couple of years spreading himself thin as show runner, his old ideas keep rearing their heads. Writing this is actually a bit difficult for me because I like most of these ideas! But let's face it. We all got de ja vu at the Spoonhead mantra "don't click it" in the Bells of St. John. We just got another tale of a companion who is a mystery that needs solving. And someone please tell me, what is the difference between the Whispermen and the Silence? After a few seasons, we'll always start seeing similarities in the writing. There's nothing wrong with a need for someone fresh at the helm, and if Moffat went back to writing a script or two each season we'd see more of his episodes reaching Blink levels of perfection.
2. Shut The TARDIS Doors
One thing we could use from Steven Moffat is a bit of closure. It has quite literally taken us years to get answers out of this guy. Instead of clear answers that bring more questions, some of Moffat's mystery has felt as though it's spinning out of control (i.e. The Wedding of River Song). We are finally drawing to the close of the massive arc that has been his run: we understand the Silence's mission, the first question, River, the exploding TARDIS. Giving the audience closure in plain English isn't exactly a strength for Moffat, but we do what we can and when we look at the facts, we can see that we do indeed have most of the threads in Eleven's gigantic web of a story. Now that the biggest bomb of all has been dropped, it would be excellent to see the 50th Anniversary and Christmas toy with the Doctor's greatest secret of all time before coming to a fitting end. Crucially, this should be an ending with actual closure. Please for the love of god, give us some closure. All this mystery is starting to Hurt (See what I did there?...because John Hurt...never mind).
1. We're All Stories In The End
Despite Steven Moffat's issues, he has delivered a run of Doctor Who that has been creative, smart, and emotional. Moffat never talks down to his audience, demanding instead that we keep up with what's happening at the Doctor's pace. His run has been downright exciting, which has felt so right for a show with infinite possibilities. This is the time for him to step out, and it's a shame he's avoiding it. We're going to have to face facts: Steven Moffat is sticking around to mess with us a little longer, and if we're not careful, we might just end up enjoying the show.