Doctor Who: 5 Reasons Why The Second And Eleventh Doctors Should Share Adventures

doctorwhotroughton1 Though the Eleventh Doctor's time is almost up, he can at least rest assured that he could live on through the audio Whoniverse or future multi-Doctor TV specials. This in turn raises the intriguing possibility of adventures with his Second self, arguably the past incarnation with whom he shares the most in common ground. Indeed, Matt Smith's costume and performance for his own take on the role owes much to Patrick Troughton €“ who he's acclaimed as his own favourite past Doctor, with ' Tomb Of The Cybermen' his favourite serial. So why not pair them together? Anyone familiar with classic 'Who' couldn't fail to note that 'Cold War' served as Mark Gatiss's love letter to 'The Ice Warriors' either. While these are perhaps obvious lead-ins, we think there are several more ways in which these two particular Doctors overlap. And while its sad that the late, great Patrick Troughton wasn't around to grace the screen once more with Smith as he had with William Hartnell's First, Jon Pertwee's Third, Peter Davison's Fifth and Colin Baker's Sixth Doctors in 'The Three/Five/Two Doctors' specials, but Frazer Hines proved himself a more than capable vocal double in 'Shadow Of Death' and 'The Light At The End',as did Pat's son David in 'The Hexford Invasion'. Admittedly,David's take on his dear pa's most famous role was played as a clone of the universe's favourite cosmic hobo,but why the possibility of featuring a similar scenario on screen alongside the incumbent Eleventh wasn't at least discussed nobody knows. We think its about time this was put right, in tribute to the recorder-loving legend!

5. A Meeting of Bow Ties/Personalities

Doctor Who Bowties When they briefly psychic-link in 'Shadow Of Death' the first observation the Second makes is that his future self's tie is 'rather fetching'. And what an introduction it would be if they were to bumble over how great each other's fashion sense is before realising something's a bit wrong and teaming up to stop it. After all, they're both great clowns,with an undercurrent of steel and calculation. New Whovians are referred to the likes of the aforementioned 'Tomb Of The Cybermen', 'The Evil Of The Daleks', 'The Seeds Of Death' and ' The Web Of Fear' for brilliant examples of this. Rigging the doors of the Cyber-Tombs for maximum electrocutional effect, giving the Daleks the 'Human Factor' in a neat reversal of their original plan to Dalek-ize humanity,steering an Ice Warrior fleet into the sun,double-crossing the Great Intelligence and undoing the Land Of Fiction were all in a day's work despite the facade of buffoonery. And the Eleventh does it just as well. Consider his back and forth with those sexy fish vampires in 'The Vampires Of Venice' regarding the nature of their plan. 'Someday that's going to work',he laments, and later on it does, sort of. The 'self-destruct button' that turns out to be a Jammy Dodger in 'Victory Of The Daleks'. Yet despite all this buffoonery, they both realise that some corners of the universe have bred the most terrible things and must be stopped at all costs. Hence his gambit to deal with the Silence and faking his own death to escape their clutches, seemingly fulfilling their prophecy. Dealing with 'Mr Clever' by bluffing over a chess move? Piece of cake. And so perhaps the most compelling case for putting the two together rests.

4. Swapping Companions

Doctor Who Patrick TroughtonImagine the rich potential offered when you throw in the prospect of companion-swapping. No, not like that! Jamie McCrimmon with the Eleventh, Clara Oswald with the Second, that sort of thing. Would they embrace the similarities between 'their' Doctors and work in harmony with them,or find them too strange in comparison to either the younger or older incarnation? And indeed how the companions would interact with each other is a fascinating conjecture. Most likely Amy Pond and Zoe Heriot might have more than a few clashes, for sure. And a teaming of Rory Williams and Jamie might prove irresistible to Mrs Williams's Caledonian sensibilities... Based on how she dealt with the young Queen of Years in 'The Rings Of Akhaten,' Clara may well find her nannying side coming to the fore in meeting Victoria Waterfield some time after 'Evil' €“ her father dead at the gunstalks of the Daleks,she'd need someone to lean on and Clara could very well fill a role as a sort of model for Victoria to grow into before she leaves the TARDIS behind for good in 'Fury From The Deep'. Plus,they'd have common ground in having lost a parent and been taken in by the Doctor,which adds a possible whole new dimension to the 'they sleep in my mind' philosophical tangent briefly pursued by the Second and Ms Waterfield in 'Tomb Of The..' If they were feeling really adventurous there's even scope for the younger Doctor to meet the Paternoster Gang,who may well be forgiven for wondering if the Beatle lookalike before them could ever really become the Doctor they know,respect and even fear a little. Throw River Song into the mix and we could really have something, too!

3. Base Under Siege

doctor-who-journey-to-the-centre-of-the-tardis-review-whatculture-whatculture_trrrj_0 It's a classic story in the early years of Pat Troughton's time at the TARDIS controls- the base under siege. It made up most of his first two series in the role,and it would be great to have he and Matt Smith,on the basis of 'Cold War',do something similar in future. Go back and watch the awesome foursome of 'The Power Of The Daleks','The Underwater Menace','The Moonbase' and 'The Macra Terror' for further examples. Plus of course, it would be churlish to forget 'The Ice Warriors',the introduction for the chilly Martian invaders who'd pop up once more in 'Cold War'. The two Doctors who know them best in a race against time to stop them once more. Could work. Add in the fact they've both battled the Great Intelligence ( 'The Abominable Snowmen','The Web Of Fear','The Snowmen','The Bells Of Saint John' and 'The Name Of The Doctor') and that's two potential avenues to go down. A case could be made for them taking on the Daleks and Cybermen, as both did ad nauseum ( 'The Invasion', 'The Wheel In Space', 'The Power Of The Daleks' and countless others). But wait. There's a massive gap in time between the Macra as massive sentient crabs and dumber devolved beasts as they appeared in 'Gridlock' with the Eleventh's preceding incarnation,so perhaps another adventure involving them is the way forward.

2. A 'Time Crash' Moment

time crash doctor who Anything the Fifth and Tenth Doctors can do, the Second and Eleventh should at least get the chance to replicate. They do briefly in ' Shadow Of Death' and it serves as a mouthwatering prelude. It could have happened at the end of 'Cold War' €“ such was Mark Gatiss's intent to give the Eleventh Doctor more in common with his younger self than just a bow tie and initial love of hats €“ but sadly didn't. It could even be built into the Season 6B theory,with the Second working for the Celestial Intervention Agency and needing the older incarnation's help at the end of separate adventures in their own timelines. Whether or not 'The Two' or 'Three/Five Doctors' would have occurred for the younger man, or 'The Day Of The Doctor' for the senior, wouldn't necessarily matter. A number of alternative televisual angles could also have been opened. What if the Eleventh had attempted to save the Second from his fate at the end of 'The War Games'? It could have left the door open for future meetings between the two whether or not the plan had a satisfying pay-off. Not to mention set the scene for future meetings with the Third Doctor,who may or may not be pleased to see him. They may have the Silurians in common, but anything else...

1. The Scene's Already Set

Doctor Who Shadow Of Death We got a listen to how the two Doctors might interact, though it was all too brief. He'd go on to pay similar visits to his other nine incarnations,having started by dropping a cryptic radio message to the First and Susan in 'Hunters Of Earth'. The scope is there for similar adventures to continue beyond the 50th anniversary and that should be explored. After all, Big Finish already hold the audio rights to the first eight incarnations of the Time Lord, and should they snaffle the other three anything's possible. A thought which should cheer you whether your Doctor of choice is the one who sprang up at the end of 'The Tenth Planet' after Bill Hartnell's body wore a bit thin or David Tennant's literally explosive replacement following those dreaded four knocks. Or indeed if you love both! And there's no reason you shouldn't, so tell us what you think. Does it deserve to go the way of 'The War Games' and Trenzalore, or could it work?

Contributor

Journalist, musician, sports fan, citizen of the universe and a gentleman to boot!