Doctor Who: 50 Unanswered Questions
30. Why Were The 2nd Doctor And Jamie Working For The Time Lords In "The Two Doctors?"
Previously it was understood that the 2nd Doctor, like his predecessor, was on the run from his own people. So how did he come to be calmly acting on their behalf in "The Two Doctors?" Also, companion Jamie McCrimmon had never heard of the Time Lords before the 2nd Doctor' swan song serial The War Games, so how could he be aware of them before then? Paul Cornell, Martin Day and Keith Topping in The Discontinuity Guide came up with a theory that many Whovians have embraced. "Rather than undergoing the regeneration shown starting at the end of The War Games, the Second Doctor was recruited to work for the Celestial Intervention Agency, a clandestine Time Lord organization shown to exist in TV: The Deadly Assassin. "During this time, the Second Doctor regained Jamie and Victoria as companions, acquired a Stattenheim remote control device to summon his TARDIS and undertook an unknown number of missions, including that depicted in The Two Doctors. "Eventually, the Doctor's association with the CIA ended for reasons not known and his full War Games sentence was executed at the beginning of Spearhead from Space."This explanation was never given on screen and certainly makes sense but is it the answer?
The Third Doctor
29. Why Does The 3rd Doctor Have A Tattoo?
Soon after regenerating the 3rd Doctor hops into a shower. While gifting the audience with a flash of his chest and a rendition of "La donna è mobile," a brief glimpse of a snake tattoo is spotted on his arm. In reality this was a relic of Jon Pertwee's time in the navy, but what is the significance of this regeneration having a tattoo? Considering that the 3rd Doctors face and body were selected by the Time Lords, fans have argued that this was a mark placed on him by his jailers to identify the Doctor as a criminal. Interestingly, the only other Time Lord seen to have a tattoo is The Doctor's friend the Corsair who also had a tattoo of a snake on his arm (The Doctor's Wife). Is the serpent a Gallifreyan mark to identify criminals? Did the 2nd Doctor somehow manage to manifest a tribute to his fellow Time Lord (and drinking buddy) the Corsair on the body of his 3rd incarnation?
28. Why Do The Doctor And The Master Only Meet In Chronological Order?
As time travelers, isn't it odd that the Delgado Master never plagued the 4th Doctor or targeted the 1st incarnation of his rival Time Lord? While the Dalek and Cybermen who haven't always had time travel capabilities have met the Doctor out of sequence all over his personal timeline, The Master always follows time in a straight line. Why?
27. What Is The Real Connection Between The Doctor And The Master?
In "The Sound of Drums," when companion Martha Jones asked if The Doctor and The Master were brothers, the 10th Doctor dismissed it by saying, "You've been watching too much TV." Well we know The Doctor lies and he didn't really answer the question, did he? The original concept was that either The Doctor and Master were brothers or that The Master was some form of evil manifestation of The Doctor (perhaps a forerunner of The Valeyard concept). Another concept bandied about was that the enemies were the id and ego of The Doctor somehow split and given form. The Master's storyline was to conclude in a story titled The Final Game where the Robert Delgaldo Master would have died sacrificing himself to save The Doctor's life. The untimely death of Robert Delgaldo forced the storyline to be dropped and the relationship between the antagonists was often hinted at but never revealed. In "Planet of Fire," The Master says to the 5th Doctor, "Won't you show mercy to your own..." before seemingly being burned alive. Your own, what? It has been confirmed that the two characters grew up together but might they share familial bonds as well?
The Fourth Doctor
26. When Did The 4th Doctor Visit The Planet From The Face Of Evil?
This unnamed planet was visited by the 4th Doctor at some point in his history when he attempted to repair the Starfall Seven's computer Xoanon, inadvertently leaving it with a split personality. It is an event that he vaguely recalls so one can rule out the theory that his first encounter with the Sevateem is later in his timeline. Also the monument with the 4th Doctor's face rules out the possibility that it was another incarnation of The Doctor. In the novelisation, writer Terrance Dicks suggests that the Doctor first visits this planet during the events of Robot when suffering from post regenerative trauma he jumped into the Tardis for what appeared to be a few seconds, but could conceivably have been much longer. As a writer for the series itself, one could argue that the novel gives the definitive answer, but who knows?
25. Are All Gallifreyans Time Lords?
In "The Invasion of Time," Leela encounters the outsiders; members of the Doctor's species who have rejected Time Lord Society, choosing instead to live in the wastelands outside the Capital Citadel. As outcasts from Time Lord Society the story makes it appear that they were no longer considered Time Lords, yet the Doctor who fled Gallifrey all together is still considered a Time Lord. It remains unclear whether the title only refers to Gallifrey's elite their politicians and people of stature. Is Gallifreyan the species and Time Lord an earned title?
24. What Caused Romana To Regenerate?
Romana's regeneration in "Destiny of The Daleks" is played for laughs and to highlight how Romana is so much better at the whole Time Lord thing than The Doctor, but it also raises several questions. Can Time Lords regenerate spontaneously without wasting one of their 12 "lives?" Did she perhaps suffer a mortal wound in an untold tale set between the events of "The Armageddon Factor" and "Destiny of The Daleks?" "The Christmas Invasion" and "Let's Kill Hitler" established that Time Lords have quite a bit of flexibility in the hours after regenerating so the switching of bodies before settling on a carbon copy of Princess Astra's body is not as odd as it appears at first blush, but the question still remains; why is Romana regenerating in the first place?
23. How Did The Master's Body Become Disfigured?
The Master was last seen working with the Daleks in the 3rd Doctor story, "Frontier in Space." At that time he seemed to be in perfect health. Yet when we see him again in The Deadly Assassin he has become a walking, dessicated corpse. What happened? Was it a failed regeneration? An experiment with mystical forces that went wrong? A natural result of being on his last regeneration?
22. Is The 12 Life Limit On Regenerations Biological Or Imposed By The High Council?
First revealed during the events of The Deadly Assassin, this limit adds another twist to the regeneration concept. Examining the history of the Time Lords, it is evident that there was some point in their history when they were regularly facing death and adapted to survive and learn from the their experiences. During the war with the Great Vampires perhaps? But what is the story behind the limit? During the 5 Doctors the Time Lords promise to give the Master more regenerations in exchange for his cooperation. It has also been revealed that despite his using up all of his regenerations, the Time Lords were able to resurrect him with a new set. But what kind of biological process can be regulated and circumvented by a government?
21. What The Heck Is The Watcher?
Logopolis has to be the oddest multi-Doctor story ever. Throughout the story the mysterious Watcher, a shadowy figure resembling a man sized misused Q-Tip, is lurking about watching the final hours of the 4th Doctor's life. As the 4th Doctor regenerates, The Watcher merges with his dying body while Nyssa exclaims, "He was the Watcher the whole time!" What? In one of the DVD commentaries it was argued that circumstances were so bad that the 4th and 5th Doctor's timelines overlapped and The Watcher was an echo of the Doctor's next incarnation. Considering the fact that for most of Logopolis, all The Watcher does is stand around watching and takes the Tardis for a brief spin, this answer is quite unsatisfying. I have yet to hear or read any explanation of The Watcher that makes a lick of sense.
The Fifth Doctor
20. Do The Doctor's Regenerations Follow A Pattern?
Each regeneration appears to address the weaknesses or inadequacies of their predecessor, almost as if the Doctor is learning and adapting to better suit the circumstances. Consider the history of the Doctor's many faces. The 1st Doctor lived to a ripe old age and regenerates into a younger, more humorous and warmer man. The 2nd Doctor is forced to regenerate becoming more serious, more petulant and better able to handle himself in physical situations he might encounter while in exile. The 3rd regenerates into a more laid back, more alien, more bohemian Doctor better able to enjoy his wanderlust, enjoy travel with or without companions and freed from the bonds of his exile. The 4th regenerates into a younger, more collaborative Doctor. The regeneration from 9 to 10 is particularly interesting as it appears that he regenerated into a Doctor best equipped to attract and reciprocate Rose's affection. From 10 to 11 its almost as if he felt that the being a romantic Doctor was too painful, so he became a Doctor self-described as rubbish around women. If we look at regeneration from a biological standpoint, it can be argued that any species that evolves a means to cheat death and return to life could plausibly have incorporated a further adaptation addressing the weaknesses that led to that death.
19. Could The Doctor Have Saved Adric?
Snatching Adric from the crashing starship (Earthshock) should have been a snap for The Doctor. The damage to the Tardis could have been repaired and a quick leap back to one minute before the explosion could have had everyone's least favorite companion back in the fold without even mussing his hair. Even though the explosion resulting from the crash was most certainly a fixed point in time, Adric did not have to be aboard that ship for history to play out as it should, so why didn't The Doctor even try? Perhaps The Doctor was as glad to be rid of Adric as everyone else was!
The Sixth Doctor
18. Was The 6th Doctor Really Forced To Regenerate By "Tumultuous Buffeting?"
Considering the last time we saw Colin Baker's Doctor he was being cajoled by Bonnie Langford into subsisting on a diet of carrot juice and engaging in vigorous use of a stationary bike (seen in the background on the Tardis floor as he regenerates). It could be said that one of the finest actors to play the Doctor received the most ignominious death in the history of the Doctor Who franchise. As if being saddled with a costume that viewers needed ear plugs just to look at, having his Doctor die from apparently bumping his head on the Tardis console after falling off an exercise bike was the final indignity. The novelisation cited the 6th Doctor's cause of death as "tumultuous buffeting." As if that was any better. Outside of the official canon the 6th Doctor received a heroic send off in the book Spiral Scratch, while elsewhere it was theorized that 6 was bumped off by the conniving 7th Doctor in an effort to get an early start on his time championing schemes.
The Seventh Doctor
17. Is The Doctor Much More Than A Time Lord?
In an attempt to restore a bit of mystery to The Doctor, The Cartmel Master Plan was unleashed. Created by Andrew Cartmel, Ben Aaronovitch and Marc Platt aspects of the Doctor's true nature were hinted throughout the 25th and 26th seasons. In "Silver Nemesis," Lady Peinforte shakes her head when The Doctor is described as a Time Lord and in a scene cut from the broadcast version of "Remembrance of the Daleks" the Doctor claims to be "far more than just another Time Lord." The plan would have culminated in the revelation that The Doctor was one of the founders of Time Lord society alongside Rassilon and Omega, and that Susan Foreman was not really his granddaughter. The cancellation of Doctor Who meant that this storyline was dropped and many of the ideas contained in the plan were never carried forward. With the mystery surrounding The Doctor's name, perhaps there might be something to the idea that the Doctor is more than a Time Lord.
16. Whatever Happened To The Rani?
Like Susan Foreman and the Meddling Monk, this is another Time Lord who has disappeared from Doctor Who. When last we saw her, she was cornered by a dinosaur, but was that the final end for the villain responsible for offing the 6th Doctor? Was she eventually laid low by one of her schemes? Did she use up all of her regenerations and the Time Lords never bothered to offer her a few more? Was she drafted into and killed in the Time War?
15. Which Doctor Fought Fenric Originally?
17 centuries before "The Curse of Fenric" The Doctor battled the malevolent Fenric, defeated him in a game of chess and trapped him in a flask that was later stolen by the Vikings and buried in a church in Northumberland. It is not explained which Doctor had battled the ancient creature and as a time traveler it could have been any Doctor at anytime between his adventures. Could this have been an incident experienced by the 1st Doctor prior to "An Unearthly Child?" Could The Doctor have defeated Fenric in the much speculated about 6B series on a mission at the behest of the Time Lords? Or could it have happened during one of the 4th Doctor's solo adventures? Based on Fenric's recognizing The Doctor by face, the most logical answer is that the 7th Doctor was Fenric's jailer, but the door has been left open.
14. Why Did Ace Leave The Doctor?
When we last saw Dorothy Gale McShane, she was strolling off into the sunset with the 7th Doctor. In his final story, the 7th Doctor was traveling alone. Later in "The Death of The Doctor," Sarah Jane Smith reveals that "Dorothy something" had formed a charity called A Charitable Earth and had "...raised billions." But what led to Ace and The Doctor parting company? Had the Doctor determined that his final trip to Skaro was too dangerous to take Ace? Had The Doctor been summoned to Gallifrey and like Sarah Jane Smith in "The Hand of Fear," been unable to take her with him? Had Ace simply tired of The 7th Doctor's secretive and scheming nature? I guess we'll never know.