Doctor Who: 7 Reasons Why Peter Capaldi's Doctor Shouldn't Be Dark

General consensus says the Doctor should become darker, do these assumptions have any real reasons?

BBCBBCEver since Scottish actor Peter Capaldi was revealed to be the lucky man who had the daunting, but exciting task of taking on the iconic role of the Doctor, everyone's brains went into overdrive. The world began speculating about the possible nature of this new incarnation; What would he be like? Would he have a catchphrase? What character traits would he have? Everyone seemed to think exactly the same thing: he will be dark, mysterious and brooding, but why? Is it just because he has a scary face, or because he is famous for playing the profanity proficient spin doctor Malcolm Tucker? Whatever the reason, everyone appeared to have the dark Doctor theory simultaneously. In light of the events of 'The Day of the Doctor' and the following Christmas special, however, these theories seem to have less justification than first perceived. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TivqZTq5u6Y A recent trailer featured the Doctor asking companion Clara, "Am I a good man?" but why would he be bad, is there any real reason? There's nothing to say that Capaldi's Doctor shouldn't be a bit moody from time to time, and have a similar manner to Hartnell, but should he be dark, or do the next seven reasons show that actually, Capaldi's Doctor should be one of the happiest of them all?

7. The Doctor Can Start Afresh

BBCBBCNot only is our Time Lord a fresh new face to add to the roster of Doctors, he's also the first Doctor in a brand new regeneration cycle. This gives the Doctor the biggest of the new beginnings he's ever had, a chance to have a major renewal, rethink his values and morals. The Doctor has changed his point of view on certain aspects of his life before. For example, after €˜The Eleventh Hour€™ the Doctor mentions the Time War very rarely, in contrast to his two previous incarnations who frequently made reference to this major point in the Doctor€™s life. This contrast between incarnations even earned Tennant€™s Doctor the title €˜The Man Who Regrets€™ and Smith€™s €˜The Man Who Forgets€™. Whether or not the fact that he is on his second regeneration cycle causes problems remains to be seen, however it will definitely be a big moment in the Doctor's life, a sort of comma, a breath (a 'Deep Breath' in fact), a time to look back and forwards on his life. David Tennant€™s first adventure provided the Doctor with an even more gleeful outlook on life, with his more sorrowful and angry side bubbling away in the background. Some of his enemies may not even recognise him any more, giving him the opportunity to leave elements of his past behind and begin anew. Regeneration will have brought him not only a new body to play with, but a new personality, meaning a different view on the world, which could send him two ways, either into the dark or further into the light, but so soon after the dramatic revelation of John Hurt's War Doctor, it would be a strange move to take the Doctor into the dark once again.

6. The Doctor Has Allies Around Him To Help Him Through His Regeneration

BBCIt has been confirmed that Series 8's début episode will feature the Paternoster Gang, made up of Silurian Madame Vastra, her human wife Jenny, and their Sontaran butler, Strax. These three allies of the Doctor, who originally appeared in the Matt Smith era, along with Clara, will help to ease the Doctor back into normality. These companions will most likely work in a similar way to Sarah Jane Smith, who was the bridge between Jon Pertwee and Tom Baker. Back when Matt Smith's first episode aired, we were introduced not only to his Doctor, but also a few other new additions. New companions, a new TARDIS, and a new sonic screwdriver. Nothing was familiar, it was all a bit manic, albeit a fantastically well executed sort of manic. This time, the Doctor will have these familiar characters around him, who can be there to look after him and help him become the Doctor again. The fact that Clara is here for the entirety of Series 8 will also help to ease the transition, not only for the audience but also for the Doctor himself. Having someone the audience can identify with is of paramount importance, and the fact that we already know four of the characters from the first episode will keep us watching, whether we warm to the character of the 12th Doctor immediately or not. His four allies can also care for him as he gets used to his new body. This could take place in a similar manner to how Rose cared for the 10th Doctor in €˜The Christmas Invasion€™, or we could be surprised in the way they do it.

5. He's Going Back To His Roots

BBCBBCWe know that in the eighth series of Doctor Who's new run the Doctor returns to Coal Hill School. Danny Pink, Samuel Anderson's new character, is a teacher there, along with Clara. Coal Hill School first appeared in Doctor Who's début serial 'An Unearthly Child' (originally 100,000 BC). This location later reappeared in 2013's 50th anniversary special, and is the school at which the Doctor's granddaughter, Susan, was taught. This school also introduced us to Ian and Barbara, who, along with Susan, became William Hartnell's first companions. It very much seems like the Doctor Who team are trying to replicate the dynamic from the original series within series 8. This setting, familiar to the Doctor as it is, will provide a comfortable backdrop to some of his adventures, and will help him to settle into his new life without trouble.

4. He Has Cheated Death

BBCBBCIn Matt Smith's final episode 'The Time of the Doctor', the mad time traveller managed to cheat death. The Time Lords granted him a brand new regeneration cycle, and surely this big achievement will have given the Doctor a boost in confidence. He now knows that he has another 11 regenerations left, and this should enable him to have the same spring in his step as early Doctors like Patrick Troughton and Jon Pertwee. Towards the end of Matt Smith's era, the Doctor became a more sombre, reserved character as he headed closer towards what he believed to be his final death. The new cycle, however, is quite the new lease of life, contributing another reason why Capaldi's Doctor should be a grand, beaming hero.

3. He No Longer Has The Looming Threat Of Trenzalore

BBCBBCIn 'The Name of the Doctor' we saw Matt Smith's 11th Doctor become quite terrified at the thought of Trenzalore. This mysterious planet was, in one time line at least, the location of the Doctor's grave. We also see in 'The Day of the Doctor' that both Smith's and Tennant's Doctors are afraid of Trenzalore and what might ensue when he eventually travels there. Now that 'The Time of the Doctor' has wrapped up this story, however, the Doctor no longer has to worry about what he always thought would be his final battle.

2. This Doctor Knows That He Saved Gallifrey

BBCBBCOne of the major reasons why this Doctor should be jollier is because he knows that he actually managed to save Gallifrey, rather than destroy it as he first thought. This controversial move will surely bring some peace to the Doctor, not only because he knows that there are other time lords out there, maybe even his family, but also because he now doesn't have the guilt of destroying his home planet and everyone on it. It made sense that Gallifrey€™s destruction should make the Doctor slightly depressed, and this was one of the best aspects of Christopher Eccleston's Doctor. Yet even with the knowledge that he destroyed his own home, he still manages to muster up a smile now and then. This new knowledge, therefore, should put a bright spring in the Doctor's step, not make him darker. He now knows that out there somewhere is the place in which he grew up, and that one day he will find it, which leads nicely into the final reason...

1. He's Got A Definite Mission

Capaldi Future WhoBBCSo where is Gallifrey? We know it's somewhere, in another universe, in a painting, in a cube, it's all a bit Sci-Fi. The Doctor now appears to have a clear goal set in front of him: to find Gallifrey, whatever it takes, and to restore it into our universe, whilst being careful not to restart the Time War. Back in the Tom Baker era, the Doctor had a mission, spread over a whole series, to find the Key To Time. It reinvigorated the show along with the Doctor, and the hunt for his home planet is bound to have a similar effect. He's got a lot on his plate then, but, as our favourite time lord flies randomly around the universe, he knows he's always got another adventure to look forward to, possibly the biggest adventure of his life. When the Doctor eventually does find Gallifrey and manages to restore it, we can be sure that he'll be the happiest he's ever been.

To Conclude...

BBCBBCAlthough many people may wish to see Peter Capaldi playing a darker Doctor, it may not make sense for Capaldi to be dark from the outset. An alternate route would be that the 12th Doctor could become darker as his series progresses, maybe as he experiences more shocking events or has to battle even more terrible creatures. All we know for certain is that Capaldi will completely knock it out of the park, and hopefully take the place of the coveted 'favourite Doctor' position in many peoples hearts. We won't know until August whether or not the 12th Doctor will be more menacing than his predecessors, but there is substantial evidence to suggest that he shouldn't and that he should remain the jolly traveller that we all love.

Contributor
Contributor

Thomas Field hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.