Doctor Who: All Doctors Ranked From Worst To Best

Allons-y. Or should that be Geronimo?

Who is the greatest Doctor of all time? Matt Smith's old man alien in a young man's body? David Tennant with his emotional powerhouse performances? Tom Baker with all his charisma or Jon Pertwee's debonair gentleman? Has Peter Capaldi won your heart already? Or are you one of those who think Colin Baker was deeply maligned and is actually deserving of greatness?

It comes down to your Doctor - the Doctor you first started watching - and the stories they had. Great companions help too. But it also depends on how your favourite Doctor rises above a terrible script. If the episode is pants but you're still entranced by the Doctor, then the chances are he's doing something right.

This article takes a look at all fourteen incarnations of the Doctor, from William Hartnell to Peter Capaldi. In the Doctor Who canon, the meta-crisis Doctor and the War Doctor do count but Peter Cushing's movie Doctor doesn't. Taking into account their greatest and worst episodes and their contributions to Doctor Who history, let's rank all fourteen Doctors.

Is your Doctor number one? Will you agree with our choices? Feel free as always to comment below and click NEXT to start with number fourteen...


14. The Meta Crisis Doctor - David Tennant

Best Episode: Journey's End. Worst Episode: Er...Journey's End. Technically he counts as a regeneration and as such should be documented on this list. Shot by a Dalek at the end of The Stolen Earth in what was possibly the best cliffhanger of the RTD era, the Tenth Doctor siphoned off his regeneration energy into his hand in a jar. That hand was famously cut off by a Sycorax when the Tenth Doctor was still dealing with his post regeneration trauma way back in The Christmas Invasion. The Tenth Doctor's DNA was mixed with Donna Noble's, making her half Time Lord and him half human. For real this time - just ignore that statement made by the Eighth Doctor in the TV movie. David Tennant was a great Doctor, but this meta-crisis version must sure place last in this list for the simple fact that he was only in one episode and his soul plot-purpose was to reunite Rose with her lost love. But there is more to him that a plot device. While we've seen plenty of dark Doctor moments before, the meta-crisis's single action in Journey's End might be one of the darkest; committing the genocide of the entire Dalek race, at least for a couple of years. Before Matt Smith's swan song in Time Of The Doctor, this meta-crisis regeneration had never had a defined place. But the moment Matt Smith referred to the vanity issues of his predecessor, this version became the Twelfth Doctor. Yes everyone calls Peter Capaldi's Doctor the Twelfth, but he's actually the fourteenth version, except that he is the Twelfth Doctor if you count the meta-crisis and War Doctors as not 'Doctors' in the traditional sense. Still with us?

13. The Sixth Doctor - Colin Baker

Best Episode: Vengeance On Varos - The acid bath might be nasty but there is an intriguing moral story in there. Worst Episode: Timelash - The universally hated of all Doctor Who episodes. With his technicolour dream coat and surly nature, the Sixth Doctor is surely a Doctor of great contradictions. Colin Baker's Time Lord tends to get a bad rap and that is really rather unfortunate. Listen to any of his Big Finish audios and the Sixth Doctor really shines. Perhaps its because you can't see that horrible coat? The trouble with the Sixth Doctor is that he had too much of the First Doctor's grumpiness without much redeeming qualities. He started his life by strangling poor Peri and finished off his career muttering the terrible line "carrot juice". In between, he was a smug, superior Doctor that audiences failed to connect with. Also his scripts contain some rather horrible moments, making his stories quiet uncomfortable to watch. Colin Baker never got his wish to play the Doctor for as long as Tom. With better stories and a different look, he could have been brilliant - try the Big Finish Davros as a taster for what could have been. Sadly he was fired by the BBC and didn't even get to film his regeneration.

12. The Fifth Doctor - Peter Davison

Best Episode: The Caves Of Andronzani - the greatest regeneration story of all time. Worst Episode: Warriors From The Deep - Silurians and Seas Devils? How did it end up so bad? Enter the Myrka... After the huge impact of Tom Baker's Doctor on the show, his successor was always going to have a tough time meeting audience expectations. Producer John Nathan-Turner went for a character far removed from the imposing, larger than life persona of Baker; the result was Peter Davison's boyish Doctor - the youngest actor to play the role until Matt Smith came along. But it wasn't just the look, it was the character that was radically different and it wasn't fully successful. The Fifth Doctor had some great stories - The Caves Of Andronzani is still the greatest regeneration story of all time - but he himself didn't make much of an impact. Overpowered by loud companions and reactive rather than proactive in nature, this Doctor often came across as a bit of a wet fish and certainly not in control of the situation. He was simply too nice at times to be imposing. He wasn't a bad Doctor, just not a dynamic one and sadly he comes across as forgettable on more than one occasion.

11. The First Doctor - William Hartnell

Best Episode: The Aztecs - Possibly the best historical Doctor Who has ever done. Worst Episode: The Web Planet - Giant ant people on a moon, this does not get better with age. The original article, there would be no Doctor now without the marvel of William Hartnell's grumpy old grandfather. Starting off as a rude, solitary figure, whose only connection was to his grand daughter Susan, he quickly became a hero to audiences, fighting Daleks, solving moral dilemmas and protecting Earth's history. Hartnell may have fluffed his lines more than once an episode, but that is part of his charm too and the actor certainly gave it all his worth to shape the hero we know today. Compared to today's Doctors - even Capaldi's - the First Doctor will come across and brash and distant. He wasn't very likable or someone audiences could relate to. But much of that is down to the Doctor being the beginning of a long journey, from a Gallifreian runaway to protector of Earth. In the early days he was the companion's - and the audience's - guide through time and space. Without William Hartnell we wouldn't have Doctor Who today. For all the vision of Verity Lambert as the show's original producer, it was Hartnell that captured the imagination of audiences for all time, making Doctor Who the success it is today.

10. The War Doctor - John Hurt

Best Episode: The Day Of The Doctor - The War Doctor steals the show. Worst Episode: The Name Of The Doctor - Still a cracking introduction and totally unexpected. From one grumpy old man to another, John Hurt's introduction in The Name Of The Doctor was one of the biggest cliffhangers in Doctor Who history and certainly raised the excitement levels for the 50th anniversary celebrations. He didn't disappoint either; taking center stage alongside the heavyweights of the Tenth and Eleventh Doctors, the War Doctor was still able to make himself the absolute highlight of Day Of The Doctor. Before Pete Capaldi's debut, it was John Hurt's Doctor that brought a very classic feel to Nu-Who. He wasn't one of the boyfriend Doctors we had been used to. He instantly called them out on their immaturity and proved to be the voice of reason, deducing that they were still running from the horrors of the Time War. He was also the Doctor that went head to head with the Daleks like no other. He was a warrior, a general and made the hard choices that his other incarnations may have run away from. In just on episode, the War Doctor cemented his place in Doctor Who history. There is a certain appeal in seeing more of him in the future but there is also reason in not bringing him back. His story is solely linked to the Time War and with the 50th anniversary done, that story line - with the exception of bringing back Gallifrey - is now over.

9. The Ninth Doctor - Christopher Eccleston

Best Episode: The Empty Child / The Doctor Dances - Are you my mummy is still scary! Worst Episode: Aliens Of London / World War Three - The Slitheen...urgh! The Doctor from the north, Christopher Eccleston was a marvel as the modern Doctor that helped relaunch Doctor Who for the 21st Century. For the first time the Doctor had a crew cut, a no-fills outfit and an accent. A lot of that no-nonsense look was attributed to his character; he was still suffering from the events of the Time War and - as we learned later - the genocide of his own people. It was Rose that helped bring him back from the brink and make him the hero we all know and loved. But he wasn't all doom and gloom either. He made have had the brashness of Jon Pertwee or Colin Baker but he was also fun. Part of his journey was rediscovering the joys of the universe through Rose's eyes and he was able to laugh and have fun at times. But he was also able to dip into cold aggression where necessary, none more so than when he faced the Daleks. Eccleston only stuck around for one series but his Doctor made a huge impression. He was sorely missed, particularly in the 50th. He made the Doctor his own and made him accessible to the masses once more.

8. The Second Doctor - Patrick Troughton

Best Episode: The Invasion - The original Cyberman invasion down the steps of St Paul's Cathedral. Worst Episode: The Dominators - Dull. Just utterly dull. The Doctor that proved you could continue the show without the original leading man; if Patrick Troughton had not made the impact he did, the show might have faded way into failure and obscurity. Thankfully the Second Doctor was a terrific success. He not only brought something fresh with his playfulness and ability to disarm his enemy with his 'apparent' buffoonery, he also brought out a Doctor that audiences could truly engage with. Hartnell wasn't un-relatable, but he was the grandfather Doctor; he could be caring and wise but he could also be arrogant and aloof. Troughton's Doctor was the first Doctor who seemed to genuinely care deeply for his companions and who appeared to enjoy his experiences travelling the galaxy. There is so much of the Second Doctor's character in every subsequent Doctor - particularly Matt Smith's - that ensures his Doctor endures even today. Despite being more heavily affected than his predecessor by the BBC cull of the 1970s, some of those stories that remain are absolute classics. If Hartnell was the king of historical episodes, then Troughton was the king of monsters and in his episodes Doctor Who delivered some of the best scares of all time.

7. The Seventh Doctor - Sylvester McCoy

Best Episode: The Curse Of Fenric - Sark and utterly brilliant. One of the last Classic Who stories is an absolute winner. Worst Episode: Time And The Rani - Pointless regeneration and too much Bonnie Langford in pink! The Seventh Doctor started off as a bumbling clown in his first series; in fact series 24 is often noted as the worst series in Doctor Who history. Unfortunately that was down to the writing and unfortunate choice of Mel as a companion than Sylvester McCoy's performance. Because in his following two series the Doctor transformed into a Machiavellian, shadowy figure that reinvigorated some of the mystery into the show and left us wanting more. In the beginnings of what was called the Cartmel Masterplan, we saw a Doctor who knew far more than at first appeared. He manipulated his companion Ace to his own agenda, half mentoring her - apparently her original end goal was to train at the academy on Gallifrey - half controlling her in an effort to fight the evil of Fenric. He was darker without being aggressive. Some might argue that his decision to blow up Skaro was the first firing shot of the Time War. There was a sense of transition too. If you took his final story Survival and the first episode of the reboot Rose, they would feel like a natural continuation of the show. Sadly the Cartmel Masterplan, which was designed to add new mystery to the Doctor, never materialised, due the show's cancellation. It was also unfortunate that we never saw more of the Seventh Doctor. His final series was one of the best in years and there was still so much more potential to come.

6. The Eighth Doctor - Paul McGann

Best Episode: The Night Of The Doctor - Some of the finest seven minutes of Doctor Who that has ever been on screen. Worst Episode: The TV Movie - Amazing Doctor, shame about the story. For a character that has had two official appearances on screen - and one of those an internet minisode - there is so much to love about Paul McGann's Eighth Doctor. Most people generally slate his TV movie - a lot of that is probably justified - but it's usually tempered with "but Paul McGann was awesome." It is probably part or the reason it has never really been excluded from Doctor Who canon. There is so much passion in his performance, eloquence in the way he speaks and even in the Lord-Byron-esque costume he is still able to control the room. Fans were re-introduced to the Eighth Doctor in the true surprise of the 50th anniversary celebrations, The Night Of The Doctor, and it immediately set the internet abuzz with demands for more Eighth Doctor stories on screen. While it probably was the right decision not to show more Eighth Doctor during Peter Capaldi's first year, don't be surprised if he shows up again in 2015. In fact, he might have been higher on this list had there been more of him on TV. Like the Sixth Doctor, the Eighth Doctor is best served with the Big Finish audios. From the Lucie Miller years to the 50th anniversary audio The Light At The End, there is so much to enjoy. His interaction with Tom Baker's Fourth Doctor was one of the highlights of that 50th celebration audio adventure. Let's hope for more Eighth Doctor adventures to come!

5. The Twelfth Doctor - Peter Capaldi

Best Episode: Kill The Moon - The first instant classic of series eight. Gothic horror returns to Doctor Who! Worst Episode: The Forest Of The Night - A wonderful fairy tale but it makes no sense whatsoever! Over the course of series eight, audiences were introduced to a very different Doctor to his immediate predecessors. Cold, arrogant and more alien, Peter Capaldi's Doctor harked back to the classic Doctor's of old. There was very much a Jon Pertwee vibe to this Doctor and even a little bit of Sylvester McCoy's ability to manipulate; to audiences that had only watched Nu-Who, this was quite a shock but for fans of Classic Who too, this was a Doctor that was very much a sum of all his preceeding parts. There was no question that Capaldi was excellent from the start; but it wasn't his performance but his character that took a long time to adjust too. Series eight was about the Doctor dealing with the trauma of The Name/Day/Time Of The Doctor trilogy and finding himself again. But by the end of series eight he had named himself protector of Earth, claiming it as his home and reconnecting with Clara in a way that he hadn't thought possible. He is still a ruthless character and he doesn't like hugs but over the course of those twelve episodes he has emerged as a truly great Doctor in every sense. Is he likely to be listed as a favourite Doctor? Quite possibly, but as we have only seen him emerge as the proper Doctor we all know and love at the end of series eight, it will be series nine when we truly see him become one of the greats.

4. The Tenth Doctor - David Tennant

Best Episode: Human Nature / The Family Of Blood - Still the best two-parter of Nu-Who. Worst Episode: Fear Her - A scribble monster and the Oympics. The biggest stinker of Nu-Who! We're arguably at the point now where any of these final four entries could be interchangeable with each other. David Tennant certainly struck a chord in his portrayal of the Tenth Doctor, accelerating Doctor Who from good show to great over the course of his four years as the lead. A very human Doctor, he brought charm, humour and energy to the role and a whole lot of romance too; from Madame de Pompadour to Rose herself. Arguably, the Tenth Doctor is the most emotional Doctor of them all and Tennant always had audiences riveted. From his grief over the Master's death in Last Of The Timelords to his fury as the Time Lord Victorious in The Waters Of Mars. His "I don't want to go" pulled at the heart strings of every fan who has at least one heart, so much that it was repeated in his thrilling return in The Day Of The Doctor. Of course, there was a downside to this Doctor too; his emotions were easily swayed; he became too smug with Rose at times and almost ruined poor Martha, whom he treated like little more than a rebound. Arguably his best partnership was with his 'mate' Donna in his final full season. Tennant could deliver anything the script threw at him and that performance easily made him the new number one in polls after Tom Baker. But he was also so human at times that it was easy to forget that he was an alien and that is what stops him from reaching the number one spot.

3. The Third Doctor - Jon Pertwee

Best Episode: Inferno - One of the greatest alternate reality TV stories of all time. Worst Episode: Planet Of The Spiders - Horrific acting and special effects despite the beautiful regeneration scene. The debonair Doctor with the penchant for fine wines, velvet capes, fencing and karate chops, Jon Pertwee took the role of the Doctor in an unexpected new direction and created one of the best versions of our beloved character in the show's history. No longer was he the carefree traveller across space and time; he was an Earth-bound alien working as a scientific adviser to UNIT and more than any other Doctor he firmly became the protector of humanity. There was great warmth beneath that frosty exterior that was developed so beautifully between the Third Doctor and Jo Grant. The Fourth and Sarah-Jane, the Seventh and Ace, the Tenth and Rose and the Eleventh and Amy; that transition from guide to true friend was founded in that relationship between the Third Doctor and his second companion. So too was the close connection between the Doctors and the Brigadier, a kinship that was paid tribute to so wonderfully in that 'salute' in the recent Death In Heaven. In fact so many aspects of the Doctor were built here, particularly the Master. Delgado was the Moriaty to Pertwee's Sherlock and that love/hate relationship was never bettered. The Hinchcliffe era might be the 'goldern era' of Doctor Who but many of the all time classics came from Barry Letts' tenure. The Silurians, Inferno, The Daemons, The Time Warrior; there are many classics in the Third Doctor's era, but none would have reached the status they deserved without the grandeur of Jon Pertwee's Third Doctor at the helm.

2. The Eleventh Doctor - Matt Smith

Best Episode: The Doctor's Wife - Neil Gaiman's debut episode is superb on every level. Worst Episode: Closing Time - Defeating the cybermen with love? Really? When David Tennant announced he was leaving everyone wondered how he could possibly be bettered. Tennant had brought Doctor Who to a whole other level and had officially been voted the number one Doctor of all time. But then something amazing happened. By the end of the fish custard scene in the opening of Matt Smith's debut episode, many of us begun to think "David who?" In the space of ten minutes we had been introduced to something magical; an alien in a human's body, that played the role like a 900-year old man but looked in his late twenties. That magic never stopped. While many complained over the drawn out story arcs and influence of River Song on the show, no one ever questioned just how amazing Matt Smith's performance was. He captured the child-like quality of Troughton, the energy of Tennant and the darkness of McCoy. Even the less-good episodes became a treat with the Eleventh Doctor in the role. He might have been what Steven Moffat referred to as another "boyfriend Doctor" but he was also his own person, never fully adapting to humanity but loving planet Earth and its people all the same. All the way up to his aging moments in The Time Of The Doctor, Matt Smith stole the show. His story arc was certainly ambitious but he always rose to the occasion. While it was somewhat intentional that it would take a whole series to make the Twelfth Doctor' likeable, it is also telling that it took a long time to get over the wonder that was Matt Smith's Eleventh Doctor.

1. The Fourth Doctor - Tom Baker

Best Episode: The Seeds Of Doom - The Thing meets The Day Of The Triffids. Worst Episode: The Horns Of Nimon - Minotaurs are awesome, this one wasn't. Of all the surviving actors that had played classic Doctors, it was Tom Baker Moffat chose to bring back in the role of the curator in The Day Of The Doctor. It was a decision no one questioned: Tom Baker's Fourth Doctor is the iconic role of the show, the one Doctor everyone remembers above all others. The longest running Doctor and the best, no one captured the essence of the role quite like him. It helps that he has same amazing companions in Sarah Jane, Leela, Romana I and II and that his first three series under producer Peter Hinchliffe are known as the golden era of Doctor Who. The Ark In Space, Genesis Of The Daleks, The Seeds Of Doom, The Deadly Assassin, The Robots Of Death, Horror Of Fang Rock; these are all some of the mightest stories the show has ever produced and they are all Tom's. But it is more than that. The Fourth Doctor was a character that brought the gravitas of his predecessors, mixed with a very alien outlook on humanity. There was great joy in his exploration of space and time and the thrill of danger too. Even his look was iconic, with the never-ending scarf and hat. Sure some of his later episodes didn't match the heights of his early years but they are all still watchable thanks to Tom Baker. He didn't just play the Doctor, he was the Doctor. Arguably there was or will be no actor that could ever take his crown, even Tennant and Smith, who came close. And so concludes our look at every incarnation of the Doctor - all 14 regenerations - and their contribution to the 51 years of Doctor Who. Do you agree or do you feel has your favourite Doctor has been cruely overlooked? Do you find the top-rankers worthy or over-rated? Please let us know in the comments below!

In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

A writer for Whatculture since May 2013, I also write for TheRichest.com and am the TV editor and writer for Thedigitalfix.com . I wrote two plays for the Greater Manchester Horror Fringe in 2013, the first an adaption of Simon Clark's 'Swallowing A Dirty Seed' and my own original sci-fi horror play 'Centurion', which had an 8/10* review from Starburst magazine! (http://www.starburstmagazine.com/reviews/eventsupcoming-genre-events/6960-event-review-centurion) I also wrote an episode for online comedy series Supermarket Matters in 2012. I aim to achieve my goal for writing for television (and get my novels published) but in the meantime I'll continue to write about those TV shows I love! Follow me on Twitter @BazGreenland and like my Facebook page https://www.facebook.com/BazGreenlandWriter