Doctor Who: Ranking Debut Doctor Stories From Worst To Best

A Doctor's first story is meant to calm the fear and light the blue touch paper, but how do they rank?

It was the end, but the moment had been prepared for. It happens every few years, breaking the hearts of millions whilst simultaneously filling them with hope. Regeneration. Matt Smith's Eleventh (Twelfth?... Thirteenth?... oh who cares) Doctor said his farewells on Christmas day, but the show must go on. The Doctors' lives are few but filled with fantastical adventures, everlasting friendships and lots of tears and laughter. Every Doctor has their day (or the Day of the Doctor€) and every Doctor has their debut. From 1963 all the way to 2010 we've experienced eleven debuts, filled with villains, post regenerative stress and our fair share of shop window dummys. A Doctor's first story is meant to calm the fear and light the blue touch paper, but which is better (according to me), and why (still according to me)?

11. Time And The Rani - The Seventh Doctor

Sylvester McCoy€™s debut as The Doctor wasn€™t in question marks holding an umbrella, but lying on the floor wearing a blonde wig pretending to be Colin Baker (long story) . His first story is equally as bizarre, and see€™s returning Timelady villainess, The Rani, attempting to kidnap the universes' greatest geniuses (who all seemingly are from Earth) to, um, do something about Black Matter. I€™m not really 100% sure of what's happening, which doesn€™t help how unbelievably awful this story is. The third story written by Pip and Jane Baker (shudder), wasn€™t even script edited as there was nobody around to do it, and it really does show. McCoy has not found his Doctor yet, and is forced to mispronounce famous sayings whilst dressing up as Napoleon. Companion Mel€™s screams are louder and more irritating than ever before or after, and the alien locals are by far the worst in Doctor Who history until Aliens of London came along. It also marks the musical debut of a certain Keff McCulluch, who€™s nickname, €œDeaf Keff€, should give you a clue about the quality of the incidental music. It does have a couple of saving graces, namely some cute references to former Doctors costumes, fantastic computer effects throughout, and a rather good monster costume for the Tetraps. None of that can save this show however, which is by far the second worst outing for Sylvester McCoy's Doctor (nothing can be worse than Silver Nemesis€), and the worst Doctor debut.

10. The Twin Dilemma - The Sixth Doctor

Let me say this straight away. I LOVE The Sixth Doctor. He€™s my third favourite Doctor (behind Matt Smith and Tom Baker). But even his most unwavering defender will have trouble defending The Twin Dilemma. Anthony Stevens' only contribution into The Doctors adventures is appalling in a number of ways. Despite the general negative fan reaction towards The Doctor STRANGLING HIS COMPANION BECAUSE HE THOUGHT SHE WAS A SPY, I€™ve always thought it set up Colin Baker's Doctor quite well, allowing him to mellow through his travels with Peri until she gets her head shaved and marries Brian Blessed (long story). The Doctor's post-regeneration mental breakdown means his character is more bizarre than it ever has or will be in this story. The story itself is a barrelload of absolute tosh and piffle about the kidnap and subsequent tracking down of two twins who are very good at maths, although they didn€™t have a badge to prove it. It€™s just that it€™s so poorly performed by the Twins, that it deflates the entire story, which isn€™t very good at all anyway. Infact I€™d say that the only thing that saves it is Colin Bakers eccentric and brilliant performance as The Doctor. The main antagonist, and the plot, are both quite frankly rubbish. But still better than Time and the Rani. The absolute nail in the coffin however was that it came directly after quite possibly the greatest Doctor Who story of all time, The Caves of Androzani.

9. The Christmas Invasion - The Tenth Doctor

Arthur Dent reference or not, I wasn€™t impressed. Ok so the story isn€™t actually that bad. But where the heck is The Doctor? It features robotic Santas destroying a peaceful market by firing fireball/lazers out of tubas. Filling time with killer Christmas trees and zombie-fied kids about to commit suicide might be the very definition of Christmas, but this is the debut of a new Doctor? We€™d all cried and crumpled after Christopher Eccleston€™s short but sweet stint in the TARDIS came to an end, and to have David Tennant€™s first story being a whole lot of waiting and uncertainty just feels agonising. The big crescendo moment however is rather fantastic, with The Tenth Doctor quoting the Lion King, and dissolving the alien invasion within about 40 seconds before lamenting the decline in blood control technology. The sword fight is also brilliant, the first swordfight the Doctor€™s been in since The Kings Demons (you€™re welcome) was nice to see, and that whole €œone chance€ thing was broody and sexy (I guess). It€™s a below average RTD episode that didn€™t feature enough Timelord for my liking.

8. Castrovalva - The Fifth Doctor

Change my dear, and not a moment too soon! Ok so it€™s the wrong story but the words ring true. After seven years of scarfs and jelly babies, you can imagine people were getting a tad bored of Tom Baker's Fourth Doctor. So along comes Peter Davison€ only he€™s asleep for the first two episodes€ and then the whole story makes absolutely no sense when he wakes up. But what do you expect from Christopher H Bidmead? Named after the Escher painting, the story itself features a city with moving staircases, eventually. The first two parts of Castrovalva are the better half. It€™s fan service galore, with quotes and references to the previous Doctors and most of the action taking place inside the TARDIS. Adric is kidnapped by The Master, and The Doctor escapes in his TARDIS, without Adric (oh the horror) . Thusly he enters post regeneration trauma and has to sleep for an episode, in the €œZero Room€. Team Nyssa/Tegan discover that the TARDIS is being forced into Event One (The Big Bang, for you lot out there who aren€™t Brian Cox) as a trap by the not-done-yet Master. As a last resort, the Doctor jettisons ¼ of the TARDIS, including the zero room. Tegan decides, after reading a bit of info, to send the Doctor to the planet of Castrovalva AND FINALLY THE STORY BEGINS. It€™s a lot of nothing. It€™s Saving graces are Peter Davisons debut, Antony Ainley€™s brilliant Master portrayal, and all the references I talked about earlier. All in all, not bad, a bit dull but could be a lot better.

7. The TV Movie - The Eighth Doctor

Ok, wait a minute, let me explain why you€™re all wrong. The TV Movie is fantastic. As a backdoor pilot to a potential new television series, it€™s absolutely awful. But as a standalone story, it€™s magnificent. As a debut for a new Doctor? Not so much. The Master is tried in court (what?) on Skaro by the Daleks (what?) and it sentenced to death for crimes against the universe (pot calling kettle black from the Daleks I feel). Long story short, The Doctor lands in San Francisco, gets shot, and a nurse wrongly assumed her patient was human and acciently killed him with a camera, introducing Doctor Sexy MD, aka Paul McGann. The rest of the story is all the things I said earlier, with the Master brilliantly (if a tad OTT) played by Oscar nominated actor Eric Roberts, with motorbike chases, good special effects, lots of jelly babies and screw drivers, and the magnificence of Paul McGann. Despite the fact it makes absolutely no sense at all, in relation to both €œDoctor Who continuity€ and as a story, it€™s still a jolly good romp. McGann€™s heroic, romantic flamboyance is so promising, later delivered by the good people at Big Finish audios, but is ultimately cut off before he even begins. The interior of the TARDIS has never looked better, the Time vortex has never looked better, and Doctor Who has never looked so darn good. Oh yeah I forgot also The Doctor snogs Grace three times, but that€™s not important is it€ Well yes it is. It allowed RTD to get away with romance, the reason the show didn€™t end after one year.

6. Rose - The Ninth Doctor

€œRun€. And that was it. My 13 year old self has never recovered from that single syllable so beautifully and rightfully uttered by the wonderful Christopher Eccleston. I wasn€™t watching on the 3rd of December 1989 when Classic Who ended, but I€™d heard enough from my mother about €œthe sexy man in the scarf€ to be interested. And the 26th of March 2005 saw the long awaited return of everyone€™s favourite Timelord. But wait€ He€™s wearing normal clothes? He€™s got hardly any hair? He€™s northern? Well lots of planets have a north, and lots of doubters were silenced when Doctor Who came back, and it was serious thanks to Russell €œThe T€œ Davies. As the name of the episode suggests, this episode was about the introduction of Rose, as much as it was re-establishing The Doctor. The story features the Nestene Intelligence for the first time since 1971, the beautiful €œthat€™s who I am€ speech, and the return of the big blue box that can apparently repel the assembled hordes of Genghis Kahn. Who knew. This story also features the kick-starting of the mythos that would shadow Doctor Who for the next 8 years: The Time War. A fairly decent romp, with lots of unseen PG death, and the first real introduction of a companions family since The Keeper of Traken (you€˜re welcome). There are some downsides however. The story is lacklustre and the Autons are criminally reduced to benign drones without menace or the creepiness that they because famous for in the early 70€™s. On the whole, the episode is rather dodgy, but It€™s with a hint of nostalgia that I say, isn€™t it just fantastic?

5. An Unearthly Child - The First Doctor

5:16pm, November the 23rd 1963. The theme tune. The weird alien pattern on the screen. Suddenly two words appeared, those words were: Doctor Who. And thus began a television legend. 5 million people couldn€™t believe what they€™d seen. The very first episode of Doctor Who, called An Unearthly Child, is a phenomenal piece of television, and it€™s wonderful Doctor Who. Anthony Coburn€™s script sees Teachers Ian Chesterton and Barbara Wright follow their school pupil Susan Foreman home, and begin exploring the junkyard she apparently lives in. It€™s during this that we first witness our hero, The Doctor. Wearing a hat, a cape, and a scarf, he finds Ian and Barbara, and has an unbelievably sassy and aggressive confrontation. The story begins, the 50 years of history begins. But not before a little trip back to 100,000 BC. The next 3 episodes are almost bizarre in comparison, with inter-tribal politics and the quest for fire being the big bad of the day. The Cavemen themselves are rather good actually, with one of my favourite lines in Doctor Who ever being €œTomorrow, I will kill MANY bears!!!€ being a top top highlight. The story features some very interesting elements, such as the Doctor being selfish enough to offer to go first in a line being chased by angry Cavemen, and even attempting to kill someone with a brick to the head in order to move on and leave. This story on the whole, is a tad on the dull side, but not offensively so. It€™s really the first 25 minutes that are truly magnificent, and set the benchmark for the future of science fiction telvision.

4. Robot - The Fourth Doctor

Brigadier Alistair Gordon Lethbridge-Stewart€™s comment of €œhere we go again€ at the end of Jon Pertwee€™s regeneration story Planet of the Spiders, seems to be incredibly relevant when discussing Tom Baker's debut as the Doctor. Robot is essentially a Jon Pertwee story, with Tom Baker's Doctor slammed in the middle. It€™s Tom Baker's amazing, hilarious, and just perfect performance as the Doctor that really makes this story. Doctor Who legend Terrence Dicks has said that he wrote the Doctor in Robot as manic and crazy, without even knowing who was going to be cast. There are such brilliant moments as the Doctor forcing Harry Sullivan to skip before putting him in a cupboard, and then trying on several different outfits before donning the scarf. Despite the plot being about a giant Robot (good title eh?), who ends up developing feelings, the story is far more about the obviously blossoming trio of Tom Baker, Elisabeth Sladen and Ian Marter. The human villainess is as dastardly as she is dashing and sworthy, whilst being utterly convincing too. The rest of the season would be produced under the guidance of Phillip Hinchcliffe and Robert Holmes, and would see Doctor Who returning to the top of the television tree. Perhaps a purely personal favourite but with wonderful characters (Professor €œOhhhhh NO!!!€ Kettlewell) and excellent scripted eccentricity, it certainly has its moments.

3. Power Of The Daleks - The Second Doctor

This is a tricky one. The great tragedy about the wonderful Patrick Troughton is that hardly any of his stories visually exist in full. To count at the time of writing, there are 7 complete stories, with several stories having gaps filled by wonderfully creative animators, the count rises to 12 (though three of the five animated are currently unreleased). Power of the Daleks is one of the many that has been stripped of the majority of it€™ visuals, and currently has exactly none of it€™s Six episodes available. However, there are reconstructions and a few narrated audio versions available, so it€™s not completely lost. The first post-regeneration story features a bizarre, recorder playing Patrick Troughton, and a shed load of Daleks. The Doctor sees a murder, and is determined to discover the caused before eventually discovering Daleks, much to his chagrin. The Daleks are sneakier than ever, as they manage to convince scientists on the planet Vulcan, to help rebuild them before claiming €œI am your servant!€, which clearly inspired the 2010 Dalek episode Victory of the Daleks. The (key word) eccentricities of the €œrenewed€ Doctor range from sleeping after he€™s had enough, to playing Gilbert and Sullivan on his recorder. This Doctor slowly faded into the recognizably Doctorish Doctor template we see in Tomb of the Cybermen, but this jokerish €œcosmic hobo€ is an interesting take on the Doctor. This David Whitaker written tale of rebellion and death is a sadly missing, and oft remembered classic, that introduced the wonderful Second Doctor to our screens, changing Doctor Who forever.

2. The Eleventh Hour - The Eleventh Doctor

A fairytale, with giant alien eyes, a duckpond, a creepy fish-snake trying to escape from prison, and a very intriguing crack in a very intriguing wall€ The Eleventh Doctors introduction serves as a completely clean slate for the show with a new production team, new Doctor, and a new companion. The Eleventh Hour is the most unique and interesting interpretation of a companion introduction since Turloughs €œmust kill the Doctor€ trilogy with the Fifth Doctor in 1983. Amy Pond meets the Doctor as an 8 year old girl, cooking him dinner before he swans off for 12 years. Returns to find Karen "blimey she's attractive" Gillan dressed as a police officer, with psychological issues relating to a certain " Raggedy Man". Our new man is Tennant-esque from the outset, but recovers after a crack round the head with a cricket bat. Despite losing his sonic screwdriver, his TARDIS and having a new body to cope with, he manages to save the world from being boiled alive by the Atraxi, space police who look like giant eyes (It€™s Doctor Who, go with it). Matt Smith's first episode is beautifully shot, acted, directed and written, and starts the season with a bang. It also sets up the rest of The Eleventh Doctors entire era, with references to €œThe Silence€ the aforementioned Crack, and the Pandorica opening. A New TARDIS, a new outfit (bowties are cool) a new screwdriver, and a new companion, Matt Smiths first outing really feels like something completely new, in a very very good way. I don€™t care what the internet say€™s, Steven Moffat is a genius.

1. Spearhead From Space - The Third Doctor

How could it not be? From the outset it€™s absolutely game-changing stuff. The new Doctor, is exiled on earth by the Timelords after being on trial (see The War Games), he€™s managed to get himself roped into U.N.I.T (United Nations Intelligence Taskforce) his companion is (almost) his intellectual equal, he€™s got a tattoo and he€™s driving a car!? That€™s just onscreen. Offscreen, there€™s a new production team, new lead actor, new €œcompanions€ and the return of several actors from previous stories. Oh and it€™s also the first Doctor Who of the 1970€™s. Oh and it€™s the first Doctor Who that€™s broadcasted in colour. Oh and it€™s shot entirely on film (as opposed to film and video€ it€™s technical stuff) thanks to a BBC production screw up. Of course those aren€™t the only reasons why it€™s at number one. It€™s at number one because it€™s stone cold brilliant. Jon Pertwee€™s Doctor is absolutely mesmerizing, Caroline John€™s performance as scientist Liz Shaw€™s equally brilliant, and Nicholas Courtney€™s Brigadier is as sharp and dashing as he always is. U.N.I.T is very homespun and quaint by todays standards, and it hasn€™t quite reach it€™s potential yet.The concept of the Nestene Intelligence as devised by Doctor Who genius Robert Holmes is so dark and fascinating, despite being so basic. An alien life form that can manipulate plastic to give it life in order to carry out it€™s needs is so firmly based in science fiction, but is also so close to home that it feels genuinely scary. The only slight down point is the confrontation with the Nestene, which features The Doctor doing some incredible facial expressions whilst being strangled by unexplained tentacles, being watched by a perplexed Liz Shaw. On the whole it€™s an absolutely wonderful story, and it€™s a wonderful introduction to a wonderful Doctor. Most fans of the classic era will say that Season 7 (1970) is the best in the show€™s history (see also The Silurians, The Ambassadors of Death and Inferno), and they€™re probably right.

Contributor
Contributor

Massive Doctor Who fan, guitarist, chubby fella with a passion for long coats and heavy metal. Journalism graduate, and comedy fascist. Occasionally spotted in dark alleys dressed as The Undertaker. Tweet me.