Doctor Who: Ranking The Introductions Of Every Doctor

The performances Peter Capaldi has to beat.

The Doctor loves an entrance. Well, any person who has a time travelling blue box is bound to! Once the doors open, the Time Lord strides into wherever he lands like he owns the place, whether that's being a moody Northerner in a leather jacket or donning a ridiculous coat with every conceivable colour on the spectrum. The Eleven Doctors have all had their own introductions to the audience. For the majority of the incarnations, their first scenes are usually lopped onto the end of their predecessors swansong with barely enough time to make an impression. Off-screen, the audience is always well aware of who the next Doctor will be for months before his introduction with the press hordes looking for every juicy detail about the new Doctor. However, the true first impression is found in their first story/episode, written especially for them. Sometimes he's fine, sometimes the regeneration threatens to fail and sometimes he's asleep, but however the new Doctor is introduced, it is usually memorable. With Peter Capaldi's début on its way, hold on as we fire up the TARDIS in a journey backwards and forwards in time to the first ever stories of The Doctor ranked in order of worst to best.

11. The Twin Dilemma

As introductions go, this is possibly the worst for any new character in all of television. The Sixth Doctor (Colin Baker) spends the first half of the story bickering with his inherited companion Peri, who takes an instant dislike to the new man in her life, especially his choice of rainbow style. In his troubled state, The Doctor tries to strangle his companion in the most violent act the Time Lord has ever attempted on his crew. The plan was to make an initially unlikeable Doctor before revealing the warmer core of the character as the seasons went on. It started to pan out in that sense, with The Doctor coming across as pompous and arrogant, considering himself the greatest specimen in the universe. Peri was right about his style with that garish costume, though - it really was unsuitable for the lead character of a drama series. For those still watching, The Doctor meets a Time Lord known as Azmael who together foil the plans of the Gastropods to spread their eggs across the galaxy through an enormous explosion, worked out by kidnapped Earth twins Romulus and Remus via their mathematical equations. Whovians have never let the BBC forget how awful this story is, having voted it the worst in the show's history, in Doctor Who Magazine polls conducted in 1998, 2009 and 2014. Sadly it set the tone for an era full of poor scripts and poor production with an overuse of violence. As first impressions go, this was a failure. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bcwiXY7YCyY

10. Time And The Rani

Having failed to learn some lessons from introducing a new Doctor, the beginning of Season 24 started with a terrible beginning for the Seventh Doctor. Sylvester McCoy has the distinction of playing two different Doctors as the sacked Baker refused to do the regeneration scene in episode one. Sadly for him, this doesn't mean he was twice as good in this story. The Rani (Kate O'Mara) forces the regeneration of the Doctor, in a way unclear on screen - arguably she has the best entrance in the story with "Leave the girl, it's the man I want" line in typical O'Mara style. The renegade Time Lord has kidnapped geniuses across time to use them for a hive mind to manipulate strange matter, which can correct what she considers to be errors in the timeline. Pip and Jane Baker were never the strongest writers for Doctor Who. The Seventh Doctor is introduced as a comical oaf who plays the spoons while, in his troubled state, unable to recognise his own companion - O'Mara's impression of Bonnie Langford's Mel is terrible. The overly comical style failed in this story and really did not help introduce McCoy as a serious enough actor in the role. Luckily, for us all, Andrew Cartmel had just taken over as script editor and over the next three seasons his "masterplan" redeemed the Seventh Doctor as he evolved into one of the darkest and most manipulative of his incarnations. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4_OT2obe710

9. Castrovalva

Tom Baker was a beloved national treasure when he hung up his scarf as the Fourth Doctor, and Peter Davison was already known to his audience by those who watched him in All Creatures Great and Small. Despite the familiar face, his Doctor needed a good start to help the audience get used to a new man in the role. With "Castrovalva", it was never quite right. Everything was new about the show at the time, alongside the new Doctor, Tegan (Janet Fielding) and Nyssa (Sarah Sutton) joined Adric (Matthew Waterhouse) as companions. A new Master - in Anthony Ainley - was still terrorising his old foe after being the villain for the final eight episodes of the previous season. For much of the Fifth Doctor's introduction, the new lead hero spends much of his time lying down or in a wheelchair. In terms of the narrative, this was the first time in the history of the show that a regeneration could be this problematic. The problem with that is the lethargic pace that is presented on screen. The Master sets his trap and The Doctor eventually foils him, but the whole experience is stop/start without really exploring the new Doctor aside from his regenerative struggles. The youthful Doctor was the least agile, at least for his beginning. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JovVVUMD_0w

8. The Power Of The Daleks

With the BBC's haphazard ways of of wiping films to be used again, many of the Second Doctor's stories are lost in the time vortex that is the BBC archive. For whatever reason, the BBC decided not to keep the first episodes of their new Doctor. As such, the modern viewer will never get to see Patrick Troughton take helm of the TARDIS for the first time. However, an audio version of the story does exist, with narration by Anneke Wills (Polly). The story is low on this list for the lack of its existence but more due to the fact the new Doctor is not really seen as an important change. It was a change of character and the audience were pretty much told to accept him, after one episode of Ben and Polly questioning this new man. Maybe if the BBC had cared more about the change, then so would we. If only they had "lost" the previous two stories instead.

7. Robot

Tom Baker is so synonymous with Doctor Who that you forget he had to start off on the show somewhere. He did so in 1974, with an Earth-based story with The Doctor's friends at UNIT. They fight a big robot (which is a man in an awful costume) with the usual guns and even a tank, and anyone who has seen that scene will know the tank is not that impressive. Baker gives us a performance filled with humour, with little signs of the barking delivery we would see in later seasons. There's smiles, wit and even jelly babies. A ruthless side is shown with the finishing of the robot but his delivery is still rather light-hearted. The costume-changing scene was hilarious and one of the memorable scenes of the Fourth Doctor era. The episode is fun and I am sure many still laugh at the special effects on show. You just don't take the four episodes seriously, despite the Science Reform Society's best efforts as villains. As introductions go, it wasn't the strongest for the perennial favourite of the Doctors. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K3CWXqUqPFA

6. Spearhead From Space

A new Doctor has arrived in the shape of Jon Pertwee and you can see him in colour. A new foe is followed with him too - the Autons. This was the earliest example of new changes in the regeneration process with The Doctor spending half of the story in a self-induced coma. The hilarity of a medical doctor, confused at the sight of two hearts with another doctor shouting at him for sending non-human blood was certainly entertaining. It takes time for Pertwee to assert himself on screen but he certainly does with a charm that you instantly warm to, as does new companion Liz Shaw. The Earth Exile story of the new few seasons was also established very well with The Doctor putting the Brigadier in his place. The Autons were certainly frightening with their soulless plastic faces and proved a worthy first foe to the Third Doctor. However, the less said about the fight with the Nestene Consciousness the better... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-ZKKs2mVM08

5. The Christmas Invasion

Another Doctor that suffered from falling asleep on the job was the Tenth Doctor in the first Christmas special in the series. With Christmas in mind, Russell T Davies dipped into his treasure trove of Christmas cheese with robot Santas and spinning Christmas trees that attack. Struggling with post-regenerative symptoms, it is left to Rose, Mickey, Jacqui and Harriet Jones, Prime Minister, to try and save the Earth. Luckily for them, The Doctor is saved by the vapour of a spilt cup of tea to sword fight his way past the Sycorax, after ridiculing them and their plans. It was a triumphant moment. At least this story gave use a glimpse of what the Tenth Doctor would be like with his jokey, cheeky style coupled with a dark serious side in his condemnation of the Sycorax and Harriet Jones' actions alike. He was shown to be more welcoming of Rose's family than his predecessor, leading you to warm to the new Doctor. It isn't a perfect episode. It is dragged down by the Christmas tag but there were moments to enjoy here. Tennant asserts himself as The Doctor very well. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=liGD3vcnpHI

4. Doctor Who: The Movie

Paul McGann burst onto the scene as the Eighth Doctor in the biggest budgeted episode of the series to that point. With the money of FOX behind him and a big audience watching in the UK, big things seemed expected of the only Doctor of the Nineties. Sadly, the Americans, at that time, just didn't get it and it nothing more came of it than this. It was a shame they did not as it was a superb beginning and ending to an on screen era that should have been. The Eighth Doctor slams his way out of the morgue, like Frankenstein's monster, chases the surgeon who caused his operation (and kissing her), is involved in a great motorbike chase and even has time to give cheeky hints of the future to some of the people he meets whilst offering jelly babies. Oh, and h even stopped The Master from destroying the Earth. McGann did all this in his one on-screen story. This episode did not get it right in introducing Doctor Who to a new audience but it did a lot of things well with the audience who wanted it. At least the Eighth Doctor got to shine in the spin-off media. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cKRa06hP6vc

3. An Unearthly Child

On November 23rd 1963, Doctor Who was first broadcast on BBC One. William Hartnell was introduced as the First Doctor in an episode now considered a great example of classic science fiction. The old man in the phone box was introduced as the grumpy Grandfather of super pupil Susan Foreman. In the adventure that follows, he disregards the lives of Ian and Barbara to try and save himself. Effectively, the Doctor kidnaps the two humans to stop them telling the authorities about him. The selfish nature is coupled with even murderous intentions on the cavemen they encounter. The character was given a very alien aura, leaving an uneasy feeling towards this Doctor with no name. Over the the four episodes, although seen best in the first part, that mystery surrounding this time travelling man gets you through what is a drab story - for the first part alone, it is high on this list. As introductions go, the First Doctor had quite the opening with the beginning of a man who would change so much over his fifty years on screen. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hRsfKK34SFY

2. The Eleventh Hour

In 2010, swift changes had been made in Doctor Who, in front and behind the camera. Matt Smith was cast as the Eleventh Doctor by new executive producer and head writer, Steven Moffat. The Tenth Doctor's era had been massively popular with audiences, elevating David Tennant into the popular culture pantheon. Recently, The Moff revealed that the BBC even considered ending the series after his predecessor, Russell T Davies, decided to leave. With such pressure to deliver on the series continuation, it is no wonder the team was on top form with "The Eleventh Hour". Smith owns the screen from start to finish as he messes with the life of Amelia Pond, who grows from an innocent child to a confident kissagram, in a battle to save the Earth from incineration due to Prisoner Zero hiding from the Atraxi. The lack of any real regenerative trouble allowed the new incarnation to really introduce himself, and Smith's ability to seamlessly turn instantly between the light and dark side would become a trademark trait of the Eleventh Doctor. The scenes between young Amelia and The Doctor are wonderful - the first real representation, on screen, of most of the audience's first relationship with the Time Lord. The 65 minutes was so much fun, overall. There was a good story here. It was quite a symbolic moment with Eleven finally completed his costume and stepping out of the hologram of past incarnations before telling the Atraxi to "Run". The Doctor is in. Who da man?! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C_s-b8Z9Suo

1. Rose

Run! The first word uttered by a new Doctor in the relaunch of Doctor Who. Back from its long hiatus, from episodic television, in 2005, the Ninth Doctor and Rose would never stop running in a superb first series. It all started with "Rose", an episode where the Autons have returned to take over Earth. The Russell T Davies penned script dodged the pitfalls of the American movie and introduced Doctor Who to a new audience in the perfect way - continuity-lite with a good story. Christopher Eccleston was the perfect choice as the Ninth Doctor with a performance where you truly believe in this alien Doctor. There's enough wit and charm to counter his darker moments and it's no wonder many enjoyed his portrayal. The northern swagger, in the leather jacket, commanded your attention and you were willing to give it to him. Davies wrote in "The Writer's Tale" that he felt there were some in the BBC who had hoped the relaunch would fail. With "Rose" and many other great episodes to come, this was never going to happen. As introductions in Who go, there is no topping this one... so far. Fantastic! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WX-R1lfycmw

Contributor
Contributor

Graduate Writer. Big gamer. Loves Doctor Who... a lot.