Doctor Who: 10 Actresses Who Could Replace Jenna Coleman

If Clara's on her way out, who could be on their way in?

Rumours have been flying around since before Series 8 finished that Jenna Coleman might be leaving Doctor Who soon. Some 'sources' claimed she was leaving in its finale, Death in Heaven, which ultimately turned out to be false. Others have suggested she'll be leaving in this month's Christmas Special, Last Christmas, which has yet to be determined. Peter Capaldi has told fans that they'll simply have to €œwait and see€ what lies ahead for the impossible girl on Christmas Day, but, most recently, rumours suggest she won€™t be leaving in the festive episode after all, resulting in one very confused fanbase indeed. Regardless of whether she leaves at Christmas or not, Coleman will be leaving the show at some point, even if it€™s after another series. It€™ll probably be before Capaldi goes, too, since he€™s allegedly signed up for Series 9 and 10. Therefore, the person who replaces her will need to have good chemistry with him, as well as the ability to hold their own against the sheer talent he exudes through his performances. No pressure, but there's plenty of actresses out there who are worthy to take on the coveted challenge. The following list will take a look at 10 of them, detailing why they should and shouldn't, and why they might and might not. So, let's get started!

10. Kelly Adams

Why she should be next: Kelly Adams is a British actress who is probably best known for her work in the BBC series Hustle, in which she played Emma Kennedy, one of the team's main con artists, from Series 5 through to Series 8. She acted opposite superb actors such as Adrian Lester and Robert Vaughn and held her own with ease, suggested she€™d also be able to manage opposite Capaldi. Her strengths include a fire and toughness - the foundations of a strong dynamic to have for any actress playing opposite the Doctor. This could be used to introduce a role reversal within the TARDIS, with the the companion mellowing rather than Capaldi€™s incarnation of the Time Lord. This would make for some interesting character drama to keep the viewers hooked. She can also do vulnerability well, a no doubt useful attribute for making the viewers like you whilst facing the various horrors of the universe. Why she shouldn€™t be: She was debatably the least versatile of the Hustle crew. While the likes of Robert Glenister and Lester were transforming believably for the different roles the con artists would play each week, there was rarely the sense that Adams could transform herself in the same way. Often the different roles her character would have to play felt less imbued with less realism than the ones embodied by her co-stars. While realism isn€™t necessarily the key strength of the Doctor Who universe and she could probably no doubt pull a great performance out of the bag, it€™s still a potential cause for concern. She€™s also been a bit unmemorable in a couple of guest roles for shows designed to fill the Doctor Who slot. She had a bit part that no one really remembers in the 2006 Robin Hood series and, while this wouldn€™t necessarily mean she couldn€™t pull off the role of Capaldi€™s new companion, it€™s another cause for concern, especially as the actress filling the role next will have to stand out against the countless others from throughout the show€™s long history.

9. Kate Bracken

being human Why she should be next: Having been the new ghost for the final series of BBC cult hit Being Human, Kate Bracken has previous experience of replacing an actress beloved by an enthusiastic fanbase. Having faced the prospect of following Lenora Crichlow€™s Annie, the last of the original cast left over from the first three series, and the daunting spectre of being relied upon to help revitalise a show, Bracken should be no stranger to the demands of following someone like Coleman. In addition, thanks to Being Human being cancelled after its fifth series, Bracken never really got the chance to settle and show the audience what she could do. She€™s had guest parts in shows like Misfits but hasn€™t really made a role her own since, so Doctor Who would be the perfect vehicle for her to really showcase her talents. Working on Being Human also means she€™s developed a good working relationship with occasional Who writer Toby Whithouse, who has often been tipped as a future showrunner. She€™s able to embody down to earth characters and can manage both the toughness and the vulnerability required for dealing with the Doctor€™s countless enemies. She€™s also a Scot, like Capaldi and showrunner Steven Moffat, which could allow for a good sense of celtic camaraderie between the three. Why she shouldn€™t be: Like Kelly Adams, Bracken was not the stand-out performer from her own show, often being overshadowed by Damien Molony in his role as Hal. There€™s also an argument to be made that the fans didn€™t take her to their hearts in the same way as they did with Crichlow. Furthermore, she€™d best fit a twenty-first century companion role. That€™s right - another modern day human being in the TARDIS. Nine years since the revival, there€™s a sense that the fans are getting a little bit tired of that now and are yearning for something different. It remains to be seen if Bracken could pull that something different off, however. As bad as it sounds, being Scottish could also be a problem. It€™d give Moffat the platform for even more Scottish jokes, and there have already been way too many of those over the last four seasons...

8. India Fisher

Doctor Who India Fisher Why she should be next: So this choice is a bit of a cheat, as India Fisher has already played a Doctor Who companion. She has been Charlotte Pollard - a companion for the Sixth and Eighth Doctors - for Big Finish for many years. This is actually why she€™d be a great choice for some of the older fans who€™ve been avid followers of the Big Finish adventures. What better than to see one of the many companions who only exist in audio form on the screen for the first time? Especially when it€™s a fan favourite like Charley. Her experience in the Who universe would help even if she wasn€™t to reprise the role she€™s played so effectively for Big Finish. She is used to the ridiculousness inherent of some of the alien races that the Doctor and his companion encounter on a regular basis. This helps a great deal with making them seem believable, which is key in getting the audience to suspend their disbelief. When playing Charley, Fisher can get across the sense of a love of adventure. This would be a great dynamic to have on the TARDIS, whether she€™s reprising the role or not, as it would create a sense of just how wondrous the Doctor€™s exploits actually are. She can also get across the sense of keeping deadly secrets from the Doctor, as she did when playing Charley opposite the Sixth Doctor for a brief spell in the audios, which could leave a lot of potential for conflict. Why she shouldn€™t be: While it would be great to see one of the Big Finish companions make the jump from audio to the TV screen, bringing Fisher in as Charley would mean she comes with a lot of baggage. The character has had a number of complicated arcs as part of the audio stories and it would take away from the next series if these all had to be explained to a new audience. It might even cause problems with the BBC charter, which says that shows have to make sense without people having to buy something else first (with a bit of a sizeable definition). While some of the Big Finish audios have been broadcast, this could put the show on dodgy ground. Even with another role, there would still be baggage, as aficionados of the audios would be constantly comparing the new part to Charley. There€™s also the problem that Fisher has very little on-screen experience. Her biggest TV role has been on Masterchef€ as the narrator. While she is a very competent voice actress and a lot of performers have taken to TV like a duck to water, it means she could still be a bit of a gamble.

7. Montserrat Lombard

Why she should be next: Another performer from the BBC€™s vast array of cult hits, having been a regular on Ashes to Ashes, Lombard is a talented actress with experience of acting opposite some of the best actors working in Britain today. She€™s held her own on the screen with Philip Glenister€™s iconic Gene Hunt and provided solid support for Keeley Hawes in the same series. She€™s even got previous experience of working with a Doctor, having been in St Trinian€™s 2: The Legend of Fritton€™s Gold alongside David Tennant. This all suggests that she€™d be comfortable working alongside an actor as talented as Peter Capaldi. She exudes a sense of likeability, a useful trait for any companion to have as it means they€™ll connect with the audience that bit sooner. She€™s got a great range, too, able to play down-to-earth and relatable as well as a bit wacky, so there€™s vast selection of potential characters she could play and directions the show could take under the guise of this new Doctor/companion dynamic. She€™s also got one of the best names in the British acting industry, which is in itself worth casting her. Why she shouldn€™t be: Again, she has not been the most memorable character from the things she€™s been in. Glenister overshadowed her in Ashes to Ashes, Rupert Everett and David Tennant did in St Trinian€™s 2, and in The Imaginarium of Dr Parnassus she€™s in it so little it€™s a surprise to see her name in the credits. While this is probably to be expected of someone who€™s mostly taken supporting roles, and while she can give solid support, it remains to be seen just how well she can handle a lead role, especially on a show as big as Doctor Who. In addition, people from the Life on Mars/Ashes to Ashes universe haven€™t always transferred over well to Doctor Who. Marshall Lancaster was underused in the Gangers two-parter and Keeley Hawes was a bit disappointing in Series 8€™s Time Heist. Matthew Graham, one of the writers of the series, gave Doctor Who Fear Her, arguably one of the least loved episodes since the revival. While John Simm did manage to capture the hearts and minds of the audience as the Master (with a few naysayers who felt his performance was somewhat over the top), it€™s not an otherwise hugely inspiring record. While it€™s no fault of Lombard€™s in particular, it would be a reason to be nervous about her casting.

6. Summer Glau

Why she should be next: Since Steven Moffat took over, the show has been gaining more and more of an American fanbase. Casting an American as the next companion (rather than someone with a dodgy American accent, naming no names *coughs* Peri *coughs*) would do a lot to thank them for their support, and who better than cult queen Summer Glau? Ignoring the fact that she would appeal to an American audience, as that in itself isn€™t the best argument for casting someone, she is an absolutely phenomenal performer. Anyone who has seen her in Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles as the series main Terminator, or as the iconic River Tam in Joss Whedon€™s Firefly, has to admit that she has bags of talent and a great range. This would allow the writers the creative freedom to pick an interesting dynamic with Capaldi and know that they€™d have a memorable character at the end of it. She can play anything from a strangely sympathetic robot to an everyday human whisked away from Earth by the Doctor, so there€™s an awful lot of potential there. She€™s got experience with the whiplash dialogue Moffat writes, having experienced a similar thing working with Whedon€™s scripts, so she€™ll be great at making that side of it seem believable. She€™s also got a lot of experience of interacting with enthusiastic fandoms, so she€™ll be a hit at the many conventions the Doctor Who cast are required to attend. Why she shouldn€™t be: As said before, casting Glau to appeal to Americans wasn€™t the best argument. Well, if the furore over the an American convention getting the first trailer for the 50th anniversary is anything to go by, a lot of British fans aren€™t hugely happy with the increased focus on those over the pond. And it€™s the Brits that pay the license fee to fund the show, after all. Still, that shouldn€™t stand in her way. It€™d be a bit worrying if the only thing the showrunners looked at when casting was someone€™s nationality. Glau is a good enough performer. So good, in fact, that she already has a number of iconic roles to her name which has made her something of a cult hero. This could mean that any role she plays on Doctor Who has the potential to pale in comparison with what she€™s already done. As great a character as River Tam is, the Doctor Who fandom and the people who put the show together probably don€™t want to risk her overshadowing the new character they€™re trying to put on the screen. Another problem with casting Glau is that she€™s got a bit of a reputation as a show-killer. While this is quite unfair, as it€™s rarely, if ever, her performances that are bringing a show down, it€™s there nonetheless. There were numerous jokes about Arrow only lasting two seasons when she was cast in that, and similar jokes would potentially have the power to undermine her being cast in Doctor Who. Even though she insists she€™s not a show-killer, anyone around during the wilderness years would be looking over their shoulder if she was cast, especially given the BBC€™s current push towards cutting things for bigger budgets.

5. Niamh McGrady

Why she should be next: She may be less well-known than other actresses on this list, but Niamh McGrady could be one to watch in the future. She€™s best known for playing PC Danielle Ferrington in the BBC serial killer drama The Fall, where she manages to hold her own against science fiction royalty in the form of Gillian Anderson. In fact, she has some good chemistry with Anderson, so much so that you want to see more scenes of them working together. There€™s the potential basis for a strong Doctor/companion relationship there, with Capaldi instead of Anderson, and this basis could be a springboard for some fantastic stories over the next couple of series of Doctor Who. She manages to make Ferrington, a supporting character, seem resourceful, practical and kind, always having the best interests of the other characters at heart. She€™s also hugely likeable and despite the sense of her many different competencies, she never ceases to be relatable. These are all useful characteristics for someone playing the companion to have, as she€™ll be able to believably play someone who can go head to head with Daleks and Cybermen, all while acting as the audience cipher, which the companion classically is. Given her performance in The Fall, there€™s little doubt she could pull all these off. Why she shouldn€™t be: It€™s a repeated reason but true nonetheless. Like others on this list, she wasn€™t the standout from the show she€™s most famous for. Instead, it€™s Anderson and Dornan who take most of the plaudits. Again, this isn€™t raising doubts about her ability, but she€™s still an unknown quantity when it comes to taking on a lead role. In addition to that, she€™s also quite busy as a performer. She has an ongoing role on hospital drama Holby City and The Fall has potential to go on to Series 3, which she would probably be a key part of. This means she might not have the time for Doctor Who in her busy schedule.

4. Pippa Bennett-Warner

Why she should be next: At times, Series 8 seemed like it was trying out potential new companions, and many fans picked up on that. Maybe the writers felt they needed to try some new ideas to see what worked and what didn€™t. One of the many characters who seemed like they could join the Twelfth Doctor on his travels was Saibra, a human mutant with the ability to change into anyone else by touching them. She was played by Pippa Bennett-Warner, hence the actresses€™ inclusion on this list. Saibra was a hit with sections of the fandom, as was Psi, the character introduced alongside her, so she€™s already got an established connection with the audience. She€™s also got experience of what working on modern day Doctor Who is like due to this previous appearance. It€™s not like there€™s no precedent for actors returning to play companions after a guest role - it€™s already happened with Freema Agyeman, Catherine Tate, Karen Gillan and Jenna Coleman, so Bennett-Warner would be in good company there. There€™s also a lot of potential in the character of Saibra. She€™s a wounded individual, having been unable to make contact with any other human due to her genetics. That could lead to a lot of conflict, but it would also be a great creative challenge for the writers. She wouldn€™t be the modern day companion the fans are tired of, either, which would be an added plus. Why she shouldn€™t be: Even though she€™s only had a guest part in Time Heist, there€™s the feeling that the character of Saibra might be done with already. She got what she wanted; the serum that would supress her genetics and allow her to touch others without transforming into them. Without that, a lot of the potential internal and external conflict for the character could be lost, meaning she would be far less interesting to watch as a result. The decision to have her lose her powers could be undone, but it would be at the cost of negating the end of Time Heist. There€™s also the implication through a lot of fan fervour that she is popular as part of a pair with Jonathan Bailey€™s Psi, and there€™s an argument to be made that if only one of the two is brought back, he€™d be the more interesting choice. Especially since he has all his rediscovered memories to deal with. Even if they brought back both, that would be a bigger expense for a production team already dealing with stretched budgets. Furthermore, there€™s the problem that Time Heist wasn€™t all that loved by the majority of fans. While this doesn€™t mean that the characters can€™t have a fruitful future on the show, the lack of appreciation for the episode they started in might have a negative impact on their reception, especially in the short-term.

3. Louise Brealey

Molly Hooper Sherlock Why she should be next: So the companion needs to be someone who can deal with an abrasive, arrogant genius outsider who nevertheless has the best interests of the world at heart. This sounds like the part Louise Brealey has been playing on Sherlock for the past few years, so she has the experience to show she€™d be good in a similar role. She€™s able to hold her own with fantastic actors such as the now-superstar Benedict Cumberbatch, so she wouldn€™t be overshadowed by Capaldi€™s talent, and she€™s had good chemistry with a lot of her past co-stars too, which suggests she€™d be able to build a good rapport and an interesting relationship between the companion and the Doctor. She€™s also got a good working relationship with both showrunner Steven Moffat and potential future showrunner and regular writer Mark Gatiss as a result of Sherlock. This means that she€™s used to bringing their scripts to life which should help her to hit the ground running. It also means that they€™ll be used to her strengths and weaknesses as an actor, so will be able to write a role that fits her to perfection accordingly. Why she shouldn€™t be: Despite the likes of Arthur Darvill saying they€™d love to work with him again, Steven Moffat doesn€™t have a huge habit of re-using actors. There€™s some crossover between the likes of Sherlock and Doctor Who, but no more than you€™d expect from two shows using the same limited talent pool. More intriguingly, neither show has had a guest performance from lead actors Moffat has used in the past, such as Jack Davenport and James Nesbitt, despite how often they€™ve been linked with the show. Matt Smith, too, was rumoured to have a role in a future Sherlock, but, as far as anything is known goes, that has thus far failed to materialise. All these would count against the chances of Brealey making the jump between shows. In addition, were Brealey to make the coveted leap to Doctor Who companion, it might make the show as a whole feel too similar to Sherlock, increasing the sense of repetitiveness between two shows that share the same writers. Since Doctor Who thrives on feeling refreshed and vibrant, making it appear similar to something that audiences have already seen a lot of might be something best avoided.

2. Zawe Ashton

Why she should be next: As mentioned before, Series 8 often felt like it was trying out new companions. Another role that fitted this description was Zawe Ashton€™s turn as Journey Blue, the human soldier the Doctor saved from being blown up by the Daleks and who joined him on the trip inside one of his mortal enemies. Ashton brought depth to the character, who even wanted to join the Doctor on his journeys (no pun intended), and made a lot of fans wish he had said yes. There€™s a lot of potential for Journey Blue being the next companion. She€™s a soldier, which could mean a lot of challenges towards the Doctor€™s attitude towards them, as well as a lot of conflict between the lead pair as they come to accept each other. This would help to make the start of Series 9 - or whichever series she would actually join on for - gripping and engaging. Furthermore, the Doctor said no to her previous request to join them, so anything happening to change that could lead to some interesting stories. She€™d be following in the footsteps of the previous four female companions in appearing in the show before becoming a full time TARDIS resident. According to IMDB, she has very few projects coming up, suggesting that she would have the time to commit to the intense filming schedule that Doctor Who requires. Why she shouldn€™t be: Journey€™s request to join the TARDIS crew was one of the worst parts of Into the Dalek, as it was barely set up during the story itself. Mostly, it felt forced to allow the Twelfth Doctor to express a distaste for soldiers that would be a key part of his character through the Series 8 arc. While both future writing and Ashton€™s performances could lift the character above this, it would be a cause for concern that the character had gotten off to such a shaky start. There€™s also an argument to be made that the aspect of Ashton€™s performance that most sold Journey as a future companion was the chemistry that she had with Jenna Coleman towards the conclusion. They had a really interesting dynamic between them that implied they would work really well together on a more permanent basis. This would suggest that Ashton might not be the best choice to replace Coleman - instead, it€™d be better if she worked alongside her.

1. Rose Leslie

Why she should be next: Leslie is perhaps the most obvious pick for a list like this, having been extensively linked with the role of Doctor Who companion when the initial rumours of Coleman€™s departure came flooding in. That said, she€™d be pretty good in the role. She can pull off all the aspects required of a successful Doctor Who companion. She's courageous, defiant, confident, vulnerable€ all things that would help make for an interesting character. She€™s also had experience of being in a hit cult series with an enthusiastic fandom. She played Ygritte in Game of Thrones, capturing the hearts of numerous fans before she was cruelly killed off at the end of Series 4. Furthermore, she€™s been in Downton Abbey, playing the role of Gwen Dawson. This means that she will be able to deal with the increased fame, attention and adulation that would come with being a key part of Doctor Who. The two very different roles in two very different cult TV hits suggest that Leslie has a lot of range as well, which will be highly useful for a potential companion, given that it means the writers could take a number of different directions with her character. Why she shouldn€™t be: As with Summer Glau, Leslie€™s past roles could overshadow her making a huge impact as the companion. She€™s very well known as being Ygritte from Game of Thrones, especially having been the character that sparked a thousand memes with €œYou know nothing, Jon Snow€. This would mean it would take her a while to get past that which in turn could mean she struggles to make an immediate impact as the new companion. She's also quite busy, by the looks of things. She has two films currently in production according to her IMDb, so there may be concerns about her ability to commit to Doctor Who€™s schedule, especially if getting into the movies is what she€™s really aiming to do. So, who do you think should be the next companion and why? Is there anyone we missed here? Let us know in the comments below.

Contributor

Adam Livermore hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.