Doctor Who: 10 Times The Doctor Lost

Think you're having a bad day? Bet you've never inadvertently destroyed the universe.

Old Amy Pond The Girl Who Waited
BBC Studios

One thing we learn in almost every single episode of Doctor Who is that the universe can be a dangerous place. Flesh-eating shadows, merciless robots and gigantic arachnids roam the galaxy like it's their own personal playground, and considering that the Doctor is thousands of years old, it's not surprising that the character has suffered countless notable defeats in that long lifetime.

Things don't always result in a cheery stroll back to the TARDIS once the day's adventure has come to a close, and across the classic and modern incarnations of the show, the character has led companions to their deaths, watched the stars explode, killed his own people, and ran into many situations that simply prove unwinnable.

Even though the BBC will never kill off the title character of their flagship show, the Doctor's hijinks usually come at a cost, and often, that cost is high. Things do tend to work out eventually (the show must go on, after all), but the road to get there is rarely smooth, and the ancient Time Lord has tasted many instances of defeat as a result.

10. When Bill Potts Was Turned Into A Cyberman

Old Amy Pond The Girl Who Waited
BBC Studios

In an amazingly taut scene near the start of Peter Capaldi's last series finale, companion Bill Potts is shot through the chest - with a bullet that leaves behind a massive, gaping hole - and drops to the ground.

Here, we get to see just how powerless the Doctor is against something as simple as a gun, and for all his talk about saving the universe and doing the right thing, he can't stop one of his companions from just... being shot. And while Bill's death seems like a bad enough way to start the episode off, things only get worse from here.

Bill's body is taken by a group of sinister-looking doctors, who escort her down to the lower levels of the ship. As things unravel, we learn that these doctors are early descendants of the emotionless Cybermen, and that Bill - in order to restore her life - has been converted into one of them.

It's a nasty turn of events for the kind-hearted Bill to be put through, and this whole situation can be pinned directly on the Doctor himself. He trusted Missy to handle this particular mission, which led to things getting out of hand, which led to Bill taking a bullet, which led to her becoming a Cyberman. The Doctor's overconfidence got the better of him and he messed up, big time, and he only had himself to blame.

In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

WhoCulture Channel Manager/Doctor Who Editor at WhatCulture. Can confirm that bow ties are cool.