Doctor Who: 10 Worst Things Amy Pond Has Ever Done

Who doesn't love Amy Pond? But it can't be avoided she has made a few questionable decisions.

Doctor Who Amy Pond
BBC

When it returned for its fifth series in 2010, Doctor Who saw its greatest changes since returning in 2005. The series, opening with the Eleventh Hour, saw the first full appearance of the Eleventh Doctor, as played by Matt Smith, and Steven Moffat took over as show runner, as well as featured the first new TARDIS interior and sonic screwdriver. But what is the Doctor without their companion, and series five gave us Amy Pond.

Played by Karen Gillian, Amy became an instant hit with fans, and her tenure is heavily praised for the enthusiasm she brought to the role, as well as clear chemistry with co-stars Smith and Arthur Darvill, who played her husband Rory. The grouping of 11th, Amy and Rory are highly regarded as one of the greatest TARDIS teams in the shows history.

Now whilst this list is technically negative towards some of the actions made by Amy during the show, it is in no way intended to pick at Gillian, Moffat or anyone else in the shows production. As mentioned, this TARDIS team is regarded as one of the greatest put together and the era as a whole is very highly enjoyed.

However, as is very common for a Doctor Who companion, Amy has made some questionable decisions during her TARDIS adventures...

10. Space/Time - Wearing A Skirt

Doctor Who Amy Pond
BBC

Now this entry maybe a little unfair on Amy's choice of outfit (a rather short skirt), but this choice could have led to a significant space-time catastrophe!

As a part of Series 6, 2011 saw several mini-episodes filmed aboard the TARDIS, filling in little adventures between the main episodes. Two such mini-sodes were Space and Time. This two-part short saw Rory assisting the Doctor with TARDIS repairs when something goes wrong, and so the TARDIS materialises at the nearest safe place. The issue is, the nearest safe place is within the TARDIS itself. This results in a Logopolis type situation where there are two TARDIS's within one another. But what has this got to do with Amy's skirt? Well...

The Eleventh Doctor's first TARDIS is a beautiful design, part of which is a glass floor raising the console up above the maintenance section, where Rory is. So, without obviously going into too much detail, our dear Rory looks up to the Doctor and Amy (wearing the skirt in question) and as a result Mr Williams drops a thermocoupling, setting the events of the mini-sode in motion.

Once everything starts going pear shaped, Amy even apologies to the Doctor saying it was "my skirt, and my husband, and your glass floor", which of course takes our innocent Eleventh Doctor a few seconds to catch onto. As it is Doctor Who, in the end all is resolved, but the Doctor does insist Amy puts so trousers on...

You can watch the Comic Relief mini-sode below:


9. The Girl Who Waited - Pressing The Wrong Button

Doctor Who The Girl Who Waited Amy Pond
BBC

Again, maybe not a situation that Amy could have helped, but it is a mistake which easily could have been avoided and stopped a whole chain of awful events taking place.

Series 6, The Girl Who Waited ends with one of the most tragic ends to a Doctor Who story. And it all revolves around one choice. Quickly summing up how the events of the story kicks off, the TARDIS arrives at the Two Streams Facility, and the Doctor and Rory wander out, and are presented with two buttons, Red Waterfall and Green Anchor. Rory chooses the Green Anchor and waits in a room with the Doctor.

Amy then comes out from the TARDIS after looking for her phone and is presented with the same two buttons. She asks what to do and is simply told "press the button", resulting in her choosing Red Waterfall, leaving her in a room completely different to the boys. As a result, the episode tragically plays out, and will be addressed properly in a later entry.

But these events didn't need to happen. Okay, yes, equal blame could be given to Rory and the Doctor for not specially telling Amy which button to press, but equally she could have asked more specifically. This may not sound like a grave action, but those who know the episode will definitely feel this tragedy could be avoided.

Didn't your parents (or Aunt Sharon) tell you not to randomly press buttons, Amelia?


8. The Beast Below - Reckless Decision Making

Doctor Who The Beast Below Amy Pond
BBC Studios

The Beast Below is Amy's first trip in the TARDIS, picking up directly from her and the Doctor's departure in the closing scene of the Eleventh Hour. And straight away, she's making decisions with potentially awful consequences.

With the revelation that the Starship UK is being transported through a tortured Star Whale the Doctor is left with a decision to see if he can save the creature, or as harmlessly as possible put the creature out of its misery. As is a theme throughout the story, there are two buttons with two options, this time presented to Liz Ten. She can either abdicate (releasing the creature), or get on with the way things are going with no memory. But Liz doesn't make this choice.

Amy sees that the Star Whale is kind to the children, and believes that it is here by its own free will. As a result of her theory, she makes Liz abdicate, and the torture of the beast halts, potentially leaving Starship UK to be destroyed. With that the ship rubbles, but then stops. The Star Wale continues to help the ship travel through space.

So whilst it all worked out for the best in the end, there is no way Amy could have been certain her actions would end as positively as they did. What if it didn't? Well, the whole of Starship UK would have been destroyed killing the entirety of the population of England, Wales and Northern Ireland (but not Scotland - they wanted their own ship).

That's two entries in a row where Amy is making questionable decisions with buttons, thankfully this one was the right choice, but the alternative would have been horrific.


7. Asylum Of The Daleks - Not Properly Talking To Rory

Doctor Who Asylum of the Daleks Amy Pond Rory
BBC Studios

Series 7A features the last five episodes to feature Amy and Rory travelling with the Doctor. By this point, after series 6, the couple from Leadworth travel more on a now and then basis. But, as shown in prequel mini-sode Pond Life, "something is wrong with Amy and Rory".

When we are first reintroduced to Amy and Rory for the series, Amy is at a modelling job, and after being told her husband is here, she heartbreakingly replies "I don't have a husband". Going to her dressing room, she is met by Rory, who is waiting for her to sign divorce papers. The story goes on and the two are separately captured by the Daleks and taken to their Parliament before being sent into the titular Dalek Asylum along with the Doctor.

Later in the story, whilst the Doctor is off trying to collect Oswald, the Ponds (or really Williams) begin to discuss why they are separating. Rory reveals Amy kicked him out, the couple argue and Amy breaks down revealing she did not kick him out, rather she gave him up. We learn Rory has always wanted kids, and after whatever was done to her at Demons Run last series, Amy can no longer get pregnant. Everything gets more emotional, before they discover Amy has the Doctor's bracelet and so is now safe.

Now waiting for the Doctor, and the Asylum beginning to be destroyed, Rory asks how long they can wait to teleport off. To that Amy responds "for the rest of our lives", they kiss and seemingly everything's okay again by the end of episode.

Whether a slightly rushed script element or not, it can't not be said whether would the two have reached the stage of near divorce if they would have actually spoke to each other properly, rather than the argument and storming off we are shown.


6. The Girl Who Waited - Not Saving Herself

Doctor Who Amy Pond
BBC

We've already mentioned the Girl Who Waited and the first questionable decision of the episode, but moving on from that, is another questionable decision.

By Amy entering the Two Streams Facility by the alternative button, she finds herself on a faster time track. When Rory finally gets into the facility, Amy has waited for 36 years, and has totally changed and grown whilst trapped. Eventually, the Doctor and gang get a plan to restore their younger Amy and get her out of the facility. However, in doing so, the Doctor convinces older Amy that he can save them both, allowing them both to live.

However, time doesn't work like that. You remove younger Amy, then older Amy can never exist, and in the end older Amy realises this. Knowing she will cease to exist, older Amy demands to be taken with the Doctor and Rory, rather than giving back the younger version of herself.

If you think about it, it's not out of Amy's character; she's been through so much, you can understand why she would be selfish about this matter. But she would also know that a happier Amy would take her place. This poor older Amy has lived alone with a robot companion for 36 years, why would she not want the proper life with her husband and best friend for her younger self?

In the end this could come down to a wanting to survive. But when you know you could give yourself a better life, would you take it? Who knows.


5. Flesh And Stone - Kissing The Doctor, The Night Before Her Wedding...

Doctor Who The Doctor Amy Pond Flesh And Stone
BBC Studios

This is the big one for a lot of people really, but let's get inside Amy's head for a minute.

Amy has just been through an ordeal. The Doctor, Amy, River and Clerics have just climbed out of the Byzantium, in which Amy had an Angel in her mind and had to climb out with her eyes shut (or did she?). For anyone, that seems pretty traumatic.

After this, she asks to go home and show the Doctor what she's running from, returning to Amy's bedroom, the night before her wedding. She reveals the dress and engagement ring to him, saying this is what she ran away from during the closing moments of the Eleventh Hour. After this, Amy tells the Doctor that she needs comforting, and proceeds to make advances on him. He tells her that 907 years old, and that this wouldn't work out, but still she continues to try it. In the end, as we all know, Amy kisses and tries to undress an awkward Eleventh, and even jokes at the fact he considers this more than just a one night stand!

Realising the incoming date of the 26/06/2010, he quickly collects Amy and hurries them into the TARDIS, to avoid the incoming temporal explosion, which she believes to be a further advancement. And with that the episode closes.

Most people may personally feel this is the worst thing Amy ever did, and maybe it is. Cheating, the night before her wedding night to one of Doctor Who's most precious companions Rory, for some weakens Amy's character. But maybe it is not that deep, and the rest of the entires on this list are worst than a bit of a snog with her Raggedy Man.


4. The Impossible Astronaut - Shooting The Astronaut

Doctor Who The Impossible Astronaut Amy Pond
BBC

The sixth series of New Who begins with the Impossible Astronaut, which kicks off the timey-wimey story arc of the events which take place at Lake Silencio. In these opening moments, Amy amongst others, witnesses an astronaut step out of the lake and seemingly kill the Eleventh Doctor.

Jump forward in time to the closing moments of the story, where the TARDIS team go back in time to the year of the moon, Amy and a younger Eleventh Doctor are met by the same Astronaut. In a heated cliffhanger, the Astronaut approaches, and Amy picks up a gun. Whilst busy picking up the gun, the Astronaut lifts its mask, revealing a little girl, but Amy instantly fires the gun, before even realising this, trying to eliminate the potential threat to her friend without second thought. Obviously guns are not something the Doctor approves of, and so when asked what she is doing, Amy simply responds "saving your life".

Later in the series, the audience learns that the person inside the suit is actually Amy and Rory's daughter, who grew up without her parents, so that's some potential trauma for your first meeting with your mum being her taking a headshot at you. Thankfully, Amy is an appalling shot and misses the little girl, and simply damages the suit.

We know Amy takes this drastic action to save her friend, but it is another example where she seems to act before any thought. But again, luckily this does not come with any horrific ramifications.


3. The Angels Take Manhattan - Risking Time And Space For Her Husband

Doctor Who Amy Pond Graveyard
BBC

Amy and Rory's departure from the show comes in the form of a clash with the Weeping Angels, in the Series 7A finale. This is maybe an incredibly sweet moment, but was also potentially catastrophic...

After already having thrown themselves off a block of flats to crash a timeline in which Rory is previously got by the Angels, the couple reawaken in a graveyard along with the Doctor, River and the TARDIS. But this graveyard has popped up in the episode before, and we're left to wonder its significance, well here it comes.

When the team wanders back into the TARDIS, Rory spots a gravestone with the same name as him. ZAP. An Angel gets him, and once again he's sent back in time, to the horror of his wife. Asking if once again they can go back in the TARDIS and collect him, but apparently another such trip would rip the universe in half. Thinking there is room on the gravestone for another name, Amy decides to make what could be considered an ultimate sacrifice.

After the various escapades of the episode, creating paradoxes to stop the angels, Amy decides to create a fixed point in time, by letting the angel touch her too and find herself in the same time as her dear husband. Taking time and space into her own hands for the man she loves does seem very much in Amy's character, whether it is the wrong thing or not. Either way, it's a moment that really breaks the Eleventh Doctor.


2. The Wedding Of River Song - Killing Madame Kovarian In Cold Blood

Doctor Who The Wedding Of River Song Amy Pond
BBC

"But you'll still save me, though. Because he would, and you'd never do anything to disappoint your precious Doctor". That's a quote from Madame Kovarian, seconds before being killed by Amy in the series 6 finale.

As you should already know, series 6 is a beast of a story when it comes to its series arc, all coming to a conclusion in a timeline where River refuses to kill the Doctor. In the closing moments of this story, all our heroes present are doing Nick Fury impressions by wearing eye patches (or eye drives rather), which they believe allows them to view the Silence. However, these turn out to simply be a ruse, and the eye drives turn on their wearers as they begin zapping them.

Madame Kovarian, believing she is incharge of the Silence, thinks herself safe from this massacre, incorrectly. Kovarian's drive begins twitching too, leaving her also to get zapped. In order for the Doctor, River and Amy to escape Rory stays behind, keeping his eye drive on to defend them from the incoming silence. As they burst through, Rory goes down from the pain of the deadly eye drive, about to die once again. Until...

Amy returns with a machine gun, and mows the incoming Silence down. Brutal, but justifiable to save the man she loves in another timeline. What isn't so justifiable is her actions towards Madame Kovarian. Amy goes over to the still conscious Kovarian, has a little exchange with her over what she'd done to her daughter, and reapplies the eye drive firmly, allowing it to kill her as she casually walks off.

Yes, Kovarian turned Amy's daughter into psychopath, but is casually murdering someone in her character? Maybe.


1. Rory Williams Or The Doctor?

Doctor Who Night Terrors Eleventh Doctor Amy Pond Rory
BBC

When we first meet adult Amy Pond we learn that her first encounter with the Doctor when she was younger left quite the impression. The little girl from Leadworth had everything from custom figures of the Doctor and TARDIS to making her future husband dress up in 'cosplay' of him.

But a thread of Amy's character, especially in her first two series, is whether the Doctor or Rory was more important to her. Yes, both characters were significant in her life from a young age, but were both vastly different from one another, obviously. As shown by a previous entry in this list, in the end Amy risks time itself, but before that Rory still questioned their relationship.

Most of us know what it's like to compared to someone else, but imagine that person is a 1,200 year old Time Lord? How does one live up to that. Particular examples include Vampires in Venice and the Day of the Moon, where Rory feels totally overlooked compared to the Doctor. An argument can be made that Rory is very insecure about the situation and should simply trust his Fiancé. However, we've all seen the Eleventh Hour to the Angels Take Manhatten, and whilst we do see the couple grow, we also see Rory get unfairly treated from time to time.

Technically the Williams get their happily ever after, but her early treatment of Rory is largely wrong. Amy is an exceptional companion, but just not always the best person, especially to her Rory...


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a simple man, trying to make my way in the universe