Doctor Who: 10 Worst Things The Twelfth Doctor Ever Did

What are the worst things that the Doctor with the attack eyebrows ever did?

Doctor Who Hell Bent
BBC

As Jodie Whittaker's time in the TARDIS is drawing to a close and people wait for news on the casting of the Fourteenth Doctor, it's a reminder of how regeneration is possibly the greatest concept a TV show has come up with for ensuring longevity.

Every few years the actor playing the current incarnation of the time traveller will exit and a new actor steps in to take their spot as the iconic Doctor. However, for all the good the Doctor has done, it's worth remembering that isn't always the case.

Despite their mantra being "never cruel or cowardly" this doesn't mean the Doctor is above questionable actions. In fact, throughout Doctor Who's nearly-60-year run, every incarnation of the Doctor has committed actions that are at the very least morally grey.

This is especially true when it comes to certain regenerations, such as Sylvester McCoy's Seventh Doctor or David Tennant's Tenth Doctor. It's also true of Peter Capaldi's Twelfth Doctor; while he does soften over the course of his run, he was still at times more willing to take drastic action than some other versions of the Doctor would be.

Here's a look back at the times where Twelve really let his ruthlessness come through.

10. Using Maisie As Bait In Mummy On The Orient Express

Doctor Who Mummy On The Orient Express
BBC Studios

Given the situations the Doctor often gets tangled up in they often have to make tough calls in order to save as many people as possible. However, in Mummy On The Orient Express the Doctor's pragmatism seems particularly cruel.

The titular Mummy only appears to those it's about to kill, therefore the Doctor has limited information to work with and uses the people about to die as opportunities to learn as much as he can. Enter Maisie, who's an emotionally vulnerable passenger on the train - and the Mummy's next target.

The Doctor convinces Clara to lie to Maisie and tell her he's has found a way to save her. Fortunately the Doctor does manage to stop her from dying, saying he only lied because he couldn't risk letting the AI running the train in on his plan.

Later on, though, the Doctor confesses that he wasn't sure he could save her, meaning that he was willing to use Maisie as bait if he needed too. While the Doctor was in a tough spot with no ideal options, he did gamble with the life of someone who was in distress for his benefit.


9. Lying About Not Being Blind In Pyramid At The End Of The World

Doctor Who The Pyramid at the End of the World Twelfth Doctor blind
BBC Studios

Everyone knows the Doctor is prone to lying. Unfortunately, the Doctor's aversion to the truth doesn't always play out in their favour.

In the Series 10 episode Oxygen, the Doctor loses his sight while attempting to save Bill. He tells her it's only temporary and at the end of the episode he assures her that his blindness has passed. However, two episodes later the Doctor gets trapped in a lab that's about to explode and confesses to Bill he is still blind and can't enter the code to get out.

This forces Bill to make a deal with the Monks, a hostile alien race, who restore the Doctor's vision but at the cost of giving them rule of Earth. While the Doctor couldn't have known this would happen, his reluctance to tell Bill he was still blind meant she was put in a difficult situation where she either had to let her friend die or risk the fate of the planet to save him.

Had she have known from the start it's possible that her, the Doctor and Nardole could have better planned around the Doctor's lack of sight. While not a terrible action on the part of the Doctor, his lying did needlessly complicate the situation.


8. Using O'Donnell As Bait In Before The Flood

Alice O'Donnell Doctor Who
BBC

In the two-part Under the Lake and Before the Flood, the Doctor and Clara land on an underwater base where the crew are being attacked by what appears to be ghosts. One of these crew members is Alice O'Donnell, a systems technician who is also a fan of the Doctor.

The Doctor decides to travel back in time to figure out what caused the ghosts, taking O'Donnell and another crew member with him. After they leave a ghost of the Doctor appears in the base and he's repeating a list of all the characters' names.

The Doctor manages to deduce that this list is likely the order that they're going to die - and O'Donnell is next.

Upon realising this the Doctor decides not to inform O'Donnell of her impending fate, something that leads to her dying moments later. Even Bennett, a close friend of O'Donnell, states that it was as if the Doctor wanted to test his theory, which the Doctor doesn't deny.

While she may have still died even if she knew her life was in danger, as it stands the Doctor took no direct action to protect her and all for the sake is seeing if he was correct.


7. Making Bill Shoot Him In Lie Of The Land

Doctor Who Lie Of The Land Bill
BBC

Across multiple incarnations the Doctor has had a habit of playing mind games with both friend and foe alike, but what the Twelfth Doctor puts Bill through in the episode The Lie Of The The Land shows how far the Doctor can go when messing with people.

In the episode a hostile alien species known as the Monks have conquered the planet and the Doctor makes regular broadcasts to humanity in support of them. However, Bill believes he's playing the Monks and with the help of Nardole she tries to rescue him.

Surprisingly though, the Doctor claims he has really joined the Monks, claiming they will save humanity from self destruction. When Bill realises that with the Doctor's help the Monks will be unstoppable, she takes a gun and shoots the Doctor, only for it to be revealed that this was an elaborate trick to test Bill.

Surely for someone as smart as the Doctor, he could have come up with a better way to see if Bill was secretly working for the Monks than putting her through an emotional rollercoaster.

Instead the Doctor's plan was to verbally berate Bill until she's in enough distress to want to shoot the Doctor - showing little regard for her wellbeing.


6. Leaving Davros In The Magicians Apprentice

Doctor Who young Davros
BBC

The Doctor's temptation to kill Davros is something that has stretched far back into Classic Who. As the creator of the Daleks, Davros has probably caused more death and destruction than anyone else in the universe, and it's understandable why the Doctor would consider putting a stop to him permanently.

In the Series 9 premiere the Doctor almost succumbs to this desire when he encounters a young Davros in mortal danger. While the Doctor does initially try to help, when he learns the identity of the child he leaves him to his fate.

The Doctor can be ruthless when it comes to dealing with his enemies, but to leave a child to die is cold and something you'd more expect to come from a villain - not the hero of the show.

Typically the Doctor is someone who often goes out of their way to save their enemies, including Davros himself in episodes like Journey's End.

While the Doctor does go back and save him, it's only after learning that this act of mercy would let him save Clara in the future. If not for that it's possible he would have never gone back to help, leaving a child helpless and afraid.


5. Leaving Clara Alone In Deep Breath

Doctor Who Deep Breath
BBC Studios

Regeneration is always a complicated process for the Doctor and it's not uncommon for the Doctor to be a little off their game after regenerating. However, the Doctor is at least used to regeneration, less so for any companions who are with them.

For Clara Oswald this proved to be even more challenging, as the Twelfth Doctor wasn't the easiest Doctor to get on with at the start. Especially after he left her in mortal danger during their first adventure together.

When the Doctor and Clara are investigating a restaurant that's a front for androids that are harvesting humans, the two get separated. Clara ends up trapped in a room with the androids and, rather than try and save her or even offer any words of comfort, the Doctor leaves.

Of course being the Doctor he does come back to save her, but he still did leave her and didn't offer any reassurance that he'd come back. It's little wonder Clara took some time to adjust to Twelve after an experience like that.


4. Abandoning Ashildr In The Girl Who Died

Doctor Who Ashildr
BBC

The Doctor more than most should know immortality can be more of a curse than a blessing, so it's all the more puzzling why he'd subject that fate to someone else.

When the Doctor and Clara travel to a Viking village they encounter Ashildr, a farmer's daughter who helps the to save her village from the control of an alien species called Mire. Unfortunately, while the Mire were fended off, Ashildr was killed in the process.

Feeling guilty over her death and the countless other people the Doctor has lost, he decides to use Mire technology to revive her, but in doing so makes her immortal. Later in the episode when talking to Clara, he even confesses that he acted rashly and may have made a terrible mistake.

What's worse is that he abandons Ashildr, meaning she is completely unprepared for what she's about to experience. When the Doctor encounters her again he discovers she's lived a lifetime of pain and loss.

While the Doctor was trying to save Ashildr, his rashness lead to all the suffering she's had to endure. If he wanted to save her, he could have talked to her before leaving and tried to prepare her for what she was going to experience.


3. The Way He Treated Danny Pink In The Caretaker

Danny Pink Doctor Who
BBC

A common trait among NuWho Doctors is their distrust of people in the military, something that is often implied to be part of their own guilt for participating in the Time War. However, while distrust is one thing, his treatment of Danny Pink was actively cruel.

Danny is a maths teacher at the school Clara works at, and the two eventually develop a relationship. Danny is also an ex-solider, which the Doctor takes an immediate disliking to when they first meet in the episode The Caretaker.

Even before he knows Danny is Clara's boyfriend, the Doctor is standoffish and rude as he frequently questions Danny's intelligence and ability to teach maths, condescendingly referring to him as PE. Then when he does find out about Clara and Danny's relationship, his attitude is even worse, going from patronising to actively aggressive.

This is all later explained as him thinking Danny isn't good enough to Clara, but that doesn't excuse the way the Doctor treated him. It's possible that if the Doctor had gotten to know Danny they could have bonded over their negative experiences in combat. Unfortunately the two would remain antagonistic towards each other thanks to the Doctor's initial hostility.


2. Abandoning Clara, Courtney And Lundvik In Kill The Moon

Doctor Who Kill The Moon Twelfth Doctor Clara Oswald
BBC

The infamous Kill The Moon; there are few episodes that have such a negative reputation as this and for good reason. Not only does it engage with some of the loosest science fiction the show has ever done - which is saying something for Doctor Who - but it includes one of the most callous acts the Doctor has committed.

In this episode it's revealed that apparently the Moon is a giant egg and the characters are forced to make the choice whether to let it hatch and risk the lives of everyone on Earth or kill the baby and save the Earth. Either option isn't ideal and someone with the knowledge and wisdom of the Doctor should be a major asset. So what does the Doctor do? Leave.

While the Doctor later justifies this by saying he can't make decisions that big for humanity and they had to make choice for themselves, it's hard to argue he did the right thing by just abandoning the situation.

To make matters worse, one of the people he leaves to make that choice is Courtney Woods, who's only a teenager and thanks to the Doctor she gets left in an incredibly tense and dangerous situation.


1. Everything The Doctor Does To Try And Save Clara In Hell Bent

Doctor Who Gallifrey Hell Bent
BBC

Most of the worst things this Doctor did could have come just from this episode, but instead of pick out everything bad the Doctor does in Hell Bent, it's easier to just put the whole episode at number one.

In Hell Bent, the Doctor is still suffering from grief over the loss of Clara and decides to break all his own rules save her. He uses Time Lord technology to pull her out of her timeline and is told that doing this could risk fracturing time as her death is a fixed point. When told this, the Doctor, who appals the use of guns and violence, shoots the Time Lord General, causing him to regenerate.

He then steals a TARDIS and travels to the end of the universe to keep Clara safe. He even plans to wipe her memory of him against her will so the Time Lords won't find her.

Eventually the Doctor does come to his senses but only when talked down by both Ashildr and Clara. If not for them, he could have risked destroying the entire universe.

This is not just one of the most selfish things that this Doctor did, but one of the most selfish things any Doctor has done. Making this easily the worst thing that the Twelfth ever did.


In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Alex Paget hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.