Doctor Who: 12 Best Twelfth Doctor Episodes

It'll take a lot longer than 4.5 billion years to get bored of Peter Capaldi's greatest episodes!

Doctor Who Peter Capaldi
BBC

Matt Smith left huge shoes to fill when his time in the TARDIS came to an end. Fortunately, Peter Capaldi quickly proved himself to be a magnificent replacement, bringing greater darkness to the Doctor and taking his heroism and compassion to new heights.

The Twelfth Doctor’s era represented a creative triumph for Doctor Who, thanks to Capaldi’s acting abilities and the imaginative genius of Steven Moffat, who maintained a brilliant standard of storytelling with the aid of other talented writers like Jamie Mathieson, and ingenious directors such as Rachel Talalay.

Considerable credit for the success of the Twelfth Doctor’s era is owed to his superb companions. Clara, Bill and Nardole all had engaging, multifaceted personalities, and proved themselves to be the Doctor’s equals in their thrilling adventures. Capaldi’s tenure also pitted the Doctor against some phenomenal opponents, ranging from new hostile species to classic villains taken in bold, original directions.

From the beginning of his quest to discover who he really was, to his decision to regenerate once again despite the losses he’d suffered, the Twelfth Doctor was a riveting presence, and his journey was a joy to watch.

Now, the time has come to stand with him, and relive the greatest stories of the Capaldi era...

12. Mummy On The Orient Express

Mummy Orient Express
BBC

“Start the clock.” An excellent combination of the classic “base under siege” formula and an Agatha Christie mystery, Mummy on the Orient Express proved that Jamie Mathieson had a natural talent for writing great Doctor Who. The 66-second countdown made the Foretold’s appearances all the more intense as it slowly closed in on its victims, and was brilliantly realised thanks to the on-screen clock graphic and some clever editing.

The revelation of the journey’s true nature upped the stakes even further, as Gus took full control of the train and tasked the gathered experts to work for their lives. Combining callousness with cordiality, the mysterious AI’s twisted personality provided additional flavour and drama to an already gripping tale.

Mummy on the Orient Express also included some great character moments, and represented a turning point in the Doctor and Clara’s relationship, as the Doctor won back Clara’s trust and shared the burden of impossible choices with her, and Clara realised that she couldn’t live without her travels with the Doctor. Clara’s decision to lie to the Doctor and Danny about her decision to remain in the TARDIS gave her character further complexity, and would result in painful repercussions.


11. The Zygon Inversion

Doctor Who Clara The Zygon Inversion
BBC Studios

With Clara replaced by Bonnie and the Doctor in mortal danger, the Zygon Inversion began with the Time Lord in a desperate position. It quickly proved even more exciting and imaginative than its predecessor, as Clara managed to take control of her dreamscape surroundings and save the Doctor’s life in the nick of time.

The thrills didn’t stop coming, as Bonnie interrogated Clara over the Osgood Box in a riveting battle of wills, and Kate turned the tables on Truth or Consequences through a cunning deception (complete with a great reference to the Brigadier).

The episode featured superb character work, as Osgood and the Doctor bonded on their journey to save Clara and encountered the tragic Etoine, whose hopes of living in peace were dashed by Bonnie's ruthless dedication to her vision. Clara and Bonnie also established a great dynamic, which allowed Jenna Coleman to showcase her amazing range as a performer.

The story culminated with an unforgettable confrontation in the Black Archive, as the Doctor drew on his compassion and memories of the Time War to try and convince Kate and Bonnie to stand down. Peter Capaldi’s acting was phenomenal, and his beautiful speech raised powerful points about war and forgiveness. It was heart-warming to see him finally succeed in his efforts, and ensure that the peace would survive.


10. Last Christmas

Doctor Clara Hug Last Christmas
BBC

Featuring nightmarish monsters, an intelligent plot and strong character development, Capaldi’s first Christmas special was anything but festive fluff. The Kantrofarri were an impressive, grotesque creation, that provided the episode with some considerable scares as they hunted down their prey. Moffat did an excellent job of building the layered dreams, gradually undermining the faith of the characters (and audience) in the reality they could see, and bringing them to the chilling realisation that they were all slowly dying.

The supporting characters were compellingly brought to life, and established a believable group dynamic which did a great job of concealing the artifice of the dreams. The presence of a snarky Santa balanced the episode with some levity, as well as providing touching moments of hope and comfort.

Last Christmas also did a beautiful job of addressing the loss of Danny, as Clara came to terms with her grief and moved forwards. Danny’s final moments on the show were a fitting tribute to his heroism and love for Clara, and his last lines were truly poignant. With Clara and the Doctor given a second chance and setting off to resume their travels, the episode ended on a joyful note.


9. Oxygen

Doctor Who Oxygen
BBC

Jamie Mathieson showed his considerable worth as a writer once again with this grim space adventure, that may have deterred many a would-be astronaut. Exploring the harsh realities of travelling in a vacuum, Oxygen maintained an atmosphere of fear and intensity as the Doctor, his companions and the Chasm Forge survivors were relentlessly hunted by the corpse-carrying suits through a hostile environment. Making nightmare fuel out of matter-of-fact occurrences like malfunctioning suits and limited oxygen supplies, few Doctor Who episodes had ever been as terrifying.

The concept of corporate-dominated space travel was an ingenious one, as the cast were charged for the air they breathed and realised that they really were “fighting the suits”. It also paved the way to a brilliant resolution, as the Doctor saved the lives of his allies by making their survival more profitable than their deaths.

Oxygen was a particularly brutal experience for the Doctor, who sacrificed his sight in order to protect Bill from the vacuum (that dodgy suit has a lot to answer for). While the Doctor’s genius and resourcefulness enabled him to triumph at Chasm Forge regardless, the revelation that he hadn’t been able to restore his eyesight ended the episode on a chilling note.


8. Flatline

Doctor Who Flatline That's Just Weird
bbc

One of Season Eight’s most inventive episodes, Flatline confronted the Doctor and Clara with an outstandingly conceived and realised foe in the Boneless. The mixture of superb writing, direction and visual effects that brought these monsters to life represented a true creative tour de force, as the creatures hunted through two dimensions before evolving into grotesque, flickering 3D forms.

Similar praise is owed to the other inventive uses of space and dimension within the episode, particularly with regards to the TARDIS. It was hilarious to watch the Doctor become trapped inside his shrunken vessel, and interact with his surroundings using his comparatively giant hand. It was particularly fun to watch him manoeuvre the TARDIS away from an approaching train, in another special effects triumph.

Flatline was also a great showcase for Clara, that had her assume the Doctor’s role with the Time Lord out of action. She quickly demonstrated how much she’d learned on her travels, confidently taking charge of the frightened community service team and devising a cunning plan to restore power to the TARDIS and defeat the Boneless.

Her time as the Doctor also gave greater insight into her flaws, as she quickly considered deceiving those under her protection to give them hope, and continued to lie to Danny. With even the Time Lord himself admitting that Clara had been “an exceptional Doctor”, Flatline continued to consolidate her place as one of the greatest companions of all time.


7. Face The Raven

Doctor Who Clara Face the Raven
BBC

Face the Raven was shaping up to be a strong episode even before its tragic ending, with the sinister countdown tattoo and imaginative Trap Street concept providing plenty of great material. The nature of the street’s concealment and the scene in which the Doctor, Clara and Rigsy tracked it down gave it a true air of mystery and originality, and stoked expectations for its discovery. Trap Street itself was a spectacular design, combining a magical, Dickensian setting with an array of classic Doctor Who aliens. The episode then seemed to turn into a mystery, with the Doctor and Clara attempting to discover the truth behind Anah’s “murder” before time ran out for Rigsy.

In reality, a far more complex scheme was at work, which ultimately used the Doctor’s compassion to trap him. But the worst was yet to come, as it was revealed that Clara’s attempt to buy time by taking the chronolock had in fact sealed her fate. The farewell between the Doctor and Clara was performed with great sensitivity by Capaldi and Coleman, and Clara’s death was indeed both sad and beautiful, as she stood her ground as no-one had before.

Without being given a proper chance to grieve, the Doctor was then transported to an unknown location, barely containing his rage and vengefulness. However, instead of ending on this ominous note, the episode concluded with Rigsy’s touching tribute to Clara, which served as a powerful reminder of the hero she had been.


6. The Magician's Apprentice

Doctor Who Skaro
BBC Studios

The Magician’s Apprentice got Series Nine off to an excellent start, as the Doctor was confronted with a dreadful moral dilemma in the form of a young Davros. The episode only became more epic and intense as the monstrous Colony Sarff sought the Doctor across the universe.

Meanwhile on Earth, Missy returned with a bang, freezing planes in the sky and warning Clara that the Doctor was preparing for his death. Moffat continued to build on the idea of the friendship between the Doctor and Missy, as the renegade Time Lady revealed that she, not Clara, had been given the Doctor’s confession dial.

Things became all the more ominous with the revelation that the Doctor had abandoned the young Davros, and the Time Lord’s decision to surrender to Sarff. The following meeting between the Doctor and Davros didn’t disappoint, as the two revisited their previous confrontations in anticipation of the end.

Davros then displayed the depths of his cruelty, as he was revealed to have brought the Doctor, Clara and Missy to a rebuilt Skaro and revelled in the apparent deaths of the Doctor’s friends. The episode concluded on a shocking cliffhanger, with the Doctor seemingly attempting to murder Davros in his youth to change history and save Clara.


5. The Witch's Familiar

The Witch's Familiar
BBC Studios

The Witch’s Familiar was a brilliant character piece, that managed to rise above its formidable predecessor. It brought unprecedented depth and humanity to Davros, as the creator of the Daleks congratulated the Doctor for saving Gallifrey and looked on the Time Lord with his own eyes. But just when it seemed as though Davros might prove capable of some form of redemption before his death, it was revealed that he had been attempting to manipulate the Doctor all along in order to harvest his regeneration energy.

However, the Doctor himself had been deceiving Davros, and used the energy to unleash decaying sewer Daleks on an unsuspecting Skaro in a triumphant twist. The ambiguity over how much of what the Doctor and Davros said to each other was genuine made their interactions even more fascinating in retrospect.

The unlikely Clara/Missy team proved equally compelling, with Missy’s unpredictability and ruthlessness keeping Clara’s life on a knife edge. It was hilarious when Clara was forced to climb inside a Dalek and deal with its limited vocabulary, and Missy’s unbelievably cruel attempt to trick the Doctor into killing his companion came as a disturbing reminder that despite her fun personality and bond with the Doctor, Missy was still a sadistic murderer.

Concluding with a moving act of mercy that proved that the Doctor had made a difference, however small, in Davros, the episode’s vindication of the Doctor’s faith in compassion brought it to a fitting thematic close.


4. The Doctor Falls

The Doctor Falls
BBC

The Twelfth Doctor’s last stand was beautifully touching, as he sacrificed himself without hope, without witness, and without reward. The fact that he gave his life for a small group of terrified humans instead of the fate of the universe proved once again the immense depth of his kindness and heroism. His enthralling speech to Missy and the Master beforehand was another defining moment, in which he bared his soul in a desperate, final effort to convince his best friend to stand with him. Needless to say, Capaldi’s performance of the material was astounding.

It was a treat to see Missy and the Master interacting with each other, as John Simm’s incarnation lusted over his future self and Missy struggled to choose a side. Their last, self-destructive scene would have served as a masterful final end for the character, and was made all the more tragic by the Doctor’s unawareness of his friend’s decision to help him at the end.

Pearl Mackie was superb at portraying Bill’s horror and grief at what had been done to her, as she came to a heartbroken realisation that people would always be afraid of her. The farewells between the Doctor and his friends were genuinely poignant, especially Nardole’s admission that he would never be able to find the words. However, the episode ultimately managed to bring joy out of despair, as Bill was given a happy ending and ensured the Doctor’s regeneration with a tear.


3. Dark Water

Dr Who Dark Water
BBC

Commencing with the sudden, everyday death of Danny, Dark Water quickly secured its position as one of Doctor Who’s bleakest episodes. Jenna Coleman portrayed Clara’s grief with incredible truth and subtlety, as she betrayed the Doctor to force him to change history.

Their dynamic in the riveting volcano confrontation, in which they fought to take control of the situation and Clara demonstrated just how far she was willing to go, was breathtaking. It was followed by a deeply moving testament to their friendship, as the Doctor chose to forgive Clara and help her find Danny in the afterlife.

The Nethersphere itself proved to be a cold, grim realm, that forced Danny to confront his past in a particularly painful scene. His situation became increasingly nightmarish, as he was forced to sacrifice his connection with Clara to prevent her following him there, and was offered the chance to delete his emotions by the callous Seb.

Dark Water did a great job of gradually building up to some shocking revelations, as the Doctor and Clara investigated 3W and its apparent quest to protect the dead. It was chilling to realise that the Nethersphere and 3W were part of an elaborate plan to create an army of undead Cybermen, which was unleashed on London at the episode’s climax. But even this was overshadowed by the momentous revelation of Missy’s identity, as the Doctor learned that his old friend/arch-nemesis had returned in female form.


2. World Enough And Time

Doctor Who Missy Mondasian Cybermen The Master
BBC

“Pain. Pain. Pain.” World Enough and Time brought back the Cybermen at their most disturbing, and served as a terrific origin story for the iconic foe, as the desperate inhabitants of Floor 1056 sacrificed their humanity to make their dreams of Operation Exodus a reality. Steven Moffat’s use of time dilation as a storytelling device made for one of his most ingenious ideas, as Bill was forced to wait ten years for the Doctor after suffering a dreadful injury, watching from below as her friend’s grandstanding cost her more and more of her life.

However, the episode’s greatest achievement was hiding the Master in plain sight as “Mr Razor”. John Simm did an excellent job of making Razor an engaging personality in his own right, as he built a seemingly touching relationship with Bill and helped her to navigate the dreadful world she was trapped in.

His treachery in taking her for conversion initially seemed to be an authentic act of twisted kindness, before being revealed as something far more terrible when Razor encountered Missy, and revealed how much he still loved disguises.

World Enough and Time culminated in an exceptional cliffhanger, as the Doctor realised to his horror that he had arrived too late to save Bill, and was confronted with not one but two incarnations of the Master.


1. Heaven Sent

Doctor Who Heaven Sent
BBC Studios

From the ominous opening monologue to the vengeful homecoming at its conclusion, Heaven Sent was an astounding masterpiece, which trapped a grieving Doctor in an elaborate torture chamber. Peter Capaldi rose to the challenge of a single-hander with seeming effortlessness, and demonstrated the full range of his unbelievable talent.

It was astonishing to be granted unprecedented access into the Doctor’s mind, as he struggled to devise solutions to apparently hopeless scenarios alongside an imagined construct of Clara, while dealing with the pain of her loss.

The Doctor’s environment was chillingly ghoulish, particularly the genuinely frightening monster that relentlessly pursued him. But Steven Moffat was still concealing the true horror of the situation, ultimately revealing that the Doctor had been trapped for 7000 years, and had died countless times in his seemingly futile attempts to punch through the Azbantium wall.

What followed was an unforgettable montage, as the Doctor relived his torment for 4.5 billion years, complete with the incredible revelation that he was gradually wearing the wall away through his unyielding efforts. The Doctor’s refusal to give up or give in despite the terrible cost was an extraordinary act of heroism, which culminated in a moment of beautiful triumph as he finally broke free and finished his story.

Thanks to the brilliant combination of Moffat’s writing, Capaldi’s acting and Rachel Talalay’s superb direction, Heaven Sent represented a magnificent peak for the Twelfth Doctor’s era, and stands as one of Doctor Who’s finest moments.


Contributor

Tim Hand hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.