Doctor Who: 15 Villains That Should Not Come Back

doctor who peter kayDoctor Who has almost no boundaries. A show with an unprecedented premise has almost no set rules, excepts for the ones that it sets for itself. And even those don't seem all that important sometimes. This is as true with the villains as it is with the plots and heroes. Some villains are so well-received that it may be too tempting to show runners not to bring them back, no matter how much closure that there was at the end of the episodes. Other villains are so effective in single doses that further appearances lessen just how frightening they are as being the bad guys (and yes, I am talking about a specific species. But I'll get to that.) There are some ideas constructed in the reboot that we can say are hypothetically interesting--finding out the Doctor's name, seeing the destruction of Gallifrey, watching Eight regenerate into Nine--but that we really don't want or need to see happen on our TVs. It's actually the root of fan fiction and fan videos and daydreams that we totally don't have when we're supposed to be paying attention to something else. Logically, it's almost certain that some of these villains won't return. Impossible, even. Nevertheless, this is a sci-fi television show that has lasted for half of a century about a time-traveling alien who can change his whole body and personality. A little bit of rule-bending is to be expected. After all, as Matt Smith is either the Eleventh of Twelfth Doctor (depending on John Hurt's role in the upcoming 50th Anniversary special), current show runner Steven Moffat is soon going to have to find a way to wriggle past the 12-regeneration rule to keep Doctor Who going. Besides, Moffat seems determined to make nothing on the show absolute; pulling some unlikely villains from past episodes wouldn't be much in comparison. There are a lot of villains in Doctor Who, some of them much better than others. The problem is that contextual legitimacy matters a lot more than some writers and producers seem to sometimes think. Here are some of the rebooted villains that should be left behind.

15. The Reapers - Father's Day

The Reapers were good antagonists in an episode in which there weren't any bad genuine guys. "Father's Day" gives us our first look at the rules of time travel and what can happen if they're broken. The whole thing is really Rose's fault, although you can also argue that it's Nine's unhealthy attachment to her (as a woman, as a human, as a friend, as a tether, however you want to look at it) and inability to tell her "no" and mean it for very long that got them into the mess. Still, he told her not to touch the infant version of herself, and that seems like a fairly easy direction to follow, Rose. Altogether, though, the Reapers were pretty good, and it gave viewers quite a shock when the creatures devoured the Doctor in a church. Granted, it was Nine and Season 1, so we hadn't yet seen the Doctor die or disappear and come back over and over again. The big reason why the Reapers shouldn't come back, however, is because the time paradox as established in the wonderful "Father's Day" has been broken time and time again (I'm looking at you, Season 5) without Reaper repercussions to the point that it would just be embarrassing to bring them back now.

14. The Family of Blood - Human Nature/The Family of Blood

Screen Shot 2013-07-18 at 2.07.03 PM "Human Nature" and "The Family of Blood" are two of the best episodes of the rebooted Doctor Who, and certainly two of the the best of Season 3. The guest stars were great, Tennant gave some of his finest acting as John Smith/Ten, Martha was awesome, it was a premise that hadn't been done before on the show. And the villains were fantastic. Their rise and demise through the two-parter features some incredibly unnerving images, with everything from an army of animated scarecrow soldiers to dozens of young boys firing machine guns to Ten doling out terrible punishments. No second chances indeed. While members of the Family of Blood were theoretically locked away into various states of eternal suffering, it would be hardly impossible to bring them back. If Rory could come back from the dead half a dozen times, the Family of Blood could find themselves brought out of exile by a showrunner or writer eager to recreate the quality of the two establishing episodes. But it definitely shouldn't happen. Aside from my argument that context matters and can't be repeated (especially the Doctor turning human), they were exiled for a reason, and to pull them out would lessen the harsh implications of Ten's retribution. Serving as a precursor to the god complex that would manifest itself toward the end of Ten's era, the conclusion of this episode should be enough to keep the entire species out of the franchise forever. Besides, there is nothing creepier than a little girl with a balloon, and there are only so many ways that that can happen. (It would be awesome, though, if Sister of Mine could make an Easter egg appearance every once in a while in a mirror.)


13. The Lego Daleks - Victory Of The DaleksScreen Shot 2013-07-18 at 2.07.28 PM Even without the picture, if you were at all familiar with Season 5, you'd know what I was talking about. These Daleks were not the metallic killing machines of deadly dead death. They looked like oversized toys and came in primary colors. Thus they are "Lego" Daleks. Granted, I wasn't around when classic Who was on and I can't attest to all of the stories of British children hiding behind their sofas at the sight of a Dalek, but if I were a kid when I saw "Victory of the Daleks," I would have wanted to have one of Eleven's cookies and bug my mom to get me the red robot. Eleven's speech to them paled in comparison to Nine's in Season 1's "Bad Wolf" (although I've never been a fan of the "jammie dodger" speech, and not only because I'm an American and had no idea what jammie dodgers actually were), and while I understand that Doctor Who is technically made for children, the villains are supposed to seem villainous rather than an assembly of the Dalek Power Rangers.


12. Lilith And The Carrionite Witches - The Shakespeare Code

Screen Shot 2013-07-17 at 5.53.53 PM While they may sound like a girl band from the 90s, these were the villains of a fairly important (if also fairly nonsensical) episode from Season 3. It featured Martha's first trip to the past, Shakespeare, "Expelliarmus!", Shakespeare, the first mention of Ten possibly devirginizing the Virgin Queen, Shakespeare...it was all terribly British and a good enough standalone, but the conclusion was open-ended. As the episode was more about Ten (sort of) getting over Rose and adjusting to Martha than it was about the Witches, it wouldn't be surprising if you forgot that they existed. Ten probably did too, and since he trapped the Witches and stuck them somewhere in the TARDIS, they could just be hanging out and waiting for a plot dry spell to come back. What with Moffat's constant destruction and reconstruction of the poor TARDIS, the witches could turn up any time. They just shouldn't.

11. The Wire - The Idiot's Lantern

Screen Shot 2013-07-17 at 5.55.41 PM I won't lie. I love this episode. Yes, there are huge plot holes. "Hungry, hungry!" is admittedly not a particularly rousing statement unless it is immediately followed by "hippos" (in which case it becomes awesome). Yes, the victims should have all died for lack of oxygen, food, and water. But Ten has a quiff and his oral fixation makes an appearance and there's a detective inspector who both detects and inspects and there's a woman who comes into her own and kicks out her emotionally abusive husband! Also, Rose's shoes. Okay, so it's not a great episode, and the Wire is pretty much the worst part of it. As I am one of the four people in the entire world to actually like this episode, Doctor Who is likely to remain Wireless. Still, the Wire was only Beta-maxed and taken aboard the TARDIS. For all we know, Ten forgot to tape over one of Season 2's least impressive villains and the Wire is hanging out with the Carrionite Witches as they bide their time.


10. The Creature - MidnightScreen Shot 2013-07-17 at 5.58.10 PM A lot of Nu-Who viewers seem to be divided over "Midnight," and I can certainly understand why. Almost the entire episode takes place in a single location, we never actually see the creature that is terrorizing the tourists, everything pretty much screams "low budget." At the same time, it's an unsettling look into the dark side of human nature, and watching the other passengers trying to "Lord of the Flies" the immobilized Doctor is surprisingly creepy, considering that we know that he's not exactly going to be flung out and left to die in a standalone. I fall into the category of viewers who loved the episode, and it's not so much that I don't want the creature to come back because of the fantastic lack of closure (and the fact that "Midnight" wouldn't have worked with a Doctor other than chatterbox Ten) as well as the unlikelihood of a feasible plot to bring it back, but Moffat has a bad habit of bringing back scary monsters and then over-explaining them until the fright is gone. And if you think that I'm building up to a certain villain, just you wait.


9. The Abzorbaloff - Love and MonstersScreen Shot 2013-07-17 at 5.59.29 PM Yes, you're welcome for the picture. I'm going to be honest. I haven't rewatched "Love and Monsters" since the first time that I saw it, whereas I can quote almost every other episode from Season 2 (except for "The Girl in the Fireplace," which I'll get to). Despite my lack of rewatch, however, there are two scenes that have been unfortunately burned into my memory. One of them concerns the very disturbing implication of a certain type of "romance" between the episode's civilian protagonist and a slab of concrete that was once his girlfriend, who now only exists as a...face. The other scene that I recall with far too much clarity is the one in which the Abzorbaloff is revealed in all of his saggy green glory. Designed by a 9-year-old contest winner, the Abzorbaloff is a creature that absorbs people. Yes, you definitely wouldn't guess that it was created by a child still in single digits. This particular creature dies at the end of the episode, but there seem to be plenty like him living on his home planet of Clom, where they should absolutely stay, for just so many reasons. The poetically-named Clom happens to neighbor a planet called Raxacoricofallapatorius, which brings me to...


8. The Slitheen - Aliens Of London/World War III

Screen Shot 2013-07-17 at 6.00.36 PM The Slitheen--or "Sliveen," as Rose Tyler might say--are the villains of the Season 1 two-parter "Aliens of London"/"World War III," in which aliens from Raxacoricofallapatorius capable of zipping themselves into human skins basically take over the British government from the inside. While the implications of their mass-murdering spree are lessened by the ongoing flatulence gag, the Slitheen were a formidable enemy and the threat that they posed to Nine, Rose, and M.P. from Flydale North Harriet Jones was real. However, if the Abzorbaloff is any indication, a creature that tries to rely too much on bodily humor loses its appeal very quickly. The Slitheen have been absent from the series since the end of Season 1, and they should stay that way. Still, if you say that you haven't tried to say "Raxacoricofallapatorius" out loud, then you're either lying or going to try to do it now. Note: it's a very satisfying accomplishment and you should definitely do it.


7. The Clockwork Repair Droids - The Girl In The FireplaceScreen Shot 2013-07-17 at 6.02.24 PM Just as I am one of the few who love "The Idiot's Lantern," I am one of the few who absolutely hate "The Girl in the Fireplace." For me, the most redeeming factors were the costuming, horse jokes, villains, and characterization. Just kidding. Ten's characterization was terrible and I still haven't forgiven Moffat. The best part of the episode by far, however, is the antagonists. Like the Reapers, they aren't actually bad. They're just trying to do their jobs. The amazingly creepy clockwork repair droids that stalk Madame de Pompadour for her entire life (a plot that Moffat will repeat in Season 5 with Amy Pond) are fantastic. The scene with her as a girl hiding under the covers as the Doctor sleuths out the ticking noise in the dark brings back every childhood fear that any of us have ever had. In an episode filled with flopped characterization and poor decision-making, the clockwork droids rank up as one of Moffat's top three villainous creatures. All the same, Madame de Pompadour is dead and Ten is gone and pre-Revolutionary France has been done. So the clockwork repair droids should remain bottled in their episode, which I hear some people think is a slightly good one.


6. The Cybermen - Rise of the Cybermen/The Age of Steel

Screen Shot 2013-07-17 at 6.04.18 PM I know that the Cybermen are some of the iconic villains villains of all of Doctor Who, but that doesn't meant that they have to come back nearly as often as they do, although I'm not saying that they should omitted forever. Remember what I said about about bringing back a villain too many times and making them not scary? Enter the Cybermen. Moffat is especially guilty of this, although his excessive bringing back of characters in not limited to villains (see: Rory, River, the Ponds) and lessens the emotional impact of the return for the good as well as the bad. For anyone who thinks that I'm picking on Moffat (although, yes, kind of), see "Journey's End" for an example of Russel T. Davies going overboard with return appearances. Still, Moffat seems to have a habit of constructing a plot around a single event or image that he wants in a particular episode. Remember the episode when Eleven visited Craig from "The Lodger" (don't worry, I love Craig and he can come back whenever he wants) and there were hijinks about a baby called Alfie? Of course you do. It was a great episode, and you probably immediately wanted to correct me and tell me that the baby prefers to go by "Stormageddon, Dark Lord of All." Although, really, who wouldn't want to go by "Stormageddon"? In any case, it was a fun episode with Eleven trying to fit in with the humans and Craig trying to contain him and there was a baby called Stormageddon. Oh, and some Cybermen. They were there too. I think. Whatever.

5. The Master - Utopia

He doesn't necessarily have to stay away forever. He's the Master, so--like the Cybermen--he can come back eventually. His first appearance in "Utophia" was a nice twist, even for new viewers like myself who had no idea who the hell he was supposed to be. His reappearance in "The End of Time," (also known as The End of Ten), however, already took some serious suspension of belief, and he'd already been gone for a season and a half. He was a Time Lord that was somehow coming back to life. It would have been one thing if they'd had him regenerate somehow and come back as a new actor. As it was, his triumphant return (and bleached blond hair) was pretty implausible, even for Doctor Who. Although he got one of my favorite lines from the "The End of Time" two-parter, he would have benefited from a longer break and the surprise of a new actor. Moffat has so far seemed to prefer to keep away from the Master, so it's entirely possible that the character finally did die off with Davies' departure.

4. The Sontarans - The Sontaran Stratagem/The Poison Sky

Screen Shot 2013-07-17 at 6.08.25 PM I'm just going to come out and say it. The Sontarans--on their own and without context--look kinda silly. Not quite Abzorbaloff silly, but they're not the most physically imposing of villains. But as we learned quickly in "The Sontaran Stratagem" and "The Poison Sky," the Sontarans are more than formidable. The massacre of British soldiers--unprepared and equipped only with inadequate armor and inadequate weaponry being shot down by the merciless Sontarans--made us all feel at least a little bit guilty that we laughed at them for looking like potatoes. Now, however, with the introduction of Strax as a friend to the Doctor and a comical figure to the viewers, the Sontarans seem so much less threatening. His interactions with Rory in "A Good Man Goes To War" were poignant and touching, but his transition from warrior/nurse to Victorian butler both lessens the circumstances of his original death and reduces the fearsome reputation of the mighty Sontarans. Strax may still want to blast the crap out of everything and he definitely works as the lovable comic relief that is sometimes very much needed on this show, but a Sontaran invasion should probably be delayed until a time when they can be properly scary again.


3. The Silurians - The Hungry Earth/Cold BloodScreen Shot 2013-07-17 at 6.09.50 PM The Silurians now face the same problem as the Sontarans, although they face it with much more dignity. Madame Vastra is a competent detective whose spinoff I would totally watch, and the Silurians are so much more humanoid than the Sontarans that they are at once more relatable and more unnerving. Of course, in the face of a Silurian attack, her love for Jenny could even justify Vastra siding with the humans rather than her own people and provide an interesting twist. Still, we're so used to seeing Madame Vastra as a friendly if formidable figure, and most of us only remember the Silurian introductory episodes of Nu-Who as being the first time that Rory died, so enemy Silurians should not be on the top of the list of villains for upcoming seasons.


2. The Daleks - Dalek

Screen Shot 2013-07-17 at 6.11.59 PM Alright, I sort of already covered the Daleks, but I thought that those Lego Daleks were special enough to have deserved their own special place on this list. I should also disclaim that--like the Cybermen and the Master--I don't think that the Daleks need to stay away forever. Just for a while. The Daleks were great in Season 1, if for Nine's (and Christopher Eccleston's) reactions to them than nothing else. Of all three Doctors so far, Nine is the one who has most convinced me that the Daleks are actually the devastating killing machines that warranted the destruction of Gallifrey and as they are so frequently described to us. They were frightening, and they gave Nine what was one of his best moments when he tells Rose--then a captive of the Daleks--that he's coming to get her. And he does, because he's Nine, and Nine is awesome. The Daleks were even still good in Season 2, when their single storyline return in "Army of Ghosts"/"Doomsday" had devastating consequences for the Doctor. Also for the innocent population of Great Britain. But we mostly cared about the Doctor and--if we had hearts in our chests--cried buckets at the Bad Wolf Bay scene. And then there came the "Daleks in Manhattan"/"Evolution of the Daleks" two-parter in Season 3, and it's all gone downhill from there. While it was a nice change for them not to be the season's ultimate bad guy yet again, those two episodes episodes were pretty bad. More people were probably impressed with "The Idiot's Lantern" than these two episodes, both of which really should have taught Moffat never to make an episode with "in Manhattan" in the title. Season 4's "The Stolen Earth"/"Journey's End" was slightly better with regard to the Daleks, but there are only so many times that there can be devastating Dalek genocides that are definitely totally 100% permanent this time before the emotional impact is gone. And then there were the Lego Daleks.


1. The Weeping Angels - Blink

This is the big one. The Weeping Angels. Don't get me wrong. I loved "Blink" as much as anyone. I jumped at all the right places and grew attached to characters that I'd never seen before and would presumably never see again. I gave a few suspicious looks at my local artwork. I loved the Weeping Angels and considered them the creepiest Nu-Who villains since the Devil and possessed Ood in Season 2's "The Impossible Planet"/"The Satan Pit." It's a fantastic episode, and I would recommend it to anyone, familiar with Doctor Who or not. But then the Angels came back. Although their first reappearance in Eleven's "The Time of Angels" was a nice surprise and validated every single person who had shouted at Sally Sparrow to just close one eye at a time when Amy did it for us, and although they were still scary, the bottled fright of "Blink" wasn't there. Without the Weeping Angels stalking their victims on the familiarities of Earth and having a bit more mystery and misunderstanding about them, we missed the level of discomfort and confusion that scared us the first time. And then there came "The Angels Take Manhattan" in Season 7. While the end of that episode hit me almost as hard as did Nine's regeneration in "The Parting of the Ways" and Rose's departure in "Doomsday," there's no escaping the fact that the plot was actually really really stupid. The Statue of Liberty was a Weeping Angel? How does that even work? I honestly believe that Moffat came up with the image of a living and malevolent Statue of Liverty and constructed an episode around it. Unfortunately, the premise was too ridiculous to be frightening. There had to have been a better way for Amy and Rory to make their theoretically (and hopefully, for the sake of emotional honesty) final departure. The worst part of what has happened to the Weeping Angels is that they were originally the scariest and most effective antagonists created in the reboot rather than drawn from the past, but over-explained and over-exposed by Moffat. He's the creator of some incredibly eerie bad guys--the clockwork droids, the gas mask zombies, the Weeping Angels--but a lack of moderation has spoiled the eeriest of them all. At some point, we stop jumping when the Angels appear out of the dark and start wondering if the Lego Daleks are going to come back. Disclaimer: I promise that I do actually love Doctor Who. And I don't totally hate Steven Moffat.

In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Fiction buff and writer. If it's on Netflix, it's probably in my queue. I've bought DVDs for the special features and usually claim that the book is better than the movie or show (and can provide examples). I've never met a TV show that I won't marathon. Follow on Twitter @lah9891 .