Doctor Who: 5 Reasons Why Jack Harkness Might Not Return
He is our favourite con man, chancer, charmer and flirt. Omnisexual, openly lascivious and a man who has men, women and aliens falling all over him. He has, quite literally, shagged his way around the universe and charmed his way out of trouble. He made us laugh in Doctor Who; he was a fine leader in Torchwood. I believe that nobody will ever forgive Russell T Davies for the events in Children Of Earth. I'm sure that I wasn't the only one who had their heart torn out, stomped all over, ripped to shreds and repaired just for it all to happen again. There have at least been references to Jack since Matt Smith took over as our beloved Time Lord. Not least the scene where Dorium Maldovar is selling River Song "A transportation device, fresh from the arm of a Time Agent". Well, we only know of one Time Agent, don't we? A former Time Agent perhaps, but he still refers to himself as such. We also know that you could chop his head off and it would grow back. Let me get one thing straight here: I love Jack; I would love to see the character in Doctor Who again. I would love for this to happen but I don't believe it will, and here are my five reasons why.
5. Jack Has Outlived His Usefulness
The introduction of Jack in The Empty Child was a totally inspired idea. Dashing, handsome, heroic and pretty much ready for anything. He manages to save Rose from her own stupidity (but only because he thinks she has an 'excellent bottom') and then ingratiates himself with The Doctor for nefarious purposes. He is after anything and everything he can get until he discovers what his ploy has achieved in The Doctor Dances. He faces The Doctor's wrath and anger concerning the nanogenes which changed Jamie into what he became upon his tragic death. Jack is killed by a Dalek in The Parting Of The Ways, and then brought back to life by Rose. He's not immortal, but he doesn't stay dead for long. All well and good if you want near-immortality, but I suspect that Jack would have been quite happy to die and stay dead. Aside from a few more episodes, Jack's story is done. There is honestly no reason for him to appear again, aside from the fact that he's a lot of fun to have around - unless you're Mickey, of course.
4. The Doctor Doesn't Like Jack
I have always sensed that The Doctor feels overshadowed by Jack. David Tennant's Doctor wants to be the "Big I Am", the one that people notice. Nobody is allowed to be more interesting or attractive to humans than he is, or so it would appear. He finds Jack to be an irksome hinderance and he is highly displeased when the TARDIS crashes because Jack has launched himself to cling on to the outside - thereby setting the TARDIS off course. In the episode "Utopia," having a love-lorn companion must have been bad enough, but then Jack hitches a ride and needs babysitting too. The delight on The Doctor's face when he sees Jack on the screen, running towards The TARDIS and thinking he's dematerialised in time to leave Jack behind is delirious. The Doctor's displeasure concerning Jack "gatecrashing" The TARDIS is evident in the way he reacts to finding Jack dead on the ground when he steps out of The TARDIS. Whilst Martha recovers from her shock and her nurses' training kicks in, The Doctor merely looks at the inert body and says "Hello again. Oh, I'm sorry." When Jack eventually recovers (sending Martha into shock again, since she's already realised that he is perfectly dead) The Doctor berates him for "flirting" when Jack introduces himself to Martha and says hello. Essentially, here we have the return of Battle Of The Egos. Bonus points to Jack for scaring Martha - and the viewers - out of their collective skins on suddenly reviving.
3. Jack Is Running Torchwood
Jack is successfully running Torchwood Caerdydd (Cardiff) at this point. There are references to The Doctor, and Martha features in at least two episodes, but Jack cannot possibly rejoin the TARDIS crew - he has his hands full with alien activity on earth. Not to mention having his hands full of Ianto. Personally I prefer Owen, but then I'm not Jack. There is also Myfanwy the Pterodon and Janet the Weevil to care for. Not only that, but Gwen brings her husband Rhys into the equation and Owen gets shot and becomes a Zombie. Okay, not running it so successfully after all, but Captain John Hart (James Marsters) turns up and provides some entertainment anyway. Oh, and let's not forget that Zombie Owen becomes King Of The Weevils. When you're running an empire such as The Torchwood Institute, you are far too busy identifying strange meat, killing Weevils, trapping sexually promiscuous aliens that invade the body of an unfortunate human host and discovering that "Adam" doesn't really exist. Perhaps you may still dream of it, but you won't be travelling in (or hanging on to) The TARDIS any time soon. Let's also not forget Blowfish in sports cars, and little old ladies cursing Torchwood.
2. Children Of Earth
There is only one way to destroy a man who cannot stay dead, and that is to make him watch as his loved ones are killed off one by one. In the most shocking and gutwrenching Torchwood series ever, Jack can only stand and watch helplessly as he loses his friends, his lover (Ianto) and eventually his grandson to the 456 - losing his daughter in the process. The look on Jack's face as his daughter turns her back on him says it all; he's completely and utterly broken. He has nothing left besides Gwen. Torchwood is gone, all but one of his colleagues are dead; the one person he truly loved died before Jack could even tell him how he truly felt and now he has no family. Had he been able, I think that he would have taken John Frobisher's way out. In the final scenes, Jack meets with Rhys and a pregnant Gwen to say goodbye. Torchwood is hers now, if she wishes to keep it alive, but he no longer wants any part of it. He's done; finished. He uses his transporter device to leave Earth, not to be seen or heard from again until Ten finds him in the bar with Alonso in the closing scenes of End Of Time.
1. Jack Became Too Big For The Whoniverse
Jack has been a wonderful, funny, endearing character for Doctor Who and Torchwood fans of all ages. However, by dint of John Barrowman's own personality and his passion for the role of Jack Harkness, I feel that he was eclipsing both Doctor Who and Torchwood. Miracle Day was the killer - so awful and such an insult to all of the cast - but it served to tell us all that Jack has gone for good. We shall possibly meet The Face Of Boe again some time in the future, but not Jack himself. Okay, so The Face Of Boe is Jack, but I am fairly certain that we shall not be seeing John Barrowman in Doctor Who again. To say that he will be missed would be an understatement of epic proportions, and I had hoped to see him return just one more time for the 50th anniversary - but it wasn't to be. Neither Doctor Who nor Torchwood were big enough to be able to contain Jack - he is such a big personality who would eventually clash with the equally large personality of The Doctor. I genuinely believe that Eleven and Jack would detest each other, given the fondness of both for theatrics and absolute attention. Thank you for the wonderful episodes, the laughs and even the tears John; we love you.