Doctor Who: 5 Worst Companion Exits

Nothing will be the same again after the departures of Amy and Rory in €œThe Angels Take Manhattan€. Until Christmas, of course, when the Doctor gets a new companion. Arrivals and departures are a major part of life, airports and €œDoctor Who€. The good Doctor has seen his share of friends leaving the TARDIS, some out of their own choice, and yes, some for reasons far more sinister. But not all exits from the show are heartbreaking or, heck, even very interesting. Here's a look at some of the strangest and most inexplicable adieus:

5. Adric

One of the most famous, tragic and yet welcome (to many) exits from the TARDIS. You see, Adric was a boy genius. What's that, ST:TNG fans? You understand immediately? I knew you would. Coming on board during the final days of Tom Baker's tenure was difficult enough for Matthew Waterhouse; being one of three companions for the fifth Doctor when Peter Davision arrived was even harder, as poor Adric often couldn't seem to find his place in a given episode. Finally, in €œEarthshock€, he found his place: on a freighter bound towards prehistoric Earth. Our pal Adric crashed it into the planet, causing the extinction of the dinosaurs, and himself. And you thought Deanna Troi was a bad pilot. Still, the freeze frame during the final credits of Adrics beloved badge floating in pieces in space was a chilling reminder that not everyone lives...

4. Peri Brown

The lovely Peri was a college student who decided to spend her vacation traveling with the Doctor. No, I did not make that up. She was the companion the Doctor nearly died to save after not having enough bat's milk. No, I did not make that up either. Peri was one of those companions everyone likes and remembers fondly, but really didn't get a chance to develop characterization onscreen. Admittedly, it's hard to shine up against a powerful persona like Colin Baker, but Nicola Bryant had her moments. Her exodus from the Doctors company was not one of them. Peri started and ended on vacation. The Doctor decided she needed a break from all the action going on, and brought Peri to the Earth-like planet Ravalox. Well, not so much Earth-like as actually Earth, just in a different place in space. Why? Never mind. This lead the Doctor and Peri to...er...somewhere else, where someone was doing something bad, and they tried to implant themselves into Peri's mind, but the Doctor had to leave before he could save her, so she was blown up...and bald...or maybe she married Brian Blessed...it's all very confusing, and has something to do with the Valeyard. It was a messy, undeserved end for Peri. But we'll always have the regeneration scene to remember her by, much to Davisions chagrin.

3. Leela

Anyone trying to follow Sarah Jane Smith is in for a hard time. But the producers of Doctor Who at the time, well aware of this problem, replaced our beautiful, sweet and decidedly well-dressed reporter with a wild, leather bikini-clad savage from the future. And it worked. Louise Jameson's Leela was was as wild as they get when she first meets the fourth Doctor, but quickly becomes loyal to her new-found friend, if often quite confused by what her puts her through. And how is she repaid for this loyalty? By being shown that she is only complete when she has a man. Yay for women's rights and stuff. In reality, Jameson had accepted a role elsewhere, and decided her time as Tom Bakers favorite person to dislike was done. So in €œThe Invasion of Time€, Leela meets a dreamy guy. They say, oh, maybe 10 words to each other. And, like you do, decide to get married. The Doctor, understandably baffled by this turn of events, basically says €œGood riddance, and you can keep K-9 too€. He didn't care much, you see, as he promptly wheels out a box with a new K-9. Cheeky.

2. Harry Sullivan

Poor Harry. He wasn't needed even before he started. You see, when Ian Marter was cast as a companion for the upcoming fourth Doctor, producers had no idea WHO would be Who. It was actually assumed they would choose someone older than Jon Pertwee, so in case some muscle was needed, they would need a young, fit gentleman to fill the role that a decrepit old Doctor couldn't. Then they hired the fit as a fiddle Tom Baker, and Marter's days were immediately numbered. But he had a good time while on the TARDIS, and fans have always had a warm place in their hearts for him. Too bad the writers were somewhat ambivalent. After battling Daleks, Cybermen, Sontarans and the Zygons with the Doctor and Sarah, Harry seemed to have had enough, and just took a train back home. Simple. Except he inexplicably pops up again some time later in €œThe Android Invasion€. And then just goes away again at the end of the episode. An ignoble end to a noble friend.

1. Dodo Chaplet

When the first Doctor started choosing his companions on the basis of their resemblance to the granddaughter he kicked out of the TARDIS, you knew nothing good could come of it. Dodo was so amazing that she could simply change her accent for no reason. But her time as a companion is basically only remembered due to her bizarre parting. You see, in €œThe War Machines€, there's one of those giant, bad computers they used to think would try to take over the world in the future. After the Doctor challenges said computer,as you do, Dodo is somehow taken over by the thing, and begins complaining about a buzzing in her ears. That, Dodo, is the sound of producers deciding you aren't cutting it and writing you out. She meets sailor Ben and swinging 60's gal Polly, does some weird stuff, is un-hypnotized by the Doctors ring, and by episode 4 is promptly forgotten. All we know is the Doctor allowed some guy to take her out to the country to rest for a few days. Which seems caring. But he's not coming back for her, by crack. Now he has two far spiffier assistants, whose accents stay relatively the same throughout their journeys. Dodo was such a lame character, she was later killed off unceremoniously in the novel €œWho Killed Kennedy€. No heartbreak, no tears. Just forgotten. Unlike our beloved Ponds. Any we missed out? Do throw us a comment.

Contributor

I am me, essentially. I'm a 40-something year old college student, a father, and a photographer. I love Doctor Who and The Beatles equally, no matter how much people try to tell me it's not natural.