Doctor Who: 8 Actors That Would Make AMAZING Doctors!

We Can Already See These Actors Bursting From The TARDIS Doors For Adventure!

Doctor Who Hugh Grant
BBC

It's almost time for Jodie Whittaker to regenerate as the 13th Doctor and pass over the reins to an as-yet-unnamed successor.

Traveling back in time to 2017, the world was enlightened of the new incarnation of the household name, 'Doctor Who,' when Jodie Whittaker, the first female doctor, was to take the controls of the Tardis for a five-year spin (2018–2022).

Fast forwards to 2022, and we already know that fan favourite showrunner Russell T. Davies is returning to create more wonderful stories and adventures, but one name has yet to be revealed.

The new doctor's announcement could come at any time, and fans are already speculating and guessing who their ideal timelord would be. Olly Alexander, Jo Martin, Hugh Grant, and even David Tennant, who played the tenth doctor, have been mentioned as possible candidates.

Although some people are led to believe these rumours, the truth is that we won't know who the new face is until an official announcement is made. Today we've compiled a list of actors that would make amazing doctors in their own right, not just for number fourteen! Some are very familiar faces, while others may not be!

8. Timothee Chalamet

Wonka Timothee Chalamet
Warner Bros.

I'm sure the Doctor Who writers would leap at the opportunity to cast Timothée Chalamet as the Doctor, but unfortunately this wouldn't happen because Hollywood has already snatched up this one! But it'll be an incredible performance...

26-year-old Timothée Chalamet is a critically acclaimed actor most known for his breakout role in an emotional performance as Elio in the film Call Me By Your Name (2017). Since then, he's been in several groundbreaking films, including Beautiful Boy, Little Women, and Dune. Timothée Chalamet's dramatic acting, humour, and emotional depth are all characteristics of a great Doctor, making it easy to see how spectacular he'd pull off the role.

Furthermore, Chalamet is particularly anticipated for his upcoming role as Willy Wonka in a 2023 film based on Roald Dahl's classic tale, which would undoubtedly showcase his whimsical and musical side, which would align with orginal flair and style if he were to portray the timelord. But alas, we can only dream.

So if Timothée Chalamet were the doctor in some insane parallel universe, he'd surely give David Tennant and Matt Smith a run for their money, in terms of notability and above all, desirability as the iconic character!


7. Rose Matafeo

Starstruck 2021
Hulu

New Zealand comedian and actress Rose Matafeo may seem like an unfamiliar and unusual option to play the doctor's role, but from her humour and zany frizzy hair (much like River Song), it isn't hard to see her at the front of the TARDIS consoles.

Starring in her own BBC One series 'Starstruck', it's clear her portrayal would defiantly be a clash made in heaven between the eccentrics of Matt Smith, and the clumsiness of Jodie Whittaker, while also giving it her own rework. And even as a rising star, Matafeo has already been tipped as the Doctor, in an article by the Guardian acclaiming her for being a 'creative force in comedy,' which makes us assume her interpretation would be of a hilariously campy nature.

But the problem is, is that Doctor Who has never had a lead actor who isn't from the United Kingdom but bringing New Zealander Matafeo into the mix could be exactly what the programme needs in terms of delivering something new to the table.


6. Eddie Redmayne

Fantastic Beasts Eddie Redmayne
Warner Bros.

Eddie Redmayne's portrayal of Newt Scamander in the Fantastic Beasts series alone demonstrates that he could effortlessly play the Doctor. So much so that we can see an inner-timelord exploding from him, as seen by his eccentric messy hair and fascination with strange and fascinating creatures. It wouldn't be a surprise if Redmayne's character, Newt Scamander, was an incarnation of the Doctor all along! But let's save that fan theory for another day!

Already used to playing a role in a fantastical environment, Redmayne's charisma as an actor already reveals doctor-like mannerisms. So watching him operate the TARDIS in time and space seems almost perfect for the actor, from his quirkiness and adventurous energy. Although, the Doctor Who crew may fear that Redmayne's peculiarities are too similar to Matt Smith's incarnation, we would still love to see him take on the iconic role.

It almost seems criminal that Redmayne has still yet to portray the timelord, but we can only hope in terms of the future! If not the doctor, Redmayne should be the next companion or even villain in the new series!


5. Olly Alexander

Olly Alexander Doctor Who
BBC

The one and only Olly Alexander is, without a doubt, one of the most rumoured actors that will be playing the 14th Doctor! And, if we're being honest, there's some validity to this speculation.

Olly Alexander is a well-known British singer and actor, thanks to his band's hit song "King" in 2015, with over 450 million Spotify streams as of this date. Furthermore, Olly has also featured in the critically acclaimed series It's A Sin, which has received numerous awards and nominations. This demonstrates Olly's strong acting ability, which is essential for the timelord's role.

The most intriguing aspect of the rumour is that Russell T Davis, the next Doctor Who showrunner, wrote It's A Sin, which might easily be where he selects the new doctor. This is also how Chibnall discovered 13th Doctor Jodie Whittaker, who he met while working on Broadchurch, a drama he wrote before taking on Doctor Who. This supports the theory that Olly Alexander could possibly be the new Doctor, even though he claims he won't be!

If the rumour turns out to be accurate, we'll be introduced to a totally fresh and original Doctor. This change of tune for the show would give a distinct style and spirit, and with Russell T. Davis as showrunner, we're sure it'll be amazing!


4. Domhnall Gleeson

Star Wars Domhnall Gleeson
LucasFilm

The Doctor's wishes have finally been fulfilled since this entry is ginger!

It's reasonably difficult to find someone who hasn't heard of Irish actor Domhall Gleeson or seen his work. Among his most notable roles are those in the global phenomenons Star Wars & Harry Potter. Where Gleeson played both antagonistic (General Hux) and heroic characters (Bill Weasley). This shows that Gleeson can have a darkness and lightness within him, which is crucial when it comes to the Doctor for the purpose of presenting different layers.

It's possible to imagine Gleeson's Doctor having storylines parallel to the tenth Doctor's and Rose's relationship. This could be owing to Gleeson's role in the romantic 2013 film 'About Time', in which he played a young man who uses time travel to make a woman he meets fall in love with him.

This could be an intriguing possibility because Gleeson's portrayal as the Doctor could be more of a romantic incarnation. As an idea, this hasn't really been explored to its fullest and Doctor Who is all about bringing new stories and adventures. As a romantic doctor, we can definitely see that Gleeson will excel in the role!


3. Tilda Swinton

Narnia Voyage Of The Dawn Treader White Witch
20th Century Fox

Tilda Swinton as the Doctor feels like such a perfect fit that we're surprised she hasn't appeared in the show before, even as a supporting character!

If we had to pick a role where we could sense Tilda Swinton's Doctor bursting from her, it would have to be The White Witch from The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe. Her ethereal and mysterious portrayal in the Narnia film shows that she could deliver a magical interpretation of the iconic timelord through a dominant presence and ability to alter moods swiftly but elegantly.

In terms of playing the fourteenth Doctor, this could be precisely what the show requires. Tilda Swinton's transformation from Whittaker's quirky, awkward Doctor into a mystical yet glamorous portrayal seems ideal for the programme to change things up.

Her depth as an actress might make her portrayal of the Doctor one of, if not the best, we've ever seen. Like her character, Ancient One says in Doctor Strange, "Arrogance and fear still keep you from learning the simplest and most significant lesson of all", which already sounds like something her Doctor would say.

She'd undoubtedly be a female version of Capaldi's incarnation, driving her interpretation with intelligence and grit. We're seriously hoping for this entry to become a reality...


2. Sebastian Croft

Sebastian Croft
MGM

If Doctor Who wanted to go back to the days of David Tennant and Matt Smith with a new, young and fresh face, Sebastian Croft would be our first choice!

The show became a global phenomenon due to its reinvention with Tennant and Smiths era, attracting many viewers worldwide. However, since Matt Smith's departure, the show's spirit has somehow faded. This is because the premise of a charming young man in the Doctor's shoes seems to appeal to the majority of fans and if Doctor Who wants to re-engage viewers, this is a path they should consider.

Sebastian Croft, the twenty-year-old English actor, could be the face of a new generation of Doctor Who, delivering a familiar but charming charisma that fans already adore. Crofts has appeared in 'The Horrible Histories Movies,' as well as a brief role in 'Game Of Thrones.' More notably, he will appear in the highly anticipated Netflix series 'Heartstopper,' which will premiere in late April 2022.

We totally think Croft would be ideal as a new rising star in the Doctor's role, bringing the character a feeling of familiarity and freshness.


1. Hugh Grant

Paddington 2 Hugh Grant
StudioCanal

Hugh Grant is arguably the most well-known name on the list. And he'd be an amazing doctor in any shape or form, there's no doubt about that!

He has a diverse range of performances, from his early 2000s days in romantic comedies (Notting Hill, Love Actually, to name a few) to today, where he plays villainous characters, whether it's a hilariously twisted conman in Paddington 2 or a more serious role as seen in A Very English Scandal.

If Hugh Grant becomes an incarnation of the Doctor, there's just no knowing what direction he'll take the character, which makes this entry so intriguing! His versatility as an actor reveals that he could perform the doctor as a charming spy-like character comparable to James Bond or as a comical and extravagant persona reminiscent of his role as Phoenix Buchanan in Paddington.

Hugh Grant even mimicked the Doctor in a 1999 parody, and based on his comedic style; we can easily imagine him combating Daleks and Weeping Angels with wit and finesse in a full series.

It's no surprise he was already approached by Russell T. Davis, who was interested in Hugh Grant for the role of the ninth doctor in 2005, but Grant turned him down. This is due to Grant's doubts about the revival's success. He was clearly mistaken, and he has openly expressed regret for declining the role since then. Hopefully, this hints that Hugh Grant could be a strong contender in the new Doctor Who series, written by Russell T. Davis. And we're surely not complaining!


Watch Next


Doctor Who Quiz: How Well Do You Know NuWho?

TARDIS Doctor Who
BBC Studios

1. Which Of These Hasn't Played The Doctor?

Contributor

James joined WhatCulture in early 2022. He is an expert on Doctor Who (well, the modern era) and Harry Potter. James graduated from the University of Otago in Dunedin, New Zealand, in 2025 with a degree in Communications and Media.