Doctor Who Listen Review: 10 Things We Learned

There were plenty of revelations among the chills of Moffat's latest episode...

Amid the chills and somewhat confusing narrative, the latest episode of Doctor Who certainly delivered some big moments. Considering that it was the first episode of series eight not to bring up Missy or the Promised Land arc, Listen still had plenty of revelations to give around the Doctor and Clara. And that was the biggest success with this week's episode; in addition to having the scariest sequence since Blink, we learned a little more about the two central characters. Listen was an episode that examined Clara's future. We learned that the arrival of Danny Pink in Clara's life was going to have a big impact; he's destined to be far more than a passing romance. However we still have many questions before we get there. It also set up a possible end game for the Doctor's companion, though intriguingly we're still early enough in the relationship to know whether some of these revelations will take place a year or ten years from now. It wasn't just the future the episode looked into, though it did go very far. Listen also delved deep into the Doctor's past, taking us further than we had ever gone. Just like the revelations in the brilliant pre-title sequence of Name Of The Doctor, the connection between Clara and the Doctor was magnified further, making her possibly the most important companion in the history of the show. But that's enough teasing. Let's look at those revelations a little morfe closely and examine the ramifications for the show moving forward. Click 'NEXT' to continue...

10. Danny Pink Might Be The Love Of Clara's Life

One of the most fun things about the introduction of Danny Pink into the show is that is has allowed Moffat to have another crack at the at the romantic situation comedy he delivered so well in his show Coupling. We assume of course that the scenes with Clara and Danny at Coal Hill School in Into The Dalek were his contribution to that episode. They certainly had the same vibe as their scenes in Listen. The banter, the flirting and the horrific realities of dating were played to great effect in Listen and it was great to see Clara moving on from the quasi-girlfriend relationship she had with the Eleventh Doctor. This series has been a revelation for Clara, not just in terms of Jenna Coleman's performance but the more mature relationship she shares with the Twelfth Doctor. In Listen we saw that she had a future with someone other than a mad man in a box (though Danny certainly seems to have issues of his own) and that connection may make Danny Pink the love of her life. Considering what we learned about her great grandson - more on that later - we're starting to see the future for Clara Oswald and it isn't all darkness and despair in the farthest reaches of space.

9. Danny Pink Had A Troubling Childhood

In Listen we learned that Danny was in fact Rupert Pink. What was supposed to be a trip into Clara's childhood turned out to be the trip into the childhood of the man with whom she now shares a connection. A place where the Doctor's nightmare manifested; a children's home in Gloucester where orphan Rupert Pink sat alone on his bedroom floor, fearful of the thing lurking under his bed. The death Danny faced as a solider was only part of his troubled life. In Listen we were given another question to ask about Clara's new potential love interest. What happened to his parents? Between that and the mystery of his actions prior to coming to Coal Hill School, Steven Moffat has created a lot of potential in this new character. Uncovering those mysteries, seeing his relationship with Clara develop and the inevitable meeting between the two men in Clara's life; there's plenty more to come from Danny Pink.

8. Time Travel Will Be A Family Business For Clara's Descendants

The last of the big revelations concerning Danny also served as a big moment in the future of Clara Oswald. We've already talked about the connection between these two potential love interests. Samuel Anderson has a great awkward charm that balances with Jenna Coleman's quirkiness. But the biggest revelation concerning them was the arrival of their descendant, Orson Pink. The trailers for series eight showed Danny Pink in the orange space suit worn by the Tenth Doctor. We all assumed this was one of his adventures with the Doctor but it turns out we were all wrong. Danny Pink hasn't even entered the TARDIS yet but his great grandson has as he looks a lot like the man Clara has started dating. What's more, he's a time traveller too just like his great grandmother Clara Oswald. If she wasn't sure if her relationship with Danny would go anywhere before, meeting her descendant cemented that truth that Clara was going to have a family with him some day. That's a lot of pressure after the first date!

7. Doctor Who Still Can Be Really Scary

Not such a revelation within the episode as much as much as what we learned about the show. The phrase 'hiding behind the sofa' has always been associated with the show, but how many times has it genuinely been scary? Deep Breath was creepy. The Silence were chilling. The Angels - well in Blink they terrified us - but we've really seen that phrase manifested in the show we're watching. But this week, Moffat did it, delivering his scariest moment since the Angels turned out the lights in Blink. The thing under the blanket was genuinely chilling and sure to give children nightmares. It only got considerably worse when it began to move, getting closer and closer behind Clara's back. Add to it a creepy score and lots of heavy breathing and Doctor Who delivered on the chills promised in the trailer. There was a lot of talk of Doctor Who being too scary after the Silence in appeared at the start of series six. They certainly were creepy but it was Listen that showed hiding behind the sofa isn't always a bad thing...

6. We Saw The End Of The Universe

Series three's Utopia took us further than the Doctor had ever gone as the last remnants of humanity sought to find a last refuge before the end. We discovered of course that the Master enslaved them all - or at least the majority of them as the Toclafane - and brought them back to 21st Century to attack humanity at its most vulnerable. But in Listen the Doctor - and Clara - went even further, to the point where all life was dead and just one man had made it; time traveller Orson Pink. The Doctor was a little disappointed to learn that he wasn't the last man alive, though as we discovered his worst nightmare was still there waiting for him. Or so we thought. The revelation behind what the thing banging on the airlock door and hiding under Rupert's bed was sure to divide fans, but finding the bleak desolation that was the end of the universe was just as terrifying.

5. The Doctor Is Becoming Increasingly Isolated

Not since the early days of the Ponds has the Doctor had a constant companion, or companions, on board the TARDIS. After Amy and Rory left for the first time, the Eleventh Doctor travelled for hundred's years alone, occasionally dipping into the Pond's, and later Clara's, lives. That's a long time to be by yourself and perhaps in light of all that we've seen recently, the cracks are starting to show. This Doctor isn't a man who likes hugs, we know that. But if Listen is anything to go by, he's also a man reduced to talking to himself, questioning the mysteries of the universe in the absence of a regular companion to bounce off. You could take the opening scene as the Doctor addressing the audience, scaring us with thoughts of the creature lurking under your bed or night. Or perhaps it's just a man that has gone a little crazy. In light of the ending, where it was revealed the creature wasn't real, you have to ask yourself just what was the Doctor seeing when the airlock opened? Has he gone completely delusional? Did Orson's growing isolation have an impact on the Doctor? Is he really broken? It will be an interesting avenue to explore as series eight continues...

4. The Doctor Isn't Just Ruthless - He's A Kleptomaniac

It isn't the same as letting poor Russell think he had a chance of surviving just to track his remains to a place of safety, but it is a side to the Doctor that is less like the heroic figure we've watched in recent years. Not only does he seem to genuinely delight in scaring the poor man who runs the children's home, he steals his mug of coffee when he isn't looking. In the grand scheme of things, it isn't the worse thing he's done. He certainly showed little compassion in helping a frightened Rupert Pink after the 'creature' appeared under his bed clothes. But this is not what we've come to expect from a hero like the Doctor. At least not the recent versions. Last week the Doctor and Robin Hood both asked if they were really heroes at all. Perhaps the truth is that the Doctor's heroism is a little murkier these days.

3. The First Time The Clara Met The Doctor

Audiences were stunned when Clara led the First Doctor and Susan to his TARDIS on Gallifrey. Fractured across his time, saving him from the Great Intelligence, she became one of the most important companions in the history of the show. But despite that surprise appearance in series seven's The Name Of The Doctor, it wasn't until Listen where we finally saw the first meeting between the Doctor and his future companion. We'd glimpsed the Master's childhood before but now we saw the Doctor as a boy; weeping and huddled in a barn (more on that later), possibly orphaned and isolated from the other boys around him. It was a dramatic revelation not just because Clara grabbed his arm from under the bed, becoming the very nightmare the Doctor was seeking, but also because she was the one to sooth his distress and presumably allow him to continue on the path before him. While Clara being the nightmare ruined the impact of earlier scenes, her meeting with the young by on Gallifrey only cemented her connection to the Doctor . Just as long as you don't question how the TARDIS made it to an early point in the planet's history when it's supposed to be time locked!

2. Dan The Soldier Man Is An Important Figurehead In The Doctor And Danny Pink's Lives

A simple toy soldier had a big impact in the lives of two characters on the show. We first saw the toy when Clara laid out the toy soldiers in Rupert's room to protect him from the creature he had just witnessed. Clara proclaimed Dan the hero, the leader that would protect him and that moment had a huge impact on his live moving forward. Particularly as Rupert took on that name sometime between Gloucester and Coal Hill School. We later discovered that it became a family memento, which his great grandson carried with him when he took that fateful trip into the future in the 22nd Century. Orson then passed Dan the soldier man on to Clara who passed it on to another another frightened boy; a younger Doctor. While she may have become the very thing he had nightmares of, Clara was also able to help the Doctor face those fears and gave him the soldier to keep him brave and strong. That one little memento may have shaped the Doctor we have come to know over the last 50 years, proving yet again that Clara has made one hell of an impact in his life.

1. The Barn In Day Of The Doctor Has Huge Meaning To The Doctor

In the 50th special, the War Doctor trekked across the deserts of war-ravaged Gallifrey, taking shelter in an old barn where he sought to unleash the Moment. We assumed he chose the location simply because it was isolated and he wouldn't have interference from his people of the Daleks. But as Listen revealed, he chose the location because it had a special connection to him. It was the place where a very young Doctor faced his fears and used that to become the hero he became. We assume that he joined the army and became a Timelord after the night he met Clara and was given the toy soldier. It was the place where he found his strength and placed where he needed that courage again to end the Time War, destroying his own people and the Daleks in the process. Rather than delivering an unnecessary journey into the adventure of a young Doctor, Listen delivered a big revelation in the Doctor's life and added depth top his character, while putting the events of Day Of The Doctor in a new light. Scares aside, that was the biggest success of the episode. And there you have the ten big things we learned in Listen. It may have been a mix of chills, shocks and confusing narrative but there is no denying that it will help shape Doctor Who as it continues. We learned more about the Doctor and Clara and that is a great thing.

Contributor
Contributor

A writer for Whatculture since May 2013, I also write for TheRichest.com and am the TV editor and writer for Thedigitalfix.com . I wrote two plays for the Greater Manchester Horror Fringe in 2013, the first an adaption of Simon Clark's 'Swallowing A Dirty Seed' and my own original sci-fi horror play 'Centurion', which had an 8/10* review from Starburst magazine! (http://www.starburstmagazine.com/reviews/eventsupcoming-genre-events/6960-event-review-centurion) I also wrote an episode for online comedy series Supermarket Matters in 2012. I aim to achieve my goal for writing for television (and get my novels published) but in the meantime I'll continue to write about those TV shows I love! Follow me on Twitter @BazGreenland and like my Facebook page https://www.facebook.com/BazGreenlandWriter