Doctor Who: The Best Episodes From Each Modern Series
MAJOR SPOILER ALERT! Midnight is on this list.
Although the first series of NuWho was first broadcast during spring 2005, news that the cult sci-fi show was being revived – or regenerated – actually took place two years previously.
The only thing confirmed back in 2003 was that a Welshman by the name of Russell T Davies would be penning the new episodes, which he described would be “fun, exciting, contemporary and scary… which embraces the Doctor Who heritage, at the same time introducing the character to a modern audience”. Four years later – when Davies turned down a fifth series as showrunner – he said:
“A fifth series! Did you ever think that Doctor Who would be this important to the BBC? That’s the maddest and best thing of all.”
Well, here we are. With a 13th NuWho series on its way, the show has become a worldwide phenomenon thanks to some of the greatest-ever episodes from the modern era. So let’s take a look at the very best to join the pantheon of Classic Who greats like Genesis of the Daleks, City of Death and The Caves of Androzani…
14. The Empty Child/The Doctor Dances (Series 1)
It was a close run thing with the other par excellence episodes of Robert Shearman's Dalek and Paul Cornell's Father's Day. But Steven Moffat's very first (proper), award-winning Doctor Who story has everything, and is memorable for many wonderful reasons.
Things quickly escalate, literally, when Rose takes her new Union Jack T-shirt for a spin around London via... barrage balloon during a Blitz bombing raid. Fortunately, a rather dandy and dashing 51st century Time Agent, whose invisible spaceship is casually (and awesomely) tethered to Big Ben, rescues her in suitably spectacular fashion. Hello our favourite cheesy beefcake!
We have a sweetly-sounding child in a gas mask looking for his mummy, innocently going about Wartime London transmitting cries of "mummy" via the TARDIS telephone, a radio, in sync with a cymbal-banging toy monkey, and a typewriter - which was added later on because the episode was originally too short.
It has one of the best cliffhangers, which followed that viscerally vivid scene straight out of a Lovecraftian horror where Doctor Constantine's face agonisingly and terrifyingly transforms into a gas mask. But best of all, following the traumatic events of the Time War, it continues the Doctor's personal healing process in the most uplifting and joyous way: just this once, everybody lives!
It showcases some of the very best in British acting talent with Richard Wilson's resolute Doctor Constantine, Florence Hoath's brilliantly nuanced portrayal of the canny and caring Nancy, and the best NuWho Doctor-companion dynamic - alongside Ten and Donna - in Christopher Eccleston and Billie Piper.
13. The Impossible Planet/The Satan Pit (Series 2)
This cerebral spine-chiller was written by Matt Jones, who got his first big writing break on Doctor Who Magazine, so there's hope for us discerning article writers! Although Russell T Davies did have a significant input.
The 'Welcome to Hell' writing on the wall is attention-grabbing enough, but you know s**t is real when the TARDIS can't translate the ancient lettering on the wall, and she sounded eerily queasy on materialisation anyway. Those Type 40 TARDISes have great instincts.
It feels suitably industrial, showing the real-world danger and struggle of humanity's deep space exploration. Quakes devastate the sanctuary base, members of the crew die, and worst of all, the Doctor gets put on laundry duty. Then the Beast (wondrously voiced by Gabriel Woolfe) dusts off his psychological playbook by targeting vulnerable archeologist, Toby. He also makes a brief, growling appearance on Zach's visual display, when the good captain is looking away of course. The second part is then excitingly set-up with a Classic Who-esque cliffhanger. He's a devil that one.
As the Beast stirs from his eternal slumber, the Doctor's infectious - and vital - optimism shines through his praising and hugging of the intrepid humans. His line of "or a good psychologist" is a gem of mental fortitude. It's the ultimate battle of wits which is epically spine-tingling:
"This one knows me as I know him. The killer of his own kind."
The final showdown has too much Rose-tinted schmaltz, but it does have a great snarl-off between the Doctor and a flamingly furious Beast. Moreover, it whets the appetite for more Doctor-immortal beings battles.
12. Blink (Series 3)
"I think I nailed something really well when I wrote Blink. I think I was really proud of that. I didn't know immediately it was a great episode. I remember Julie Gardner saying 'That's your best one,' and I said 'Can't be. The Doctor's not in it.' But I've realised over time that was an important moment."
"The Doctor's not in it" - and not just any Doctor, but one of the most popular incarnations in David Tennant, which makes Blink's regular topping of greatest episodes lists even more impressive. Conversely, the mysterious absence of the Doctor piques our curiosity even more so: from his warning message behind the peeling wallpaper at Wester Drumlins to the TARDIS key dangling from a Weeping Angel's merciless grip.
Up steps - or rather over the foreboding wrought iron gates - the intrepid Sally Sparrow, who displays Doctorish qualities of her own as she cleverly follows the Nolanesque Hansel & Gretel breadcrumbs throughout, complete with her own natty scarf and long brown coat.
The casting is perfect. Carey Mulligan's tour de force performance and the supporting characters, and the very satisfying way they assist Sally: Larry's impressively intrinsic shorthand, Billy's ingenious DVD Easter egg, right down to Banto and his line of "Go to the police you stupid woman... why does nobody ever just go to the police?" Similarly to what Russell T Davies said about the taxi driver from Partners in Crime, it's a small part for an actor, yet he says those words perfectly. Then, of course, there's Murray Gold's uniquely eerie yet energetic score.
Steven Moffat said that "it was Blink that got me the showrunner job". Truer words were never spoken.
11. Midnight (Series 4)
As the Doctor says: "taking a big space truck with a bunch of strangers across a diamond planet called Midnight? What could possibly go wrong?" Well, as the Tenth Doctor would say, everything goes right from a viewers' perspective.
There are plenty of brilliant episodes from series four: from Steven Moffat's de rigueur seasonal special (Silence in the Library/Forest of the Dead) to Russell T Davies' epically spectacular The Stolen Earth/Journey's End. However it's Davies' less showy more stripped-back, stage show-style allegory that's more immersive.
While the knocking from the unknown entity is straight out of the Moffat playbook of simple psychological scares, it's the top form acting all round throughout which heightens the claustrophobic terror. Mechanic Claude's look of astonished wonder to sudden panic when he sees something dark running towards the shuttle. How many times have you rewatched/paused/zoomed in on that segment? So it begins.
Lesley Sharp is terrifyingly transfixing as the troubled Sky Silvestry - her look of sinister satisfaction after stealing the cleverest voice in the room, and then trying to manipulate the rest into murdering the Doctor. As the freaked out humans and the Doctor mention frequently: it's her eyes, those deep blue pools darting between one panicked person to the other. It sounds positively demonic when her voice perfectly synchronises to what the others are saying.
Sharp and David Tennant are an absorbing watch, with the Tenth Doctor’s Time Lord Victorious persona evincing itself here. Fat lot of good it does him here though, as the brave hostess heroically fulfils her duty by saving his life.
10. The Waters Of Mars (2008-2010 Specials)
During the watchalong/tweetalong of Gridlock, (God bless Emily Cook for organising those during lockdown), Russell T Davies tweeted:
"Truth is, I like pushing that character. I don't have much time for character descriptions like 'never cruel or cowardly.' Sorry. But never limit your lead."
Well, the Doctor becomes dangerously limitless near the end of this particular life. We all know and love David Tennant's popular incarnation for his infectious, cheeky chappy charisma, and slim and a little bit foxy look. But there's always been an undercurrent of self-aggrandising - yep, much like his previous and later versions. Ancient North Martian? Linguistic showoff!
He sees that limitless ambition in Captain Adelaide Brooke and her descendants. But this goes from wide-eyed wonderment to wild-eyed wanderlust: screwing the Laws of Time to save someone as "important" as Adelaide. Undaunted in the face of the Doctor's vainglorious omnipotence, Adelaide - in a bravura turn by Lindsay Duncan - blindsides the Time Lord Victorious in the most devastating way.
Conversely, it would've been an equally dramatic denouement had the Doctor activated Action Five - a la pushing the lever in The Fires of Pompeii. Imagine it: the Doctor, instead, having to stop Adelaide from escaping her fixed point fate, catalysed by Steffi Ehrlich's heartbreaking final moments of watching a message from her little girls, then devastatingly transformed by the infected water.
The water zombie monsters are effectively terrifying with their Halloween contact lenses, and remarkable running speed when almost catching up to the Doctor and Adelaide despite them rocketing away on good old Gadget. Their ear-piercing scream is akin to the bone-chilling Aztec death whistle. And to think, their scary features were toned down following the rushes.
9. The Eleventh Hour (Series 5)
"When I say 'fairytale', a better way of saying it would be 'modern fairytale'. It's not that it's like the old fairytales, or that it resembles them, it's the modern equivalent. It's the way we teach our children that there are things in the world that might want to eat them. It just feels like a fairytale: a man who fights monsters but never becomes one."
We see Steven Moffat's fantastical approach to Doctor Who immediately after the opening titles: the invitingly sweeping shot of an enchantingly overgrown and rustic back garden, with pinwheel whirling away, owl hooting, and a swing creakily swaying in the breeze. All musically encapsulated by Murray Gold's wondrous Little Amy.
The episode tagline: "The new Doctor has 20 minutes to save the world, and only Amy Pond - the girl who waited - can help him", is indicative of The Eleventh Hour overall - the 64 minute runtime really does fly by thanks to Moffat's bustling and naturally funny script.
Smith brilliantly banishes away any initial "too young to play the Doctor" fandom backlash with a performance full of energetic eccentricity and engaging idiosyncrasies. Together with Karen Gillan and Arthur Darvill, they form a terrific time travelling trio. And, of course, let's not forget the star turn from Olivia Coleman which clearly set her on the way to stratospheric stardom.
When all you have to say is "fish custard" - much like "the Angels have the phone box" - it's testament to its pantheon of popularity amongst Doctor Who episodes.
8. The Doctor’s Wife (Series 6)
One of the greatest love stories ever told. No, this isn't about Amy and Rory, although waiting 2,000 years for your beloved would usually trump any classic boy meets girl tale.
Matt Smith and Suranne Jones make a playful pairing, delightfully conveying the spectrum of sweetly smitten and deep affection between the Doctor and his one true love TARDIS. Jones is brilliantly barmy with a convincing air of otherworldliness making her the definitive TARDIS, if ever there was one. The kiss of golden energy she transfers to the makeshift TARDIS is the glorious icing on the cake.
The ever-brilliant Neil Gaiman packs a lot of imaginative ideas into 45 fast-paced minutes. The thought of "lots and lots of Time Lords" goes from gleeful amazement to painful realisation. It's a visual delight: the asteroid reminiscent of the planetary junkyard Sakaar from Thor: Ragnarok, and the Doctor and Idris racing towards then entering the TARDIS is a sheer spectacle. Gaiman also throws in some old school with infinite TARDIS corridors, and a green-eyed Ood for good, scary measure. Plus, it's always nice to see the Ninth and Tenth Doctors' desktop theme.
Michael Sheen's masterstroke in malevolence as House is one of his best chameleon acts (I honestly thought it was Gabriel Woolf's voice). The only minor grumble is Rory "dying" *insert groan here*, which becomes more of an annoying running gag at this point.
There are many memorable lines, from Idris' poetic: "No, but I always took you where you needed to go," to the Doctor's chilling "Fear me. I've killed all of them."
In the end, it's your classic Old Girl floating in front of her Doctor, just wanting to say hello.
7. The Angels Take Manhattan (Series 7)
Just like Ellen Ripley and the acid-drooling Aliens, Amy Pond is inextricably linked to the Weeping Angels. Therefore, it had to be the quantum-locked lonely assassins to provide a dramatic and heartbreaking end to hers and Rory's adventures in time and space. Plus Karen Gillan wanted to be "offed" by a Weeping Angel anyway, according to Steven Moffat.
If Blink was unknowingly foreboding, then The Angels Take Manhattan is knowingly foreboding - the doors creakily and creepily opening up for Sam Garner at Winter Quay (yep, would run like hell at that point); Rory's name on the gravestone; the unnerving chuckling and padding of the Baby Angels, where one of them rather inconsiderately blows Rory's match out; and the close-up of the foreboding chapter title: Amelia's Last Farewell.
Murray Gold creates a fittingly frightening film noir soundtrack that seems to include the Weeping Angels' version of a Velociraptor call, or an inbuilt alarm system to notify them of potential escapees from Winter Quay.
It was cruel enough that the Angels continually zapped those poor souls even further into the past at the "battery farm", but taking away Rory was just jaw-droppingly sadistic. Although the standard companion-departure-blubbing starts when Amy decides to follow her heroic centurion, the real hefty heartrending stuff is brutally albeit beautifully observed in the emotional aftermath.
Firstly, there's Amy's afterword to the Doctor, asking him for one final favour to go back and tell her younger self all the adventures she's going to have. Talk about spoilers though! Then if that wasn't enough to empty the Kleenex tissue box, we see Rory's dad, Brian, discover he won't ever see his son again...
6. The Day Of The Doctor (2013 Specials)
The 50th anniversary special was an unequivocal critical and commercial success. Five-star ratings across the spectrum of time and space. Simulcast in 94 countries. Shown in cinemas, in 3D (when 3D was still in vogue. Yep, that long ago; we're now closer to the 60th anniversary special). An impressive box office gross of $10.2 million, and voted the greatest ever Doctor Who story in 2014 by readers of Doctor Who Magazine.
Matt Smith and David Tennant are a delightful and dextrous Doctor double act; John Hurt said that he and Tennant "should do a revue together". Tennant was equally effusive about the British acting icon:
"As I pull another face, John Hurt has slightly raised an eyebrow, imperceptibly raised an eyebrow, and you know he's winning an Oscar right there."
This zenith of Steven Moffat's many Doctor Who achievements is even more impressive considering how "monstrously stressful" he found it when writing the monumental episode.
Overall, it's a Moffat masterstroke - "This 50th anniversary adventure is the new direction (saving Gallifrey instead of burning it). We're going forwards (the Zygon subplot going on to form the fantastic two-parter in series 9)."
But, and it's a positive but. OK, more of an if only. If only Christopher Eccleston had gone to conventions sooner because meeting Whovians has "healed" him. If only Moffat had worked that extra quarter magic having "three-quarters talked him into it", given that we were teased the Ninth Doctor's involvement in the A Second Target for Tommy book.
Happily - and fantastically - Eccleston is reprising his role as the Ninth Doctor in a series of Big Finish audio adventures. Hopefully that goodwill continues in time for the 60th anniversary special...
5. Listen (Series 8)
Sam Mendes has spoken how his impressive opening "one-shot" scene from Spectre inspired him to use that directorial approach for 1917. For Steven Moffat, Listen acted like a precursor - a very informed precursor - to Heaven Sent in many ways.
We're immersed straightaway in a sinisterly otherworldly atmosphere, with the Doctor engaged in a Sherlockian soliloquy about whether we're ever really alone when we're enjoying some me time. Moffat imaginatively plays on that fear - along with our basic fears of what might be lurking the dark, and what might be lurking under our bed - then heightens them.
The suspenseful scene where the Doctor, Clara, and Rupert turn their backs on the scary bedspread harks back to The Impossible Planet where the demonic voice tells Toby: "Don't turn around." Although Clara and Danny's awkward first date comes a pretty close second for suspense - we all know how nerve-racking those situations are.
There are many takeaways from this episode. Clara hasn't half been intrinsic to the Doctor's life - giving him a symbolic unarmed toy soldier. Providing him reassuring words - never cruel or cowardly - for when he returns to the barn for that near fateful day. There's definitely a bootstrap paradox at work there. Blokes can pick up some useful "dad skills" by telling their wee ones that fear is a superpower. However putting them to sleep with the merest touch might need some refining. But most importantly, we now know who takes our mug of coffee!
4. Heaven Sent (Series 9)
"Some days... all the windows align and everything seems to work, and you think: this episode's a cracker."
We could use Steven Moffat's own words to sum up this breathtaking episode. However it's more of a pleasure waxing lyrical about Heaven Sent for ages, but perhaps not for 4.5 billion years.
Everything really did align here. Moffat's gorgeously enigmatic script, which included the welcoming version of the Doctor's own mind palace, and this gem of a brilliantly funny in-joke: "I've finally run out of corridor. There's a life summed up." Rachel Talalay's arresting and artful direction - making the torturously thudding Veil as menacing as the Terminator, and Principal Skinner chasing Bart Simpson. The satisfying sprinkling of some classic foreboding Doctor Who synth, and the rousing crescendo when the Doctor finally breaks through the tough son of a bitch Azbantium wall. Oh Rassilon, you've done it now.
Out of the many mesmerisingly mind-bending performances from Peter Capaldi, Heaven Sent is his magnum opus - enthralling an audience alone. Think Tom Hanks in Cast Away, Will Smith in I Am Legend, Sam Rockwell in Moon, and Sandra Bullock in Gravity. Yes, that good. Oh and the quick glance to the camera in his "storm room" is a delightfully deft touch.
This is the Doctor fuelled by incandescent and unforgiving rage. Scared yet heartbreakingly resolute after billions of brutal, burnt and bloody years painstakingly punching his way out of the Time Lord’s version of Fort Boyard. That's a hell of a bird. It's one hell of an episode.
3. World Enough And Time/The Doctor Falls (Series 10)
Even though Twice Upon a Time served as Peter Capaldi's swansong, it's the immersive series ten finale which provides the blockbuster ending for the Twelfth Doctor.
There are many epic ingredients that are carefully and captivatingly crafted by Steven Moffat; no hint of spaghetti being thrown at the wall here.
Take a dash of regeneration teasing. However this is less a red herring - here's looking at you The Lie of the Land - instead it's a crafty piece of misdirection by Moffat. There is definitely no fake out this time. The Doctor, looking bedraggled, is clearly struggling and summoning all his will to stop regenerating. And, yeah, Capaldi had already announced he was leaving the show beforehand.
Mix a handful of shocking twists for poor old Bill Potts. First, the WOW! and skull on her jacket does, rather unfortunately, neatly sum up the graphically godawful hole in her chest. Secondly, the harrowing penny-dropping moment we realise that she's been fully converted into a throwback Cyberman.
Add a couple of memorable and magnificent Masters. Michelle Gomez and John Simm are naturally and effortlessly brilliant, beguiling, and bananas. Although there's some tweaks with a conflicted Missy and a simmered down version of Simm's manic Master from the Russell T Davies era. They and Capaldi are an enratpturing triumvirate throughout, particularly when the Doctor makes that impassioned plea to them to stay and fight out of simple kindness. Master, you callously wicked man, nice to have you back.
Augment an awe-inspiring 400 mile-long Mondasian colony ship and black hole to create a mesmerising coruscating vita.
Chuck in a cliffhanger with the First Doctor and you've got the best series finale since series four's The Stolen Earth/Journey's End.
2. Rosa (Series 11)
Although we still have a long way to go, the world has, thankfully, moved on significantly from the downright shocking societal ills Rosa Parks had to endure in 1955.
Series 11 had its far share of politically correct/woke criticism, but Rosa spotlighted how racism is still prevalent in society today. There's no harm in going back to the show's educational roots now and again, especially for our impressionable wee Whovians. Moreover, the fact that racism is still a prevailing evil within a 52nd century character is a stark and damning indictment, albeit this sci-fi element felt a little tacked on.
The episode pulls no punches, and quite literally in Ryan's case as he receives a brutal slap for having the audacity to kindly pick up a white woman's glove, then try to hand it back to her. Though we'd loved to have seen the Doctor dishing out some crowd-pleasing Venusian aikido, it would've cheapened a powerful scene.
We also get a hint of - shock, horror - character development for Yaz as she describes her own struggles against everyday prejudices. But she provides a boon of optimism:
"But they don't win, those people. I can be a police officer now cos people like Rosa Parks fought those battles for me. For us. And in 53 years, they'll have a black President as leader. Who knows where they'll be 50 years after that? But that's proper change."
Segun Akinola harnesses that feeling with a fittingly heroic score. It's very apt that an asteroid - 284996 Rosaparks - should be named after the trailblazing heroine given the extraordinary impact she made on the world.
1. Ascension Of The Cybermen/The Timeless Children (Series 12)
Right, let's start off with the all round excellence.
Ascension of the Cybermen follows on from the equally excellent The Haunting of Villa Diodati. The ominous pre-title message from Ashad (the Lone Cyberman sounds better and more suitably badass), followed by the title sequence elegantly via a Cyberman's eye socket serves notice of this episode's breathlessly action-packed intentions.
There's a dash of the Christopher Nolan's here: criss-crossing time from early 20th century rural Ireland to the far-flung future of the Cyber-Wars' aftermath, all incorporated by the dramatic beats throughout. There's a hint of the TIE fighter sound with the Cyberdrones, which seemingly do more considerable damage than any main Cybermen guard would. The relentless Lone Cyberman was clearly a Terminator and Nemesis fan during his fully human days, and along with his Cyber-Army, makes them the most threatening generation of Cybermen in the NuWho era.
"I think you’re going to need a very strong drink.”
Indeed we did, Chibbers. In fact, us Whovians hit the Maldovarium and Zaggit Zagoo bar hard in despair or delight, or a conflation of both. Either way, the bombshell Timeless Child revelation felt more like the belabouring Master hosting the Doctor's episode of This Is Your Life. Plus it was pretty obvious who the cantankerous cloths from The Ghost Monument were alluding to.
Here's hoping Chris Chibnall has taken a leaf out of the Russo brothers' book by writing himself into a corner in order to deliver a stupendous payoff. Still, we'll always have the mind-blowing Matrix scene replete with Morbius Doctors.
The visual effects from DNEG are the winners here. The imposing Cybership, the breathtaking Boundary gateway, and satisfying time-lapse of Gallifrey's Citadel construction look impressively cinematic.
Doctor Who Quiz: How Well Do You Know The New Seasons?