Doctor Who: The Robot Revolution Review - 6 Ups & 5 Downs

A much less rocky start for Fifteen’s second run, in spite of the cliches we’ve come to expect…

Doctor Who The Robot Revolution
BBC Studios

We are back on screens! Doctor Who season two is now officially underway, though with seemingly little promotional fanfare this time around. The Robot Revolution is premiering to a rather bleak backdrop of rumours regarding the show’s future, with the next series yet to be greenlit and murmurings of Gatwa’s departure. This press has sadly overshadowed what little promo work was mustered to promote the second series, which, on the whole, is looking great from the trailers alone.

Does this episode help put these rumours to bed and reassure us that the ship is being steered away from the meteor shower? Not quite. Is it a vast improvement on last year's make-or-break opener, Space Babies? Thankfully, yes. Massively so.

In fact, in terms of RTD’s series openers in general, this definitely comes out relatively near the top. I could make a comment about that not being much of an achievement, but frankly, I’m just glad this series hasn’t kicked off with a total dud at time where it is under a lot of scrutiny. We, as a fanbase, are in need of a win right now, and this will do just fine.

As ever, we will dissect this episode using the tried and tested medium of breaking up our thoughts into ‘schwups’ and downs. In this climate of negativity sorrounding the show, let’s begin on a massive UP!

11. UP - Miss Belinda Chandra (Does It Have To Say Miss?)

Doctor Who The Robot Revolution Belinda Chandra
BBC Studios

I would like to start with what I believe is the biggest positive of this opener by some margin: Varada Sethu’s performance as Belinda Chandra.

Straight out of the gate, I’m a big fan of this character and, with no slight on Mille Gibson intended, I found myself warming to her a lot quicker than I did to Ruby. Belinda, with her NHS job and her house share complete with troublesome landlord and bickering roommates, feels relatable and real in a way most characters did not in the last series. This was something that was always one of RTD’s strengths in his first era and I’m glad to see is a skill that remains  in his wheelhouse. I also think a big part of this is owing to Chandra’s performance too, helping to sell both her competence and her ‘so over this’ attitude.

My favourite scene in this whole episode was the brief moment where Fifteen hits Belinda with the technobabble and exposition and Belinda is not into it, caring far more about the fact that he was at her house, uninvited. “Am I six?” as a response to the phrase “Timey-wimey” was the line of the week for me. Great to see that Sethu has some solid comedic chops to match Gatwa.

Doctor Who The Robot Revolution Belinda Chandra
BBC Studios

I also enjoyed the scenes in which Belinda got to flex her skills as a nurse, and show off the skills she will bring to the TARDIS, as well as her natural fascination with the internal biology of both the MissBelindaChandrakind and The Doctor (also, the X-Ray blanket was neat). Speaking of the latter, it was a lot easier to buy into the chemistry between the Doctor and his companion this time too, and I’m very excited to see how these two play off each other as, presumably, their friendship starts to blossom.

I can’t move on before acknowledging that The Doctor instantly referring to Belinda as ‘Bel’ feeds unwelcome credence to a certain circulating theory regarding a couple of adventures from Flux, an as yet unborn child, and a RTD-style mash-up name. Please, please don’t do this, RTD. Let her be her own character.


10. UP - Written In The Stars

Doctor Who The Robot Revolution
BBC Studios

The central premise of this episode was so, so goofy, but in my opinion, it was perfect for a light-hearted opener, in which the plot always takes a back seat in favour of screen time for the new companion.

We’ve all seen those star diplomas – for a time, they were all the rage. Many of us may have even received one when our partner ran out of good ideas and, like Belinda, might have had to feign excitement for such an occasion. I love the ludicrous twist that this lazy, faux-sentimental present is what drags Belinda half way across the universe and into a world of chaos.

Whilst the strange time dilation between the two planets feels a little undercooked, it’s passable enough to believe that somehow this diploma might serve as a foundation myth for the society springing to life on this distant star. It’s the kind of silliness this show thrives on.

I will say though, that, if we’re going to do another ‘73 Yards’ where the mystery of how the robots got the star certificate in the first place is left unexplored, I retroactively declare this plot point a down…


9. UP - Retro Robots

Doctor Who The Robot Revolution
BBC Studios

I was a big fan of the visual stylings of this episode, which clearly took inspiration from retro sci-fi comics and B movies, with its shiny, clunky, oversized robots and eyesore of a rocket – RTD says he was aiming for 50s vibes and I think they hit the mark.

Also, I will always give a up to use of practical effects over CG. Special mention must go to Polish-bot, who is the best boy and the clear hero of the episode. I already feel fiercely protective over him, and I am extremely disappointed that he was not adopted by The Doctor and Belinda (he even had a tiny little car boot for storing dust from all that hard work he’s been doing. 10/10. Adorable.).

Whilst it required a little suspension of disbelief in the ‘but why?’ department, I also enjoyed the ‘every ninth word’ weakness for the robots, which forced some fun scriptwriting. My only criticism on this front is that I wish the editing had trusted viewers a little bit more to decode these ‘hidden’ messages themselves, without playing it back almost every time.


8. DOWN - So Long, Sasha (We Hardly Knew Ya)

Doctor Who The Robot Revolution Ncuti Gatwa Fifteenth Doctor
BBC Studios

Yes, I know. The Doctor telling a random side character that he’s going to ‘show them the stars’ is tantamount to an immediate and painful death sentence (he really should have learned to stop saying this by now, along with just maybe leaving Christmas Day alone).

It’s a trope that I don’t mind being used for it’s emotional impact, so long as it’s earned within the episode (see Lynda from The Parting of Ways, Astrid from Voyage of the Damned and Rita from The God Complex), but with Sasha 55, a redshirt so blatant that there are at least 54 more of her standing by to take a bullet, this didn’t land for me this time. I understand that Fifteen has spent six months with her, but I’d spent five minutes, and, for most of that, she was behaving as a subservient drone.

Still, at least her almost chuckle-worthy departure let Ncuti hit his crying quota and continue his as-yet-unbroken streak of shedding a tear in every single episode. At this point, I’m in it for the meme and will be disappointed when he doesn’t.

Thankfully, our fallen soldier will live on, thanks to the newly renamed ‘Citadel of Sasha 55’.

No one else will live on, though. Just her.


7. UP - Ncuti Being Ncuti

Doctor Who The Robot Revolution Ncuti Gatwa Fifteenth Doctor
BBC Studios

Ncuti Gatwa seems very at ease in the role from the off in this series, and, dare I say it, gets to do a lot more traditional ‘Doctor-work’ this week, taking control and playing the hero.

As mentioned, Fifteen’s natural chemistry with Belinda already feels like an improvement on the somewhat hard to buy ‘best friends’ dynamic of Season One. This is a cheeky Doctor, and I think pairing him with a slightly more combative companion akin to the Tennant-Tate dynamic will allow him to shine a lot more. Let my man be sassy.

Of course he hits the traditional Fifteen beats, with a Kylie Minogue reference and a ‘Yas queen’, and this is never not fun. Love to see a Doctor living his best life and this really is where Gatwa feels most at home. Also, totally digging the new trim - very sharp. Kind of wish this was the default hairstyle for Fifteen going forwards, honestly.

Side note, before I move on: I feel like we really skimmed over the horrific implications of the Doctor causing a power-cut in an Intensive Care Unit. It’s a funny bit, but crikey…


6. DOWN - Who Da Manny? (No Really, Who Is That?)

Doctor Who The Robot Revolution
BBC Studios

There’s a lot of points in this episode that feel undercooked, but none so much as the group of rebel fighters, the titular ‘revolution’.

Now, don’t get me wrong, this episode had a lot to cover, and, realistically, this tried and tested ‘rebels fight the bad guys’ plot doesn’t need a mountain of exposition - we’ve seen it before. My issue comes stems from the fact that they did try to include an additional plot line here using about thirty seconds worth of screen time, and the result is laughable.

I am, of course, referring to Manny and his utterly out-of-the-blue beef with Belinda. The show is trying to portray that he’s lashing out in his grief over all those dead redshirts (I think?). That’s fine, understandable, even – he’s allowed to be miffed that his disposable faceless friends have died saving someone he doesn’t know – there’s meat on that narrative bone. Unfortunately, instead of expressing this sentiment, Manny slaps Belinda with the dumbest line in the episode:

”You’re as bad as the robots!”

Manny… mate. In what world are you saying this with a straight face? Either you properly zoned out during the previous sequence, or you’re not as ‘good’ as The Doctor argues you are. This feels like such a tremendous leap in aggression for this character to make, based on what he’s seen so far, and appears to have been done to inject a sense of tension that feels entirely artificial.

After Manny angrily squeezes a support beam whilst staring down Belinda, he decides to rather awkwardly climb down from his rage and proclaim her the ‘Queen of Planet Earth’ later on, which is nice of him, if slightly abrupt…


5. UP - Trippy Timey-Wimey Vibes

Doctor Who The Robot Revolution
BBC Studios

I’d like to talk about another highlight of the episode for me, the scene of the two star diplomas colliding. I won’t comment on the logic of that resolution because there isn’t any. What I’d like to focus on instead is the composition of the scene – the VFX and editing of this sequence was, for lack of a better phrase, pretty dope.

The initial time-stop ripple effect is amongst the best looking bits of CGI we’ve seen from the Disney-budget thus far, and Murray Gold’s score shows a rare moment of restraint, slapping us with a distorted and minimalist piece in place of the usual bombast (this goes just as hard as a full orchestra).

What follows is a total acid trip of abstract shapes and colours, with glitchy visuals and audio throughout. We also get a few blink-and-you’ll-miss-it flashes of additional faces: an older Belinda, a young boy, a dark haired man, and an older gentleman wondering about in confusion. We’ll have to wait and see if these glimpses amount to anything, but if they do, it’ll be a welcome step in the direction of subtlety.

Doctor Who The Robot Revolution
BBC Studios

It wasn’t just this scene that hit us with the tripiness either, we got a number of instances of major schwuppage throughout the episode. Big fan of the schwup.

This was weird. I’d like more please.


4. DOWN - The Patented RTD Mystery Box

Doctor Who The Robot Revolution
BBC Studios

Here we are again. The teases begin. I hope you’re all ready for the sixth iteration of the ‘Bad Wolf’ style series arc! We know how much you enjoyed playing ‘spot the recurring thing’ the previous five times we pulled this trick!

RTD gives us multiple questions to ponder this time: What happens on 24th May that means Belinda can’t get home? What mysterious man told Fifteen Belinda’s name? And the biggest of all: who is Mrs Flood?

I have a question in return. Why should I invest myself in the answers to this after the previous season? The big reveal last year was RTD’s smug rug pull where he explained the central tease was unimportant after intentionally leading us to think it was (and that’s without getting into the other ‘twist’ involving an anagram that wasn’t an anagram).

Maybe Mrs Flood is the Rani, maybe she’s a member of The Pantheon, maybe she’s Susan, or maybe I just want a series arc that focuses on character development and not underwhelming plot twists that prioritise Twitter-buzz. I could also do without the fourth-wall breaks, but I’ll concede this is a personal preference.

Doctor Who The Robot Revolution Mrs Flood
BBC Studios

I want to be invested in who this mysterious woman is, I really do. Let me be proved wrong, but, as the old saying goes: “Fool me once…”

Before I move on, I do actually have a second question. Could we not have tried visiting the 23rd of May and having Belinda spend a night in a hotel? It feels like Fifteen didn’t try very hard there. Then again, he clearly wasn’t having the best day in terms of general awareness, as he missed a black cab, the Eiffel Tower, and the Statue of Liberty presumably floating towards the open TARDIS.

This marks the second feat of incomprehensible stealth that Lady Liberty has pulled in this show, which isn’t a lot, but it’s weird that it happened twice.


3. DOWN - We Have Martha At Home

Doctor Who The Robot Revolution Belinda Chandra Varada Sethu
BBC Studios

Now, I’m not accusing RTD2 of being a wholesale rip-off of Tennant’s (first) run, but so far there have been a few too many occasions where it’s had that ‘copy my homework but change a few things’ vibe. And the first episode of Gatwa’s second series is giving me ‘Smith and Jones’ (AKA the first episode of Tennant’s second series) in spades.

Allow me to set the scene: Actress who has appeared in a minor capacity in the prior series joins as a full time companion who works in a hospital. Said companion is transported to a different planet against her will by monotonous, plodding aliens who think they’re just doing their job, and is forced to help save the day so she can go home. Sprinkle with a bit of Donna’s essence in place of Martha, and you’ve made yourself a Robot Revolution.

This is an oversimplification, yes, but it leads me to the wider point. I would like the show to look outside the box a little more. What I’m trying to say is that, on the whole, this all feels too safe… again. Say what you want about Chris Chibs, but Flux was a swing and a half. Arguably a miss, but I think he had the right idea. I worry this season won’t do enough to fight off the accusations of the format going stale. Let’s take some risks! Please.


2. DOWN - Surface Level Commentary

Doctor Who The Robot Revolution
BBC Studios

It’s time to talk about that final act, because, as we’ve come to expect, that’s where this episode starts to buckle.

Am I thankful that this episode pivoted from the ‘Generative AI’ villain that was teased with all the subtlety of a Slitheen in a packed elevator? Yes. Though that doesn’t make the lazy attempt at commentary any better.

Instead, we get to talk about Russell’s take on incel culture. It’s (rightfully) a hot topic right now, with this airing so shortly after Netflix’s ‘Adolescence’, which is a phenomenal piece of not just television, but education. Naturally, Doctor Who was never going to be able to explore the depths of this theme to the same extent, but even so, this felt weak.

Incel culture is bad. This is the generally accepted stance, but I do feel that the show could have gone beyond this baseline just a little more. Instead of having Alan be turned into a power crazed lunatic because he played a video game, show us glimpses of the culture that led him down this path, and the dangers of it. There was enough screen time here to do something a little braver, and a little punchier, than what we got. This man wrote Turn Left, I know he can do better. It felt to me like this was written someone who didn’t have a great understanding of the pipeline to this sort of harmful thinking. A missed opportunity, on the whole, to hit an audience who are most at risk of this type of radicalisation.

Doctor Who The Robot Revolution Alan
BBC Studios

On a lighter note, and speaking of doing better, we know Russell loves a bit of sub-par wordplay and I have to say “It’s not AI, it’s Al” might just be his worst yet. I wholeheartedly believe that RTD once misread the phrase Generative AI and built this entire episode around it. Viewers of this show have an above average tolerance for utter cheese, but this is a fromage too far.

At least Alan got the most out-of-pocket and grim character ending since Ursula turned into a paving slab.

“Polish, polish.” 


1. UP - A Reluctant Passenger

Doctor Who The Robot Revolution Varada Sethu Belinda Chandra
BBC Studios

I know it’s not going to last the whole series, but boy am I pleased to see a new Doctor-companion dynamic (at least for the post 2005 series). Belinda may have enjoyed the Doctor’s company, and taken to planet-saving like a fish to water, but she’s in no rush to make a habit of it.

The last few minutes of this episode were amongst the most interesting, to me. It starts off looking like any other ‘all of time and space’ chat, with the Doctor seemingly convinced Belinda will be charmed enough to join him for further adventures. He even hits her with the reveal he’s met her descendant Mundy Flynn straight out of the gate (yes, we spotted the ‘Boom’ title drop), attempting to dazzle her with some big talk about destiny, mysteries to solve, and all the good stuff. Belinda, in a really welcome change of pace… is not having any of it.

Doctor Who The Robot Revolution
BBC Studios

Belinda berates him for taking her DNA sample without permission (once again, acting like an actual nurse), and point blank tells The Doctor she’s not ‘one of his adventures’, insisting that he take her straight home. Instantly, we have an additional layer to this relationship – a hurdle to overcome, even. It’s been a good few years since anything like this happened in any significant capacity, and I, for one, am far more interested in the character interactions this could potentially give us than the actual reason Belinda can’t get home.

Let us see The Doctor challenged by his companion, have him grapple with his responsibility, and allow Belinda to stay in this phase of reluctance long enough to squeeze some interesting material out of it.

Once upon a time, character work was RTD’s bread and butter. I really, really hope that, this time around, our showrunner remembers what made his first run so special.


Contributor

Alex is a sci-fi and fantasy swot, and is a writer for WhoCulture. He is incapable of watching TV without reciting trivia, and sometimes, when his heart is in the right place, and the stars are too, he’s worth listening to.