Doctor Who: Why Peter Davison's Fifth Doctor Is Underated

peter davison doctor who The Fifth Doctor, portrayed by Peter Davison from late 1981-1984, has always been unfairly judged by a certain amount of fans. It's either the personality of the Fifth Doctor that tends to make people wary about his era, or people are unsure about his era just by the stories alone. Some fans didn't think that Peter Davison could ever be as good as Tom Baker, who had the role of Doctor for seven years. But sometimes it's the fact this Doctor was part of the John Nathan-Turner era as producer that turns people off from watching. Whatever the case, some of the criticisms can be downright harsh and it's time to set things straight. This article is going to look in depth at the Fifth Doctor, his era and what makes him special in his own way, and what makes him so underated compared to some of the other Doctors.

Young Looks

peter davison doctor who2 The youthful looks of the Fifth Doctor came in handy. The enemies underestimated him, and were mostly caught offguard. Looks, as observed here, can be very deceiving. He had the looks of youthful, athletic cricketer; not as some older, wisened Time Lord that had been travelling for quite some time. Some people did not warm up to that. People who grew up with Patrick Troughton as the Doctor, or Jon Pertwee, or even Tom Baker, and were quite used to the older looking Doctor, and wanted it to stay that way. But why not try a different approach... after all John Nathan-Turner did work with Peter Davison on All Creatures Great and Small. With his amusing and wonderful performance in that show, the producer must have felt strongly that Peter was perfect for the role of the Fifth Doctor. Someone with the young looks, and a love of cricket. With the young looks, he also had the young companions. A feisty stewardess named Tegan, who ended up being the one companion to stay on the TARDIS the longest, a Traken scientist named Nyssa, and an Alzarian named Adric. Adric had been with the Fourth Doctor and Nyssa was introduced in the Fourth Doctor story, Keeper of Traken, but did not join the crew until the following story, Logopolis, just like Tegan. The companions may have been issue with some fans, not just the Doctor. Tegan was written to be a tempermental and a bit abrasive, but with a good heart. Adric tended to complain more after Tegan and Nyssa joined. The TARDIS crew had become crowded, and without the amount of writers that were used to writing for three companions in the sixties, it was much more difficult. So eventually they got rid of Adric first. It was then the Doctor, Tegan and Nyssa. Despite what some think, the rapport with the Fifth Doctor and his companions, no matter how rocky they started, they always were close. Tempers would flare up, or one would lose patience, but by the time the companion would leave, the departure was certainly felt. The Fifth Doctor seemed to treasure his friendships, and one that seemed to disturb him the most was Tegan's departure. She had been with him for so long and suddenly was running away. To call out to her and say not to leave, not like this, certainly leaves a little tear to someone's eye as they see someone's friendship just disappear so quickly and emotionally.

Personas

fivedoctors People claim the Fifth Doctor is possibly the worst Doctor besides the Seventh Doctor. Of course this is all a matter of opinion, but there are more fans of the earlier Doctors from the eighties than the later years. The Fifth Doctor was reunited with his previous selves in The Five Doctors, excluding Tom Baker, who at the last minute decided to not participate, so writer Terrance Dicks had to come up with something clever for the Fourth Doctor, and it worked out wonderfully. When we first see the Fifth Doctor in post-regenerative state, he starts acting out his previous selves. Starting out with William Hartnell's First Doctor, and it was well done. The mannerism was spot on, clutching onto his braces (or suspenders if you live in either U.S or Canada), and letting out a little high pitched giggle. This was of course Peter Davison's performance, but it all leads to him building up his own persona for his Doctor, while having traces of the previous Doctors as well. Also seen is the Second Doctor persona as the Fifth Doctor marches down the corridor, calling Adric Jamie and that he needs to go back, and that his regeneration is failing. The Five Doctors is a wonderful anniversary episode, no matter what people think of it. With last minute changes, it came out rather well. And Richard Hurndall was excellent as the First Doctor. With this episode the mannerisms of each previous Doctor can be more noted in the Fifth Doctor. He tends to be a bit grumpy like the First Doctor, the enthusiasm of the Second Doctor, and yes, he can insult people just like the Third Doctor, but not as uncontrollably. The Fifth Doctor is able to control himself before really letting someone have it, but you can see when his temper is at its peak. There's not much of the Fourth Doctor persona in him since Tom had just recently left, but the Fifth Doctor has a charming boyish smile that tends to set his companions at ease when things are running smoothly.

The Fifth Doctor Stories

98peter davison doctor who2 The Fifth Doctor's stories were very enjoyable. On occasion there were some that were questionable, such as Time-Flight, the very last episode of the first season.By the time they filmed that particular episode, they had already spent the budget for the season, and there was literally nothing left for Time-Flight. So they had to make do with what they had. The first season of his era was quite enjoyable, kicking off with post-regenerative story Castrovalva. Of course a viewer can tell they were filmed out of sequence due to the hair length of all of the cast. Four to Doomsday was the first one filmed, while Castrovalva was fourth. They brought back the historicals with the first season episode Black Orchid, and we see Tegan fall victim to an enemy called the Mara, and the Doctor has to save her. Towards the end, we say farewell to Adric and then to Tegan, but Tegan would be back in Arc of Infinity, in the second season. The second season seemed questionable by Davison himself, mainly by the scripts, but for some, a few of the stories were at their best. The Mara returns in the second story of the season, called Snakedance. Amazing performances done by all, especially Janet Fielding and Peter Davison as Tegan and the Doctor, and Martin Clunes as Lon. Afterward, there is the introduction to Mark Strickson's character, Turlough. Turlough is an alien exiled to an all-boys school on Earth and will do anything to get back home. The Black Guardian sees this, and offers him that trip home if he does something in exchange. Kill the Doctor. The Fifth Doctor is seen in Mawdryn Undead as a trusting sort, allowing Turlough to join Nyssa, Tegan and himself on the TARDIS, after Turlough had already tried to kill him once or twice in the first of three stories alone. The third season the stories get darker, and the Doctor seems a bit more tired then his first few episodes on the TARDIS. The travels seemed to be getting to him at this point. His outfit has changed, and his hair is noticeably shorter since The Five Doctors. This is most likely due to Peter working on All Creatures Great and Small around the same time in 1983. At this time, John Nathan-Turner found the new Sixth Doctor, who would be Colin Baker, and his companion Perpugilliam (Peri) Brown, played by Nicola Bryant. The Fifth Doctor would be the last to have a rather subtle costume, excluding the question marks on the collar of the dress shirt. But considering the costumes that would be following, he was the last one to be rather gentlemanly. His cricketing outfit had the Edwardian look to it, so it had headed in the right direction of the previous Doctors.

Heroic

thth The Fifth Doctor proved to be trusting and loyal to his companions, despite his impatience and grumpiness. He cared for those around him. Just like the circumstance trying to get Adric back, he fought as hard as he could, but knew at the end, there was no way of saving him. The fact he was willing to give up his life in order to save someone else who he barely knew, showed he was not selfish either. If not giving up a life to save someone is not heroic enough, then there is something even this writer must be missing out on. The Fifth Doctor's swansong, The Caves of Androzani, was voted the best story ever in Doctor Who in Doctor Who Magazine issue 413.

Audio Adventures

74042 The Caves of Androzani, however, is not truly the end of the Fifth Doctor. He had returned for Time-Crash, a Children in Need special written by Steven Moffat in 2007, featuring the Tenth Doctor. But besides that, since 1999, Peter Davison has been recreating the life of the Fifth Doctor in audio adventures from Big Finish Productions. True, you can't physically see the adventure, but the dialogue between the Doctor, companions and enemies, and etc., are truly wonderful. The writers for Big Finish have definitely given more life to the Fifth Doctor, and within the past two or three years, we have seen the return of Janet Fielding as Tegan Jovanka, and Mark Strickson as Turlough. And all of them have given amazing performances. If anyone has any doubts about the onscreen episodes, recommendations of the Big Finish range is extremely high. There are Fifth Doctor adventures with just Nyssa, some with Tegan and Nyssa, and a few with Turlough. But most are with Tegan,Turlough and Nyssa. The chemistry between them all have been the same for thirty years. Suggestions include Sirens of Time, the first audio of the range featuring Fifth Doctor, Sixth Doctor and Seventh Doctor, Cobwebs featuring Tegan, Nyssa and Turlough, and part of the Lost Stories, The Elite, featuring Tegan and Nyssa with the Fifth Doctor. Of course these are just a few suggestions, there are many more that could be recommended as well.

Contributor
Contributor

I am a sales associate by day, and 3D artist and writer at night. I have a passion for Doctor Who, especially the Fifth Doctor era. I go to conventions when I have the funds, and I also make costumes on my spare time.