Emmys 2017 Nominations: 10 Most Outrageous Snubs

When you're living in a golden age of television, tough decisions get made.

American Gods Emmys 2
Starz/ATAS

It's been said before, but it's worth repeating: this is a great time to be alive when it comes to the sheer breadth and creativity of popular television.

Once upon a time, people were shackled to the same unimaginative sitcoms and procedural dramas offered by the very few major networks, and if you didn't like it, too bad. But now that there are so many channels and non-traditional services like Netflix and Hulu churning out more and more fantastic original content, we're spoiled for choices.

So what's the downside? Well, admittedly it isn't much of one when looked at with any measure of perspective, but there is the simple fact that with so much quality television out there, the possibility for some great shows to be overlooked, especially when it comes to awards time.

The Primetime Emmy nominations were revealed last week, with Westworld and SNL leading the way with 22 nominations each. However, even with the frankly absurd number of categories that the Emmys have to offer, there are some fantastic shows that have been left out in the cold this year.

10. Jude Law - The Young Pope

Jude Law The Young Pope
HBO

The Young Pope was, let's face it, a polarizing show. There were people who got it, and people who definitely didn't. But no matter where you fall on The Young Pope, Jude Law's raw power in the lead role is undeniable, and there is no reason why he shouldn't have at least received a nomination for his performance.

The story of a brash, authoritarian American who seizes global power in the unlikeliest of moves feels tailor made for our times, and the unconventional filming style kept audiences constantly in a state of wrongfootedness.

And Jude Law, for better or worse, is at the center of all of this. He commands our attention in every scene, and shows the sort of acting prowess that he rarely utilizes.

So why no Emmy nod? There are plenty of actors who were nominated but created far less of a stir than this performance. For example, Liev Schreiber is an excellent actor, but who is out there still watching Ray Donovan? It seems that Law will have to be content with continuing on his series of "young" roles (he is due to star in the next Fantastic Beasts film as the young Dumbledore).


9. The Leftovers

The Leftovers Season 3
HBO

The Leftovers feels like it's shaping up to be one of those shows where your friends keep saying, "You have to watch this, it's so good!" but it never really ends up being a huge hit (until years later when it becomes revered as a cult classic.)

Among the viewers it already has, there's a lot of love, but it isn't quite getting the audiences that it probably deserves. And sometimes with shows like these that's where the Emmys can help, by bringing attention to a show that is by all metrics critically acclaimed.

But that's apparently not in the cards this year, because The Leftovers was almost completely shut out, with the only nomination being a nod for Ann Dowd in the Outstanding Guest Actress category.

For an awards show that has about seven and a half million categories, that is quite frankly indefensible, especially with Season 3 being the show's last ever.


8. Oprah Winfrey - The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks

The Immortal Life Of Henrietta Lacks Oprah
HBO

You may have gone through life just assuming that Oprah Winfrey has never been overlooked for any achievements she's ever had. And it's also not a difficult argument to make that surely she has had her fair share of accolades, so what's the harm in her missing out this one time?

But it's not like anyone is bemoaning the poor, underappreciated Oprah. It's just a little bizarre that she, normally an awards show favorite, didn't receive a nomination for her performance in The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks, one that richly deserved acknowledgement.

Based on the true story and bestseller of the same name, Oprah portrays a poverty-stricken black woman whose cancer cells were used to create the first immortalized cell line, one that is still used in research today.

It shines a light on the ethical abuses in medical culture, as her cells were used without her consent and without compensation to her or her family. It's a really solid television movie, and Oprah puts in an excellent performance. Alas, she'll have to be satisfied with being a household name and having millions of dollars.


7. Insecure

Insecure Issa Rae
HBO

The Best Comedy category is an interesting one. Normally, it's filled with traditional sitcoms that have overstayed their welcome. The Big Bang Theory, a perennial entry on the list (although excluded this year), has no business still being relevant, and Modern Family is funny, but is way past its glory days.

This year, however, sees a lot of more creatively interesting shows that break out of the traditional network sitcom mode, and more than ever shows that celebrate creators and talent of color.

But there is one glaring omission in the category, and that's the HBO comedy Insecure. Heading into its second season, Insecure tells the story of two black women in their early 30s navigating the world and the contemporary black experience.

Its first season received rave reviews from critics and has amassed a loyal following, but was shut out from this year's Emmys. The bright side is that since this show is still fairly early on in its life cycle, and hopefully will have plenty more opportunities for glory.


6. Freddie Highmore - Bates Motel

Bates Motel Freddie Highmore
A&E

The curse of the former child actor is the eternal struggle to be taken seriously, and to have every role one takes seen as a deliberate attempt to be taken seriously.

Unless of course you happen to be Freddie Highmore and you launch your adult career with an unnerving turn as Norman Bates on the criminally underrated Bates Motel. Because after that, no one was thinking of his as the little boy from Charlie and the Chocolate Factory or Finding Neverland.

He's always been good on the show, but this past season has required more from him as an actor, as the young Norman descends further into madness, and his character's isolation strips him of any meaningful screen partners.

But while Vera Farmiga has been nominated in the past for her performance as the equally off-putting Norma Bates, Freddie Highmore has yet to receive any significant attention for his work on the show.


5. Winona Ryder - Stranger Things

Stranger Things Joyce Winona Ryder
Netflix

While we were all bemoaning the undeserved fate of Barb, Winona Ryder's out here in the cold with no Emmy nomination, despite rightfully earning one at the Golden Globes. What gives?

Sure, the fever pitch of the Stranger Things phenomenon feels like ages ago, particularly with the cultural pace where a week feels like just under three years and memes become outdated in a matter of days.

But Winona Ryder's frenzied yet somehow understated performance as a mother whose son goes missing under mysterious circumstances uses every once of her wild-eyed oddness in the best possible way, and she should have received a nomination.

After all, Hollywood loves nothing quite so much as a great comeback story, and the former film star finding renewed success on a bizarre little science fiction/fantasy show on Netflix would make one for the books. We were looking forward to her nomination if only so that we could see her priceless facial expressions at the awards ceremony. But alas, it was not to be.


4. The Americans

The Americans Keri Russell And Matthew Rhys
FX

As they so brilliantly stated in Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt, you know you're living in a golden age of television when you can take a show like The Americans for granted. It's so incredibly true, and nowhere is it more evident than when looking at the Emmy nominations.

To be totally fair, Keri Russell and Matthew Rhys were both nominated for their powerhouse performances as the Russian spies constantly trying to balance their apple pie home lives with frequent bouts of espionage.

But what world are we living in that this show isn't constantly talked about as the piece of art that it is? It deserves so much more attention than it gets, and now that it's officially approaching its final season, chances to take home some Emmy gold are dwindling fast.

And real talk: This is Us nominated for Best Drama while The Americans sits on the sidelines like the kid who was picked last in gym class? Come on.


3. Legion

Legion David Syd
FX

Somewhere along the line, amidst a busy television season, everyone seems to have forgotten about Legion. And that is just not OK. Sure, genre shows rarely do well at the Emmys (an argument it's getting harder and harder to make, considering the success of Game of Thrones and Westworld), but Legion is such a creative experiment that it doesn't feel like just another science fiction/fantasy series.

It simultaneously solves the problem of what to do with a superhero who is too powerful to function and fundamentally changes what a Marvel property can be. Because when you're watching this show, superheroes in spandex are the furthest thing from your mind.

It's an emotionally and intellectually draining assault on the sense and nothing has been done quite like it before. Dan Stevens is devastating in the lead role, channeling his effortless charm into a mentally broken character.

Legion changes the game for the wide universe of superhero programming and while it might not be exactly the sort of thing the Emmys usually go for, it deserves some attention, especially in the more visually creative categories.


2. American Gods

American Gods Mr Wednesday Ian McShane
Starz

Every time that one of Neil Gaiman's wonderful novels actually makes it to film or television rather than dying a painful death in development hell is always a cause for celebration. Unless of course you're the Emmys, in which case you will do everything possible to ignore it.

American Gods has been the recipient of a pretty positive critical response, as well as praise from viewers for the short time its been on the air. Yet the Emmys threw only a few minor categories in its direction (main title design and special visual effects, come on, who are they trying to kid?).

It seems unjust that actor Ian McShane isn't being acknowledged for his efforts as the enigmatic Mr. Wednesday, but probably the most obvious category that show was overlooked for have to do with its impressive visual style. It seems like in other years, it might have been a lock for cinematography and direction, or even gotten a nod for the big prize.


1. Ed Harris - Westworld

Westworld Ed Harris
HBO

It's sort of a funny little quirk, because Westworld was actually tremendously well-rewarded in terms of Emmy nominations. In total, it received 22 nods, tying Saturday Night Live for the most and doing incredibly well for a genre show.

But despite the Emmys showing a great deal of love for the show as a whole, they've somehow passed over what is probably the most intriguing performance in Westworld. Which is...bizarre. What is this show without the mysterious Man in Black, after all?

He's a riddle wrapped in an enigma, and his unclear motivations throughout the show were a driving force in a series arc that was often purposefully cyclical and repetitive.

And also, in case you forgot, it's Ed Harris. He could stand in front of a blank wall and just stare and it would be captivating. Interestingly enough, there was no love for Jimmi Simpson either, although Thandie Newton, Jeffrey Wright, Anthony Hopkins, and Evan Rachel Wood all received nods.

What shows do you think deserved Emmy nods this year? Share your thoughts down in the comments.


Contributor
Contributor

Audrey Fox is an ex-film student, which means that she prefers to spend her days in the dark, watching movies and pondering the director's use of diegetic sound. She currently works as an entertainment writer, joyfully rambling about all things film and television related. Add her on Twitter at @audonamission and check out her film blog at 1001moviesandbeyond.com.