Friends: 10 Ways It Should Have Ended

The finale of Friends still gives us that warm fuzzy feeling, but what if it had ended differently?

Friends Joey Subway Advert
WC

The finale of Friends is still one of the highest viewed episodes in television history. It’s hardly surprising is it? We grew up singing Smelly Cat, defending or criticising Ross depending on your gender because ‘they were ON A BREAK’, hoping Chandler would keep Richard and Monica apart because they were meant to be, willing Rachel to get off the plane, and patiently waiting for Joey’s big acting break.

Despite the struggles of some other high-profile shows in offering a satisfying finale, Friends' end came with that tangible warm fuzzy feeling that made the depressing finality of it seem a little less awful. Plus the writers tied up critical loose ends, and Rachel did get off the plane, so it's impossible not to love it.

What the finale didn’t give us though was something unpredictable; the opportunity to surprise, shock and scandalise was there for the taking and the writers really missed a trick. And while there may have been outrage if there wasn't a happy ending for everyone, it would have made a reunion show far more likely. (I hate to break it to you, but it wouldn’t work guys, the characters are older and the time for reunion has passed).

So how else could Friends have ended?

10. Rachel Should Have Stayed On The Plane

Friends Ross Rachel
NBC

What Happened

Rachel got off the plane. After 10 years of Ross and Rachel's on and off relationship it was obvious that neither of the characters could have ended up with anyone else; Ross was Rachel's lobster.

Being together and Rachel moving to Paris needn't have been the only two options though.

What Should Have Happened

Ross could have moved to Paris. Yes, that would have meant leaving Ben behind, but he hadn't been in the show since 2002 and that went unquestioned... plus the alternative was to have Emma in Paris where he wouldn't see her either?

By getting off the plane and remaining stateside Rachel sacrificed her dream job in Paris. Forcing her to choose between love, her family and a career was something that the finale didn’t answer, obviously at the time we didn’t question it; we were too busy being glad they were back together. Ross should have followed Rachel to Paris, where they both could have stayed for a year before coming back.

That way we'd have still seen Ross and Rachel finally get back together, but things would have been a little less... obvious.


9. Phoebe Should Have Had Her Own Family

Friends Phoebe babies
NBC

What Happened

Well, nothing. The Friends finale really left Phoebe out. She'd been there through all 10 seasons being hilarious and brilliant, making up ridiculous songs like Smelly Cat and The First Time I Met Chandler, and then she was just left hanging.

Okay, so she'd had a happy ending with her marriage to Paul Rudd, but why was she left feeling like a support to the excitement surrounding the other characters?

What Should Have Happened

In the show’s one-hundredth episode we saw Phoebe give birth to triplets after going through surrogacy for her own brother. As well as giving us the fantastic ‘Chandler’s a girl’ line, this process demonstrated that Phoebe wanted her own children too. She went so far as to get Rachel to talk to Frank about her keeping one of the triplets, but unsurprisingly he was happy with keeping his three children.

We saw the beginnings of Phoebe building a family, getting married to Mike and deciding they wanted children together. The final episodes were a perfect opportunity for Phoebe and Mike to announce that they were pregnant with a brood of their own beautiful babies.


8. Joey Should Have Found Happiness

Friends Joey Subway Advert
WC

What Happened

The final episode left Joey with two forms of poultry, a shattered foosball table and very little else.

Throughout the show we saw him struggle to catch a break in the acting world, we followed his journey to being an expert player of Cups, and we saw multiple failed relationships. Leaving Joey with a failing career and no love interest whilst the other characters were happily coupled off felt so unfair, unlike the rest of the characters though he did get his own spin-off show, but that was essentially a fail too.

What Should Have Happened

In terms of his past relationships we only really saw Joey get caught up on girls that he couldn’t have – Kathy and Rachel being the two most memorable. Bringing in a new character for him to settle down with would have allowed his character to move on to the next stage in his life, just as the rest of the gang had.

A big career break would have worked just as well, and didn't need to be anything massive. Winning awards would have been unrealistic given his past experience modelling lipstick in Japan, but it would have been nice to see him with a little more security. 

Maybe the final scene could have been the cameras panning out for us to see him on a billboard for something he truly loves, sandwiches, pastrami, pizza…?


7. We Should Have Seen Monica And Chandler Be A Family

Friends Erica
WB

What Happened

It was great that we finally got over the ongoing joke of Chandler’s fear of commitment, and it was lovely seeing him and Monica start a family together; but the writers didn’t give us much in the way of rounding off this storyline.

What Should Have Happened

Both Chandler and Monica’s characters developed as a result of the Erica surrogacy storyline, but it could have ended in a much more satisfactory way. Chandler and Monica were never told they absolutely couldn't have children, they were told it would be difficult. 

The surrogacy allowed Chandler to grow up a little – though the addition of a surprise twin at the very last minute gave us another opportunity to doubt his ability to handle adult life. We didn’t need this opportunity; we needed to see Chandler being a Dad, still being his sarcastic self but with added Dad dancing.

It also allowed Monica to stop being such a control freak, which was endearing and made her much more likeable. What would have been perfect though, would have been the one baby surrogacy we expected, and Monica being pregnant. 

Plus Courtney Cox was pregnant in real life so this wasn't exactly a big leap for the writers to make.


6. Ben Should Have Met His Sister

Friends Emma
NBC

What Happened

The show ended in 2004 and Ben hadn't appeared in it since episode 12 of season 8 which aired in 2002. This is weird and has caused numerous strange fan theories about why Ross didn't seem to see Ben at all since before Emma was born (2003).

Ben was only mentioned 6 times in the 54 episodes that followed his final appearance, and these could have easily been Ross referencing a child he no longer saw. Was Ross denied access by Carol and Susan, did he lose custody all together as a result of his bizarre behaviour?

What Should Have Happened

No problems with Ross' access to Ben were ever mentioned, so perhaps this wasn’t the case. More likely Ben was just forgotten about in the excitement of Emma's birth, and the whole Ross and Rachel thing. That's pretty sad though. A few extra scenes with Ben would have allowed Ross’ character to develop a more responsible side, adding weight to the Ross and Rachel saga by making his distress about Emma being so far away in Paris more believable. 

Aside from Ben adding to the Paris storyline, it’s really not cool that he didn’t get to meet his baby sister.


5. Gunther Should Have Been There

Gunther Yellow Shirt Friends
NBC

What Happened

Gunther was the best character aside from the core 6; he’s the character with the most appearances after the main cast, totting up 185 episodes. 

He was consistently there, supplying coffee at all hours of the day and hoping Rachel would one day succumb to his bleach blonde charms, yet his character didn't feature much at all towards the end.

What Should Have Happened

The coffee house was central to the entire show, it was where the characters bonded and where we bonded with them, where we first met Rachel and where she got The Fear, where Chandler discovered the wonders of pen with the naked lady, and where Ross uncovered the state of Unagi.

The final scene should have been the gang introducing Emma and the twins to Central Perk, a place where they’d all grown up. One final scene in the coffee house with an attempt to get Rachel would have been a lovely little feature for Gunther.


4. It Should Have Ended Earlier

Friends Final Bow
NBC

What Happened

Friends was brilliant, there is no denying that. It went on for 10 seasons though and that's a really long time and it's all terribly impressive.

But the whole Ross and Rachel saga went on for way, waaaaaay too long: were they on a break or weren't they? Does it really matter after season 3 when the whole thing actually happened? No, it absolutely does not. They should have got together when Emma was born, but instead the whole Joey and Rachel thing was needlessly distracting.

What Should Have Happened

It should have just wrapped up earlier.

By the end, the characters were getting too old to be living the same lifestyles as they had for the previous 9 seasons. At the beginning we could identify with each and every member of the gang at a different stage in our own life. 

From the weird transition to adulthood and having to think about how we could afford to live (Joey), going through the heartache of relationship breakups for all the right reasons (Monica), and finally realising that our career might not be right for us after all (Chandler), we could see ourselves in these characters. 

Towards the end though they Ross and Rachel were too old to be constantly going through on/off relationship breaks, and the premise of the show kind of stopped working so well.


3. It Should Have Ended On A Cliff-Hanger

Friends Joey Shocked
WB

What Happened

Rachel got off the plane.

It’s over 21 years since Friends first aired, and over 11 years since the gang said goodbye to Apartment 20. The ending answered our most burning questions and allowed us to say goodbye to the show as we would an old friend. 

Fans were happy and somewhat satisfied that the gang would be alright and we’d one day fill the hole Friends left with another American sitcom. The warm fuzzy feeling may have benefitted our own mental health, but it didn’t do much for the show itself.

What Should Have Happened

It should have cut before Rachel's decision was clear.

Other shows have ended their finales on huge cliff-hangers. These shows may have tortured viewers but they reached new heights because of it. Theories about The Sopranos’ famous blank screen are still rife, we’re still wondering if Tony Soprano was ever arrested for his crimes, whether his empire would ever come crashing down, and the show finished in 2007. 

We never got that with Friends; we still hope that the gang will get back together for a reunion show, but the writers made it clear a reunion just wasn’t necessary.


2. They Should Have All Been In A Mental Asylum

Friends Asylum Theory
NBC/WC

What Happened

They all went off into middle age together happily.

What Should Have Happened

Now we get to truly shocking ways to end the Friends finale, and this one draws on the characters’ experiences throughout the show.

The finale should have uncovered the fact that each of the gang are residents at a mental asylum, and they have fabricated perfect lives as part of their delusional tendencies to hide from the harsh realities of their mental health issues.

Each character has an underlying reason for being this way, which have all already been explained in the show.

Chandler was scarred by his parents’ divorce; Joey crumbled under the pressure of being the only boy in a family of fiery Italian women; Monica was left scarred by her school bullying; Rachel had serious Daddy issues and was self-destructive; Ross has abandonment issues, and Phoebe never came to terms with her Mother’s suicide.

And suspiciously, every character made themselves the perfect ending that answered their dysfunctions. Plus they all live in dirt-cheap apartments in prime locations in New York, have their dream jobs (eventually) and spend most of the working week at the coffee house – this is clearly the stuff of delusion.


1. It Should Have All Been Phoebe’s Imagination

Friends Phoebe
NBC

What Happened

The perfect happy endings.

What Should Have Happened

Well, the Phoebe Theory.

Phoebe was a loveable weirdo, an obvious outsider as she didn’t live close to the rest of the gang and she hadn’t known them growing up. She references her life on the streets regularly throughout the show, but what if she never made it out? Fan theories have suggested Phoebe may have been a meth-addict but we’re just going to stick with the entire plot, locations and character-quirks being a result of Phoebe’s wacky imagination for this one. 

She never managed to get her life back on track after her Mother’s suicide, and she’s desperately wishing for a solid group of friends that she could find some semblance of a family unit it. She sees the gang at the coffee house each day, makes up names for them and builds her dream life into theirs.

The finale should have panned out from Central Perk to show Phoebe (that’s not even her real name) preparing for another night on the streets, staring intently at the gang drinking coffee and celebrating the arrival of Monica and Chandler’s twins (again, they are not their real names).

Sure this one may have emotionally crippled us as fans, but we’d probably have gotten over it at some point. And it would have stopped the endless call for a reunion show, at the very least.

How do you think Friends should have ended? Share your thoughts below in the comments thread.


In this post: 
Friends
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I have a pet hedgehog, I like to bake and I do science for a job.