Genius Superhero Cartoons REPLACED By Worse Versions
Was there any need to replace Avengers: Earth's Mightiest Heroes?
Every television series eventually must come to an end (unless you're the Simpsons). This has been the case for numerous superhero shows, which constantly come and go.
While this is common place in the television industry, there have been some cancellations that have been met with scrutiny. This is mainly due to the fact that an awful lot of superhero cartoons get cancelled before their time. Other times it is simply because their replacement is subpar compared to the one that preceded it.
There are a variety of reasons that reboots and replacements do not meet the level of what came before. This could be due to different tones, writing differences or major changes to the mythos that leave fans with a sour taste in their mouths.
Many superheroes have received a number of reboots and new adaptations in cartoon form over the years. There are a number of different choices that could have been selected for this article, however these seven stand out as strokes of genius in the cartoon realm that were replaced with something much, much worse.
7. Batman: The Brave And The Bold Replaced By Beware The Batman
After adaptations such as Batman: The Animated Series and The Batman, it was pleasant to watch a campier side of Batman. Batman: The Brave and the Bold focused on Batman's team-ups with superheroes from various parts of the DC Universe, including heroes such as Green Arrow, Plastic Man and Aquaman.
The series tied closer to the Silver Age of the fifties and sixties than the darker, more modern stories that have involved the Caped Crusader. While the animation had no overarching plot, it focused on a different story and team-up per episode, much like the source material that was used for inspiration.
The Brave and the Bold was a breath of fresh air for fans who loved the classic comic book team-ups, and were getting tired of every adaption of Batman being grim and full of brooding.
After three seasons, The Brave and the Bold was replaced by Beware the Batman, which focused on the Caped Crusader in his early years of crime fighting. Beware the Batman received criticism from fans for having Alfred in a more active role, while featuring Katana as Batman's sidekick rather than Robin. The use of D-list villains was also criticised by fans who yearned to see A-listers make an appearance.
While the grim CGI animation did have its moments, and gave some more unknown characters a chance to shine despite only lasting one season, it did not reach the heights of The Brave and the Bold, which tied closer to the comics and had a more adoring fan base.
6. Spider-Man: The Animated Series Replaced By Spider-Man Unlimited
Spider-Man: The Animated Series was one of the best adaptations of the Wall Crawler, as it was heavily influenced by the comic book storylines and constantly gave justice to the source material. It introduced nineties kids to the Spider-Man mythos, while having a good combination of tones as the series could shift from a serious tone to a lighthearted one whenever the story required.
Another draw was the characters, with Venom and the Green Goblin being particular highlights. Crossovers were also a constant, with characters such as the X-Men, Iron Man and Captain America appearing whenever it fit the story. The series remains one of the most loved adaptations of the Web Slinger, and gave fans their first experience with the idea of a Spider-Verse.
While having a decent tenure, chalking up an incredible five seasons and ending the series with a brilliant two hour series finale, many were disappointed when the series came to an end. Fans were even more disappointed when they discovered Spider-Man Unlimited, the replacement for the much beloved series.
Spider-Man Unlimited was based on another Earth called Counter-Earth. On this Earth, Spider-Man battles Venom and Carnage and encounters Beastials, animal/humanoid hybrids who are the dominant species on the planet. Sounds crazy, right?
Unlimited unsurprisingly did not perform well, and was ultimately canned after a mere 13 episodes. It would not be until Spectacular Spider-Man that Spider-Man was given justice once more on the small screen.
5. The Spectacular Spider-Man Replaced By Ultimate Spider-Man
That's right, the Wall Crawler makes two appearances on this list. Despite being short lived, The Spectacular Spider-Man was arguably the most comic accurate portrayal of Spider-Man in animated media, along with the previous entry in this article. Spectacular Spider-Man focused on Peter struggling to balance his daily life as Peter Parker as a high school student along with his heroics as Spider-Man.
The series has everything a Spider-Man fan could wish for, focusing on the coming of age story for the hero, who deals with life as a high school student, a dangerous cast of villains, and an overarching plot tying everything together. The cast is phenomenal, the writing is spectacular (pun intended) and it is what every Spider-Man fan should dream for when watching an adaptation of the Wall Crawler.
Despite producer Greg Weisman hoping to reach 65 episodes, the series ended with just a 26 episode run after Disney acquired Marvel Entertainment. Shortly after, Marvel announced Ultimate Spider-Man to the disappointment of fans who held out hope that this adaptation of the Web Slinger would return.
Ultimate Spider-Man focused on Peter Parker being recruited by Nick Fury to join S.H.I.E.L.D. and train to become the "Ultimate Spider-Man," working alongside heroes such as Luke Cage, White Tiger, Iron Fist and Nova. The show had its moments, however the style of humour felt more like a toned down version of Deadpool. The end result was that Ultimate Spider-Man never reached the quality of its predecessor.
4. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (2012) Replaced By Rise Of The Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
The 2012 TMNT series attempted to reintroduce the Ninja Turtles to young viewers. Initially, the show was judged for its use of computer generated animation, with many fans accustomed to seeing the Turtles in a 2D animation style. The show also had the tough task of following the much adored 2003 TMNT series.
However, Nickelodeon's first take on the Turtles exceeded expectations, becoming arguably the best adaptation of the Heroes in a Half Shell yet.
Fans of the franchise were treated to an adaptation that was unafraid to pull from all aspects of TMNT lore. From the eighties series, to the serious tone displayed in the 2003 series and the comics, there was something featured for fans of every iteration to enjoy. While having goofy episodes and moments, Nickelodeon were also unafraid to take the Turtles into dark territories, killing off key characters and pushing the Turtles and allies to their absolute limits.
The quality and love put into this series by everyone involved left fans sour when the show was eventually cancelled and replaced with Rise of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. Rise of the TMNT was criticised for changing many major elements of the mythos, including making Raphael the leader and making Leonardo's personality a lot like Mikey's. These changes, along with the series being more childish in comparison to its predecessor, made fans yearn for a 2012 series revival.
3. Justice League Unlimited Replaced By Legion Of Superheroes
Justice League Unlimited is arguably the pinnacle of superhero animation. Set in the same universe which began with Batman: The Animated Series, Justice League Unlimited builds upon the storylines from the smaller scale Justice League show. Unlimited expands the league, bringing in a roster of characters ranging from well-known characters such as Green Arrow and Black Canary to lesser known such as Vigilante and Shining Knight.
Unlimited featured a mixture of storylines and a variety of different team-ups, which contributed to its overarching storylines. Season 1 focused on Amanda Waller and Cadmus, while Season 2 focused on the Justice League battling the Legion of Doom. The show featured numerous callbacks to comic book storylines and the history of DC media, making it one of the most beloved by DC fans.
While Justice League Unlimited wrapped up perfectly, any cartoon that followed was going to be compared to Unlimited. This was the case for Legion of Superheroes, which focused on a young Clark Kent travelling to the 31st Century and adopting the persona of Superman, teaming up with the Legion of Superheroes. Legion gave some lesser known characters the spotlight, while offering a different interpretation of Superman, which was refreshing.
Unfortunately for the Legion of Superheroes, it will always be in the shadow of the far superior Justice League Unlimited.
2. Avengers: Earth's Mightiest Heroes Replaced By Avengers Assemble
Avengers: Earth's Mightiest Heroes is one of the best Marvel animation projects ever, and easily the best iteration of the Avengers on the small screen. From the iconic theme song to the unforgettable characters, Earth's Mightiest Heroes had it all.
The adored series was highly influenced by the comic books, even utilising the original Avengers line up featured in the team's first comic appearance, rather than the lineup from the MCU. It also brought many iconic heroes together, such as Spider-Man, Wolverine, the Fantastic Four and the Guardians of the Galaxy. Characters who were barely known to the general public before the Marvel Cinematic Universe were also given stunning portrayals, such as Black Panther and Ant-Man.
However, Earth's Mightiest Heroes was unfortunately cancelled after only two seasons. While there was still plenty of story left to tell, Marvel decided to create a new Avengers show that was in the same universe as Ultimate Spider-Man, titled Avengers Assemble.
The new series featured a lineup mirroring the movie lineup, and featured many different characters and crossovers much like Earth's Mightiest Heroes. However, Avengers Assemble never met the heights of Earth's Mightiest Heroes, with the characters and storylines feeling bland in comparison to the genius cartoon it replaced.
1. Young Justice Replaced By Teen Titans Go!
While Young Justice did make a return, thanks to Greg Weisman and fans of the show banding together to push for a third season after the first two seasons were released on Netflix in early 2016, it does not take away from the fate the show originally received.
Young Justice was pure brilliance, following a team comprised of sidekicks and other young superheroes who wished to step out from the shadow of their mentors and become heroes in their own right.
The brilliant cartoon did an excellent job of shining a light on characters which are often overlooked. Characters such as Superboy, Miss Martian and Aqualad were given a chance to shine away from their mentors, allowing the characters to develop and grow as heroes in their own right. Featuring a young array of characters, themes of classic coming of age stories were also featured, with the development of the characters being showcased through the ageing between seasons. The series was not afraid to showcase serious themes for a children's program, while still managing to remaining lighthearted allowing for a diverse audience of both children and adult viewers.
However, Young Justice was eventually canned and replaced with the lacklustre Teen Titans Go!, which focused on the Teen Titans partaking in wacky adventures.
Teen Titans Go! was criticised from day one, as it kept the voice cast from the original Teen Titans series, making fans assume it was connected to the original series and opening it to constant comparisons with the original series. However, Teen Titans Go! made the characters stereotypical and bland versions of the originals, lacking a cohesive storyline and choosing to instead focus heavily on comedy rather than decent storytelling.
While Teen Titans Go! may be fun for young children, it pales in comparison to the original Teen Titans and it certainly doesn't meet the quality of Young Justice.
Watch Next
Quiz: How Well Do You REALLY Remember Justice League: Unlimited?