How DC Can Craft The PERFECT Shared Universe On HBO Max
In five simple steps.
DC's attempts to create a shared on-screen universe over the last decade have been obvious.
On the big screen Batman v Superman and Justice League tried and failed to launch a universe comparable in scope to the MCU, while on the small screen the Arrowverse triumphed with the 'shared' bit, but was ultimately unsuccessful in providing DC with a space to display their most well-known characters. On top of that, the shows on DC Universe did not live up to the streaming platform's name.
As all of DC's non-CW shows now seem to be moving to HBO Max, alongside a few new projects designed specifically for this new service, the company now has the opportunity to craft the shared universe it always wanted. Complete with big budget adaptations, A-list actors (it is HBO, after all), and even the ability to bring in its big gun characters - your Supermen, Batmen, Green Lanterns etc.
There is also the possibility that DC could royally mess this up though, leaving behind elements that were better kept, or rushing too quickly ahead with the new stuff and leaving fans with yet another disappointment.
In order to help prevent such an outcome, here are some guidelines that they should follow.
5. Start With Justice League Dark
Why start with this and not Green Lantern? Well, there has been very little said about the Corps so Dark is likely to come first and Dark would provide a better foundation for this DC universe anyway.
That is because it can do two things - establish the world as one filled with superheroes and villains, but also not feel the need to use any of those characters that do not use magic. This is a positive as what this HBO-verse needs to do is to avoid the characters that have been touched on in the recent movies until it has introduced audiences to some lesser known ones.
The Justice League Dark tackles mystical threats, the original League does not - so there would be no need for the likes of Batman to get involved, especially if the mystical threat being dealt with was one that could not be detected by non-magic heroes.
The words 'Justice League' need not even be mentioned. I mean, the 'Dark' name was not immediately bestowed upon the group the first time they met in the comics, so why should it be in the show?
4. Fold In Swamp Thing
As one of DC's most original shows, and one that was canned way too soon, it would be a shame to leave Swamp Thing behind in the move to HBO.
The titular character is a recurring character in the most recent Justice League Dark run, so including him would likely be a must regardless of whether it were the version from this show or not.
As such, it would be wasteful to recast all the characters that debuted in the DC Universe original, especially when certain ones (namely Madame Xanadu) were instrumental in the formation of Dark.
Though, if it is decided that it would be best for the HBO shows to all be completely new, then I'm sure DC would be able to find a suitable replacement.
3. Then Do Green Lantern(s)
Much like Justice League Dark, Green Lantern has the benefit of not having to involve the Justice League (except for its Lantern members, obviously).
This show should have most, if not all, of the human Lanterns already established and should take place almost exclusively in space - as Earth-based Green Lantern stories are simply not as interesting, plus it would be another excuse to avoid the League.
If it were down to me, then the first season of this show would be all about Sinestro's downfall and the creation of the Sinestro Corps. Sort of like what the Star Wars prequel trilogy did for Anakin Skywalker and the Empire, with Hal Jordan filling the role of Obi Wan (but as the mentee rather than mentor) in this analogy.
Alternatively, DC could not do that - they've just got to keep whatever they decide to do in space.
2. Reboot Titans & Leave Doom Patrol Alone
Doom Patrol should be DC's Legion - its weird show that is basically unconnected from every one of its other properties, with only some minimal references to the wider comic book universe. Now that's out of the way, let's get to Titans...
Titans, in my personal opinion, is badly written - the characterizations are all over the place, heroes and villains alike seem to be constantly being killed off for no good reason, and the second season just repeated every character arc from the first. The cast is great, however.
So, DC should retain the same actors, but replace the writers. Also, the HBO debut of those characters should not be more Titans.
Instead, it should be Batman & Robin, with Brenton Thwaites' Dick Grayson as Batman and Curran Walters' Jason Todd as Robin. Or, if Todd dies in the next season of Titans, use that as an excuse to bring in Umbrella Academy's Aidan Gallagher to play Damian Wayne and give Thwaites' Grayson a less serious personality via the reboot so that Morrison or Tomasi's Batman & Robin runs can be adapted.
This is how DC would set up its core roster of heroes for its HBO-verse after exploring the mystical side in Justice League Dark and the cosmic arena in Green Lantern. Then, after Batman & Robin, it could finally return to the Titans themselves and deliver a proper live action take on those characters.
Just two more Titans-related things:
The 'heroes committing murder' thing has got to stop. And that moody blue colour scheme the show uses? That's got to go too.
A little vibrancy in your comic book shows is healthy.
1. And, Finally, DO NOT Connect To The Movies Or CW
Why risk it?
If the HBO shows connect to the DCEU movies then they will be forced to navigate its mess of a timeline and likely not be able to use characters like Wonder Woman or Batman, meaning that the new shows would probably quickly meet a similar fate to Marvel's Netflix series.
If they connect to the CW stuff then a lack of access to characters could again be an issue, plus the budgets would be so disparate that having characters meet would only further cheapen the Arrowverse.
The only instance in which there should be any crossover whatsoever is if there were a massive budget multiversal Crisis movie, not one of the CW's yearly crossovers, but an Avengers-level funded movie.
DC has a real opportunity to craft something brilliant on HBO, it shouldn't let the promise of slightly higher viewing numbers once a year interfere with that.