How I Met Your Mother: Ranking All Ted’s Love Interests From Worst To Best

12. Jen

If Ted could have looked past all of the cats, him and Jen could have been a good couple.

After a forgetful first date years before, Ted and Jen actually end up sharing an enjoyable evening and she gives him some ready good dating tips. Just no sparkle, unfortunately.

11. Holly

This one-night conquest of Mr Mosby’s had a lot about her. She was pretty and sweet, and her and Ted were getting along wonderfully until the ghost of Robin haunted him.

They did end up sleeping together, but these two could have been so much more.