Love, Victor Review: 7 Ups & 3 Downs

Hulu's Love, Simon spin-off is another coming-of-age triumph.

Love, Victor
Hulu

You might recall how a little old film called Love, Simon made history back in 2018 when it became the first major Hollywood studio film to focus on a gay teenage romance. Yeah, well, that little old film made such an impact on audiences that it only went and spawned its very own spin-off TV series.

Originally planned as a Disney+ series, Love, Victor is now a Hulu original and it stars Michael Cimino in the titular role as a teenager struggling with his own sexuality within the halls of the very same school that Simon Spier found himself in during the motion picture. What's more is that Nick Robinson actually reprises his role as Simon (he also serves as a producer) as he narrates of the series after Victor reaches out to him for help.

The decision to create a sequel series initially shocked some because Love, Simon very much seemed like a one-and-done story, but it doesn't take long for Love, Victor to render that point irrelevant, as the show provides us with a different side to the figuring out who you are process - one that is equally as engaging and every bit as important.

Led by a charming performance from Cimino, it's heartfelt, thought-provoking and a welcome addition to the TV landscape, complementing the legacy of the Simonverse with nuanced, three-dimensional characters that are unapologetically real - solidifying itself as one of this year's best new arrivals.

First, the negatives...

Please be aware, this post contains SPOILERS for Love, Victor Season 1.


Downs...

3. There Could Be A Little More World-Building For New Fans

Love, Victor Michael Cimino
Hulu

We'll talk about how Love, Victor establishes its own identity in more depth shortly, but long-story-short, it does. That said, it could have expanded on its own universe in more detail for viewers of the show who hadn't seen Love, Simon yet.

From the lack of real explanation about what Creek Secrets actually is (something the movie delivered in its opening scene) to the quick-witted, yawn-and-you'll-miss-it monologue about Simon Spier from the returning Ms. Albright, it feels like the show expects you to have seen the film so that you won't ask any follow-up questions. And if you hadn't seen the film and were left with follow-up questions, you probably don't get the answers you're looking for as the show rolls on.

It's a little thing, but one that could have made all the difference for new fans.


2. Too Much Happens Off-Screen

Love Victor
Hulu

As great as the story that Love, Victor tells ultimately is, it does fall victim to a number of cliches along the way. The most annoying of those cliche's is the recurring problem of plot developments taking place off-screen.

Over the course of the season, there are multiple occasions where it feels like the plot conveniently relies on time-jumps so that it could avoid potential inconsistencies in the narrative. An example of this could include the fact that there is no fallout from Mia's initial disdain for Veronica, which is then swept under the carpet by a number of awkwardly placid interactions between them (before that disdain later resurfaces). The time-jumps make it difficult to gauge the dynamic between them and can therefore be relied on as a crutch to force some more conflict without every having to wrap up the original incident.

There is nothing wrong with a few developments happening off-screen, but as the show goes on, it gets a little too reliant on this plot device.


1. It Doesn't Have Enough Time To Accomplish Everything

Love, Victor
Hulu

Love, Victor sets out to tell a number of different stories.

On the top of that list is, of course, Victor's coming out story - something that leads him down a long and winding path of self-discovery through a relationship with Mia. Aside from that, however, it's also attempting to tell the story of a family struggling to start afresh and overcome finance worries, tension and infidelity. And there are times that it just feels like it doesn't have enough time to do all that.

Where the story ends up in the season finale does feel like a natural place to go, but the journey to that point isn't exactly a seamless one as it takes a little while to get there. A natural reflection of life? Absolutely, but it may result in viewers who knew of this inevitable plot point feeling a little short-changed by the time the episode concludes.

Be it the fact that each episode runs at least 10 minutes less than you'd expect (though this has its silver linings) or just the fact that 10 episodes weren't enough, Love, Victor does indeed leave you wanting more... but that's not always a good thing.

The stories don't feel like they've even begun to get off the ground yet, so let's just hope it's given a second season to explore them in more detail.

Now, for the positives...


Ups...

7. The Short Episodes

Love Victor Benji
Hulu

This writer will admit it: He was a little disappointed when he saw that each episode ran between 25 - 30 minutes (as opposed to the 42 - 60 minute length typical for a drama series). However, this actually worked in the show's favour.

None of the episodes ever feel like they've been overwritten or dragged out for the sake of it. The truth is that, on the episodic front, everything remains concise and tightly-written, ensuring and the pacing of events runs rather smoothly the whole way throughout.

With 10 30-minute episodes, Love, Victor is an easy watch in that it's both highly bingeable and just plain easy to make your way through.


6. My Story Is Nothing Like Yours

Love Victor Benji
Hulu

As game-changing and great as Love, Simon was, some were quick to point out the fact that not everyone struggling with their sexuality would grow up in a family or environment as accepting as its titular star's. And it's true - in spite of how much Simon struggled internally, there were a lot of external factors around him just waiting to accept him for who he was.

Love, Victor is very quick to establish itself as an alternative story that very much attacks the original - to the benefit of the narrative. The writers - Love, Simon's brilliant Isaac Aptaker and Elizabeth Berger - waste little time delving into the things that make Victor's story different, having their new protagonist vocalise his disdain for how much easier Simon had it, referring to his religious parents, money troubles and the conflict brewing within the family. And that allows it to set itself apart, making a case for its own existence and ultimately reminding audiences that everybody's story is different.

"My story is nothing like yours," Victor writes to Simon in the closing moments of the pilot episode, and he couldn't be more right. His character journey is different; it's more harrowing and obstacle-ridden, but man, it's every bit as compelling.


5. A Huge Step Forward For LGBTQ+ Representation

Love Victor Benji
Hulu

While modern-day television certainly has far more LGBTQ+ representation than mainstream Hollywood cinema, we should be viewing Love, Victor as just as major of an accomplishment as its predecessor.

We've seen a number of shows in the past feature a gay protagonist, yes, but just as Simon did, Love, Victor focuses primarily on a gay teenager attempting to find himself, all while toying with the idea of a romance with another boy. And he's not playing a supporting role in somebody else's story; the show is his story.

There's no downplaying this; just as Love, Simon was a huge step forward for the gay community in terms of representation on the big screen, Love, Victor does the same on the small one. And that should be celebrated for the major win that it is.


4. Nick Robinson's Return

Love, Simon Nick Robinson
Hulu

Having narrated so much of the season, it felt inevitable that Nick Robinson's Simon Spier would show up at some point. In fact, it felt so inevitable that when we found out Simon had conveniently left New York on the same weekend that Victor arrived, it was hard not to feel a little disappointed - something that the film's Keiynan Lonsdale more than made up for seconds later.

The beauty of it all, however, is that he did show up for a brief cameo in the episode's closing moments as Simon and Victor crossed paths in New York in the meeting we were all waiting on. And it was a completely justified moment too; one that never took away from the show's protagonist. If anything, it felt like a passing-of-the-torch moment.

Simon's mentoring throughout the season made his eventual appearance feel more-than-warranted, and while the scene's brevity - and the smoke-and-mirrors used to hide the fact that he wasn't actually on-set for the bar scene at the same time as the rest of the cast - robbed us of an official reunion between him and Simon's boyfriend Bram, it was just so great to see Robinson play his most famous role again.


3. The Supporting Cast

Love, Victor
Hulu

While Love, Victor is primarily about our titular character, there is a network of interesting characters surrounding him that complete the package pretty nicely. Yes, the 10 episode season does occasionally struggle when it comes to which stories to highlight, but it never fails to present its cast with opportunities to shine.

It's hard to say which story is more engaging. Is it the marriage struggles between Victor's parents? Is it Mia's inability to accept her father's new love interest? Or is it the lovable Felix's desire to woo bossy 'It Girl' Lake? While the first of those three does provide the show with some of its juiciest material, the reason that all three of them hold their own is down to the performances that each respective cast member offers up.

Ana Ortiz is exceptional as the guilt-ridden mother of Victor, Pilar and Adrian while James Martinez plays the reserved, conservative father very well. Rachel Naomi Hilson is wonderful as the enthusiastic and almost always likable Mia, making us root for her even more with each passing episode. Bebe Wood channels the charisma of Lake oh-so-well, balancing it with the subtly of the deeper character within, and her screen partner Anthony Turpel steals the show as the nerdy-but-committed best friend of Victor, Felix.

Though it would have been nice to see a little more of George Sear's Benji over the course of the season, his performance more than made up for his lack of screen-time, ensuring that we all felt (nearly) as drawn to him as Victor so clearly was.


2. Victor's Character Journey

Love, Victor
Hulu

It'd be remiss of this writer to reflect on all the things that made this show so engaging without mentioning the sole purpose for its existence. It sounds obvious when you say it out loud, but Victor's story carried Love, Victor to success. And no, I don't necessarily mean that in the obvious well-yeah-it's-about-him kind on way, I mean it as a small indication of how it remained the most consistently compelling narrative throughout the 10-episode season.

We've already looked at how Simon's story wasn't the most universal. Yes, it made for a great romcom, it was groundbreaking in terms of LGBTQ+ representation on the big-screen, and most important of all, a lot of people could relate to it - but Victor's story offers another look at the coming-out-experience; one that a lot of others can now relate to as well.

From his attempt to experience a relationship with Mia to the show's committed attempt to highlight how sexuality isn't always a straight line, Victor's character arc is an unapologetically real one. And the show is never better than it is when showcasing that. The exploration of how his standing as the 'reliable one' in the family ultimately puts him under pressure to remain in the closet is exquisite conflict that ultimately leads to some wonderful character moments. And, again, it just feels so undeniably real.


1. Michael Cimino's Performance

Love Victor Michael Cimino
Hulu

Victor Salazar finds himself going on an incredibly moving character journey that feels very authentic. Yes, there are occasional inconsistencies in the narrative, but the reason that it always feels real is, of course, down to the brilliant Michael Cimino.

Where to even start when describing his performance? He's charming every single time he's on-screen, portraying Victor as one of the most endearing protagonists we've seen on TV in some time. But it's not just the light-hearted stuff; no, his performance is authentic - powerful even - and he personifies the character's emotional journey and his struggles really, really well.

It's easy to feel what he's going through because Cimino wants us to feel what he's going through, and he effortlessly holds our attention throughout the show's 10-episode run, ensuring that Victor remains in our hearts and our minds long after the credits roll on the season finale.

The star of the show in every way possible, Cimino is an absolute revelation.

-

What did you make of Love, Victor? Tell us in the comment section below.


Watch Next


13 Reasons Why Quiz: How Closely Were You Watching Season 4?

13 Reasons Why Season 4
Netflix

1. Who Spray-Painted 'Monty Was Framed' On The Principal's Office?

Contributor
Contributor

Michael Patterson is an experienced writer with an affinity for all things film and TV. He may or may not have spent his childhood obsessing over WWE.