Metropolis: 10 Things The Superman Prequel Must Include
Less Gotham, more Daredevil.
DC's very own streaming service gathered more momentum this week, with news of a Superman prequel, called Metropolis, being developed by Gotham producers John Stephens and Danny Cannon for a 2019 release.
Gotham might get a bad rap (justifiably in parts, in others, not so much), but news of a Supes prequel shouldn't be dismissed out of hand so easily. Some of the best stories revolving around the Man of Steel have focused entirely on his supporting cast, and with Lois Lane an icon in her own right, the last son of Krypton need not be present for Metropolis to be a success.
There are certain things the series must do though, and with Gotham having as many successes as it has failures, it's clear that DC's superhero prequels have a lot to learn - and change - to compete with the likes of Marvel's Netflix shows, which continue to outclass the competition even when they're at their supposed worst.
The odds might be stacked against Metropolis' favour, but with DC's new service boasting the Titans and now Lois Lane too, fans need not be so skeptical. Even if it is a Netflix too many.
10. Lois Lane As The Primary Protagonist
Lois Lane is one of the best characters in DC's library, so there's absolutely no doubt in our minds that she'd be able to anchor a TV series of her own.
One of the few supporting characters in DC's library that needs no introduction, the Daily Planet reporter has exposed more conspiracies than Batman and Robin put together, and while writers have had a tendency to make her a damsel on all too many an occasion, it's difficult to envision this series behaving quite the same way.
And Lois, DC's premier journalist, is a cracking character to follow anyway. Smart, witty and dedicated, she's just the kind of hero DC needs right now, especially when the superhero genre itself is crying out for someone who isn't dressed in red, white and blue.
It's all well and good having plenty of capes on costumes on either the big or small screen, but the medium itself has excelled when it comes to telling smaller, more personal storylines; Gotham Central, a comic founded on the premise of following the normal cops in a superpowered environment, was revered for doing just that.
Ditch the science-y stuff, and ditch the bizarre buddy-cop premise. This show needs Lois, and Lois alone.
9. Lex Luthor As A Key Conspirator
Coupled with the announcement that DC were optioning Metropolis for production was the show's synopsis, which mentioned Lois and - who else - Lex Luthor, in the same breath as allies.
No matter how reluctant they might be, one can't help but feel like this is just a plain weird decision to take. Gotham's showrunners should know better, and while it's obviously gearing up for an inevitable betrayal in an unassuming season finale, no one wants to see Lex as a hero through and through. He's smarmy, cunning and irreconcilably ruthless. Make him duplicitous, sure, but be sure to hammer home his villainous credentials, especially since we've already seen 'Lex before he's Lex' in Smallville a whole ten years earlier.
Luthor needs to be the one pulling the strings, and while the concept of there once having been a 'good' Luthor is an interesting one to explore in a comic, it can't anchor a whole TV show, especially when the current Lex we do have is so horrendously unthreatening that he resorts to leaving jars of piss in congressional hearings to get his point across.
Make him bald, make him threatening, and make him thoroughly unlikeable. That's the kind of Lex that sells.
8. A Watergate Style Story
With Steven Spielberg's The Post tipped to win just about everything this awards season, it could be said that Pakula-esque, journalistic thrillers are experiencing something of a revival.
Chief among that genre rests All the President's Men, Alan Pakula's 1976 classic that told the tale of Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein's efforts to unearth the Nixon Presidency's ties to the Watergate break-in. Who could DC's Nixon be? Well, there is one businessman who seems to have a hand in everything in Metropolis, and not a single hair rests on his head.
Yes, the aforementioned Lex (who even became president at the turn of the century, by the way), is the prime candidate to head this kind of conspiracy. Metropolis has potential to be this crazy little House of Cards-esque thing, following on from classic capers like Pakula's opus, and it'd be a shame if it were to adopt a different tone altogether.
Plus, y'know, who doesn't want to see Lois and the rest of the Planet cracking a conspiracy on their own?
7. References To The Golden Age
With Gotham having a tendency to get carried away, mostly on account of its determination to cram every Bat-villain from A-Z, Metropolis needs to have a think about the approach it'll take to world-building.
One option, and it's one we've seen debut to acclaim in Black Lightning, would be to root the show in a linear timeline. Avoid Supes altogether, certainly, but remember that the book didn't begin with Clark Kent. In classic DC continuity, the Justice Society of America were the first real superhero team around, with characters like Doctor Fate, Jay Garrick's Flash and Ted Grant's Wildcat dominating headlines as the world's precursor to the Justice League.
Not only does this make the world feel lived in, but less contrived as well. Contextualising Lois' misadventures in a world already known for super-drama makes sense, but having everything bubble up out of thin-air would, like Gotham, feel a little forced, if not entirely cynical altogether.
Make the world feel storied, and Metropolis will be able to get away with ten times the stuff Gotham has.
6. The Rest Of The Daily Planet
The Daily Planet is the DCU's most famous newspaper, but it's not just Lois who's lent her name to it. Clark Kent, Perry White and Jimmy Olsen are among the most famous employees of the newspaper giant, and while Lois has to be the main attraction for Metropolis, the show needs a competent cast of supporting characters too.
Jimmy Olsen is the most obvious in line to make an appearance, with himself, Lois and Clark forming a formidable friendship inside the company's offices. Perry, portrayed by Laurence Fishburne in the DCEU, is the J. Jonah Jameson to Lois' Ben Urich, and while it's true viewers have lent these particular characters only the most cursory of glances until now, it's high time they got to know them better.
A show centred around the Lois, Perry, Olsen dynamic would work with the right kind of approach, and while Clark would have to be absent, the Daily Planet was going long before Smallville's finest turned up.
5. A Classic Score To Rally Behind
Superman, like Batman, has had plenty of iconic turns in live action over the years. None, however, are more iconic than the Richard Donner films of the late seventies, which really did live up to the tagline of making us all believe a man could fly.
And while a lot of that can be attributed to a plethora of things, including Christopher Reeve's magnetic performance as the eponymous character himself, there is something to be said of John Williams' incredible composition and how it elevated that entire series. To this day, Williams' piece is cited as being among the most memorable the medium's ever seen, and while it's always great to see artists leave their own mark with a theme of their own, it's nice to hear the odd homage here and there.
With that in mind, Metropolis would do well to look towards classic themes like Williams' when composing a new soundtrack. That doesn't mean copying things entirely, but - like we saw in Justice League - sampling a beloved staple can inspire an audience, however briefly that may be.
There are a whole host of classic Superman themes to look at, but to hear a riff on Williams' original piece would be fantastic.
4. Villains That Make Sense
One of Gotham's biggest problems as a show was that it rushed head first into concepts and characters it wasn't ready to handle, certainly not in an organic way for a show revolving around Bruce Wayne's childhood.
Certain villains do make sense in that context, but when teases for the Joker abound by Bruce's fourteenth birthday, things clearly aren't working out.
With Metropolis, that same temptation to implement classic Superman villains will be there. The show's premise, said to revolve around 'the world of fringe science' and Metropolis' 'dark and bizarre secrets', screams that it will follow in its predecessor's footsteps, but that's not a good thing. There are certainly Superman villains that would work in this context, but most - either because they're too powerful, or because they're extraterrestrial in origin - would not, and that in itself invites attempts to retrofit a new continuity that neither fans nor mainstream audiences will likely appreciate.
It needn't be that way however, and with DC being able to boast a catalogue of villains tailor-made for this kind of context, Metropolis' showrunners would do well to exercise restraint, and pick the bad guys that lend themselves well to a genuine Superman prequel.
3. Classic DC Iconography
One thing Gotham definitely has going for it is its set-design; the city looks like it's been ripped straight from the comics, boasting a quasi-Burton-BTAS aesthetic that divests from the real world vibe of Christopher Nolan's Dark Knight Trilogy.
It's a vibe that Metropolis should work with too, although there are challenges in doing so. Gotham City has always been a European locale trapped by American geography - an aberrant hodgepodge of gothic architecture less utopian, more dystopian in nature.
Metropolis, on the other hand, is the complete opposite. It's meant to be the City of Tomorrow, and a place where no Dark Knight would ever be needed. It's grand, all-encompassing and the exemplification of DC's brightest elements, and while it does have a nasty underbelly, the visual connotations of the DCU's most famous locale are there for all to see.
As such, Metropolis has a lot to live up to. The Daily Planet has to have its ridiculous globe atop its building, skyscrapers need to fan out as far as the eye can see and, most importantly, it has to feel abstract.
It's all well and good having a city and calling it a Metropolis, but if it's one only in name, then it just won't be the same.
2. Proper Serialised Storytelling
While it's possible to argue that Gotham is a procedural to a certain degree, it never really managed to live up to the expectations of those who'd read Gotham Central, the Ed Brubaker and Greg Rucka comic everyone thought the series would take inspiration from.
While the merits and faults of serialised storytelling have been well chronicled in recent years, there are certain concepts that lend themselves well to that style of TV series. Gotham isn't one of those concepts, and while Star Trek: Discovery continues to draw criticism for its shift away from procedural storytelling, the gamble has managed to pay off in the long run.
For Metropolis, a serialised format would seemingly make the most sense. The official synopsis sounds like it won't be heading in that direction, with Lois and Lex engaging in a 'caper of the week' almost, but it's definitely the route to take should the series value the lessons imparted by shows like Game of Thrones and House of Cards.
Have Lois and co. work away at a scheme over the course of one series, rather than small ones week by week, and it'll be so much better for it.
1. A City Without Superman
Whereas Gotham has gotten progressively crazier as the years have gone by, Metropolis has to tone things down.
It was plain for all to see that, by its second season, Gotham's showrunners were fed-up with the prequel format. Gone was the slow-burn towards Bruce Wayne's rise as Gotham's vigilante - in its place came a new policy that accelerated the process altogether. Bruce got his own suit at the end of season 3, villains aplenty dominated the show's proceedings and, for the most part, it felt as though Gotham's original premise had been totally forgotten.
Whether this was due to a lack of patience or executive demands from Fox is unclear, but what is clear is that the show has gotten way ahead of itself, specifically in respect to Bruce's character-arc.
Metropolis has to do better, and while the temptation to bring Clark Kent in early on will undoubtedly be there, the show's meant to be a Superman prequel. That means no capes, no red trunks, and no leaping tall buildings in a single bound.
Supes' town is, like Gotham, a character in itself. It's home to more than just the Man of Steel so for once, DC, give this one to Lois. She's more than earned it.
What do you want to see in Metropolis? Are you happy with the synopsis so far? Be sure to let us know in the comments below!