Obi-Wan Kenobi Part III Review: 6 Ups & 3 Downs
Obi-Wan slips dangerously out of his element as an old friend hunts him down.
After last week's double bill opener to the untold story of a post-Order 66 Obi-Wan kicked things off with a powerful bang, Obi-Wan Kenobi has returned to screens with an episode of constant surprises and shocking confrontations.
Hoping to get Leia home by meeting up with a contact of con man Haja Estree, Obi-Wan starts Part III reeling from the news that Anakin is alive and more powerful than ever, whilst his former apprentice lurks in the shadows, waiting to strike.
Bursting with exhilarating action and effective fan service, Part III is not without its flaws - one of which makes it a slightly weaker instalment than the previous episodes overall - but makes up for them with a series of twists that will leave even the most casual of Star Wars fans thoroughly shaken.
With that in mind, from the enhanced development of its haunted title character to its staggering action sequences, here are 6 Ups and 3 Downs from Obi-Wan Kenobi, Part III. This review contains major spoilers.
DOWNS...
9. The Wildly Uneven Pacing
Though it smooths things out as it goes, the first half of Part III in particular suffers from glaring pace issues.
At first sombre and centred on Obi-Wan and Leia, the episode's decision to switch between the pair, the Inquisitors, the imminent return of Darth Vader, and a new character who's given little to work with eventually leaves it feeling far too jumbled for its own good.
Because so much is fit within this one hour, there's a distinct lack of development at play outside of Obi-Wan, which leaves many of it feeling like filler, and a set-up for bigger twists further down the line.
It's not enough to ruin the episode, especially given how excellent its last act is, but the inconsistent pacing still holds it back from greatness.
8. The Inquisitor Power Struggle
One of the main reasons the pace of the episode feels a little off is the episode's inclusion of the Inquisitors, a menacing force who have been given their own subplot outside of their shared quest for Obi-Wan.
Though the performances of Moses Ingram and Sung Kang continue to shine, the power struggle between Reva and the Fifth Brother in the wake of the Grand Inquisitor's "death" feels frustratingly underwhelming, adding little characterisation and watching like lazily plotted filler.
Since we're halfway through the show already, it seems odd that this feud would gain so much focus, and feel so dull in the process.
It might come to something further on, but right now the Inquisitors have emerged as the show's most wasted opportunity, and their petty squabbles have done nothing to elevate the drama that surrounds them.
7. It's Mostly Set-Up
Despite its strengths heavily outweighing its weaknesses, Part III of Obi-Wan Kenobi can't help but feel like an episode of set-ups for episodes to come.
Of course, teasing bigger developments happens in every episode of every show, but in the case of Part III much of its teasing is so heavy-handed and underdeveloped it's hard not to see it as a tacky ploy to keep butts in seats.
For instance, the cliffhanger ending, in which Reva kidnaps Leia after intercepting her escape route, feels far too obvious to be as effective as it clearly thinks it is, reducing both characters to plot devices in order to keep Obi-Wan fighting for three more episodes.
Likewise, newcomer Tala Durith has been thrown into the action with painfully little development, seemingly only to be used as a walking piece of exposition and a deus ex machina who swoops in to save Obi-Wan (more than once) in his time of need.
On top of that, there's also the opening scene's blunt reminder that Obi-Wan is trying to contact his deceased master, Qui Gon Jinn, and the dull Inquisitor feud, both of which are supposedly leading somewhere, but right now feel narratively flat.
These are minor gripes, honestly, but if Obi-Wan Kenobi wants to kick its second half off on a high note, it would do well to add some more gravitas to its supporting players and mysterious subplots.
Now, onto the positives...
UPS...
6. The State Of The Empire
Part III, as noted, has an awful lot going on, and whilst its execution isn't great, the way it looks into life under Empire rule is very affecting.
Through Tala, Obi-Wan learns that former Jedi and friend Quinlan Vos - a character whose fate has always been shrouded in ambiguity - survived the Purge, and spent years saving Force-sensitive children from the Empire's clutches. (Hopefully this passing reference leads somewhere for the character.)
Earlier on, Obi-Wan and Leia encounter a farmer (voiced, surprisingly, by Zach Braff), whose life revolves around doing the Empire's bidding and living in fear of the Jedi after years of being told they're evil.
The insight into Empire life is brief, but it adds depth to the broken, confused world Obi-Wan once fought for and now hides from.
5. Natalie Holt's Atmospheric Score
This week's episode had a lot of shocks in store, the vast majority of which work so well thanks to the brilliant score of composer Natalie Holt.
As with the previous two episodes, Holt's music works in perfect harmony with the inner conflict of the characters, capturing the morose heartache of Obi-Wan and then blending it seamlessly with the fear, apprehension, and thrills of the action he's forced to face.
When, in the episode's final act, Obi-Wan comes face-to-face with his greatest foe, Holt's booming orchestral sound and brief detours into crushing silence allows the danger to feel horribly real.
Star Wars has always been a great franchise for music, and Holt has earned her place as a worthy addition to its sound.
4. Obi-Wan & Leia's Relationship
Last week's big twist was that the series was actually going to focus on Leia rather than her brother Luke. As surprising as it was, Part III proved without a doubt it was a great creative decision.
Aided by the performances of Ewan McGregor and Vivien Lyra Blair, the episode gives the pair plenty of time to get to know each other, with one of the episode's most profound moments coming when Leia asks Obi-Wan if he's her father, after he says she reminds him of her birth mother.
By now, Leia completely trusts her Jedi protector, but the true takeaway from their relationship is how much Leia is forcing Obi-Wan to recall his past, his fallen student, and the children Anakin doesn't know.
As sweet as the pair are, at once funny and touching, their relationship here serves as a perfect - if upsetting - reminder of just how much Obi-Wan loves Anakin, and how far he's willing to go to protect his family and keep hope alive.
3. Obi-Wan's Rich Development
Ewan McGregor gives his finest performance of the show yet in Part III, largely due to the insurmountable tragedy Obi-Wan's been confronted with.
Not only has he just learned Anakin Skywalker is alive, but he's not yet reconnected fully to the Force and therefore dangerously out of his element. Confronted by his former padawan, the crushing realisation that he's been consumed by the dark side sends him to his lowest low yet.
It's not all death and despair, though: His aforementioned relationship with Leia and his strength to keep fighting works throughout the episode as a constant reminder that, as long as there's still something to fight for, Obi-Wan will be there and willing to give his life.
Watching him being haunted by Anakin and struggling to remain calm and strong for Leia is heartbreaking, especially when Darth Vader finally surfaces to destroy him...
2. Darth Vader's Return
In the opening moments of Part III, we get to see something we've never really seen before: Darth Vader, free from the bacta tank keeping him alive, is pieced together to reveal the monstrous figure we all know and love.
It's a stunning and haunting sequence, revealing Vader as more robot than man before his scarred face is covered by his iconic helmet, and his breathing cuts through the darkness.
Physically portrayed by Hayden Christensen and voiced by the great James Earl Jones (who, at 91, has lost none of his menace), Vader's role in Part III is much more physical than we've ever seen before. When he finally shows himself to Obi-Wan, he kills several villagers by snapping their necks in order to draw him out.
Wasting no time to show us how Vader earned such a fierce reputation, the episode paints him as a relentless monster, alive without a shred of the good man he once was. As he tells Obi-Wan: "I am what you made me." Anakin is gone.
This brutally violent reunion then leads to the episode's crowning achievement...
1. The Stunning Third Act
Having laid waste to a defenceless village and cornered his former master into a duel, Darth Vader ignites his lightsaber and unleashes the full force of his power, effortlessly beating Obi-Wan down and then - in a twisted moment of poetic revenge - burns him in a pit of fire.
Recalling their last confrontation on Mustafar, Obi-Wan and Vader's rematch works as a startling reminder of how powerful the Sith Lord has become, and how weak Obi-Wan has become after years cut-off from the Force.
Shrouded in darkness save for their lightsabers, the fight is quick and brutal, and Deborah Chow's direction captures every ounce of Obi-Wan's fear and heartbreak as his old friend promises him pain. When Obi-Wan burns, it's so dark and unexpected that for a heartbeat it feels like he's truly doomed.
Gripping and sad, the third and final act of Part III is utterly flawless, not just as a brilliantly choreographed rematch between two bitter rivals who are far removed from the men they once were, but also as an affecting piece of storytelling. Vader has never appeared this strong before, and his old master has never been so hurt.
How Obi-Wan comes back from this is a mystery.