Once Upon A Time: 10 Dumbest Character Decisions

Fairytale characters really don't operate with common sense, and Once Upon a Time characters are no exception.

Traditionally, fairytale characters don't operate with a lot of forethought when it comes to making any kind of decision. These stories heavily rely on sheer lack of common sense in order for any of the conflict and action to occur, and sometimes it is just too unbelievable that any of the events could ever actually happen.

When ABC debuted Once Upon a Time, its fairytale-centric TV show with a modern-day twist, there was some hope that some common sense could perhaps be inserted into these updated storybook tales. Unfortunately, the dual timelines established on the show both exhibit exorbitant amounts of disregard for thinking through ones actions, which leads to very convoluted story lines and family trees. You'd think that when the characters get transported to the non-magical world without their memories that they would at least make some logical decisions. But alas, they rarely do so. However, without these poor decision-making character traits, there would be no show for us to enjoy.

Although these terrible decisions lead to amazing stories and events, sometimes you just want to throw your remote at the screen to stop these fairytale characters from dooming themselves to a life of consequences.

Here are ten of the dumbest things that Once Upon a Time characters have done that warrant a flung TV remote.


10. When Anyone Made A Deal With Rumplestiltskin

Rumple's motto is literally "magic always comes with a price," but do these fairytale characters listen?

Apparently not because they always come running to Rumple to get a quick fix for their problems. Jiminy got turned into a cricket, the apprentice got turned into a mouse and countless other situations have been exacerbated by Rumple's deals.

You'd think that his reputation for making shady deals would ward off anyone from approaching him. But there are always poor, unfortunate souls willing to make deals with the devil, and without these deals there wouldn't be a show.


9. Neal Died For His Horrible Father (Who Was Already Dead)

Neal. Baelfire. Henry's FATHER. You had a son, and you had the potential to reunite with Emma.

And you just went and threw your life away to try to bring your father back from the dead. Your father who had killed countless people for no reason. Your father who finally managed to redeem himself and die a hero.

Why couldn't you let him lie? Your foolish actions led to your death, and now all of the SwanFire shippers have been forced to give up on their dreams. Shame on you.


8. Regina Held A Grudge Against Snow White For 30+ Years

It's understandable to feel angry, betrayed and sad that your true love died because Snow White accidentally let slip that you were in love with the stable boy to psycho Cora. But it was an accident. And she was like 12.

It is not logical to hold a multi-decade hatred for something someone did when they were 12, especially when it was an accident. Think of all the trouble Regina could have saved if she had learned to accept Daniel's death and moved on when she was supposed to. Sure, there wouldn't be a show, but everyone's lives would have been a lot easier.


7. Greg And Tamara's Blind Faith In Peter Pan

Greg and Tamara are a prime example that having a little bit of hard evidence can go a long way in terms of making logical decisions. Their blind faith in the cause to exterminate magic from the "real world" suckered them into a cause actually led by a magical villain by the name of Peter Pan.

And because you NEVER LOOKED TO SEE IF YOUR WALKIE TALKIE HAD BATTERIES before you traveled across worlds, you two almost deserved to die because that is just ridiculous. Peter Pan was a diabolical and horrible child, but he was very good at finding people to do his dirty work for him.

Without Greg and Tamara's blind faith, Henry would have never stepped foot in Neverland.


6. When Rumple/Gold Released The Wraith In Storybrooke

Sure, Regina was horrible and trapped everyone in a land without magic with her curse, but releasing a wraith into Storybrooke was a horrible plan.

That wraith went rogue so fast and caused Emma and Mary Margaret to travel back to the desolate Enchanted Forest for a full half season. And then when there was some hope to bring them back, Rumple did everything in his power to keep them there so as to not let Cora come into their world.

If he hadn't been so bitter in the first place, then none of these problems would have happened, dude.


5. When The Mad Hatter Trusted Regina

Oh beautiful, beautiful Mad Hatter (Sebastian Stan), why did you have to get sucked in by Regina's offer of gold? Don't you know by now that anything she says is a straight-up lie?

When Regina told the Hatter she would reward him handsomely to un-retire from hopping worlds one last time, he couldn't resist because, god bless him, he wanted to provide for his adorable daughter. But obviously Regina betrays him and he gets stuck in Wonderland. Then she was so cruel that she transported him to Storybrooke (somehow€still not clear on how she got him from Wonderland) and made him remember EVERYTHING.

If he had just quit while he was ahead, he and his daughter would have both been blissfully ignorant together in Storybrooke when the curse hit.


4. August's Stubbornness In Anything He Did

August. Pinnocchio. Whatever you go by these days. We know your father didn't raise you to be a stubborn, selfish boy. In fact, the opposite was what turned you into a real boy.

So why did you abandon Emma in that orphanage? Why did you stay hidden in your trailer as a wooden person for so long after the curse was broken? If you had come forward sooner, you would have been able to be restored to full, un-wooden health, and you would have been able to recognize Tamara before it was too late for everything to hit the fan!

You also wouldn't have turned back into a little boy, which was by far one of the most uncomfortable plot twists in OUAT history.


3. When Regina Bailed On Meeting Her Second True Love

When Tinkerbell led Regina to her second true love, later to be revealed as Robin Hood, Regina had the chance to forget her hate and move on. But of course, she decided to hold onto her hate and enact the curse.

If she had chosen to move on right then, she and Robin Hood (and the rest of the kingdom) could have lived happily ever after. And Regina wouldn't have to deal with a resurrected wife like she is in season four.


2. When Zelena Couldn't Let Go Of Her Mommy Issues

Zelena went to Oz to find out who she really was, and it seemed that after she met Glinda she was on the path to redemption. Of course, this wouldn't be OUAT without some good old-fashioned irony.

As soon as Dorothy stumbled onto the scene, Zelena's classic jealousy issue resurfaced almost immediately. She read way too much into the prophecy about a magical person coming to Oz and saving everyone, and instead of accepting that not all prophecies need to come true, she turned green again and set out on her path for vengeance against Regina, which ultimately ended in her death. But not before wreaking havoc on the residents of Storybrooke/The Enchanted Forest and killing our beloved Neal.


1. When The Genie Fell In Love With Regina

Basically, it's safe to say that falling in love with Regina is a dangerous game. To his credit, the Genie aka Sydney Glass didn't know how evil Regina was when he initially fell in love with her.

But he really should have second guessed her request for him to help her LEGIT MURDER her husband. Because of his love blinders, he murdered a man, got stuck inside of a mirror and then became Regina's puppet in Storybrooke as well.

This dude's one-sided and desperate affection for the Evil Queen is majorly unhealthy, and he really needs to sort out his priorities.


Contributor
Contributor

Holland Baker is based in New York City, where she is an editor, writer and co-host of Whatever It Takes: A Degrassi Podcast. In her free time, you can find her searching for bodega cats, eating mass amounts of pizza and using humor as a defense mechanism.