Ranking Every Arrowverse Big Bad From Worst To Best

Arrowverse villains are the worst of the worst, but which one is the best?

Arrowverse Villains
The CW

The Arrowverse has been a part of television for almost six years, ever since the launch of Arrow. The show's success encouraged the network to expand the universe and it eventually spawned spin-off shows The Flash, Supergirl and DC's Legends of Tomorrow.

While that's a lot of heroes, it's even more villains. Each year, the protagonists find themselves embroiled in battles with countless cold-hearted menaces. But there is always one entity in each show that proves to be more powerful, intimidating and a lot harder to stop than all the others - these are the annual Big Bads.

Over the years, the writers have plucked some of the darkest antagonists from DC's collection of twisted supervillains. From swordsmen to speedsters and aliens to demons, we have just about seen it all when it comes to Arrowverse villains. But which of these threats are the best of them all, and which ones ultimately failed to live up to expectations?

17. Non

Supergirl Non
The CW

Appeared In: Supergirl (Season 1)

Non was the primary antagonist of Supergirl's debut outing. Though the show originally positioned the Girl of Steel's aunt, Astra, to be the main villain, that character was killed off surprisingly early - leaving her vengeful husband Non to carry on her mission.

Unfortunately, this would prove to be mistake as Non just wasn't that interesting. He was already pig-headed and revenge-driven before Astra's death, thus he didn't change following it. He had no redeeming qualities at all and was quite bland all-round. This would only get worse when he spent the second half of the season as nothing more than a glorified puppet for Indigo.

The show would have been far better off if Astra had remained the season's Big Bad. Wronged by her own sister on Krypton, she had genuine reasons for her behaviour, even if her methods were misguided. But most of all, she had heart and this made her much deeper than her husband ever was. As a supporting character Non was serviceable, but as a major villain he was, for lack of a better word, nondescript.


16. Damien Darhk

Arrow Damien Darhk
The CW

Appeared In: Arrow (Season 4)

After Ra's Al Ghul didn't quite live up to expectations, the Arrow showrunners decided to introduce his former protege-turned-nemesis Damien Darhk as Season 4's main villain. Though this was a somewhat flawed philosophy on their part, we were willing to give it a try. However, the whole season ended up being a colossal failure, and one of the many reasons for this was Darhk's inclusion.

Despite a fantastically charismatic performance from Neal McDonough, the mystic just did not gel with Arrow's once-gritty environment. His dialogue was corny and his supernatural powers weren't the right fit for the show. Although we all hoped his storyline would lead to something (or anything), everything fell apart when it was ultimately revealed that his single purpose was to destroy the world in a nuclear blaze (because that's fresh and new, right?).

In defense of Darhk, his resurgence on Legends of Tomorrow during Seasons 2 and 3 proved that he was actually a great character when written properly. But unfortunately, his entire stint on Arrow was a huge misfire.


15. Vandal Savage

Vandal Savage Legends of Tomorrow Pilot Part 2
The CW

Appeared In: DC's Legends of Tomorrow (Season 1)

Immortal tyrant Vandal Savage was the very first big bad for the time-travelling misfits on Legends of Tomorrow. Though an iconic comic book character, his Arrowverse counterpart didn't exactly have much to offer. Sure, he was immortal and sure, he wanted to maintain that immortality by killing Hawkgirl and Hawkman, but the problem with the season-long arc lies in the fact that this exact storyline had already been resolved in the previous year's Arrowverse crossover - during which Green Arrow, The Flash, Black Canary and the Hawks defeated him, leading to his death.

Thus, parts of Legends of Tomorrow's first season merely felt like recycled storyline. What made it worse was that Savage had nothing different to offer this time around. He didn't learn anything or change his goals - he was exactly the same. Thus, the character came across as one-dimensional as he wanted nothing more than immortality. Not very deep, Vandal.

Casper Crump was as devilish as we could have hoped, and the resemblance to the comic book iteration of Savage is uncanny. It's just a shame that The CW's version didn't have much going on below the surface.


14. Cayden James

Arrow Cayden James
The CW

Appeared In: Arrow (Season 6A)

After months of teasing, super hacker Cayden James finally showed up on Arrow's sixth season, becoming the first of two Big Bads. Portrayed by veteran actor Michael Emerson, James was undoubtedly an alluring character when he first debuted. There was also an emotional crux of his villainous desires (centred on the death of his son) and thus, he was driven by vengeance. But alas, there was still something off about the character.

Once his initial sheen wore off, James began to hold the show back. Other than direct Black Siren and hide behind a computer screen, he didn't have much to offer. Unfortunately, the writers' insistence on keeping him one step ahead of everyone else encouraged this, as he had very little to do most of the time.

Emerson gave it everything he had in an attempt to make the character work. But even with his seductive voice and latter emotional performances, he just couldn't get the character to be what the writers clearly thought he was.

Interesting backstory? Check. Incredible performance? Check. James had all the tools (literally) to be a great villain, but the execution ultimately let him down and as a result, the character only lasted half a season.


13. Ra's Al Ghul

Arrow Ra's Al Ghul
The CW

Appeared In: Arrow (Season 3)

Poor Ra's Al Ghul simply wanted Oliver to become his successor. While this certainly sounded like a plot reminiscent of a Batman comic, the TV format of Arrow ultimately worked against it. For major parts of the season, Ra's came across more like a friend than a foe.

This not only led to some rather flat episodes, it allowed for some cringe-worthy moments, especially when Ra's became Nanda Parbat's biggest Olicity shipper. Moreover, when he wasn't trying to convince Felicity to sleep with Oliver, he was throwing a tantrum because Oliver wouldn't be his heir and when Ra's picks you to be his heir, you be his heir dammit.

With a year worth of foreshadowing behind it, and a strong performance from Matt Nable at the forefront, the execution of Ra's Al Ghul should have been a lot better than it turned out to be. Unfortunately, the whole storyline just painted him as a deluded ageing leader who let his mortality catch up to him and, other than trying to tear everything that was good about Arrow apart, he didn't really have anything to do.


12. Rhea

Supergirl Rhea
The CW

Appeared In: Supergirl (Season 2)

Portrayed by Superman legend, Teri Hatcher, Rhea was the queen of destroyed planet Daxam and the mother of Mon-El. Like many Arrowverse Big Bads, Rhea was spurred on by a mixture of grief and vengeance. While this made her somewhat relatable, the writers failed to realise that it isn't enough for a character to be seeking revenge or power. We need to know more about them first in order to truly care about their desires, and this is where Rhea didn't succeed.

We knew that she was angry about Daxam's destruction, and the fact that Krypton was the cause of it. But the way in which the character was written ultimately let her down. She rarely showed genuine emotion or heartbreak and always chose to be the typical high and mighty queen that punishes all who oppose her — including her own husband. Was she badass? Yes. Was she a force to be reckoned with? Yes. Was she deep? Undecided.

Hatcher sizzled on screen and had some beautifully sassy exchanges with fellow TV legends Calista Flockhart and Lynda Carter. But due to an underdeveloped goal, Rhea often came across as a one-dimensional figurehead who simply wanted to kill everyone in her path.


11. Clifford DeVoe

The Flash The Thinker
The CW

Appeared In: The Flash (Season 4)

Unlike previous entries on this list, Clifford DeVoe was a very interesting antagonist, and served as a welcome change for The Flash as it headed into its fourth season. He had the fastest brain alive and could out-think the Scarlet Speedster without blinking, but there was so much more to him than that.

Sick of the modern era, he wanted to enlighten the world and free them of their tainted minds. But as he became obsessed with knowledge, we discovered that he wanted to erase human functions, memories and most importantly emotion from everyone's lives so he could teach them the way of the new world. And around three-quarters through the season, he had become a mindless dictator who simply wanted to take over the world and enforce his own vision upon the supposedly uneducated.

On paper, The Thinker's plans sounded like they could have given The Flash its best season yet, but even with his interesting arc and a perfect performance from Neil Sandilands, the show couldn't maintain the standard for long. Though he was built up well, the execution of his storyline and ultimate defeat were major disappointments.


10. Ricardo Diaz

Arrow Richard Diaz
The CW

Appeared In: Arrow (Season 6B)

For the first time in Arrowverse history, Arrow's sixth season had two separate Big Bads. While Cayden James didn't live up to expectations, the second major villain, Ricardo Diaz exceeded them. Though he was initially aligned with James (and was incredibly underdeveloped), he eventually came out of that shadow when he killed the hacker and assumed control of Star City. Arrow should definitely be commended for this twist as it revitalized the show and paved the way for an impressive series of episodes.

Diaz was a violent individual who wouldn't let anything stop him from building his empire. But unlike previous villains, he wasn't doing it for the power or the rewards, he was doing it to prove to his childhood bully (and in effect, himself) that he wasn't a loser. A vicious loose-canon, Diaz restored that grounded sense of grittiness that had been absent from the show for years.

Although he would have benefited from a little more backstory exploration (and a lot more focused episodes), Diaz was one of the most compelling villains we have seen so far. Actor Kirk Acevedo was outstanding as the violent mobster and we can't wait to see what Diaz brings to the table in Season 7. Let's just hope he's given more screen time to fully develop this time around.


9. Mallus (And His Army)

Legends of Tomorrow Mallus
The CW

Appeared In: DC's Legends of Tomorrow (Season 3)

Legends of Tomorrow went dark this past year and decided to incorporate a time-travelling demon into its mythology. The writers did a fantastic job of heightening the tension throughout the season as they built up to his reveal, and the fact that we were all excited and unnerved by a character who didn't appear until the penultimate episode speaks volumes.

From the mere mention of his name to the terrifying demon world, Legends really made us feel Mallus before we ever saw him. Moreover, nothing could have prepared us for the giant winged bat-demon that he eventually turned out to be.

But the demon doesn't get all the credit. While he was busy demoning inside the demon world, he relied on his lieutenants in the real world to free him. With that, the unusual alliance of Damien Darhk and Gorilla Grodd began wreaking havoc throughout the season. Darhk turned in another enjoyable run on the show, but this time his relationship with his daughter Nora allowed us to see a softer side to him. He really grew as a character, which only highlighted how far he had come since the dark days of Arrow Season 4.

For the second year running, Legends of Tomorrow produced an eclectic line-up of villains that worked surprisingly well together, and it made for another unbelievably fun adventure.


8. Savitar

The Flash Season 3 Savitar
The CW

Appeared In: The Flash (Season 3)

For the third year in a row, Barry Allen faced off against a villainous speedster when he came face-to-face with Savitar. While previous speedsters had the ability to outrun Barry, Savitar could do so much more because he was the God of Speed. Well, at least that's what he wanted us to call him.

With a gigantic Transformer-like suit and the ability to move so fast that the untrained eye could not even see him, Savitar was undoubtedly a force to be reckoned with. This, along with his compelling backstory, could have made him the show's most intriguing villain yet. Unfortunately, this was simply a case of the show that went to the well one time too many. The Flash had already recycled their winning formula in Season 2 when Zoom showed up and, for the most part, it was another success. However, the same could not be said about Savitar.

Yet again we were left wondering as to who the man behind the speed-suit actually was. But this time it dragged on so long, that the vast majority of fans actually figured out the truth before the reveal. Although the reveal itself was a goosebump-inducing moment, it should have happened a lot sooner than it actually did.

Though he didn't reach his full potential, Savitar was still an incredible sight to behold. In addition, his tragic backstory made him The Flash's ultimate foil (while Grant Gustin thrived in the villainous role), but it was ultimately marred by the convoluted time-travel/time-remnant plot.


7. Reign

Supergirl Reign
The CW

Appeared In: Supergirl (Season 3)

Birthed out of fire and destined to reshape the world in her image, Reign was undoubtedly the most imposing of Supergirl's villains. Due to her complete lack of humanity, she was relentless in her approach to cleanse Earth of its sins. This led to her brutally murdering people while physically punishing Supergirl in a way that nobody ever had. Her dark motivations and lack of regard for human life added an apocalyptic vibe to the show that worked surprisingly well.

But as the season progressed, Reign became less and less terrifying as the writers came up with new ways to drag the story out until the season finale. However, one thing that kept the character interesting was the inner turmoil that was going on below the surface. While Reign herself possessed no humanity, the vessel she was inhabiting was very human. Thus, with Sam Arias's repressed humanity underneath constantly fighting to get out, Kara had to find a way to stop Reign without killing Sam.

This conflict dominated the second half of the season and was one of the show's most engaging storylines, and it was only enhanced by the two incredible contrasting performances that Odette Annable turned in as Sam and Reign. And although the season was problematic at times, it doesn't take away from the fact that Reign is easily the strongest villain Supergirl has produced so far.


6. Zoom

The Flash Zoom
The CW

Appeared In: The Flash (Season 2)

Earth-2's answer to the Reverse-Flash, Zoom took great pleasure in making life a nightmare for Barry Allen. Perhaps it was a little safe for the show to recycle the unidentified mystery speedster villain for a second year running, but it's easy to let that slide when it's pulled off so well. Additionally, the fact that Zoom came from Earth-2 introduced the multiverse, which opened the Arrowverse up to countless possibilities.

While his motives appeared to be dangerously simple (stealing The Flash's speed), it was eventually revealed that they stemmed from jealousy of Barry's blessed life. So while Zoom was undoubtedly an appropriate threat, one of his most alluring qualities was that he was actually a really deep character under the surface.

While his desires made him compelling, his greatest attribute was definitely his appearance. The all-black bodysuit with the torn mouth-holes made Zoom one of the most menacing sights to ever grace our TV screens. Moreover, the blue lightning that surrounded him as he ran added to the frightening appearance while the suit's long, sharp fingernails allowed him to kill his enemies without having to chase them. But his cold dead eyes and raspy voice were undoubtedly the two most chilling aspects about the character and helped ensure that Zoom was easily the most terrifying villain the Arrowverse has ever seen.


5. Legion Of Doom

Legends of Tomorrow Legion of Doom
The CW

Appeared In: DC's Legends of Tomorrow (Season 2)

What happens when you have a TV show full of the Arrowverse's best secondary characters? Why, you create an ensemble of the Arrowverse's best villains to duel with them, of course. It may have been as on-the-nose as it gets, but somehow Legends of Tomorrow turned the tide during its second season to deliver one of the most entertaining outings that this shared universe has ever seen — and one of the main reasons for that was the Legion of Doom.

Comprised of former Arrow and Flash Big Bads Eobard Thawne (Reverse-Flash), Malcolm Merlyn (Dark Archer) and Damien Darhk, the villainous faction were so tired of losing that they decided to procure the Spear of Destiny to rewrite reality itself. The three contrasting villains had an unbelievable amount of chemistry together and because of their history on The Flash and Arrow, they were incredibly well-developed — each one with their own unique goals and desires.

In addition, Legends revitalized Merlyn, who had grown stale on Arrow while finally allowing Neal McDonough to shine as Damien Darhk (who was much more suited to Legends). It was also great to see Matt Letscher get the chance to portray Eobard full-time (Tom Cavanagh portrayed the role on The Flash due to Eobard's possession of Harrison Wells).

Captain Cold and Heatwave were later added, capping off a dream team that highlighted just how rich these recycled villains truly were.


4. Prometheus

prometheus arrow villain
The CW

Appeared In: Arrow (Season 5)

After Arrow's reviled fourth season came to an end, the show made one of the most impressive comebacks in recent memory with Season 5. While the new storylines were compelling and the new characters were intriguing, one of the main reasons why it worked was down to its villain - Prometheus.

Fans were initially cautious to hear that the show would be introducing yet another archer but Prometheus made short work of our fears. His sword-wielding and expert fighting skills made him the perfect antagonist for a show like Arrow. There was no corny dialogue or cringe-worthy plots and instead, we got a thrilling mystery with a genuinely frightening Big Bad. Thanks to this, the series once again became that gritty crime drama that it had been in its first two seasons.

However, the thing that made Adrian Chase so compelling were the reasons behind his destruction. Unlike Darhk, he didn't want to take over the world or destroy it - his goal was much more personal than that. Prometheus was a dark and vicious avenger born out of Oliver Queen's past sins. He studied his target and grew close to him, watching his every move. And this allowed him to always remain one step ahead of the Green Arrow. It was, quite simply, the stuff that comic book fans' dreams are made of.


3. Dark Archer

Arrow Dark Archer
The CW

Appeared In: Arrow (Season 1)

Committed to making Oliver Queen's first year as a vigilante hell, the Dark Archer served as Arrow's very first Big Bad. Portrayed by John Barrowman, the villain first surfaced when he began killing some of The Arrow's former targets, effectively framing Starling City's saviour for murders that he didn't commit. With his hooded mask and all-black uniform (which would later be revealed to be the standard League of Assassins' uniform), the Dark Archer was undoubtedly one of Oliver's most physically threatening foes. But he backed up that reputation with his superior fighting skills and ended up besting The Arrow in battle throughout Season 1.

While the comic iteration of Merlyn was one of the Green Arrow's best-known villains, Arrow gave him a compelling new backstory that only complemented the character. Seeking revenge for his wife's death, Malcolm Merlyn plotted an "undertaking" during which he would unleash an Earthquake device on The Glades, wiping the crime-infested area from Starling City forever. This intricate plot made the show's debut season an intriguing mystery as we put the pieces of The Undertaking together and tried to figure out who was responsible and why they were doing it.

While the showrunners' decision to let him stick around after Season 1 unfortunately led to Merlyn turning into a complete parody of himself, that doesn't take away from the near-perfect villain that he was in the show's freshman year. As the Dark Archer, he never failed to out-think or out-manouevre Oliver, and because of this, he was the perfect example of a calculatingly brilliant antagonist.


2. Deathstroke

Deathstroke The CW
The CW

Appeared In: Arrow (Season 2)

Deathstroke is undoubtedly one of the most iconic DC villains of all time, and his stint on Arrow only added to that rich legacy. It took place during the show's glory days and, thanks to the most masterful piece of foreshadowing the Arrowverse has ever pulled off, his arrival in the second season was foretold at the beginning of Season 1. Portrayed by Manu Bennett, Slade Wilson was a former ally of Oliver Queen's as the two were stranded on Lian Yu together. We saw this friendship unfold throughout the flashbacks of Season 1 and 2 before the sword-wielding assassin showed up in Starling City, looking for revenge.

Broken-hearted by lost love and driven mad by Mirakuru, Slade was undoubtedly the most intimidating foe that Arrow has ever seen. But these motivations made him more than a great villain — they made him the tragic antihero of his own story and thus, we spent half of the time amazed by his badassery and the other half in awe of his emotional arc.

His ties to Oliver made the story all the more personal and its culmination was executed with such brilliance that the final few episode of Season 2 felt less like a season finale and more like a series finale. Slade's dramatic arc was enhanced by Bennett's outstanding performance, all of which helped to make Season 2 of Arrow the show's finest outing yet. Long live Deathstroke, kid!


1. Reverse-Flash

Reverse Flash
The CW

Appeared In: The Flash (Season 1)

They say that every great hero is defined by their greatest villain. Well, it doesn't get any better than the Reverse-Flash. The man in the yellow suit haunted Barry Allen throughout his young life and left us all trying to figure out his true identity. As a result, The Flash's freshman season wasn't just a superhero show, it was a compelling mystery that kept us hooked right until the very end.

After travelling through time to kill a young Barry, Eobard Thawne ended up trapped in the past. In a beautiful case of dramatic irony, the only person who could help him was The Flash. But as he had erased the Scarlet Speedster's heroic destiny from existence (by killing his mother), Eobard had to mentor his archenemy, helping him become the hero he despised so much. This led to a season-long arc in which the villain became a father-figure to the hero (and all of Team Flash). And by plotting his enemies' future downfall, Thawne ended up growing quite fond of them.

Tom Cavanagh delivered a masterful performance as the mentor antagonist, being warm and encouraging in one moment and nothing short of chilling in the next. The first Big Bad of The Flash is what all of the Arrowverse shows should aspire to create, and he set the bar so high that no other villain has ever come close to replicating the impression he made.

Which Arrowverse Big Bad was your favourite? Tell us in the comment section below.


In this post: 
Arrowverse
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Patterson is an experienced writer with an affinity for all things film and TV. He may or may not have spent his childhood obsessing over WWE.