20 TV Shows That Failed To Stick The Landing

The great TV fumbles, from The Walking Dead to The Boys.

The Boys Season Finale Bad
Prime Video

It's a tricky business, making a TV show. Because it's such a long-form piece of storytelling, taking years to move to the finish line, there are so many things that can go wrong, stopping any series from completing its run in the originally intended way... or the way desired by fans. 

Over the years, the greats have had no such issues - or, if they have, they've overcome them. Breaking Bad, Better Call Saul, Mad Men, The Wire, Succession, all of these and more knew how to end on a high. 

The same cannot be said of the following shows, many of which were, at their best, television dynamite until they tripped at the final hurdle. Others, meanwhile, were never allowed the chance to realise their potential, because they dropped the ball straight out of the gate and never found a way to pick it up again.

With that in mind - from popular dramas that couldn't tie up their loose ends to sitcoms that attempted to shift focus at the final second to wonky results - here are the biggest TV shows that failed to stick the landing...

20. Marvel's What If...?

The Watcher What If
Marvel Studios

It's frustrating, really, that Marvel's What If...? ended up such a massively anticlimactic mess.

On paper, an animated TV series exploring possible alternate fates of everyone's favourite superheroes and villains sounded great. In execution, though, things were never clear, every episode being brought to life with unimaginative animation and what-if scenarios which were never all that interesting to begin with. 

Some work, like an alternate reality in which Peggy Carter becomes Captain America, but who wanted to see Happy Hogan play Die Hard, or Iron Man meet the Grandmaster from Doctor Strange?

It was all a bit odd, truth be told, and odder still was how every character was voiced by someone new (Tony Stark with no RDJ? Criminal). It also didn't help matters that during its three-season run Marvel's What If...? attempted to link all its episodes together into one, interconnected narrative.

It needed to be fun, inventive, but What If...? was never more than forgettable and overstuffed. 


19. Seinfeld

Seinfeld finale
NBC

A key issue with a lot of shows on this list is how badly they miss the very point of their existence, and if you want the most infamous example of that you need look no further than Seinfeld. 

Throughout its run, Seinfeld was a sitcom with a unique view of its characters, who weren't so much lovelorn New Yorkers searching for comfort as they were narcissistic chaos agents who unintentionally wreaked havoc wherever they roamed.

The joy of Seinfeld was always that the show knew this - that we loved the lives of Jerry, Elaine, George, and Kramer because of their flaws, not in spite of them. 

It was a shame, then, that the series decided to end with the New York Four being punished for all the trauma and pain they'd caused throughout the show, landing themselves in jail. It didn't fit the preceding nine years of comedy, nor the point of who these people were - minor villains who always got away with it. 


18. Ozark

Ozark season 4
Netflix

Ozark was, throughout its a run, a thrilling tale of family and crime that, whilst undeniably a slow-burn, had plenty of narrative thud to keep viewers engaged. 

It was during its fourth and final season, though, that the Jason Bateman-starring drama started to lose sight of itself and its key players, rushing its character arcs to completion whilst leaving its final showdowns muted by dull action and anti-climatic twists. 

There was the dangerous and indomitable Ruth (Julia Garner), who was killed almost as an afterthought despite seasons of strength, and Jonah (Skylar Gaertner), son of Bateman and Laura Linney's embattled protagonists, who got a cut-to-black cliffhanger that really should have been played out, given the rift between him and his parents.

It was all rather anti-climactic and meh, especially when you realise the major car crash teased all season was a red herring.


17. Under the Dome

Under the Dome
CBS

Much like the Stephen King novel that gave it life, Under the Dome spent the vast majority of its three seasons as a jumbled, stuffy mess. 

Which, of course, is a shame, because the main kernels of greatness its premise contains are seriously enticing. Concerning the fictional town of Chester's Mill, Maine, after it's inexplicably encased by a forcefield, Under the Dome offers a thrilling dive into the lives of people driven by desperation and shrouded by secrets. 

It's typical King fare, and in some aspects it succeeds, especially where its effects are concerned. But thanks to its uninteresting characters and soap opera-like twists, it keeps tangling itself in subplots that carry little emotional weight.

And all that's without getting into how the central mystery turns out to be some kind of strange alien conspiracy that reverberates around the world. In what should have been a tightly wound tale of people torn apart and brought together by calamity, Under the Dome became far too concerned with the bigger picture. 


16. Sons of Anarchy

Sons Of Anarchy Season 1
FX

Sons of Anarchy was always destined to end one way: With the death of series lead Jax Teller (Charlie Hunnam), who from day one was doomed to the life he had chosen. 

Throughout its run, Kurt Sutter's gritty and grimy biker gang drama was a thrilling spectacle full of colourful characters, gripping tragedy, and brilliantly melodramatic rug pulls. But as it went on, the melodrama took over, its characters became too violent, and the fun undertones of the show were replaced by a distinct hopelessness. 

In its seventh and final season especially, Sons of Anarchy suffered, reducing many fan favourite characters to nasty props for torture and dismay - including Juice (Theo Rossi), tortured incessantly by white supremacists in prison because... reasons? - and Jax himself to a horrible, soulless weapon of mass destruction.

The nuance of the series' previous years was long gone, and the drama became too miserable to enjoy. When it did finally end (with almost everyone dead!), it was honestly a relief. 


15. Penny Dreadful

Penny Dreadful Possession
Showtime

Penny Dreadful was brilliant throughout its run, until a rushed and truncated finale left many fans scratching their heads and bemoaning the anticlimax of it all. 

A beautiful drama blending Gothic horror with bloody action to create a unique world of human heroes versus complicated monsters, John Logan's cult gem sported stunning production design, effective genre subversion, and an all-star cast led by Eva Green and Josh Hartnett offering the best work of their careers. 

It's awesome! Seriously. The problems arise in the final hour or two, when our assembled heroes line up against Dracula only for the fight to fail to deliver on the promise of previous episodes. There's no big confrontation between Drac and Hartnett, a couple of big reveals are mentioned only in passing, and in the end, everything just kind of... stops.

With all the villains still out there, wreaking havoc, and every fan favourite character dead, Penny Dreadful needed another season or two to really do itself justice. But alas, it was never meant to be, and fans were forever left with more questions than answers by the time it came to a close.


14. The 100

The 100
The CW

All The 100 ever needed to be was what it promised in its first two seasons. 

The plot, in its early days, was simple: Generations after a nuclear apocalypse, a group of teenage prisoners aboard a space station housing the last remnants of humankind are sent down to earth to see if the planet is ready for resettlement.

On the ground, the titular 100 encounter warring tribes of people lost to time, and must decide who to trust, fight with, and fight for. It's a fun, thrilling coming-of-age actioner, full of compelling characters and decent tension, until midway through its run it became far too concerned with going capital-B Bigger. 

With villainous artificial intelligence and time travel, The 100 became a textbook example of a series throwing whatever it could at the wall to see what would stick, and given how messy it became - and how many of its characters became little more than plot devices than actual people - not a lot of it did. 


13. Heroes

Heroes Claire
NBC

Heroes wasn't derailed by poor creative choices so much as it was hampered by the 2007 WGA Writers' Strike, which halted production on its truncated second season.

That being said, showrunner Tim Kring didn't do the show many favours when things got moving again. The first season was highly acclaimed, and rightly so - it was a fun, vibrant drama about everyday people granted superhuman abilities - but going forward Kring decided the vibe of the story needed changing. 

From its second season to its closing fourth, Heroes lost the sense of adventure that coloured its debut, becoming a grim affair populated by characters who didn't seem to have any life in them.

The tone change led to so many issues, chief amongst them awful dialogue, uneven character arcs, and a palpable sense of unending hopelessness, that Heroes never lived up to the potential set by its first season. In fact, the first season feels like a completely different show altogether... and an infinitely better one at that. 


12. The Boys

The Boys Season 5
Prime

We were promised scorched earth, and yet what The Boys delivered with its final season - a long-time-coming showdown between hero hunter Billy Butcher (Karl Urban) and malevolent villain Homelander (Antony Starr) - was more akin to a mild campfire. 

The Boys' final chapter had a lot holding it back: tedious subplots dragged for far too long, like The Deep (Chace Crawford) and his feud with the new Black Noir (Nathan Mitchell); characters with ample potential were tossed aside with minimal fuss, like Butcher and A-Train (Jessie T. Usher); and the show's Hollywood satire became so on-the-nose it was often irritating, like when it roped in so many A-listers in to play over-the-top versions of themselves. 

It had its moments - Antony Starr still stuns - but all told The Boys' swan song lacked the wit and meaning of all that came before, leading everyone to bloody but emotionally lacklustre fates. 

With no room to focus on the moving parts that really mattered (let's be honest, there should have been a whole season dealing with Butcher's villain arc), The Boys' finale was a real dud that failed to live up to its own standards. 


11. Buffy the Vampire Slayer

Buffy the Vampire Slayer Chosen
Mutant Enemy Productions

As almost any superfan will tell you (this writer included), Buffy the Vampire Slayer probably should have ended with its epic and emotionally poignant fifth season. 

That's to say that the next two seasons were meritless, only that they struggled to find an identity that suited Buffy's characters as they grew up and faced bigger, more adult challenges. Season six, for example, was a dour mix of dark romance and horrible tragedy that was too bleak to be enjoyed, its characters beaten by addiction and toxic relationships.

There was a slight course correction going into its seventh and final season, as the intrepid Scooby Gang were sent back to school for one final apocalypse, but even then Buffy struggled to end without finding a need to go bigger than it needed to. 

With an underwhelming final fight and some cheap character deaths, Buffy ended with chaos when it really should have leaned more into its more subtle aspects. Again, not without its merits - the arc of antihero vampire Spike (James Marsters), anyone? - but still a shaky, messy end for a fun little show that was always so confident and assured.


10. Teen Wolf

Teen Wolf - The Wolves of War
MTV

It's a recurring issue with a lot of shows that as they go on, they lose sight of what they once were. 

Teen Wolf was made very much in the mould of Buffy: A group of outcast high schoolers are thrown into a new, supernatural world, and must decide who they want to be. 

The results were always fun with Teen Wolf, the adventures and relationships of werewolf Scott (Tyler Posey) and his closest friends often leading to some solid laughs and decent horror. But as the series progressed, this nagging need to create a big spectacle and call back to previous seasons overcame it. 

In its final season, with a handful of fan favourite actors nowhere to be seen, Teen Wolf turned itself from a gritty coming-of-age drama to a show about a worldwide war between humanity and the supernatural. It was a step too far for a show once so intimate... and the less said about the impressively awful sequel movie, the better. 


9. The Blacklist

The Blacklist James Spader
NBC

By the time of its final season, The Blacklist had run out of gas.

Anchored by James Spader's commanding portrayal of criminal mastermind Raymond Reddington, the drama followed an exciting procedural format as its leading man chased down fugitives and fellow criminals with the aid of the FBI.

It was seriously good fun in its early days, but as it trudged along it struggled to keep up the tension. From around season six or seven, the mysteries surrounding Red became more tiresome and repetitive than engaging, and it seemed the writers were at a loss about where everyone was supposed to end up. 

By the time of the final season, The Blacklist was limping along, and in an attempt to give it a definitive ending they killed Red at the horns of a bull (because reasons), and let those in his orbit move on from him without any fuss. It was a lazy goodbye for a series always so smart, and Red deserved better. 


8. Friends

Friends Chandler Rachel Joey
Warner Bros.

As one of the most popular and beloved sitcoms of all time, it can be difficult to look back on Friends and realise it wasn't all that good in its final years. 

When Friends started out, it was a down-to-earth and realistic portrayal of friends hanging out, falling in love, falling out, courting careers and change faced by us all, and it propelled itself forward with a unique style, great laughs, and a witty cast. 

But as it marched forward - particularly around the eighth season, maybe earlier - it became too unchallenging and mechanical with its laughs, each character became far too linked to their loudest traits (Ross and his over-the-top outbursts, Joey and his stupidity), and the relationship drama too artificial. 

Polished within an inch of its life, Friends lost that realistic edge that made it such a relatable gem in its early years, as well as that element of emotional surprise that made Ross and Rachel's will-they-won't-they so engaging, and the friends themselves so lived-in and real. 


7. Dexter

Dexter Michael C. Hall
Showtime

Looking back, it's safe to say Dexter was never a show destined to maintain its quality over an eight-season run. 

It's not exactly a surprise, then, that the serial killer drama started to tie itself in knots toward the end. In an attempt to keep viewers engaged with outlandish twists, all it really managed to do was alienate its audience and betray all its characters to unwanted bolts from the blue. 

Where to start? For one thing, there was the general structure of the show, which as a procedural from the view of killer who kills killers (Michael C. Hall), became a bit stale after almost 100 episodes. For another, there was that final season, which allowed Dexter to get away for his crimes whilst his tormented sister died for his sins. 

Dexter leaned into cruelty for its last stretch and failed to give audiences what they wanted - justice - and whilst its various spin-offs have allowed the franchise to feel fresh again, nothing can wipe away the stain of the original's fall from grace. 


6. Killing Eve

Killing Eve
BBC

In hindsight, Killing Eve was always going to end with tragedy, the only problem is that when it finally did, it rushed what should have been a much more considered farewell with shock value over emotional substance. 

In the final season of the thrilling cat-and-mouse saga, MI6 officer Eve (Sandra Oh) and lethal assassin Villeneuve (Jodie Comer) come together to destroy the assassin organisation the Twelve, which was fitting given their complicated history of animosity and, eventually, shared affection.

The final clash makes for quite the ride, the pair working together to destroy their enemies and grow closer until finally admitting their feelings, a long-awaited development that allows both women a chance to share a rare moment of happiness and peace. 

That is, until Villeneuve is killed by an unseen sniper in a last-second rug pull. No, Villeneuve and Eve were never destined to ride off into the sunset together, but the latter's death - mixed with the ambiguous fate of the former, left destroyed and stranded - should have been given more time to play out. 


5. Lost

Lost Jack
ABC

Lost was always going to struggle to bring together all its moving pieces together in a satisfying way, doomed by its own complexity. 

One of the most thrilling dramas ever made, Lost followed a group of plane crash survivors who find themselves stranded on a mysterious island tangled in secrets. At first, everything seems simple enough; the survivors find they're not alone on the island, and are left scattered by their new foes. 

But as the show progressed, things became too messy. The island's mysteries kept becoming more complicated, blending time travel with alternate realities until the final season had to bring everything together in a way that made it all make something resembling sense. 

The answers, though, never really came, and Lost decided to end its run not with an explanation of all that audiences had seen, but with an emotional farewell to its characters after years of conflict and torment. It's touching, sure, but shining more of a light on the island's mysteries - young Walt's psychic powers, the numbers! - would have gone a long way. 


4. Game of Thrones

Game Of Thrones Red Wedding
HBO

Game of Thrones is the best show and perhaps most popular show on this list, which is exactly why its half-baked final seasons were such colossal disappointments. 

Based on the novels by George R. R. Martin, Game of Thrones had the world in a chokehold throughout its run, thanks in large part to its epic storytelling, compelling character work, and gritty drama. 

Going into the final season, there were so many powerful storylines to unpack, but all of them fell victim to lazy writing and awful pacing issues. We see Dany (Emilia Clarke) fall to the dark side with minimal build-up, Cersei (Lena Heady) become a helpless victim despite years as the show's best antagonist, and everyone else lose their spark.

Jon (Kit Harrington) is tossed aside, the battle with the invincible White Walkers lasts no time at all despite seasons of build-up, and in the end everything is tidied away with almost laughable convenience. It felt like a different show than what it used to and given its highs, that's a serious tragedy. 


3. The Walking Dead

we are the walking dead
AMC

The Walking Dead never stood a chance. 

Based on the comic series by Robert Kirkman, the post-apocalyptic drama suffered from constant behind-the-scenes rifts with showrunners and cast members, leaving every season feeling different in tone and message than the last. It had its highs - season one through five, depending on who you ask - but by its eleventh chapter, it was a mere shell of its former self.

The biggest issues were pacing and character. Whereas previous storylines regarding The Governor and Alexandria were well drawn out and explored, the final seasons of The Walking Dead rushed their biggest conflicts with little character development and awkward timelines. Characters came and went, their intentions were never clear, and the writing felt painfully flat.

It doesn't help that series lead Andrew Lincoln dropped out in season nine, leaving so many thin characters to try to fill the void of his absence - Rosita, Aaron, Ezekiel amongst them. A bit repetitive and emotionally distant, TWD ended with a shrug when it should have ended with a haymaker.


2. How I Met Your Mother

How I Met Your Mother
CBS

There is no show in recent memory that has betrayed audiences more than How I Met Your Mother. 

Throughout its run, the charming little sitcom was a flawed but moving affair, a silly but meaningful exploration of one man's quest to find his soulmate that promised audiences a happy ending. A happy ending, that is, that never came. 

At the end of the show's final season, hopeless romantic Ted (Josh Radnor) revealed that his beloved wife (Cristin Milioti) had been dead for years, and that he was telling his kids the story of how they met so he could ask their permission to ask out his on-and-off-and-on-and-off-again ex Robin (Cobie Smulders). 

It was a major betrayal, reducing the title character to a footnote in her own story so our narrator could run off with to a relationship that had never worked in the past. Attempting to say something about moving on, all How I Met Your Mother did was alienate its entire fanbase. Shame!


1. Brooklyn Nine-Nine

Brooklyn Nine-Nine Jake Peralta
NBC

During production of its eighth and final season, Brooklyn Nine-Nine was derailed by the COVID pandemic, a calamity that producers used to try to say something important about the world.

This was not a terrible idea, since the themes of the comedy's final season are pretty damn vital - injustice, police brutality, racism, corruption - it's just that the series never felt like the right place for them, and its silly tone kept the importance of what it wanted to say at arm's length. 

After all, Brooklyn Nine-Nine had spent the preceding seven years a silly sitcom that had always glossed over such issues within the American police force, even actively making jokes at the expense of saying meaningful about them.

It was an admittedly bold attempt to say something more important in the midst of its typically fun misadventures, but the tone was jumbled and the sentiment felt too little, too late. It should have tackled its loftier ideas earlier, or left them be entirely. 


 
Posted On: 
Contributor

I get to write about what I love, which is cool. You'll typically find me in front of a TV, or hunkered down behind a book, or dreaming of things far away. Be good to each other. Find my other writings here: https://allthethingsineversaid.substack.com/