Riverdale: Ranking Every Character From Worst To Best

18. Sierra McCoy

Riverdale Mayor Sierra McCoy
The CW

The former mayor of Riverdale, Sierra McCoy was known for her short temper, hiding the truth and reluctantly working with the Lodges. During her time in office, she usually showed up to either threaten Jughead Jones (who was investigating the mysteries that she didn't want investigated) or be threatened by Jughead Jones.

Like many of Riverdale's characters, the end of her somewhat antagonistic behavior resulted in Sierra becoming an ally of sorts for our young kids, using her law background to represent any of our beloved characters in need - but again, she doesn't get half the focus she used to and her sporadic appearances make it hard to follow what's actually happening in her life.

There was a lot of promise in her relationship with daughter Josie, but with the former singer of The Pussycats' departure on the horizon, are we about to bid Sierra farewell too?

Maybe it's time to develop her relationship with Tom Keller a little further...


17. Fangs Fogarty

Riverdale Fangs Fogarty
The CW

Fangs Fogarty was simply introduced as a random member of the Southside Serpents in the show's second season before he became the center of a murder investigation. Though there was still some issues in the story department, fans quickly grew attached to him based on Drew Ray Tanner's endearing performance. And following a surprise relationship with Kevin in the show's third season, it felt like the writers were ready to take a chance on the character.

Unfortunately, he too became one of the many plot devices in the convoluted Farm narrative, only showing up while necessary and disappearing at the drop of a hat (and showing up in storylines that had nothing to do with him because plot device, remember?). His relationship with Kevin was never explored to the extent that it should have been as the pair just became a one-note duo used by Edgar to serve his one-note purposes.

Fangs has real potential. His relationship with Kevin has real potential. But will we ever see any of that explored in the aftermath of The Farm narrative?


16. Penelope Blossom

Riverdale Penelope Blossom
The CW

From uptight matriarch of the Blossom family to the Red Dahlia to the freakin' Gargoyle King, Penelope Blossom has always been portrayed as an antagonistic character. Out for herself to the very end, she's vile and venomous and its downright wonderful to see. Unfortunately, anything below the caricature surface is weaved in and weaved out at the drop of a hat, making it hard to fully understand what purpose the character serves other than being a plot device.

The moments of promise in when she shows genuine affection for Cheryl (telling her to stay at home on dangerous nights or throwing the St. Clairs' cheque in the fire) only end up making the character come off as even more inconsistent because when they happen, they happen without explanation and are quickly dropped whenever convenient.

That being said, Nathalie Boltt's charismatic performance is the one thing that makes Penelope such a personality, elevating the character past questionable material and making her as deliciously villainous as possible.


15. Joaquin DeSantos

Riverdale Joaquin DeSantos
The CW

Kevin Kellar's first boyfriend, Joaquin DeSantos caught us all off-guard in the show's first season - and not just because he was so dreamy. A serpent tasked with getting information out of the sheriff's son, he quickly became attached to Kevin and, dare we say it, even began to fall for him. The pair's relationship was hindered by significant lack of screen-time, but their cute moments here and there made up for it.

His departure in Season 1 may have left a lot of fans upset but his return in the third season had them beside themselves - and angry... very very angry. Having somehow ended up in the same detention center as Archie (despite leaving town), he was also drawn into the Riverdale-exclusive obsession with Gryphons & Gargoyles (despite leaving town) and was ultimately killed off after a ton of one-dimensional behaviour and no reunion with Kevin.

Another unnecessary casualty of that ridiculous Gargoyle King, Joaquin deserved so so much better.


14. Josie McCoy

Riverdale Josie McCoy
The CW

Chances are that a lot of people out there that still don't know that Ashleigh Murray was a series regular on Riverdale for the first three seasons - the reason being that her character Josie McCoy hardly ever had anything significant to do.

The lead singer of Josie and The Pussycats, she's had her moments here and there, but it just felt like the show wasn't fully committed to making her stand out like the rest of the characters. As a result, she found herself featured in a lot of main storylines without actually being involved in them, and then to top it all off, she lost her own comic-accurate band to Veronica Lodge.

That said, Murray's performance was an infectiously optimistic one that made viewers love Josie in spite of her limited screen-time, so let's hope that spin-off Katy Keene does her the justice she deserves.


13. Hermione Lodge

Riverdale Hermione Lodge
The CW

Another of Riverdale's most divisive characters, Hermione Lodge's best days were (like most of the characters) back in Season 1 when we were still getting to know her. Free from her husband's grip, Hermione decided to live life like a real person, working at Pops and with Fred while also bonding with her daughter Veronica.

Unfortunately, Hiram's return resulted in her reverting to a one-dimensional mobster's wife. Though there was potential in the fact that she did so out of fear, it was never fully explored to the degree that it needed to be and, as a result, Hermione tends to come off as a one-note character.

Even now separated from her husband (after attempting to have him killed), she switches between caring mother and crime boss far too easily without any authenticity as to what causes each change. And with each transition, she becomes less believable as a character - in spite of a great performance from Marisol Nichols.


12. Reggie Mantle

Riverdale Reggie Mantle
The CW

Reggie Mantle has had quite the journey on Riverdale thus far. Initially played by Ross Butler in the first season, he didn't appear all that often but whenever you saw Reggie, he could be either pretty decent or pretty moody - a trend that would continue when the character's role was increased.

Butler's 13 Reasons Why duties resulted in him leaving the show, allowing Charles Melton to take his place from Season 2 onwards. From there, Reggie would get more involved in the show's core storylines, but never to a degree worthy of the actors that played him. He may be a regular part of Riverdale now, but his role just feels like an extension of his Season 1 recurring role - he shows up to serve a purpose when the writers require him to, even if that purpose doesn't line-up with his previous one.

Remember when he randomly decided to attack the Serpents and wanted to kill Fangs? What about when he served as the predictably interim boyfriend for Veronica during her break with Archie? Reggie has so much potential (the storyline with his father showed real promise) but it is rarely explored and, instead, the character is written as a recurring obstacle or handyman or whatever else the plot requires him to be.

Both Butler and Melton have done great jobs bringing their own interpretations of Reggie to life and, when the writing is on the money, the character is one of the show's most enticing. The problem is that his conflicting behavior makes it hard to take him seriously as a real character - and, in all honesty, he deserves better.


11. Mary Andrews

Riverdale Mary Andrews Molly Ringwald
The CW

For being one of the show's less regular characters, Mary Andrews is surprisingly well-developed. An attorney with a passion for doing right by those who were wronged, she left town when her son was young because she always wanted to break free of Riverdale - a plot thread that regularly comes back up when she explains how she longed to take her son away too.

Mary is regularly relied upon whenever the writers find a new way to focus on Archie because she always adds a new perspective to the show. More than that, she's both a reliable and authentic source of conflict because it's totally understandable that a loving mother would attempt to prevent her son from making some of those ludicrous ideas a reality.

With Luke Perry's untimely passing, it appears that the show will be relying on Mary more often going forward. The character already has a solid foundation and has certainly benefited from the less-is-more approach, but now that she's sticking around, let's just hope that the show's bizarre storylines don't dilute her as well.


10. Kevin Keller

Riverdale Kevin Keller
The CW

Kevin Keller's history on Riverdale has been an unusual one. Initially only appearing as a recurring character throughout the first season, fans grew attached to Kevin (and his relationship with Joaquin) and actor Casey Cott rather quickly - so it was hardly surprising that he was promoted to a series regular for the second.

The ironic thing is that Kevin felt much more relevant to the plot in the first season than he has in any of the subsequent ones. He's never given the screen-time that the likes of his best friend Betty, Jughead, Archie, Veronica or even Cheryl get and that makes him feel like less of an important character - which is disappointing considering how integral he was in Season 1.

Kevin is a real asset to the show, and yet he is consistently used as an antagonistic plot device for standalone episodes before eventually learning his lesson and disappearing back into obscurity. He deserves better than that, and so does Casey Cott.


9. Toni Topaz

Riverdale Toni Topaz
The CW

Though Toni Topaz made her debut long after Riverdale's prime, she remains one of the few shining aspects of the second and third seasons. A rebel that has been both with and without a cause, she just enjoys the idea of being a rebel full stop - and she has no problem telling it like it is.

Initially a recurring character throughout the show's second season, it seemed like she was destined to become a contrived love interest of fellow Serpent Jughead Jones. Thankfully, the writers gifted us with a pleasant surprise when they subverted our expectations and kick-started the force to be reckoned with that is 'Choni' when they had the character cross paths with Cheryl.

An unexpected gem, the pair strut down the corridors like the sassy queens that they are while also having some genuinely sweet scenes when alone. Unfortunately, this wonderful couple has resulted in a little complacency which, in many ways, is Toni's biggest drawback as a character. Ever since her relationship with Cheryl was established as the solid foundation that it is, she (or the relationship) hasn't really had that much time to grow and develop further.

Two seasons in, Toni shouldn't feel this underdeveloped, and we can only hope that the show gives her some juicy material in the season ahead.


In this post: 
Riverdale
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Patterson is an experienced writer with an affinity for all things film and TV. He may or may not have spent his childhood obsessing over WWE.