Schitt’s Creek: Every Season Ranked Worst To Best

If heaven had a creek, it would be this one.

Schitt's Creek
CBC

Never has small-town life looked more and less appealing, all at once. After an unfortunate twist of fate leaves home-video tycoon Johnny Rose deprived of his riches, he and his spoiled family must move to a rundown motel in an even more rundown town to start anew. This simple premise served as the basis for one of the funniest, best-written series that television has given us in recent years, brought to us by the amazingly talented Eugene Levy and his son, Daniel, who play Johnny and his own son, David.

Over the course of six short seasons between 2015 and 2020, Schitt's Creek managed to wow, move and entertain us, with its compellingly narcissistic leads, its colourful supporting cast, and the cringe-worthy interactions between them all.

Taking a look back across its beloved run, this article is all about ranking those six seasons from worst to best. Of course, the reality is that there isn't a particular loser in the bunch, as every single season has its moments of brilliance.

(Spoilers ahead. Ew, David!)

6. Season 2

Schitts Creek David Rose
CBC

Many TV shows in their second year fall victim to what is called the sophomore slump; but while season 2 of Schitt's Creek doesn't live up to the high standards set by season 1, it's still wholly entertaining.

The second season feels like a transition period - the premise, setting and characters have been introduced and established, so now it's a matter of figuring out how they will sustain. As a result, the first half of the season gives us many filler storylines, whilst the show does a clean-up, most notably by ending the relationship between Alexis and Mutt. While there is a relatable point to be made about how the connection didn't live up to the fantasy, it's still underwhelming that the series discarded Ted for a bit to give Mutt and Alexis a fair shot, yet these two barely shared any screentime before calling it quits. Also, the awkward tension between David and Stevie was swept under the rug, with the latter getting nothing to do all season. Meanwhile, Moira joined an acapella group while Johnny... sat around at Bob's garage.

It wasn't until the second half of the season, when the kids both got jobs and Moira campaigned to be elected into council, that things were kicked up a notch. The tension between the Roses and the Schitts always makes for great television, and proved a saving grace in a season that simply didn't provide as many belly laughs as the first one did. Still, we all learned an invaluable lesson: to upload our nude pictures to the Internet before they are lost forever.

Highlights: The raw milk fiasco; David securing his boss a big, fat check; Johnny defending the town in the finale and the entire cast dancing at the barn.


5. Season 1

Schitts Creek Bob
CBC

Schitt's Creek was a slow burner in terms of popularity, so it's easy to overlook just how good the first season was. But from the very first episode it became apparent that this was not your average sitcom. The humour was reminiscent of the best British cringe comedies (thanks to Mayor Roland Schitt always making things awkward), the serialised stories allowed fans to become further invested in the characters (how hot was that romantic triangle that Alexis got into?), and the writing was sharp and punchy, something the series never lost.

Then, of course, there is the cast. In the hands of less capable actors, the Rose family and the town's locals might have never blossomed beyond mere caricatures, but the cast kept them grounded from the get-go, despite the uncanny circumstances their characters found themselves in.

Many shows struggle to find their footing this early on, but Schitt's Creek knew what it was and what it was doing, thanks in no small part to being a passion project for the Levys. The show's best years were yet to come, but the first season was as good a start as anyone could have asked for. Also, admit it: for a while there, you shipped David and Stevie too.

Highlights: Johnny's reaction to the town sign (and Roland's solution); Johnny and Moira's overcrowded tryst at the cabin; the performance of Danny Boy at the funeral; any party David and Alexis attended; and Moira shooting a commercial - "It's fruit wine! What's not to love?"


4. Season 4

Schitts Creek
CBC

Jocelyn got knocked up, but not before a hilarious mix-up in which everyone thought Alexis was the pregnant one. Ted and Alexis got back together, but not before an awkward lunch with Ted's older girlfriend. David and Patrick pursued a successful relationship, but not without Patrick's ex-fiancée dropping in for a surprise visit. And Johnny and Roland became co-workers at the motel, which was as about as trouble-free as you might expect. Schitt's Creek got funnier, soapier and more interesting as the years went on, which is quite the accomplishment for a show that was great from the beginning.

By season 4, the cast of Schitt's Creek is the best it's ever been, with Ted, Patrick and even Twyla becoming full-fledged core characters, and every Rose family member leading an important story, rather than just, you know, hanging about the motel. The only reason it's a mid-tier season is because it came right after one of the show's most memorable years, and because it was building up to bigger, better things. Also, David and Patrick's brief break-up was uncalled for.

Highlights: Patrick's open mic debut, which was simply the best; the Internet declaring Moira dead; Alexis reuniting with that obnoxious friend from her old life; and Johnny becoming a Jazzaguy.


3. Season 6

Schitts Creek David Rose
CBC

Like any TV family, the Roses go through a series of highs and lows. Though the lows far outweight the highs, usually because the characters' egos get in the way of them making better decisions for themselves. So, as the final season reaches a head and every member of the Rose family sees a dream of theirs come true, it feels very earned - the culmination of many years of character development.

In its last year, Schitt's Creek perfected the balance between grounded stories and over-the-top theatrics. Scenarios as simple as Alexis binge-watching old episodes of Moira's TV show or Johnny trying to have 'the talk' with his new son-in-law made for surprisingly entertaining or emotional moments. But the most iconic bits were the most ridiculous ones, such as Moira's movie trailer, Moira's premiere party, Moira's tourism video... okay, anything Moira did.

The one disappointment? The lack of Ted. We are all for Alexis ending the show as a strong, independent woman set on her goals, but it would have been nice to get some semblance of hope for a future with her and Ted reuniting. One can dream.

Highlights: A drugged-up Patrick wanting to have a baby; Roland standing up for Johnny after their pitch; Moira bitch-slapping Victor Garber - sorry, 'Clifton Sparks'; and Alexis in a wedding dress at David and Patrick's wedding.


2. Season 3

Schitts Creek Alexis Johnny
CBC

There's a pre-Patrick Schitt's Creek and there's a post-Patrick Schitt's Creek. The former is enjoyable, feel-good entertainment, designed to make you laugh and unwind. The latter breaks the bounds of comfort viewing to become must-watch television. No matter what else is going on, be it in the series or in the reality around you, from the moment Patrick Brewer is introduced, the very meaning and purpose of humanity becomes intimately linked to (and dependant on) the success of his relationship with David. Yes, Schitt's Creek doubled down on the unrealistic romantic expectations that Disney spoon-fed us by also giving us unrealistic expectations for business partnerships. But we're here for it, and we're never skipping town.

But while we could talk about Patrick all day (seriously - just set a date), season 3 of Schitt's Creek is also one of its best years. Some of the most memorable arcs take place, such as Alexis going back to high school, David opening his apothecary, and Johnny and Stevie joining forces to run the motel. The only duds this season are the other guys that David hooks up with who aren't Patrick. Did we need that filler story with the photographer ex?

Highlights: Moira's car dealership backstory; Johnny waiting tables at Café Tropical; Alexis contracting head lice; the bunny cam; and that first kiss - you know the one.


1. Season 5

Schitts Creek
CBC

In season 5, Schitt's Creek became more of a traditional situation comedy, featuring its characters in a variety of episodic events and settings that strayed from what we were usually shown. For example, Moira shot a film in Bosnia, Johnny and Stevie attended a hospitality awards ceremony, and Patrick convinced David to play on his baseball team.

But the thing that stands out most and makes season five the best of the series' short run is the character growth. Season 5 Alexis is far removed from season 1 Alexis, yet the freshness and sass that made her so compelling to begin with is ever-present. Patrick breaks down David's walls every which way, getting him to embrace positivity in an unprecedented manner. And the biggest breakthrough comes in the dynamics between Stevie and the Rose couple, brought on by her motel venture with Johnny and her inspired casting in Cabaret by 'television's Moira Rose.' The girl behind the counter showed that she had more to offer than blasé customer service and witty retorts; in fact, the Roses unwittingly brought out a humanity and vulnerability in Stevie that set the course for her final arc.

Besides, if this season wasn't the automatic winner from the moment we first saw Moira in her crow get-up, then it sealed the deal with 'I'm a little bit a-la-la-la-la-la-la-la! A little bit Alexis!'

Highlights: The 'robbery' at the apothecary; that saucy spin-the-bottle game; Stevie's big solo; and did we mention A Little Bit Alexis?


Contributor

Renato hails from Portugal but is obsessed with the US and UK charts, because why not? He also writes books with dozens of protagonists and will be remiss if you can't remember every single one of their names.