Sherlock: 6 Reasons It Needs To End (And 4 Reasons It Should Come Back)

Are we still Sherlocked?

Sherlock End Continue
BBC

Sherlock's long-awaited fourth season came to an end in the appropriately titled The Final Problem. As is usual for the show, the finale resulted in one question resting on everyone's lips. This time, it wasn't to do with how Sherlock faked his death or if Moriarty is alive, the question was: is that the end of the show?

As the cast and crew of the series have extensively discussed, they decided to engineer this season as a possible end for the show in the event that it turns out to be the last one. By all accounts, the team's enthusiasm to make more is still there but everyone involved is so busy these days they are not sure they can get back together to do it. In other words, Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin Freeman are contracted for too many Marvel movies.

As it was, the final moments of The Final Problem saw Sherlock and John effectively running off into the sunset - either into the annals of TV history never to be seen again, or into fresh adventures to be shown in season five.

So should Sherlock call it quits? Or is there life in the old detective yet? Let's look at both sides of the argument...


Reasons It Should End...

6. Go Out On Its Own Terms

sherlock final problem
BBC

First of all, Sherlock's phenomenal success means that the production team find themselves in a very lucky position that few TV shows achieve: the decision of whether they continue is totally up to them. Most shows are at the whim of their respective networks (or streaming services) but the BBC have already commissioned a fifth season of Sherlock. It is now up to the cast and crew to decide whether they want to make one.

As such, Sherlock could well take this opportunity to call it a day on its own terms. It is what many of the best TV shows in British history have done, after all. Fawlty Towers and The Office spring to mind as two series that knew to say goodbye after just a handful of episodes, lest they run themselves into the ground.

If Sherlock kept going, perhaps with gaps between the series reaching upwards of four to five years, the appetite for the series might just fade away, leading to an embarrassing decline in interest for the show. That was already hinted at by the lesser ratings this season received in comparison to previous runs. It might be much better, then, to end it while the going is still good after a short but sweet four seasons.


5. Hard To Keep Raising The Scale

Sherlock Watson 221B Baker Street Explosion
BBC

Sherlock might have only had four seasons but each successive run has tried to top the last, resulting in it feeling like there is now nowhere to go but down.

Let's look at the finales, for example. Season one's saw the introduction of Moriarty and the tense cliffhanger of Sherlock and Jim caught in a Mexican stand-off. The second saw Moriarty kill himself and Sherlock return from the grave. The third threw in a massive twist about one of the core characters and then ended on the infamous "Miss Me?" tease.

The fourth, meanwhile, went bigger than ever. The Final Problem raised the game on a personal level higher than ever before, seeing as Sherlock was revealed to have an evil sister who put the characters through some traumatic tests.

How could season five possibly go bigger than that?


4. Sherlock's Character Arc Is Complete

Sherlock Season 4 Finale Benedict Cumberbatch
BBC

Benedict Cumberbatch's Sherlock has undergone quite a dramatic character development over the past four seasons. He began the show as a self-confessed high-functioning sociopath, someone so callous and isolated from humanity that his colleagues on the police force thought him capable of being a serial killer.

Come the end of season four, however, he's a crusading dragon-slayer - someone human enough to offer to kill himself in order to save the life of his brother and best friend, and compassionate enough to offer forgiveness to his murderous misguided sister. In short, he has completed his journey to fully-fledged hero.

So where would the character go next? Showrunners Steven Moffat and Mark Gatiss have said that, looking back, these seasons form 'chapter one' of the usual Sherlock Holmes story and, if the show was to return, Sherlock would be much closer to the wiser, politer detective of Doyle's stories.

Really, though, would that be as interesting as the more volatile, ruder Sherlock we have come to love? Shouldn't the show just call it quits now if the main character has nowhere else to go?


3. Moriarty Really Is Dead

Sherlock Moriarty Miss me
BBC

While it wouldn't be fair to say that he steals the show away from Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin Freeman, Andrew Scott's OTT interpretation of Jim Moriarty is certainly one of the most rabidly beloved elements of the show.

His continuous games with Sherlock made the first two seasons something really special and, ever since his death in The Reichenbach Fall, the show has bent over backwards to find contrived ways to bring the character back. Moriarty became such a core part of the show that it made sense - well, in one way - when he was apparently resurrected from the dead in the season three finale His Last Vow. After years of teasing us, however, it was revealed in The Final Problem that Moriarty really was dead, after all.

With the door closed forever on Moriarty, the show has lost one of its biggest stars. Sure, Sherlock has produced a few other memorable bad guys but they will never be able to step out from under Jim's shadow. Is there point in continuing Sherlock's adventures when he has already defeated his greatest enemy?


2. It's Run Out of Major Material To Adapt

Sherlock Eurus
BBC

As you may well know, Sherlock was born out of Moffat and Gatiss' life-long love of the Sherlock Holmes stories of Arthur Conan Doyle. As such, their show is stuffed to the rafters with callbacks to those novels. In fact, most of the character moments or plot points that they have been praised for are actually just extrapolated from Doyle's work.

So far on the show, for example, we have seen Sherlock meet the one woman who turns his head (Irene Adler), encounter several of Doyle's finest villains, and face the iconic showdown between him and Moriarty (in about three different variations).

In fact, the show has burnt through so many of the major moments from the canon that season four carved out its own path - inventing Sherlock's secret sister and John's baby daughter. Some of these ideas might have featured in prior Holmes adaptations but they are not from Doyle's original stories.

Sherlock has relied so heavily on the work of Doyle, using it as a rough guideline for the development of the show, that it's difficult to imagine it continuing without that.


1. Getting Further And Further Away From Sherlock Holmes

Sherlock Season 4 finale
BBC

You can't have failed to notice that season four of Sherlock was met with a mixed reception from fans. Much was made of the fact that it was promoted as being "action-packed" and "darker" than previous series, rather than the quick-witted detective show that people fell for originally. Many argued that the show was becoming a cross between the style and tempo of a James Bond movie and the complex plotting of Doctor Who.

You don't necessarily have to agree with that point of view, but it's hard to deny that Sherlock is getting further and further from the heart of the Sherlock Holmes legend. That of a brilliant detective solving crimes with the aid of his amazing deductive abilities. Sherlock's powers of detection were heavily sidelined in the latest season in favour of more character-driven, emotionally-charged conflicts that didn't require much use of his mental powers.

Following on from our previous point, if Sherlock is running out of Doyle material to adapt, and in doing so losing that essential Sherlock Holmes feeling, then perhaps it is best if it is put to bed.

Or... maybe not. Let's look at some reasons the show should continue.


Reasons It Should Continue...

4. What About The Supporting Cast?

Sherlock Molly
BBC

I've already made the point that Sherlock's character arc is complete and so there wouldn't be much point in continuing the show if he has nowhere to go on an emotional level. However, that's not to say the rest of the cast have had their story arcs wrapped up. In fact, if Sherlock was to end after season four it would be doing its supporting characters a major disservice.

To be fair, there was clearly some sort of attempt to give at least two of the characters a last hurrah in this season. In The Final Problem, Lestrade harked back to a line he said in the pilot episode when he called Sherlock a "good man." Likewise, Mrs Hudson got some of her best ever moments this season (e.g. that awesome Aston Martin scene).

However, these characters still have a lot more to give to the show. In particular, Molly Hooper really needs some closure for her long-running unrequited love for Sherlock. In The Final Problem, there was a heartbreaking scene where she was forced to admit her feelings. It's a moment that must have torn her apart but the episode offered no resolution for it.

The fans have invested too much time into these characters for them to disappear from our screens without a proper sign-off.


3. John and Sherlock's Relationship Is Now In An Interesting Place

Sherlock Watson
BBC

As much as we would like to see more from the supporting cast, however, an even stronger reason for why Sherlock needs to return is that The Final Problem moved Sherlock and John's friendship into a very interesting avenue that would be fascinating to see explored.

You might recall that John's wife Mary was killed at the beginning of the season, which caused a rift between the two friends. Come the end of the finale, though, we see that the Baker Street boys are now stronger pals than ever and are in fact bringing up John's baby daughter Rosie together.

The idea of Sherlock and John raising a child together while still solving crimes is such a hilarious and touching one that it needs to be explored in future episodes. Given the long gaps between seasons, the show could become like a crime drama version of Seven Up, as we would see Rosie grow up under the strange parenting skills of her two dads in intermittent intervals.


2. Cumberbatch And Freeman Have A Lot More To Give

Sherlock Watson Finale
BBC

When it comes down to it, probably the number one reason why the show is so popular is because of the casting of Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin Freeman.

Yes, let's not write off Moffat and Gatiss' script work, but if they had got the wrong actors to play the leads then Sherlock would have fallen flat on its face. Cumberbatch and Freeman are two of the best British actors of their generation and they inhabit these two iconic roles like very few people have done before. In fact, they are arguably the greatest Holmes-Watson pairing we have ever seen on screen. If they only ever got to portray these characters a measly 13 times, it would be a great tragedy.

In the past, both actors have spoken about how they would love to play these characters for years to come, assuming they could find the time to. Cumberbatch, specifically, has said he would love to take his portrayal of Holmes into his fifties or sixties, so that we might see the detective evolve over his life - just as you do in the original stories.

It's unlikely that the actors have altered their opinion on this so we can assume they are still willing to play these roles for the long-term. So why kill it off now? Sure, it might be a while before the next season arrives, but that'll have to be the price we pay for its continuation. Trust us, Sherlock fans are used to waiting.


1. It Can Now Get Back To Crime Solving

Sherlock A Study In Pink
BBC

Most of our reasons for why Sherlock should end were to do with the show running out of things that would fuel a season of the show. For instance, character arcs and major story developments. While that is true, however, nothing says that Sherlock has to do those things. If Sherlock continued, it could get back to what it is at heart - a detective show.

Think back to the first two seasons. Though there was the looming threat of Moriarty, each episode was pretty standalone. It was only the next two seasons which increased the serialised nature of episodes and reduced the importance of the case-of-the-week. It's no mistake, then, that it is these two recent seasons that have rubbed a lot of fans up the wrong way.

So why not bring the show back in the form of one-off specials every now and again? You could still have the emphasis on Sherlock and John's friendship that has become a firm part of the show, but the mystery would once again be at the core of the story.

What do you think of our points? Do you think Sherlock should end or continue? Let us know in the comments.


In this post: 
Sherlock
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Spewing words on the internet daily. You can also read my stuff at StarburstMagazine.Com, WeGotThisCovered and TheQuiz.Com.