Some Longterm Fans Of Star Trek Are Nervous About Alex Kurtzman - Why, And Is It Fair?

8. Fan Stories Over Actual Stories

Star Trek Elle Fanning
Magnolia Pictures

Another responder said the following:

In my opinion, what Kurtzman is doing is writing slash fiction and trying to pass it off as Trek. I've seen better writing in fanzines.

The attached image is from the wonderful film Please Stand By, starring Elle Fanning, Alice Eve and Patton Oswalt. The story revolves around a young writer with autism whose attempting to submit her fan-script for an episode of Star Trek.

If we are to imagine this as Alex Kurtzman, then we can imagine someone with a lot of passion for what they do, attempting to get their vision across! In the recent Star Trek Day celebrations, Kurtzman, along with Michelle Paradise, spoke to their involvement with Star Trek throughout their tenure. There is very clearly a lot of passion there, yet also there is evidently a lot of research having been done as well.

Ahead of the release of Star Trek in 2009, JJ Abrams spoke openly about how he had not been a Trekkie ahead of making this film. That is not a sense that comes from Kurtzman. In various interviews in the last few years, he has spoken about the wish and concern to adhere to canon while creating something new.

This criticism seems to fit Star Trek: Picard the most, as the show is a very different depiction of the seminal Starfleet Captain.

In this post: 
Star Trek
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Seán is the host and head writer/presenter for TrekCulture, as well as a writer/presenter on WhoCulture and WhatCulture Horror. He has authored two novels, dozens of short stories, and hundreds of articles for WhatCulture. He holds a Master of Arts in Creative Writing from University College Dublin. As part of his work with TrekCulture, Seán has been invited to participate in collaborations with Roddenberry Entertainment, as well as contributing to several Star Trek community projects. An avid fan of Star Trek, Doctor Who, and the horror genre at large, Seán's expertise has helped develop these channels to the successes they are today. As host of the Ups & Downs series on TrekCulture, Seán has become internationally recognised for his positive yet critically informed approach to reviewing every episode of modern Star Trek, ensuring he is one of the go-to voices in the Trek community. Favourite Quote to describe himself: "I'm serious about what I do, just not always about the way that I do it"