Star Trek: 10 WORST Things Captain Picard Has Ever Done

He may be Star Trek's top diplomat, but Captain Picard has a fair few skeletons in his closet - we're here to set them free

Star Trek TNG Next Generation Preemptive Strike Picard
CBS Media Ventures

As fans of a property, and especially a property such as Star Trek, we are used to seeing the best sides of the heroic characters. These are the people who guide us through the world of space exploration, political intrigue, military tactics, and the great beyond of the mind. We invest rather a lot in them, gambling that they won’t let us down.

When does a hero lose their status? 

Captain, later Admiral, Jean-Luc Picard is often held as an example of how to manage everything correctly, while still running a starship. He commanded the Stargazer, the Enterprises D and E, and would command the entire Romulan evacuation programme, usually with a deft hand. There were mistakes along the way of course. No commander alive has ever been truly perfect and those who claim that they are are lying. 

What qualifies for a list of ‘worst things’ for Captain Picard? Are they overt actions of nefarious intent? Or do they hit a little bit different for the consummate diplomat? Picard is a name that commands respect, but what of those times that it doesn’t? When does following orders become a hollow excuse for inaction? And what of those officers under him that faced his wrath or, worse, his indifference?

10. Let A Planet Die

Star Trek The Next Generation Homeward
CBS Media Ventures

Boraal II was facing an extinction level event by the seventh season episode of The Next Generation, Homeward. As Captain of the Enterprise-D, Picard was tasked with monitoring the event. Monitoring, but not interfering. Boraal II contained a pre-warp civilisation, fully sentient and intelligent, save for their lack of space travel capability.

For this ‘crime’, they fell under the boot of the Prime Directive. 

Officially, Starfleet could intervene to save them, but they chose not to. Then-Lt. Worf’s brother, Nickolai, was on the planet’s surface as the disaster approached. He was working undercover, so as not to arouse suspicions, and came to deeply care for these people. Upon meeting with Picard, he pled with the man to help save these people, whatever the cost. Picard, stalwart to duty, refused. 

Though Nickolai’s actions following this refusal led to the salvation of that race, Picard’s decision to uphold the Prime Directive would haunt him for years to come. It is fair to say that his decision to help the Baku stemmed directly from this incident, and perhaps the guilt of knowing he had chosen to save Sarjenka years before.


9. Repeatedly Shut Down Worf

Star Trek The Next Generation Cause And Effect Worf And Picard
CBS Media Ventures

This occurred so often that there are video compilations online showcasing the sheer number of times that Picard shut down his chief of security. Though most of these clips are played for comedy, there is something a little more damning in them. As a department head, Worf should be a trusted member of the crew. Instead, more often than not, he is told to be quiet by his captain. 

While Picard didn’t use that exact terminology (in this case) the message couldn’t be clearer. With the sheer number of times that Worf is told no, to wait, to hold, that Picard disagrees, that he feels Worf has suggested the wrong course of action - it could do nothing but leave an impression on the officer. This impression clearly weighed on the Klingon when he took up his post on Deep Space Nine and the Defiant. 

Worf quickly gained a reputation as somewhat inflexible, not least when he butted heads with Odo about how best to run security on the station. As Deep Space Nine was run very differently from the Enterprise, one could hardly blame the man for ending up in a tailspin. Though Picard almost definitely had no ill intent in constantly belittling his security chief, these are the moments that stick with a person in the years that follow.


8. Refused To Step Down When Clearly Compromised

Star Trek First Contact Picard On The Bridge
Paramount Pictures

Star Trek: First Contact is an example where technically everybody in this situation was right and everybody was wrong. Starfleet got the ball rolling here by ordering the Enterprise-E to the Romulan Neutral Zone when the Borg decided to invade again, swiftly removing Picard from the battle. To Starfleet’s credit, an army of counsellors was probably advising them against having him near the fight. Could a former drone be trusted? 

At the same time, surely there were some security minded admirals crying out for his expertise. The counsellors would be proven correct when, after mere moments of hearing the battle over subspace, Picard orders the Enterprise to Earth, disobeying his commands. When they arrive, they make swift work of the Cube, though the events that follow do little to improve the man’s standing. 

Trauma, and particularly PTSD, are conditions that are still very much being studied thirty years after the script for First Contact was written but the film quite accurately portrayed the way they compromise judgement. As the audience, we can see that there are clear warnings that Picard is not ok. However he continues to command the ship. The argument that the ends justify the means, that the ship is saved and the Borg are defeated, will come as little comfort to those officers who were assimilated while under orders to stand their ground. 

Though it takes a few hard truths from both Worf and Lily Sloane to get through to him, Picard does have the wisdom to finally back down, proving that he has not been totally controlled by his emotions.


7. Had A Relationship With A Subordinate

Star Trek The Next Generation Lessons Nella Darren
CBS Media Ventures

When Nella Daren raised the lights in stellar cartography, sparks began to fly almost at once. Captain Picard had so rarely allowed himself the room to explore a romantic engagement with anyone, so this was something that could have been good for both of them. Alas, as it quickly became evident, their positions went against them.

As the Captain of a Starship, Picard was responsible for everyone under his command. Therefore, it was his duty to attempt to remain impartial and somewhat removed. Part of the test to become a full commander was to see if said commander could order an officer to their deaths. How, then, could a captain order someone they were involved with on a dangerous mission? While the pair began to develop their feelings for each other, the news quickly spread. Some were happy for them, such as Beverly. 

Some felt less than comfortable, such as Riker. As First Officer, he was tasked with managing all of the departments. So, when Daren came to him and even suggested that the Captain would hear her if he didn’t, the first obvious example of the problem rose its head. That is not to suggest that Daren would habitually abuse their relationship but rather that there were certain assumptions that came with having the captain’s ear. While that situation was quickly resolved, there followed the dangerous mission with the fire storms. 

Picard had to order Daren to hold her position, an order that could have resulted in her death, though she thankfully survived. It became apparent that the Captain of a Starship could not maintain an impartial relationship with his officers while also maintaining a romantic relationship with one as well. Though neither are truly to blame for this, Daren then transferred off the ship, losing an excellent career opportunity in the process.


6. Demeaning Wesley On The Bridge For All To See

Star Trek The Next Generation The Battle Wesley Crusher
CBS Media Ventures

This is one of the stranger events in Picard’s list. Though he was self-admittedly terrible with children, he was well aware of who Wesley was, having known Beverly for years. He brought the body of Jack Crusher home to the family, so young person though he was, Wesley was no simple stranger. 

With that, is that why Picard felt in a position to tell him to shut up in front of the entire bridge crew? During the show’s first season, Wesley slowly earned a place on the bridge, usually by showcasing some new innovation that endeared him to the officers, while admittedly giving audiences pause. However, despite his brash child’s nature, he became the butt of the joke.

Picard, displaying a short temper that rarely came to the surface, barked at him to shut up, loud, in front of his mother. Wesley was almost immediately cowed. Unfortunately, the script decided to make the scene into a joke, as Crusher quickly defends, then also shuts him down. It is one of the least Picard-like moments of the character on-screen, even if it did come so early in The Next Generation.


5. Abandoned Elnor

Star Trek Picard Absolute Candor Picard Leaves Vashti
CBS Media Ventures

It would be easy to say that no one could have predicted the events of First Contact Day in 2385. Certainly, reprogramming all of the A-500 synths to destroy the Utopia Planitia Shipyards was perhaps out of bounds of belief, but when one considers the events depicted in The Last Best Hope by Dr. Una McCormack, the warning signs were all there. 

First, there were many both within the Federation and indeed the Romulan Empire who weren’t happy that the two great powers were working together. Then, there were those Romulans who flatly refused to do anything, even as more and more evidence piled in around them that the supernova was imminent. Before the attack took place, only one world had successfully rehomed Romulan Refugees - Vashti.

There, the Qowot Milat, an order of Romulan nuns who practiced absolute candor, took up residence. They adopted a young boy, Elnor, and trained him in their ways. Picard came to love the boy, frequently visiting, and bringing gifts. They had what promised to be a father-son relationship until the synth attack levelled Mars, and Picard was recalled to Earth. While the events that followed that will be discussed in another entry here, one of the worst things that Picard did, pained as he was, was never going back for Elnor, leaving the boy wondering what it was that he had done wrong. When they eventually reunited, it was clear that the damage had been done, though Picard worked to repair what he could.


4. Resigned As A Matter Of Pride

Star Trek Picard The End Is the Beginning Raffi Picard
CBS Media Ventures

In the wake of the Mars attack, Starfleet made the decision to immediately halt the Romulan rescue mission. Their entire rescue armada of Wallenberg-class ships had been destroyed, with Starfleet going from one of the greatest powers in the Quadrant to one that was now seriously resource depleted. Admiral Jellico informed Picard that the mission needed to be scrubbed. As it transpired, Jellico went to Picard first, out of courtesy

Despite their less than friendly history, there was no malice in Jellico’s orders, as was clearly shown when he addressed the rest of the Admiralty, Janeway included. That’s where Picard’s fatal flaw became truly apparent. When informed of the mission’s ending, Janeway immediately set about establishing a pilot program, using the Protostar experiment, to make sure that the quadrant knew that Starfleet was still about exploration and advancement. In contrast, when informed of that same order, Picard immediately threatened his resignation in protest. To his very great surprise, it was accepted

This was something he hadn’t dreamed of, as he couldn’t envision a situation where he wasn’t a member of Starfleet. In the heat of the moment, tempers flare. However, when cooler heads prevailed, he very easily could have returned to service and worked with Starfleet, rather than against them. For better or worse, he chose not to.


3. Abandoned Laris

Star Trek Picard The Next Generation Picard And Laris
CBS Media Ventures

In the second season of Star Trek: Picard, it was revealed that Zhaban, one of the two former Tal Shiar agents who elected to live and work with Picard in the years following the supernova, had died. While the show barely lingered on this information for a moment, it effectively set the scene for Picard and Laris to begin a romantic engagement. It was a bit stop-start, but by the season’s closing, it was clear that they were intent on making a go of things.

The third season then revealed that Picard was finally leaving France and moving to Chalnok IV, at long last accepting his retirement, ready to settle down with Laris. Although, that isn’t exactly what happened in the end. While they parted amicably, with the promise that Picard would join Laris once his current crisis was averted, there was something quite knowing in how she accepted this. It would be the last time that Laris was seen on-screen.

We don’t want to be too harsh on Picard here. Beverly Crusher was calling and she badly needed his help. This was more than just ‘one last adventure’ as this was family - even if at that point he didn’t know how true that was. The true issue here is how quickly he elected to leave Laris and run back to his old life. He then doesn’t mention her again, nor do any of his actions suggest he has returned to Chalnok to see her.


2. Held A Pointless Grudge For Thirty Years

Star Trek Picard Imposters Ro Laren And Picard
CBS Media Ventures

Hindsight is a wonderful thing, but so is having the wisdom and knowledge of a person’s intent. Ro Laren was someone who Picard knew very well, so her defection to the Maquis shouldn’t have come as big of a shock as it was, nor as the betrayal he inferred it to be. Being fair to Picard, one can be single minded when in the mission, so much so that it’s hard to see the wood for the trees.

He was, however, more concerned with the mission than the person undertaking it. Ro was clearly affected by the plight of the settlers in the Demilitarised Zone, and tried to tell him as much. He responded as a captain, not a confident. This would come back to haunt him. Thirty years would pass before he would encounter Ro again. She thankfully elected to return to Starfleet before the Dominion alliance with the Cardassion Union, which definitely saved her life. 

There, she served her time, then worked her way back up the ranks once more. She confronted him on the Titan-A, as even after all that time, it was the pain between them both that proved they were who they said they were. In those few moments they had together, they both saw the futility of the grudge that had kept them apart. If we strictly judge by what we saw on screen, then this would be the last time that they would interact. It may have been too little, too late - but it was something at least.


1. After Defending Data’s Rights As A Sentient Being, Opposes His Right To Procreate

Star Trek The Next Generation The Offspring Picard And Lal
CBS Media Ventures

Though we know that Picard did, in fact, do the right thing in the end here, The Offspring shows a surprising side to him. Consider the episode The Measure Of A Man, where Picard passionately advocates for Data’s right to be treated as any other sentient officer in the fleet, winning the day with his speech. 

One would think, then, that he would never question Data’s right to autonomy, yet when Data returns to the ship with Lal, Picard is aghast. The argument is presented, initially, that Picard doesn’t truly believe Data understands the enormity of his actions in creating Lal. Data responds, emotionless as he is, that all he has done was father a child - something that anyone aboard the ship would have the right to do, without needing the permission of their Captain, or Starfleet. 

Picard continues his position, but is quickly swayed. Perhaps it is best to view this event as a minor slip, or an example of old prejudices popping back up without warning. We all, conscious or not, have them. It is our lot in life to attempt to grow beyond them. Picard certainly did, even if it was a rocky road to get there.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Star Trek
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Seán is the host and head writer/presenter for TrekCulture, as well as a writer/presenter on WhoCulture and WhatCulture Horror. He has authored two novels, dozens of short stories, and hundreds of articles for WhatCulture. He holds a Master of Arts in Creative Writing from University College Dublin. As part of his work with TrekCulture, Seán has been invited to participate in collaborations with Roddenberry Entertainment, as well as contributing to several Star Trek community projects. An avid fan of Star Trek, Doctor Who, and the horror genre at large, Seán's expertise has helped develop these channels to the successes they are today. As host of the Ups & Downs series on TrekCulture, Seán has become internationally recognised for his positive yet critically informed approach to reviewing every episode of modern Star Trek, ensuring he is one of the go-to voices in the Trek community. Favourite Quote to describe himself: "I'm serious about what I do, just not always about the way that I do it"