Star Trek: 12 Subplots That Went Nowhere
A few of the times Star Trek flew right past the fireworks factory.
Star Trek is generally considered a traditionally episodic franchise simply owing to its genesis in the years before serialized storytelling.
Still, the writers and producers were able to sneak continuing arcs and subplots into the various spinoffs and series with greater frequency as the franchise aged and we are now in the era of the ten hour movie-style structure of Star Trek: Picard.
We can point to the Klingon Civil War, the Dominion War, the Kazon's pursuit of Voyager, and the Red Angel storyline as successful ongoing plots, but there are a few subplots and arcs that Star Trek has either failed to deliver on, outright forgotten, or mercilessly jettisoned.
Here are a dozen Star Trek subplots that boldly went nowhere.
12. Worf And Troi
The romance between Star Trek: The Next Generation's Lieutenant Worf and Counselor Deanna Troi was a major plot point in TNG's final season, in the episodes "Parallels", "Eye of the Beholder", and "All Good Things..." But the flirtation dated back as far as season five when the writers saw that a Worf / Troi pairing worked in the episode "Ethics".
What followed were an alternate-timeline marriage and a hallucinatory hookup before the two finally made it real and official in the series finale – which also diverted into an alternate timeline in which Troi was dead and Worf never got over his lost love.
But while the series finale of TNG began with an almost kiss, the next time audiences saw Worf and Troi in Star Trek Generations, the two about-to-be-former Enterprise-D officers had apparently split up offscreen in the intervening months.
By the time of Worf's arrival on Star Trek: Deep Space Nine and his eventual marriage to Lieutenant Jadzia Dax a couple years later, the Worf / Troi thing wasn't mentioned. Star Trek: Insurrection featured a subtle nod to the pairing when Troi finally reignited her fling with Commander Riker and Worf grudgingly observed that they'd always had feelings for one another. But calling that an acknowledgement of Worf's own romance with Troi is kind of a stretch.
For her part, Marina Sirtis aka Troi didn't like the pairing, saying that it hurt Worf's character. And while Michael Dorn seemed okay with it, Imzadi himself, Jonathan Frakes, called it "ridiculous". The writers seemed to agree it was a failed experiment and the Worf / Troi romance subplot was never mentioned again. Troi wasn't even invited to the wedding.
11. The XBs
Star Trek: Picard spent an inordinate amount of its first season cutting away from Picard himself to Soji and Narek's "romance" aboard the Artifact. The setting itself was promising... a derelict Borg cube under the command of a shattered Romulan state, full of former drones or XBs, including "I, Borg" himself, Hugh.
Sadly, much of that promise was ancillary to the plot and while Star Trek: Picard centered around Picard (a former drone) and also featured Seven of Nine (the most famous of all the ex-Borgs), the XBs themselves didn't seem to really have much to do in the first season.
Aside from their inclusion in the Artifact-centric episode "The Impossible Box", the ex-Borg drones' promise as a reflection of both Picard and Seven's past, as well as a new take on a legacy Star Trek villain, and their peripheral relationship with the overarching plot revolving around artificial life, the XBs were sadly wasted. And even after Seven lead the XBs in a mini-revolt against Narissa and the Romulans, they disappeared entirely before the end of the season, crashed on Coppelius but... who knows?
Deleted scenes from "Et in Arcadia Ego, Part II" apparently depicted Ramdha and the other XBs going on to live a life of peace with Altan Soong and his hippie android children, but those scenes and any reference to them were sadly omitted from the episode as aired.
10. The Phage
Along with the Kazon, the Vidiians were positioned early on to be Star Trek: Voyager's main antagonists in the Delta Quadrant. The Vidiians were disgusting, devious, hellbent on stealing the organs of innocent starship crews to save themselves from the Phage, a disease killing thousands of their race. Like all good Trek villains though, the Vidiians weren't evil, they were multi-faceted, occasionally even sympathetic (as in "Lifesigns" when the Doctor fell in love with a Vidiian doctor, Danara Pel, who saved Captain Janeway and Commander Chakotay from sexy social distancing a few episodes later).
But unlike the Kazon, whose story arc gradually built and was fully resolved by the end of Voyager's second season, the Vidiians never really got the compelling story or climax they deserved.
Voyager simply flew out of range of the Vidiians' organ foraging and the aliens were mostly forgotten for two full seasons until the show washed its hand of them entirely in season five's "Think Tank". That episode explained that the titular Think Tank had cured the Phage, fully resolving the Vidiaans' entire raison d'être and doing it entirely off screen.
9. The Klingons Are Coming
After being omitted from the final cut of Star Trek (2009), the Klingons finally made their Kelvin Timeline debut in JJ Abrams' follow up, Star Trek Into Darkness. Not only did the Klingons make their rebooted debut in Into Darkness, a conflict with the warrior race was explicitly teased in the film by the fear mongering Admiral Marcus.
According to Marcus, war with the Klingons was inevitable, and while Khan made quick work of several Birds-of-Prey-worth of the redesigned baddies, the film not-so-subtly left the impression that the Klingons would be coming for revenge.
Following the release of Star Trek Into Darkness, co-writer Damon Lindelof even teased that the Klingons would be back, saying "there's a promise that there's a larger conflict on the horizon, and that would be fun to see."
But the third Kelvin Timeline installment was heavily reworked and Lindelof departed for Tomorrowland and The Leftovers. Justin Lin's Star Trek Beyond went on to feature no Klingons with even a cameo appearance on the planet Altamid cut before shooting.
The larger conflict with the Klingons, hinted at in Star Trek (2009) and made a major story point in Star Trek Into Darkness, ultimately went unmentioned and unfulfilled in Star Trek Beyond and with no future Kelvin Timelines in sight, it would appear that Admiral Marcus' war wasn't so inevitable after all.
8. Sela
Ah Sela, problematic offspring of "concubine" Tasha Yar and a Romulan general – Denise Crosby's half-Romulan, all sideburns antagonist never got the storyline or sendoff she truly deserved.
Yes, Sela was the mastermind of the Klingon Civil War as hinted at in "The Mind's Eye" and ultimately dramatized in the "Redemption" arc, but Sela's true story began a season prior in "Yesterday's Enterprise", when her mother traveled back in time and was captured by the Romulans. We learned of Tasha's fate and the origin of Sela in "Redemption", but the character's past and her connection to the crew of the USS Enterprise-D was never fully explored in just four appearances in Star Trek: The Next Generation.
There's no evidence the producers had any intention of fully fleshing out Sela's character following her stock villain turn in "Unification II", but she was a character fans expected to return, even as late as 2002's Romulan-centered Star Trek Nemesis.
With "Yesterday's Enterprise" being among the franchise's most beloved episodes and the revelation of her past in "Redemption" left dangling, Sela represented a huge well of story potential that was bafflingly forgotten by the producers.
7. Thomas Riker
While Thomas Riker could've been relegated to a single appearance in Star Trek: The Next Generation's "Second Chances" and still been one of TNG's most intriguing "guest" characters, the producers rightly saw that he was a good fit for Star Trek: Deep Space Nine's rougher around the edges tone and brought the Riker double back for "Defiant".
"Defiant" continued Tom's arc established in TNG, showing him chafing against his role as a the "second" Riker and hooking up with a band of Maquis for a suicide mission to destroy a secret Obsidian Order fleet. The episode concluded with Tom hauled off to Cardassian prison but with a kiss and a promise from Major Kira that they would meet again.
And then they never did... and Thomas Riker presumably spent the rest of DS9 in a Cardassian labor camp (or worse), not withstanding his frequent reappearances in non-canon Star Trek lit.
It's still not clear why DS9 chose not to follow up on its own explicit promise to rescue the character, but Thomas Riker was included in internal materials from the producers as a topic the writers were absolutely not interested in revisiting. Apparently the Star Trek Universe just wasn't ready for two Rikers.
6. The Warp Speed Limit
Star Trek: The Next Generation's episode "Force of Nature" was a forgettable, but well-intentioned effort by the writing staff to tackle an ecological issue and end the story with lasting consequences. The seventh season episode revealed that warp drive was threatening the very fabric of space and concluded with Starfleet enacting a warp speed limit to help mitigate the environmental damage.
The warp speed limit subplot certainly had the potential to shake up franchise's status quo, but writer Brannon Braga rightly concluded that "when you limit warp drive, the rug is being pulled out from under Star Trek" and the storyline was thankfully dropped. The warp speed limit would go on to be mentioned in two more episodes following "Force of Nature" ("The Pegasus" and "Eye of the Beholder"), both times in order to give the Enterprise-D permission to exceed that limit, and then never talked about again.
While behind the scenes material indicated the variable geometry warp engines employed by the USS Voyager in Star Trek: Voyager were intended to counteract the issues raised in "Force of Nature", this was never spoken on screen and never accounted for in Star Trek: Deep Space Nine or the TNG movies.
5. Bajor's Federation Membership
Deep Space Nine was the pinnacle of serialized Star Trek storytelling with very few of its major threads or subplots going unresolved in the show's seven season run.
While the show is famous for the Dominion War arc and, to a lesser extent, its handling of the Maquis, the primary focus of Deep Space Nine's first few seasons was Bajor and Sisko's mission to bring the Bajorans into the United Federation of Planets. This directive was clearly stated by Captain Picard in the pilot episode, "Emissary", when he told then Commander Sisko his orders were "to do everything short of violating the Prime Directive" to ensure Bajor would be ready to enter the Federation.
This goal was nearly achieved too, in the fifth season episode "Rapture", but, as the coming war with the Dominion manifested itself as visions of locusts over Bajor, Sisko persuaded the Council of Ministers to delay membership. The issue was flirted with off and on a few times, but Bajor's independence became a major plot point by the end of season five and early in season six.
The Dominion War became Deep Space Nine's driving storyline in its final two season and Bajor's Federation membership fell by the wayside.
According to writer Hans Beimler: "It wasn't an oversight. The question was, does that really matter? Ultimately it doesn't really mean that much."
4. The Borg Resistance
Following the introduction of Seven of Nine in "Scorpion, Part II", battling the Borg became a major recurring storyline in Star Trek: Voyager.
While Captain Janeway and the crew found at least half a dozen new and action-packed ways to defeat their cybernetic foes, a major blow was dealt to the Collective in the two-part episode "Unimatrix Zero". In that episode, a cabal of virtually-linked drones were freed and began a resistance moment (errr resistance-is-futile movement).
By the end of the seventh season premiere, members of Unimatrix Zero had a fleet of liberated Borg vessels at their disposal and were positioned to be a novel and exciting way for StarTrek: Voyager to conclude its ongoing Borg storyline.
But while Voyager went on to encounter the Borg twice more, Unimatrix Zero and its XB freedom fighters were never heard from again. All the promise of bringing the Borg down from within was forgotten and Captain Janeway was forced to come up with yet another way to (momentarily) defeat the Borg once and for all in "Endgame", with no mention of Unimatrix Zero.
3. The Klingon War
This one might actually more accurately be described as a "main plot that went nowhere"...
When it premiered, Star Trek: Discovery was ostensibly about what happens when you put do-gooding Starfleet scientists in the uncomfortable position of fighting a brutal war against an implacable foe. Indeed, much of the first half of Discovery's premiere season focused on getting the USS Discovery's spore drive up and running to give Starfleet the edge against the Klingons and win the war.
The show vacillated between telling us the Klingons were winning and telling us the Federation was winning the war, and then it shunted Disco off to the Mirror Universe for half a season. By the time the crew returned, the war was basically lost as was all hope.
Two additional episodes were doled out at the season's end to wrap things up and while the Klingon-Federation War was hyped to be a near-unwindable conflict, the industrious crew of the Discovery ended the war by throwing a bomb down a chute on Qo'noS.
The two episodes that quickly concluded the Klingon War were, in reality, added to the series order by CBS possibly indicating the producers intended to continue the plot into Star Trek: Discovery's second season. With two additional episodes added to the schedule, the show found a quick way to wrap things up and move on to greener pastures with the Red Angel and nobody complained.
2. Son Of Son Of Mogh
Not to pick on Lieutenant Worf's personal life, but truly the recurring thread of Worf's bad parental skills was apparently as uninteresting to the writers as it was the audience. Alexander Rozhenko cropped up in eight episodes of Star Trek: The Next Generation and four of Star Trek: Deep Space Nine and neither show found a compelling story for the poor kid.
The producers were so disinterested in the continuing Alexander storyline, writer Joe Menosky wrote the premise of DS9's "Time's Orphan" during his time on TNG in the hopes of killing off the ¾ Klingon / ¼ human child. While producer Michael Pillar nixed the idea of killing Alexander, the episode was ultimately repurposed as a Molly O'Brien vehicle and Alexander continued to make occasional appearances in the franchise between long bouts of Worf seemingly pretending to not even have a son.
Alexander's time on Star Trek: The Next Generation was mostly spent being pawned off on Worf's adoptive parents, but the storyline resurfaced periodically to remind us that Worf was not a great parent and that "the higher, the fewer" is a terrible motto that still makes no sense. His (recast) guest spots on Deep Space Nine were slightly more tolerable, but the writers' and audience's distaste for the character seemingly manifested in Alexander's storyline which only served to make him look stupid before he just sort of disappeared again, this time for good.
1. The Temporal Cold War
Included in the series at the behest of the United Paramount Network (aka UPN), the Temporal Cold War arc cropped up in twelve episodes throughout Star Trek: Enterprise's first three seasons, before being abruptly concluded in the fourth season premiere, "Storm Front, Part II".
That decision was made by freshly installed showrunner Manny Coto who stated he believed Enterprise relied too heavily on time travel in its earlier seasons and that "everything that had been said about the Temporal Cold War had already been said." The final appearance of Silik and Daniels in "Storm Front, Part II" was a resolution of sorts, with lip service being paid to the Temporal Cold War ending and the timeline being repaired by Archer the crew of the NX-01, but questions still remained.
And, more importantly, more stories remained, if only to tell us what was even going on in the Temporal Cold War. What was up the Suliban? Who was the mysterious Future Guy?
Again, non-canon Star Trek literature has since filled in the gaps and co-creator Brannon Braga has since outlined his belief that Archer was the one calling the shots, but the Temporal Cold War subplot fizzled before it got hot.