Star Trek: Deep Space Nine - Ranking Every Major Character Worst To Best
Space Stations really do have a huge cast of characters! Ranked from worst to best, here are DS9's.
Deep Space Nine boasted an enormous supporting cast, more than any of the other franchises in terms of the characters' popularity and appearances. As such, ranking them was going to be a tall order.
That said, some of the characters on this show simply lend themselves to high rankings due to the consistantly excellent writing that was on display across the seasons.
Whether it was Kira's search for her place in the new order to Nog's growth and trauma, or Sisko's struggle to reconcile his place in the Bajoran religion - these characters had arcs very different from the other entries in the franchise.
Unsurprisingly, and thankfully in terms of entertainment, there were excellent villains to pick from as well. Deep Space Nine had arguably, after perhaps the Borg, the greatest villains in the franchise (a certain genetically engineered tyrant notwithstanding). It was also the first entry to truly present an interstellar war, something which opened the playing field even wider for more characters to turn up.
Not every character on the show worked. Not every one of them settled into the swing of things quite as well as some of the others. Some were largely forgotten as the story lines went in other directions. This is true of any series, though perhaps on Deep Space Nine it is forgivable due to the sheer size of the cast.
With that in mind, starting at the bottom, we have...
27. Vedek Bareil
Poor Bareil Antos. He really did care about the Prophets and about Bajor. So much so, that he stood aside and let a monster take over. Well played, Bareil. Well played.
Taking the fall for Kai Opaka, he was forced to step down from the running to be the next Kai, clearing the path for Winn Adami to take the top job. Considering what she nearly brought about for Bajor, this was most certainly not the best decision.
His political failings aside, Bareil also never quite seemed to be the right fit as Major Kira's love interest. There was little to no chemistry between them and his peaceful manner seemed at odds with Kira's short fuse. However, his eventual death left a wound in her that would last for some time to come.
Potentially not that much time though, as later that season she would begin a relationship with Shakaar.
Vedek Bareil seems to have been conceived as something of a 'cool priest' character. While Philip Anglim did the best that he could with that, there was very little room to navigate those restraints. When he returned in the sixth season as Bareil's mirror universe counterpart, he was able to have a little bit more fun with him - yet even that episode ranks as one of the weakest of that season.
Poor Bareil. Go with the Prophets. And stay there.
26. Torah Ziyal
There were three different incarnations of Toyah Ziyal between seasons four and six. The first, appearing in Indiscretion, was played by Cyia Batten. Later, she would be played by Tracy Middendorf in For The Cause and then finally by Melanie Smith for the remainder of her appearances.
Ziyal was a character who certainly had promise, in that she could have been an excellent foil for Gul Dukat and, initially, things looked to be heading in that direction. His acknowledgement of her led to his temporary fall from grace. However, he would then effectively abandon her to be cared for by Kira on the station.
Ziyal and Garak began a relationship, much to the chagrin of Dukat. Yet even after the fall of Deep Space Nine to the Dominion, Ziyal acts in a somewhat aloof manner, opting to give her father the cold shoulder for a short time, completely oblivious to the situation around her.
Once Kira finally does manage to make her see, she agrees to help spring her friends from prison. This one moment of character growth is cut short by Damar, shooting her in cold blood.
Unfortunately, Ziyal was never truly interesting enough for the audience to feel the weight that the script was putting on her. Dukat's utter breakdown at her death does not feel earned. Arguably, the show would have been better suited if she had stayed with the Breen.
25. The Female Shapeshifter
Salome Jens is both cool and evil in this role. Appearing in The Search to Odo, she at first seems to be genuinely interested in him for the most peaceful reasons. Much like a treasured and lost family member, she invites him to return to the fold.
The fact that she's a warlord complicates matters.
Her ranking here is in no way a reflection of Jens' portrayal of her, rather it is the opposite. She is so hateful and dark that there was little other option than to have her here. Her crimes are multitude, not least of which being the attempted extermination of the entire Cardassian population. This is one changeling you do not mess with.
Her nature as part of the Great Link forms both the crux of her deep connection to Odo and, ironically, one of the most frustrating moments from What You Leave Behind. Odo links with her to cure her and, in doing so, convinces her to stand down and surrender to the Federation Alliance.
While this should be a cathartic moment of victory for the good guys, dramatically, it is just a little bit rushed. What You Leave Behind, due to completely fair budget reasons, re-used several older CG shots in the final battles, so to have another moment that felt a tiny bit rushed was just a little disappointing.
24. Kai Winn
Winn Adami is just the worst type of person that anyone would ever want to meet. Wrapped head to toe in righteous indignation, she glides through other peoples' lives, ruining them whenever she could.
That smile, that self-assurance, that contempt. It is the perfect combination for such a teeth-grindingly annoying person. And then she becomes the spiritual leader of Bajor, meaning there's no getting rid of her!
Seeing her face off against Kira was always something that set nerves on edges. There were few moments when the two of them were able to find some common ground and, even when they did, Winn always managed to find a way to ruin it. She was able to win most of these arguments due to her position, knowing that Kira's deep respect in their religion would keep her at bay.
She interferes with the supposed Reckoning, a final battle between good and evil that is to be played out on the promenade. In doing so, she sets in motion a chain of events that not only leads to the death of Jadzia Dax and the loss of the Celestial Temple, but also very nearly the death of Ben Sisko as well.
Her final comeuppance in the Fire Caves is both understated and perfect, winked out of existence by a cold question from the Pah-Wraith possessed Dukat: 'Are you still here?'
Gone, and hopefully, forgotten.
23. Leeta
Leeta is one of the nicest and most upbeat characters on the station. She initially appears as a dabo girl, working in Quark's bar and treating all of the guests to a fun and relaxed atmosphere. Long before she ever truly found the love of her life, she and Dr. Bashir both engaged in, and amicably ended, a short but passionate affair.
Few then could have suspected that her heart would actually belong to Rom!
The ultimate odd couple, they finally professed their love for each other just as Leeta was about to be whisked away by Dr. Lewis Zimmerman. Rom, terrified that the only woman for him was about to leave forever, runs through the corridors of the station, begging her to stay. Not only does she do so, but they are married a few mere episodes later.
In a show as dark as Deep Space Nine, Chase Masterson's Leeta was a bright spot on what could be very cloudy days. Few viewers could fail to watch her interactions with Rom and not feel moved. When she tries to rescue him from the Dominion, only to be arrested by Damar, the first thing that she does on her escape is run to Rom and kiss him.
Though this review may not say much, it also says everything. Leeta was just....she was just nice!
22. Vic Fontaine
Vic Fontaine, played by James Darren, was something of a love him or hate him character. He appeared late into the show's sixth season, standing out straight away as a lounge singer who knows he's a hologram in a far off space station. His first task on the show is to set up Odo and Kira, something he manages where no one else had succeeded.
His sporadic appearances over the next season would allow for little mini-breaks in the action, offering just a few moments of lightness in the dark. His two greatest appearances both fall in season seven.
The first, pictured above, concerns his attempts to help Nog recover from the trauma of losing his leg. For a time, Vic falls into Nog's fantasy of expanding the lounge and living a fuller life, before realising he is just enabling Nog's own fears. He guides the young Ferengi through the pain of re-adjusting to real life.
His second triumph comes after his battle against Frankie-Eyes, the mobster-turned-hotel owner. Vic is tossed out on his backside, leading to one of the most fun episodes of the entire series. The main crew, dressed in black tie and ready to play, take on the casino and save the day.
While the character of Vic may not have worked for some viewers, Darren injects him with such life and vigour that it is hard not to hum along with him when he belts out a classic.
21. Admiral Ross
Admiral William Ross could have been just a one note character on the show. Played by Barry Jenner, he appears at the beginning of the sixth season, taking Sisko as his aid to command a battle group against the Dominion. Initially, he has to be curt with him, reminding him he is in command of many more people than just one crew.
Over time, Ross gets more screen time and comes to be a valuable ally to have in Starfleet. He manages to take Sisko's idea of going on the offensive to the Federation and get their backing on it, twice. The first is in retaking Deep Space Nine and the second is in invading Cardassia.
He makes a friend out of Colonel Kira by supporting her in forcing the Romulans to vacate a Bajoran moon but it is unlikely he and Dr. Bashir will be lifelong friends. On a mission to Romulus, Ross works with Section 31 to secure a spot for one of their operatives in the Romulan Senate, something Bashir figures out.
This murks the character somewhat though, as the audience, we know that he is no more murky than a certain Captain who worked with a certain Cardassian, resulting in the death of a certain Senator.
Ross cares passionately for the people under his command and, when he, Sisko and Martok stand on the streets of Cardassia Prime, his disdain for the death that surrounds him shows that the cares about the enemy as well.
20. Jake Sisko
Jake Sisko was to Deep Space Nine what Wesley Crusher arguable was meant to be to the Next Generation. However, due to the remarkable relationship that Cirroc Lofton and Avery Brooks brought to the screen, Jake Sisko became more of an important character than ever could have been initially thought.
It seemed in the beginning that he would naturally follow in his father's footsteps and go into Starfleet Academy. However, early on he is reluctant, to the point that he begins to develop his skills as a writer. He is accepted into a prestigious writing school on Earth and is almost afraid to tell his father.
All of this plays out on screen and Brooks works perfectly with Lofton. They are so believable as father and son that when Sisko is proud of him, we feel it. And when Sisko is mad at him, we feel it just as keenly. Ben's unhappiness that his son wrote an article quoting him without his approval is palpable.
Jake may never have reveled in his Dad's religious standing, yet this did not stop the Pah-Wraith from choosing him as a host. It was then that he truly understood the weight that his Dad carries on a daily basis and he becomes much softer toward him for it.
He experiences battle and he experiences loss. Critics have noted that some of his episodes (The Muse) are weaker than others, but there is enough balance to say that Cirroc Lofton and Jake Sisko play a critical role in Deep Space Nine.
19. Lt. Ezri Dax
Nicole de Boer stepped into the role of Dax for the seventh and final season, a job that could quite quickly have become something of a nightmare if things had gone badly. Jadzia Dax was a fan favourite character and had only been killed off thanks to some poor behind the scenes relations.
The threads that were left to pick up then by Ezri were the friendship with Sisko, the relationships with Julian, Quark and Kira and of course Worf. The difference between Ezri and Jadzi could not have been more noticeable in her dealings with the Klingon, not least in the fact that she doesn't have anything like the same respect for Klingon culture as her former host.
Ezri is willful and idealistic, inexperienced and yet open and friendly. Her first patient as station's counselor is Garak, which is like putting a brand new boxer in a ring with Ali.
The assignment however does them both well and Ezri begins to grow more comfortable on the station. As there is such a short time left in the show, several episodes in the season are devoted to her and her backstory, allowing us to get to know her in rather a short amount of time.
She may have been more nervous that Jadzia, yet she holds her own when it comes to battle and duty. A worthy successor.
18. Luther Sloane
Luther Sloane was Section 31. While the organisation had gone all the way back to the original Federation Charter, he was the cool and commanding, yet sly face of the secretive group.
Later incarnations of Section 31 have all failed to match this master tactician. He remains one of the few humans to outwit Dr. Bashir, playing him like an expensive fiddle as he manipulates the doctor into increasingly desperate scenarios. His first appearance portrays him as an overly zealous security officer, though this front quickly fades.
He is, eventually, quite open in his intentions and tries to recruit Bashir, although the latter refuses. This would not be the last time they would meet.
Sloane had what Ash Tyler and Phillipa Georgiou need - he has believable charm, while playing his hand. Georgiou is an action hero while Tyler, at present, is still honorable and conflicted. Sloane is not honorable. Sloane gets the job done.
His eventual death suggests that Section 31 was simply an operation that was passed from person to person, rather than that supports a base. However, Discovery has shown this to be, at one point in history at least, not the case.
Whatever the situation with Section 31 is in the franchise going forward, Luther Sloane was one of the best, most devious humans that has ever been introduced into Star Trek. Frankly, the jury is still out on whether he's really dead at all...