Star Trek: Discovery - 9 Reasons To Be Worried

Cancelled before it hits the air?

Star Trek Discovery
CBS

Since its announcement, Star Trek: Discovery has been met with several widespread and potentially damaging controversies. Prompted by alleged trouble behind-the-scenes, as well as blatant canonical differences with established Trek lore, many fans have been eager to express their concern and distaste for the show, with some already labelling it as a rushed, jarring and disrespectful cash-in of the 50-year-old property.

Fan rejection has been glaringly evident in the show's marketing. The lacklustre trailers have clearly backfired as dislikes and negative comments amount on YouTube. Meanwhile, its casting, tone, music, and special effects have all been denounced by audiences. CBS have apparently noted the backlash, and are understandably concerned. If reports are to be believed, the prospect of cancellation is a genuine danger, weeks before anyone has seen the show.

Obviously, any firm, overall judgement of Discovery should be made after the show has begun airing, and its merits should not be totally disregarded. Fiercely dismissing the show at this stage would be a terrible and immature oversight, but you cannot blame the fans’ trepidation when there's almost no positive buzz surrounding the show.

This isn't typical hyperbole from an over-passionate fan-base. While we all wish for the best, there are some troubling facts and rumours that could possibly force Star Trek: Discovery to die an early, inglorious death.

9. Another Prequel

Trek Discovery Michael
CBS

Before the series was announced, it was pretty unanimous among Trekkies that any new show should focus on completely unexplored territory, preferably taking place further into the future, long after Voyager and Nemesis. It's no surprise then that disappointment with Discovery occurred quickly after its announcement, as we learnt that it would be set only ten years before the original series.

The specific timeframe has no inherent impact on the show's quality of course, but it is deflating to see a somewhat lack of imagination on the show-runners’ part; they’re resorting to an already firmly established era in Trek history. After Enterprise and Abrams’ movies, now was a fitting time to stay out of the past and excel Star Trek forward. Not only would the writers have had less creative boundaries to work with, but any progression for the timeline would have undoubtedly been a bolder and fresher move.


8. The Limited Universe

Trek Live Long
CBS

Discovery restricts itself by returning to a set time period, and also seemingly dredges up characters and ideas that previously have been exploited ad nauseam in Star Trek. Notably the central character Michael, played by Sonequa Martin-Green, is the previously non-existent adopted child of Ambassador Sarek, marking what feels like a shoe-horned return to something we know.

With this, the show exhibits dangerous signs of repeating similar narratives. From what we know about Michael, she largely sounds highly derivative of another character. As a human, Michael strives to fit in with her Vulcan peers, accepting their culture and ideology as her own, but is hindered and possibly disregarded because of her emotions and humanistic tendencies. Michael is essentially a “child of two worlds”. Sound familiar yet?

From a cynical viewpoint, the inclusion of Sarek, as well as some other returning characters (Harry Mudd, the Klingons), seems like a desperate attempt on CBS’s part to richen the show’s brand recognition. Rather than creating new things to broaden the universe, committee thinking, and lack of imagination has likely narrowed the show into a bland and stale corner.


7. Visual Inconsistencies

Star Trek The Cage
CBS Media Ventures

Most of Discovery's visuals do not remotely correspond to an era of Trek that has been cemented since the show's inception. If you remotely know the prime timeline, you've probably twigged that Discovery takes place around the same time as TOS' original pilot episode, "The Cage" (in the 2250s). Here was a bright and hopeful future, illustrated by Starfleet's colourful uniforms and vibrantly lit ships.

Conversely, Discovery depicts a significantly more dystopian and ugly destiny, complete with triangular starships, a barely illuminated bridge and a sour-faced crew that seem to hate each other. We're not expecting slavishly faithful, but the same general template, or an odd similarity here and there would have been far more faithful and pleasing. Instead, Discovery seems to be going out of its way to contradict things.

In today's pessimistic climate, a colourful 60s-throwback series may have been far more welcoming, and probably not as antiquated as people think.


6. Confused Story Focus

Trek Confused
CBS

From what we know, Discovery represents a major break from Trek tradition in terms of its structure and characters. As the trailers seem to suggest, there is an overall large story-arc that excludes room for stand-alone episodes, and strangely, centres on at least two Starfleet ships/crews as opposed to one. Michael does not primarily serve on the titular ship nor is she even a Captain; she's instead First Officer on the USS Shenzhou. The series is a character story of her, while the two Captains serve only in a supporting capacity.

The immediate issue with this regards the possible narrow scope of the series. Despite having numerous great characters, Trek has never been (and probably shouldn't be) a pinpoint character study. The bigger picture is typically at hand, where universal issues and conundrums are mused and determined by a character with major narrative power i.e. the Captain. There's a reason why the Captain is typically the main player; it's Trek's essential formula and where its best drama comes from. Unlike the crewmen (even the First Officer), Captains' decisions will distinctively drive and impact a large-scale story.

Expertly written and structured, Discovery could present an original and interesting dynamic, but the show runs a serious risk of straying too far from streamlined Star Trek.


5. Absence Of Bryan Fuller

1308713

Bryan Fuller cut his teeth with Star Trek, writing for Deep Space Nine in his early 20s and later for Voyager. With Hannibal and American Gods, Fuller has proven himself to be a viable talent for the television industry.

Naturally, when he was suddenly and mysteriously stripped of his executive position, many people became both concerned and dismayed. While Fuller is still credited, he maintains he no longer has any significant input, and his credit is likely for marquee purposes only. Other than citing his commitment to American Gods, neither Fuller nor CBS have disclosed much information about the split, which indicates a questionable, perhaps rocky relationship. It is widely believed that Fuller was fired from his own show.

His version apparently took a more faithful route in terms of canon, which was to be visually similar and designed as an anthology series, but his loyalty to Trek caused him some harmful arguments. Rumour has it he clashed with CBS executives, namely Les Moonves, who is somewhat notorious for his ignorance and overall distaste for science fiction. Moonves is already well known to Trekkies for cancelling Enterprise, and apparently insisted that Discovery break from many Trek traditions.

It's regrettable that Fuller’s singular vision may have been lost, with Trek now in the hands of excessively corporate loons.


4. Additional Behind The Scenes Troubles

Trek Scenes
CBS

Since the announcement, the premiere date has been constantly delayed. Last year, CBS seemed unusually confident the show would make a January 2017 start date - a time when principle production was still not on the horizon. It was then delayed to May and finally again to late September. Some considered it was due to extensive altercations and re-tooling, which likely lead to Bryan Fuller's departure.

Insider sources have also claimed that test screenings for the show have, to say the least, underwhelmed. Only a fraction of the test audience, which included fans and casual viewers, reacted positively while the majority stressed that the show didn't deliver.

With indifference from audiences and backlash from fans, CBS now doubt the show will go beyond one season; they're allegedly already looking to halt the series, recast and take a new direction for Season 2, supposedly pushing forward with Fuller's initial anthology idea. Firing him clearly wasn't their most enlightened decision...


3. Subscription Issues

All Access Star Trek
CBS

If you live in the United States, Discovery is available as an exclusive on CBS' streaming service, All Access. This has signalled problems for its viewership, with many fans refusing to pay a full subscription fee when their interest lies only with one show. Due to Star Trek's mass appeal, the move is chiefly considered as little more than a ploy on CBS' part to boost recognition for their relatively small streaming service.

It will likely backfire due to audience’s preference to pirate or wait for the DVD, which will put a downer on Discovery’s ratings and possibly mark an early cancellation.

In the rest of the world, you will be able to view the program on Netflix, who are apparently frustrated at not having the worldwide rights and, like Fuller, have had a shaky relationship with CBS.


2. Agenda Over Story

Trek Klingon3
CBS

In recent years especially, the public consensus of Star Trek has been heavily fixated on the show's long history of integrating science fiction with prevalent social and political topics of the day. While this is indeed essential to the show, it's something that has perhaps overshadowed its further value as a humble and exciting space adventure, as fans are keen to constantly highlight the episodes that carry hefty themes and commentary.

It's evidently been a prime selling point for Discovery, as the show runners have put square emphasis on their aims to address and provide commentary for various issues affecting the world today. Discovery will deal with all sorts, specifically a “fractured America”. These intentions are certainly admirable, but their sheer insistence has been a little troublesome, indicating Discovery might be very forefront in its approach.

Science fiction is always a good vessel for metaphor and allegory, yet the best of the genre keeps it at bay as subtext, giving priority to the drama while leaving the audience plenty of room to find messages for themselves. The previous Trek shows are notable for this, and it's majorly vital that Discovery follows suit, otherwise will feel inflated, pandering and irritating.


1. Conflicts With Fans

Jason Issacs Trek
CBS

An interesting but strange thing about social media is that we can see the creators connect and sometimes spew vitriol at a fanbase they should be trying to attract. Discovery's Captain, Jason Isaacs, recently remarked on Twitter about the show's lack of connection to previous Trek and squared up to the fanbase, forcing them to just accept it and even dared them not to watch.

Isaac's irate reaction suggests he is defensive about the show and quite dismissive of naysayers - something that has rarely ended well for celebrities on social media. If we've learnt anything from folk like Josh Trank or Paul Feig, it's that it's probably best to stay silent in case of worrying or flat-out offending the very people who you're trying to sell the product to. In the case of Feig, he was aggressively defending something that was ultimately terrible and inferior, and Isaacs' attitude hopefully does not foreshadow a similar outcome.

It's true that fans can be overly whiny, but it's always better to ignore that side and instead calmly instil confidence in those who are apprehensive. Defending the show with fire will only alienate the old fandom, and if they don't watch, Discovery has much more to lose than they do.

Bottom line - don't f**k with the fans.

Are you worried about Discovery, or do you think they'll pull it off? Share your thoughts down in the comments.


Contributor

Ben Aldis enjoys filming, writing and watching things.