Star Trek: Every Two-Parter Ranked From WORST To BEST

12. Homefront, Paradise Lost

Star Trek Deep Space Nine Leyton
CBS Media Ventures

Star Trek: Deep Space Nine made a point to point out that, even in the idyll of the 24th century, humanity was not exempt from falling back on the foibles of paranoia, suspicion, and fear when the going suddenly got tough. Homefront and Paradise Lost are prime examples of that message — not the destruction of 'Gene's vision,' but the vigilance needed to see it through.

Both episodes are a permanent reminder that, in times of crisis and doubt, we must not sacrifice our personal liberties to the excesses of state security and surveillance. It is all too easy to fall into the trap laid out for us — to start seeing the enemy everywhere, even in those nearest and dearest. The Founders didn't need to invade Earth, they just needed to make it look like they had. Thankfully, the likes of Joseph Sisko knew how to be stubborn when stubborn was exactly what was needed.


11. Fissure Quest, The New Next Generation

Star Trek Lower Decks Fissure Quest T'Pol William Boimler Curzon Dax
CBS Media Ventures

T'Pol, Garashir, CURZON Dax, Harry Kim, or rather, Harrys Kim, all under the command of William Boimler on a Defiant-class ship. What more could you ask for? Oh, yeah! Only Lily flippin' Sloane!

The first half of the series finale of Star Trek: Lower Decks (yes, we are counting it) was more than mere cameos and guest stars for the sake of it. Fissure Quest was a bona fide brilliant story — traversing the multiverse in search of the bad guys who turned out to be the good guys who hadn't quite thought things through. Its cliffhanger was as hilarious as we'd come to expect, and more than a touch climactic — "Holy f**k! We're all gonna die!"

As follow-up, and conclusion to five seasons, The New Next Generation was extremely satisfying. The gate at Starbase 80, or Starbase 80 at the gate, was, in itself, the possible set-up for what could be an intriguing spin-off series across the multiverse. We're still hoping for more from Lower Decks in some form, now with a new captain, and two provisional first officers.


10. The Menagerie, Part I, The Menagerie Part II

Star Trek The Original Series The Menagerie, Part I 'To Be Concluded Next Week'
CBS Media Ventures

Star Trek's very first two-parter could have just been Star Trek's very first clip show — of a pilot nobody had seen at the time. Instead, its framing device was largely clever enough to be captivating from the get-go, even if you have seen The Cage in the interim.

As The Menagerie, Part I begins, the Enterprise has been called to Starbase 11, only to find that the messenger could never have sent the message. The teaser ends with a shock revelation. Spock is about to commit treason and mutiny, and it all has something to do with his former captain, Christopher Pike.

Spock's plan is partly interrupted by his court-martial, or so it would seem. The Menagerie's solution to its fourth wall break is that it was all a Talosian transmission. "Lock him up" (and the death penalty) was then Star Trek's original cliffhanger — "To Be Concluded Next Week". Fortunately, the court-martial itself was all an illusion too, affording Captain Pike the same measure of salvation.


9. The Devourer of All Things, Part I, The Devourer of All Things, Part II

The Devourer of All Things, Part I Wesley Crusher TARDIS
CBS Media Ventures

Star Trek likes its Latin titles, in this case far more effective, far more comprehensible in translation — from Ovid's Metamorphoses, "tempus edax rerum," or "time, devourer of all things".

The Star Trek: Prodigy second season two-parter, The Devourer of All Things, reversed the notion, introducing us to a new species that feasted on time itself. The Loom, a terrifyingly tentacled trans-dimensional foe, fed on their victims until they were erased from it. We 'big kids' were scared in equal measure.

The Devourer of All Things, Part I also marked the triumphant, greater than a cameo, return of a former acting-ensign-ensign-cadet-dress-uniform-at-a-wedding. "I'm Wesley Crusher, and I've been waiting for you." We'd been waiting for you too, Mr Crusher, though hardly expecting you. This had been kept more of a secret than the Omega molecule!


8. Improbable Cause, The Die Is Cast

Star Trek Deep Space Nine Improbable Cause TBC Odo
CBS Media Ventures

"You blew up your own shop, Garak!" Well, of course he did! The truth is usually just an excuse for a lack of explosives. Improbable Cause and The Die Is Cast gave us a few more answers to the mystery that was Garak. The rest was the same lie twice, and a horrendous time for Odo.

Factually, this was the first two-parter in Star Trek to have two separate names, although The Homecoming and The Circle both ended on 'To Be Continued,' and concluded in The Siege. Also a matter of record, Improbable Cause and The Die Is Cast began life as a standalone episode that eventually evolved to become two.

That late-stage decision meant that both episodes were shot out of sequence — Through the Looking Glass was filmed before The Die Is Cast. An isolinear rod a day won't keep the Obsidian Order away!


7. Equinox, Equinox, Part II

Captain Janeway Star Trek Voyager Equinox
CBS Media Ventures

'Equinox' or 'equal night' is more than just the name of the Nova-class, lending itself to the title of the two-parter. As Starfleet officers, and as Starfleet officers in similarly stranded situations, the abhorrent actions of Rudy Ransom and crew cast a long shadow over Voyager, too. There also, but for the grace of a bigger ship, go we.

As a set of episodes, Equinox and Equinox, Part II benefit from an absorbing, well-executed premise, backed by Jay Chattaway's heart-pounding score, and accompanied by an acting masterclass on the part of Kate Mulgrew and John Savage.

Janeway's 'dressing-down' of Ransom, and his subsequent attempt at a defence, was nothing short of exquisite to watch. And, whatever you thought of her methods, Janeway's determination to pursue the Equinox crew for their crimes was played to pitch perfection.


6. Redemption, Redemption II

Star Trek The Next Generation Christopher Hobson Redemption
CBS Media Ventures

Sela steps out of the shadows. Data sticks it to Lieutenant Commander Hobson on the Sutherland. Enough said! Next entry. Naturally, there's more to Redemption and Redemption II than that — a Klingon civil war, funnelled and funded by the Romulans, and one half-Romulan in particular.

Klingon in-fighting (whatever next!) is not to everyone's taste. But even those with a blood pie optional palate must recognise that Redemption and Redemption II are objectively excellent. As well as letting us see parallel Natasha Yar's daughter, Redemption also introduced us to the famously boob-windowed Duras sisters. They were good fun, too, until they forgot to replace their plasma coils!


5. Scorpion, Scorpion, Part II

Star Trek Voyager Scorpion Cold Open
CBS Media Ventures

The length of Scorpion's cold open is inversely proportional to the punch it packs. In only a few seconds, several Borg cubes go from standard self-assurance to blown to smithereens. Who could be more powerful than the galaxy's most devastating assimilators? Four numbers, that's who. You know the ones, and the 8472s!

Of course, beyond interdimensional warfare with Voyager in the middle up the Northwest Passage, the Scorpion two-parter also gave us one of Star Trek's most beloved, most enduring characters — Seven of Nine, now Captain of the Enterprise-G. For that reason alone, Scorpion deserves its high place on this list. Captain Janeway's "appeal to the Devil" might not have been popular, but it paid off!


4. Unification I, Unification II

Star Trek The Next Generation Unification I Spock
CBS Media Ventures

As detailed in The Star Trek: The Next Generation Companion, Unification I & II began life as an idea from then Paramount president Frank Mancuso. As well as including references to the future in Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country, Mancuso wanted to find a way to bring Spock into The Next Generation for Star Trek's 25th anniversary. Rick Berman met with Leonard Nimoy to discuss the story.

The result was iconic, so much so that two- is now technically a three-parter, thanks to Star Trek: Discovery's third season, the titular dream having been achieved on the re-named Ni'Var. Then, if not the fourth part, the finest of addenda, OTOY and the Roddenberry Archive's 765874 — Unification most recently reunited Spock with his former captain and friend at the very end.


3. Year of Hell, Year of Hell, Part II

Star Trek Voyager Year of Hell
CBS Media Ventures

There is only one negative for Year of Hell, perhaps two, depending on your opinion of temporal do-overs. The two-parter had partly been 'spoiled' in advance in Before and After, that 'spoiler' then conveniently forgotten about post-Kes. Otherwise, it is as calculably perfect as anything calculable can be.

"It's strange, thinking there's a piece of your life you don't know anything about," Captain Janeway would say much later to Chakotay in Shattered. That strange irony exists with the viewer. We have access to information, to events, that the characters do not. The beauty of Year of Hell and Year of Hell, Part II is the high-stakes testing ground without the repercussions. "Time's up," time begins again. We still know exactly how hard Janeway and crew fought for that fresh start.


In this post: 
Star Trek
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Jack Kiely is a writer with a PhD in French and almost certainly an unhealthy obsession with Star Trek.