Star Trek: Top 10 Underrated Next Generation Episodes
The Star Trek franchise is arguably one of the most popular sci-fi franchises of all time, up there with Star Wars; I'm not even going to touch the whole "which is better" debate here or anytime soon. Lets save that for William Shatner and Carrie Fisher, eh? One of the hardest things I've ever written was the top 25 episodes of The Next Generation because, to me, nearly all of them are great and some don't get ranked as high as others. Each episode, in their own rite, mixed adventure, humour and storytelling in a way that is unique to this particular show. While there are a select few episodes which are either somewhat questionable or truly abysmal, TNG has a very strong batting average weighing in its favor with notable classics such as The Inner Light, Yesterdays Enterprise, Q Who, and, the universal favorite The Best of Both Worlds. Other episodes, including Code of Honor, Angel One, and the universally panned Shades of Gray (the second season finale for which even the producers remain openly embarrassed to this day) remain buried in our minds as they very well should. Even with the impressive track record of quality for the crew of the Enterprise-Ds adventures, some episodes have, in the test of time, wrongfully ended up lost in the limbo between the aforementioned peak and trough of quality. These 10 episodes, whether just above average or unappreciated greats, have escaped our minds for reasons that may include unfortunately subpar acting, writing or storytelling, or they could simply live in the shadow of an episode that either preceded or followed it. Number 10 after the jump
10. Where Silence Has Lease
If you asked me to name one reason why I like this episode so much, I probably couldn't tell you simply because it's a filler piece at its finest, but it is very fun to watch. Written in a catch up frenzy following the 1988 Writers Guild of America Strike, this second episode of a shortened season 2 didn't air until November and was a rehash of an old Star Trek: Phase II script that obviously never came to any fruition. In this episode, the Enterprise is caught in a black hole in space that leads to a dimension of nothingness where a giant space creature that slightly resembles a shaved chimpanzee experiments with them like a rat in a maze. You read that right. Ridiculous, right? It's cheesy science fiction at its finest, which makes it very enjoyable to watch, but be ready to bring out your inner Tom Servo, Crow T. Robot and/or Gypsy for this one.
9. Gambit
Oh, the grief I got for putting this on the last list... and, with the benefit of hindsight, rightfully so. In this seventh-season two parter, Captain Picard is declared dead in a bar fight when a midget mouse creature of some kind tells the crew that he was vaporized, and acting Captain Riker leads an investigation that leads to his subsequent kidnapping by a group of scavengers, including none other than the bald man himself who had apparently been beamed away with a special transporter by the baddies and forced to help them dig up an ancient Vulcan artifact. All around, it's an exciting story and it's fun to watch. So what went wrong? Well, for one thing, the writers felt the need to take a left turn in the middle of a battle scene and add a morality tale at the end regarding war and peace, one so in your face Picard may as well have put a bandana on his head and started blazing up. There was also the acting. "The acting in 'Gambit' makes it ineligible ," Matt Mira of the Nerdist said on Twitter. He's right; the acting in "Gambit" is absolutely dreadful. It's not entirely the cast's fault though, as they were given some pretty terrible lines that almost seemed forced. Among the top contenders for worst lines in script writing history... Riker: "I have an open wound... right here... it hurts like hell." Troi: "Do you think you have the monopoly on feelings???" Picard: "I think it's time we had a new commander!"
8. A Matter Of Perspective
The Next Generation took a stab at a good old fashioned murder mystery, and I personally think they pulled it off quite well, but some more lackluster acting at key points throughout the episode made an otherwise great one lost in the test of time. Riker and Geordi are sent to meet an independent scientist, Dr. Apgar (Mark Margolis, "Breaking Bad") to evaluate a potential new power source for the Federation, but Dr. Apgar's space station explodes right as Riker beams back to the Enterprise, and Apgar is the only man left on the station when it explodes. When the planet's chief investigator beams aboard, he immediately arrests Riker for suspicion of murder; a phaser blast was detected directly from Riker's beam out position when the station exploded. An interesting concept involved using the holodeck as a courtroom to recreate events as they happened from each side's point of view, which makes this episode worth watching. Again, there are some lines that make you wonder how this script left the writer's room, including: Riker: "You're a DEAD MAN, Apgar! A dead man!" (Watch the delivery if you get a chance and try not to laugh) Apgar's wife: "I just know he did it... *tear* he killed my husband."
7. Conspiracy
I feel like a lot of episodes from the first two seasons are overlooked, mostly because a good number of them are just rehashed plot lines from the original series and the Phase II spinoff that never came to fruition. This episode was actually not only a very original idea, but also an early draft of the Borg storyline. Yes, that bug that protruded from Remmick's chest before Picard and Riker blow it to smithereens is an early form of the Borg. These bugs invade the bodies of high ranking admirals like a parasite and breathe through a quill through the neck and begin to strategically weaken the fleet in preparation for an invasion. When Picard and Riker return to Earth to investigate, a shootout at Starfleet HQ becomes one of the most hilariously gory in the history of television (see above). There's really nothing wrong with the episode, it just got stuck in the foray of the first two seasons. Go watch!
6. Rascals
One of the most hilariously ridiculous episodes of the show's later years, Picard, Keiko, Ro & Guinan are transformed into children in a freak transporter accident, and Picard is relieved of duty because the bridge crew is too uncomfortable around him for him to lead effectively. I didn't make any of that up. Even better, that's Picard hugging Riker right there! Anyway, in a very hilarious attempt to criminalize the Ferengi once more, a rogue group of Ferengi scavengers hijack the Enterprise and it's up to the children to save the Enterprise. Yeah. It's still a lot of fun to watch, especially Picard having a temper tantrum to see Riker, "his father." The concept is way out there and it was kind of funny to see the Ferengi as real bad guys again, even if they just came in shooting which is very uncharacteristic for them.
5. Power Play
Okay, this episode is just great and I don't get why it doesn't get the credit it deserves. A highlight for the Troi, Data & O'Brien characters when their bodies are hijacked by non-corporeal beings that claim to be the bridge crew of a long lost Federation starship who want to return home. The only problem is they shoot up Ten Forward and take hostages to prove their point, something very uncharacteristic of Starfleet officers, regardless of the perils they've been through. The crew must work to rid the beings from the three bodies, save the hostages in Ten Forward and find out if these beings are telling the truth. Considering his superhuman strength and intellect, seeing Data bent with rage is a rare treat, one that was arguably pulled off here far better than it was in "Descent" two years later. Also, who knew Troi of all people would make such a convincing villain? I'm sure it's the concept of a mutiny in Ten Forward that doesn't appeal to all who watch, making this episode stand among other average ones. I personally see it as one of the top highlights of a rather touchy fifth season.
4. Encounter at Farpoint
Alright, now let's be fair, everyone who watches TNG enough to read this article has probably seen the pilot episode so it's not necessarily overlooked in significance. Quality? Well, yeah. The newly commissioned Enterprise is intercepted by Q in their first encounter and are told to return to Earth or face demise; Captain Picard challenges Q to a test to show that humans are ready for space travel, a challenge which Q happily accepts in the form of a sentient space station on Deneb IV called Farpoint Station, challenging the Enterprise to discover its true nature. The cast is very outspoken about how amazed they are that the show even got picked up whenever they watch the pilot. Marina Sirtis has said she is still amazed to this day that she wasn't fired for her performance in the pilot; Michael Dorn has said that because it was just another acting job at the time, everyone was "so serious." They're both right, and it was almost funny to watch because their characters are virtually nothing like what we see in later years once they got their feet wet in the franchise.
3. Descent
Again, it is a rare treat to see Data, a being of superior strength and intellect, cross into morally grey areas such as in "Power Play," but it is here where it goes to extremes. An awesome finale with an exceptionally weak conclusion for a premiere, the Enterprise beams down to a Federation science station where they encounter the Borg, and they show signs of independence, obviously a repercussion of the events of "I, Borg," and start shooting at the away team! Data, in a brief fit of rage, takes pleasure by snapping a Borg's neck, which causes him great distress. The Enterprise later discovers that the Borg have developed transwarp capabilities, and mirroring the technique they follow the Borg to their base on Oniaka III where they discover that their leader is, for some reason, wait for it... Lore, and he shut off Data's ethical subroutine turning him into a psychotic torture mastermind. You read that right. The first part was great, but the second part just seemed like a cop out way to bring Lore back into the picture one last time. I still say watch it, though.
2. Peak Performance
I'll admit... I didn't actually sit down and watch this episode all the way through until about a month ago on a lazy Sunday. After the events of "Q Who," the Federation begins a war games program to prepare themselves for the inevitable Borg invasion, and the Enterprise crew is divided between the mother ship and the derelict U.S.S. Hathaway, commanded by Commander Riker. Observed by Federation representative Sirna Kolrami, the Hathaway crew must use any resources at their disposal for battle ready status. However, a Ferengi vessel appears in the midst of "battle" and demands to take the Hathaway under its own flag and demands to know why the Enterprise would fire on one of its own vessels. While it was produced during an especially turbulent season with the writer's strike and the abysmal finale that immediately followed it, this episode blended humor, action and suspense in a way that few other episodes have. I recommend you dust off that sixth disc of season 2 that you probably haven't touched considering that this episode is accompanied on that disc with the abysmal "Shades of Gray."
1. Genesis
While Picard and Data are away on a shuttle mission, the crew of the Enterprise starts to deal with a widespread virus that causes the crew to devolve into animal-like creatures. Riker is turned into a caveman, Troi into a frog, Worf into a predator like animal that I can only assume is a prehistoric Klingon, Barclay into a spider, and Spot into a lizard for whatever reason. Picard and Data return to the ship and find it in ruins, and they must concoct a retro-virus while eluding the dangers on board including Riker and Worf. It's definitely the closest thing to cheesy science fiction as the show ever came with a virus causing the crew to attack each other and Picard and Data. This episode even garnered an Emmy nomination for Michael Westmore for Outstanding Makeup. While some episodes on this list took a good concept and poorly executed it, this episode did just the opposite by taking a sci-fi cliche and turning it into something great in an otherwise lackluster season 7. Have an episode that should've been listed on here? Sound off below!