Supergirl: Ranking Every Character From Worst To Best
Which of Supergirl's characters soared, and which ones were its Kryptonite?
It's hard to believe that Supergirl has been soaring through the skies of National City for four years now. Initially airing on CBS, the Girl of Steel's adventures found a new home on The CW at the beginning of its second season and has remained there ever since.
During those four years, the titular superhero has battled invading alien fleets, stomped out prejudice and ignorance and even fought her own cousin - all while the show continues to reach new heights, becoming one of the most popular on television.
While a large part of that is down to its core comic book audience, the fact that it doesn't shy away from tackling important issues and the endearing stories that it tells, the most important aspect of Supergirl's success (as with any show) is undoubtedly its characters.
Boasting a large line-up, the show has seen a number of beloved characters come and go over the years, with the vast majority of them adding something memorable during their time as part of it. But which ones stood out among the rest?
From supervillains to Superman and reporters to red daughters, let's reflect on all of the major characters to grace Earth-38 with the presence, and while we're at it, rank them.
30. Non
Blunt, irritating and devoid of any real substance, Non was perhaps the dullest of all Arrowverse villains.
Completely lacking in character growth, he started the show's debut season wanting to eradicate Supergirl from the world and ended it doing just the same. While there was opportunity to highlight how the death of Astra impacted his desire for revenge, it was impossible to capitalise on, simply because he was already vengeance-driven before that.
Without Astra by his side, he allowed himself to be manipulated by Indigo, and that only exposed the fact that he was never strong enough to carry the show as its primary villain.
29. Indigo
A deadly prisoner from Fort Rozz, Indigo was a synthetic life form that also happened to be known as Brainiac-8 (yeah, she was that deadly).
Terrorising the residents of National City throughout Season 1, she attempted to destroy everything around her as she literally hacked into the city and caused havoc - messing with street lights and other power sources to cause accidents. And, after her initial defeat, she teamed with Non in the most uninspired pairing ever, before Supergirl and J'onn defeated them.
Though Laura Vandervoort was deliciously villainous in the role, the deadly character was hindered by the fact that she felt every bit like the machine that she was, because other than wanting revenge, there wasn't anything of substance there - she was just pure evil.
Fun, yes, but not exactly original.
28. Kelly Olsen
Introduced into the show during the fourth season, James Olsen's sister went from being a newcomer to a full-time character in a matter of episodes and she has, so far, slotted in rather well.
Sure, she wasn't exactly eased in subtly, but thanks to Azie Tesfai's performance, and the character's involvement in both James and Alex's personal storylines, she has effectively contributed to the show in a rather short space of time. And although there isn't quite enough to make a full judgment just yet, it's safe to say: So far, so great...
27. Jeremiah Danvers
Alex and Kara's long lost father, Jeremiah Danvers' disappearance had a major role to play in the events that ultimately set both sisters on the heroic paths they would end up taking. However, when he finally returned from his apparent death, he sent us all on our own emotional rollercoasters.
Imprisoned by Cadmus, only to be freed, reunite with his family and then betray them for Cadmus, to then inform them that he's doing it for them and, finally, to turn his back on Cadmus - very little of Jeremiah's story actually makes sense. But it seems that was the writers' intention. However, with his location having remained a mystery for over two years, who knows anymore?
Hopefully he returns one day because Lois and Clark legend Dean Cain had some great moments with his TV daughters and that is a relationship that could benefit from a lot more development.
26. President Olivia Marsdin
Debuting in the second season, Lynda Carter's President Marsdin turned out to be an unexpected ally to the Girl of Steel and her fight against bigotry towards aliens. Though she could be firm and slightly intimidating at times, it soon turned out that she was passionate about Supergirl's cause because she too was an alien.
From being an inspirational president who showed viewers that outsiders can achieve great things too to the fact that she was Cat Grant's college friend, Marsdin slotted into the show incredibly well and ended up having a more significant role in Season 4 than expected - even if she didn't appear on-screen all that often.
Now, can we have some more of her, please?
25. Eve Teschmacher
You know what they say about a wolf in sheep's clothing? Well, you won't find a better example of that than *clears throat* "Miss Teschmacher!".
Originally little more than a humorous background character, Eve Teschmacher was Cat Grant's unfortunate assistant who constantly buckled under the pressure of her boss' rule. However, one friendship with Lena Luthor later, and it turned out that she was actually a spy for her notorious criminal brother Lex.
Eccentric, traitorous and obsessive, Eve has gone from strength-to-strength in her more comic-accurate role which, thanks in no small part to Andrea Brooks' charismatic performance, has done absolute wonders for the character - and has certainly raised expectations for her full-time role next season.
24. James Olsen
Supergirl decided to make a change to their comic book source material when they delivered Mehcad Brooks' dreamy James Olsen to us. Unfortunately, his charming personality, handsome features and confident aura robbed the character of everything that made him so, well, nerdy.
Though James has undoubtedly had his moments, such as his evolution into Guardian, the slow journey into his backstory and his struggles with PTSD, the writers have struggled to find a place for him on the show. In spite of admitting that the forced romance between him and Kara could never go anywhere, they still pursued it in Season 1 and, when Mon-El showed up, he was completely lost for a purpose.
Brooks has done an exceptional job with what he was given, but it just seems like no matter how hard the writers try, they just can't maintain a solid story for Clark Kent's best friend. Maybe he's just on the wrong show...
23. Lois Lane
After years of teasing her existence, Lois Lane finally made her Arrowverse debut in the Elseworlds crossover in which she was portrayed by Bitsie Tulloch and, well, it's safe to say that she was worth waiting for.
With plenty of charisma and a ton of charm, this Lois clearly takes inspiration from Dana Delany and Erica Durance's respective turns as the character - and it works. She's not quite as sarcastic but she's twice as loving - and anyone who can call Clark "Smallville" with the necessary amount of sass deserves to be Lois Lane.
A perfect example of how TV can indeed best film, the Arrowverse's Lois Lane was more like Lois than the DCEU version ever was. Now, we just need to spend some more time with her.
22. Astra
Kara's Kryptonian aunt, Astra was the initial Big Bad of the first season, as she and her husband Non attempted to exact revenge for the way in which they were treated on their home planet in the lead-up to its destruction.
The twin of Kara's mother Alura, Astra's presence created an interesting dynamic between her and the Girl of Steel as it forced the latter to confront both her grief over Alura's death and the fact that her mother may have been wrong to imprison her. However, as the season pressed on, it became clear that, in spite of being on opposite sides, Astra cared a great deal for her niece - and it was those familial ties that made her one of the show's more compelling antagonists and, at the very least, a heck of a lot more engaging than her one-dimensional husband.
Laura Benanti did a great job differentiating Astra from Alura, and it's a real shame that she never got to play the former for a little for longer...
21. Colonel Lauren Haley
Colonel Lauren Haley first made her presence felt on Supergirl when she was drafted in to supervise Director Danvers and ensure that the D.E.O. was doing its job in the way that the corrupt President Baker wanted it to. Though an antagonistic character, she was far from a villain and was simply a little misguided in her approach.
However, as she began to question her president, she also found herself questioning her own actions and thus, she agreed to help Alex, and the formerly-relieved-of-service Supergirl take down the anti-alien administration.
Designed as a huge obstacle for Alex to overcome during her first year as director of the D.E.O., Haley served her purpose to perfection and April Parker Jones was incredibly convincing as her decorated character.