The True Story Behind Christopher Eccleston's Doctor Who Exit

Charting Christopher Eccleston's Doctor Who career from 2003 to 2023 and beyond...

Doctor Who Ninth Doctor Rose
BBC Studios

On stage in Melbourne, Australia, Christopher Eccleston spoke about the possibility of his return to the role of the Ninth Doctor for the 60th anniversary of Doctor Who.

Eccleston denounced the idea of multi-Doctor stories as a "cash-grab" and said that if he was to return, it would be as a solo Doctor. It marks a significant shift in his original assertion that he'd return to the role "when Hell freezes over", but it also feels like his return to the TV series is as far away as ever. Eccleston has, of course, been recording a series of new audio adventures for Big Finish which have recently seen him team up with the Brigadier to take on the Cybermen.

The circumstances of Eccleston's departure from the Who show is something of an ongoing mystery in Doctor Who. Originally, it was assumed to be a simple case of a decision not to renew his contract, after all he wasn't known for sticking around in popular series for long. His character in Cracker was memorably written out after one season, for example. In the years that have followed however, more information has come out via interviews, unofficial sources and Eccleston's own autobiography.

Let's sift through this to find a chronological timeline of the hows and whys of Christopher Eccleston's Doctor Who exit.

9. 2003: He's Back, And It's About Time!

Doctor Who Scream Of The Shalka
BBC

In 2003, the 40th anniversary year, it was announced that Doctor Who would be returning to the BBC with a brand new series. Twice. The Paul Cornell-scripted, Richard E Grant-starring The Scream of the Shalka was announced in July as a new, animated era for the show. It was a bold new vision, pairing an emotionally traumatised Doctor with a robotic Master as a sort of buddy duo. Shalka's thunder was soon stolen by a bigger, bolder announcement, however.

Two months later, in September, it was announced that Doctor Who would be coming back to BBC1 as a proper television series. It would be creatively spearheaded by acclaimed screenwriter Russell T Davies. Less than two months prior to the official 40th anniversary celebrations, it was the perfect early birthday present for fans.

Between 26 September 2003 and 26 March 2005, Doctor Who fandom was reinvigorated by the possibilities of the new series. Discussing potential casting, sharing various production rumours and set photos on message boards and renewing their dormant Doctor Who Appreciation Society Memberships. It was a very exciting time to be a Doctor Who fan.


8. Eccleston Is Cast For Doctor Who's Second Coming

Christopher Eccleston arriving for the World Premiere of Thor : Dark World, at the Odeon Leicester Square, London.
Ian West/PA Archive

Names thrown around as a potential Ninth Doctor included Tom Baker and Judi Dench. As Russell T Davies nodded along to these suggestions, he was harbouring a desire to cast Hugh Grant in the role. Quite what the battle-scarred Doctor would be like in the hands of Grant is anyone's guess, as Grant declined the offer. Something he's said to have later regretted after seeing how successful the show became.

A name that nobody had even considered was Christopher Eccleston, an actor known for his work in grounded, realistic seminal dramas like Our Friends in the North and Cracker. He was not an actor known for the lightness of touch many expected from the character of the Doctor.

In an interview to announce his casting, Eccleston noted that:

"I don't think he's going to be as eccentric and foppish as he was in some of his incarnations."

Eccleston was cast after he emailed Davies to register his interest. Having previously worked on The Second Coming with RTD, Eccleston told the press he was "excited" to be working with him again. In the same interview, Eccleston noted that they were keen to modernise the series. In a nod to the classic series' perceived sexism, Eccleston joked:

"I'll be doing the running around screaming"


7. Filming Begins With Aliens of London

Doctor Who Aliens Of London Christopher Eccleston ID badge
BBC

With Eccleston cast as the Doctor and former pop star and full-time actor Billie Piper cast as his companion Rose, the 21st century incarnation entered production on 18 July 2004. Filming at Cardiff Royal Infirmary, doubling for Albion Hospital, Eccleston's first scene as the Doctor was him chasing the Space Pig down the corridor. And there's nothing more Doctorish than that!

Alongside the filming of the series, a companion show Doctor Who: Confidential was documenting the production and provided valuable insights into Eccleston's brief time on the show. In his interviews, he clearly grasps the character, noting the Doctor's open-mindedness as a great quality for a television hero while also highlighting his brutal, alien, pragmatism.

Eccleston and Piper also clearly get on very well together, and are regularly seen smiling and laughing between takes in the short glimpses of filming. In his autobiography, I Love The Bones Of You, Eccleston reflects on his working relationship with Piper:

"What truly amazes me is I know how nervous Billie was at the start. She thought I was some big serious performer and she didn’t have the belief in herself as an actor. She proved herself, of course, to be way better than any of the rest of us."


6. Eccleston Embarks On The Promotion Trail

In the run-up to Doctor Who's premiere on 26 March 2005, Christopher Eccleston embarked on the promotional trail for the new series. The return of Doctor Who was a big deal, there were billboards, specially shot trailers, and teasers. Eccleston and Piper were front and centre in all of this promotion. On top of this, there were also media appearances on some stalwart British shows.

Eccleston sat on the Blue Peter sofa to talk about how he felt about taking on such an iconic role, stating:

"I was very excited [...] I felt ready to take on something with that sort of responsibility [...] because the scripts are that strong..."

He also appeared on a special Doctor Who-themed episode of Mastermind to present the winner with the trophy. On being introduced by host John Humphries as Doctor Who, Eccleston off-handedly quips "Well, for now." For Canadian viewers, Eccleston also filmed special intros for each episode of the series.

Throughout these appearances, he's effusive about what drew him to the role, the scripts, the monsters and the importance of the Doctor. What nobody knew at this point however, was that Eccleston had already filmed his final scene as the Doctor.


5. Rose Airs, Two Days Later Eccleston Is Gone

Doctor Who Rose the Ninth Doctor
BBC

On 26 March 2005, Doctor Who triumphantly returned to screens. Not even the leak of the first episode, or an interruption from Graham Norton could take the sheen off the staggering 10.81 million viewers that tuned in to watch Rose. Two days later, the tabloids published reports that Eccleston had already departed the series and the search for a new Doctor was on.

The BBC responded to these rumours two days later on 30 March, stating that Eccleston left the role for fear of being typecast. It wasn't true. The following Monday, BBC Head of Drama and Commissioning Jane Tranter had to publicly apologise to Eccleston, stating that:

"The BBC regrets not speaking to Christopher before it responded to the press questions on Wednesday 30 March.

The BBC further regrets that it falsely attributed a statement to Christopher and apologises to him."

It was a sour note that undercut the joy of Doctor Who being back on TV and more popular than ever. The casting of David Tennant and the series' increasing popularity certainly dispelled much of this unpleasantness. However, the BBC's decision to misquote Eccleston and upset him further is a real failing on their part, especially given how much work he did to promote the series.


4. Stories Of On-Set Troubles Emerge In The Years After Eccleston's Departure

Lennon Naked Christopher Eccleston John Lennon
BBC

The abrupt nature of Eccleston's departure and the poor handling of the announcement by the BBC has led to it being revisited in various interviews with the actor conducted. In June 2010, Eccleston hit the headlines when, while promoting a drama about John Lennon, he was asked about his departure. In response, he stated that:

"I didn't enjoy the environment and the culture that we, the cast and crew, had to work in.

"I thought if I stay in this job, I'm going to have to blind myself to certain things that I thought were wrong."

As an actor who is from a staunch working class, trade union background, it's unsuprising that he left, rather than be complicit in a perceived toxic workplace. It's unclear if this refers to series 1's over-running shoots, Eccleston's rumoured disagreements with director Keith Boak, or something else entirely.

In 2018, Eccleston elaborated further, suggesting that something had gone very badly wrong between when he excitedly emailed RTD to offer to play the Doctor and his eventual departure:

“My relationship with my three immediate superiors – the showrunner, the producer and co-producer – broke down irreparably during the first block of filming and it never recovered. They lost trust in me, and I lost faith and trust and belief in them.”


3. Eccleston Meets With Moffat For Day Of The Doctor

Doctor Who Christopher Eccleston The Day of the Doctor
BBC Studios

In his autobiography, Eccleston feels that RTD didn't quite know what he wanted from the Doctor, but is incredibly complimentary of Steven Moffat saying that his scripts:

"... delivered my best work, bringing me closer to finally knowing exactly who the Doctor was than any other time during the shoot."

It's no surprise that he was open to meeting Moffat about appearing in 2013's 50th anniversary special The Day of the Doctor. Ultimately, Eccleston turned the role down because he felt it didn't do justice to the Ninth Doctor. He's glad he did, because it left room for John Hurt's phenomenal turn as the War Doctor, whom Eccleston believes is a "a far better actor than me".

It was a promising first step towards Eccleston donning the leather jacket once more, but the role still held a great deal of trauma for the actor. Not least the way in which the BBC misquoted him, in what he believes was an attempt to vilify him. Further more, Eccleston's struggles with mental health and body dysmorphia were intrinsically linked with the role, observing in the autobiography that:

"People love the way I look in that series, but I was very ill. The reward for that illness was the part. And therein lies the perpetuation of the whole sorry situation.”


2. Eccleston Begins Attending Conventions

Five years after the huge 50th anniversary celebrations, Christopher Eccleston made his first convention appearance. Rather than a full-on Doctor Who convention, it was the London Film and Comic Con, and fans could get their photo taken with the Ninth Doctor for the princely sum of £95. Eccleston's appearances on the convention circuit also open up the opportunities for him to bump into other Doctor actors like Matt Smith, with their very tactile and lovely meeting going viral on social media.

Aside from the obvious financial gain, Eccleston was clearly attracted to the convention circuit by the opportunity to meet his fans. In a 2016 video for BBC Raw to discuss The A Word, Eccleston talks with fan Gerard Groves about the series, autism and is visibly moved when Groves talks about the impact his portrayal of the Doctor had on his childhood. It chimes with Eccleston's own reflections on the impact of the role on those kids that were growing up in 2005, watching him as the Ninth Doctor.

"Everywhere I go, Cornwall, Belfast, Glasgow, wherever, I now get people of a certain age, mid-twenties, coming up to me. ‘You were my Doctor,’ they tell me."


1. "If You Want Me Back, Get Me On My Own"

Doctor Who Christopher Eccleston Ninth Doctor
BBC Studios

As Eccleston continued to make convention appearances, he came into contact with Big Finish Chairman Jason Haigh-Ellery at the Gallifrey One convention in early 2020.

"Christopher said he was enjoying meeting the fans and was pleased that his Doctor was remembered so fondly. He indicated he would be open to discussing a project with Big Finish."

Since that fateful meeting, Eccleston has recorded a full twelve episode series as the Ninth Doctor, with another on the way. It's certainly a positive sign that he's been able to move on from the damage and strain that playing the part put upon him. As for a potential return in the 60th anniversary? It's a bit more complicated than that...

At the SupaNova convention in Melbourne, Eccleston put out an open offer to the BBC: "If you want me back, get me on my own!"

With rumours of a potential anniversary anthology series with past Doctors, he may get his wish. And what better tribute to Christopher Eccleston, the man who re-established Doctor Who and ensured its continuing legacy, than by having him return in 2023, 20 years after the show was re-commissioned?


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Citizen of the Universe, Film Programmer, Writer, Podcaster, Doctor Who fan and a gentleman to boot. As passionate about Chinese social-realist epics as I am about dumb popcorn movies.