The Walking Dead: 10 Best Antagonists So Far

In a world ruled by the dead, surviving the living can be the hardest part.

Life for Rick Grimes and his fellow survivors hasn't been all too easy since The Walking Dead kicked off back in 2010. Lives have been lost, hopes have been dashed time and again and danger continues to lurk around every single corner. Whether they're coping with the ever-present menace of the undead, struggling with mysterious, life-threatening illnesses or overcoming the harsh realities of day-to-day survival, the survivors have had to clear one hurdle after another just to keep hope alive for a better future. If the group has learned anything over the years between losing refuges like the farm and the prison or their experiences with places like Terminus, it's that the most dangerous threat of all is often mankind itself. From individuals, small groups and large communities, Rick's band of survivors has had to deal with a plethora of antagonists - both inside and outside of the group - who have threatened their safety and lives. In some cases, these antagonists have embraced their new lives of being free to do what they want, regardless of who gets hurt along the way. In others, they've simply become victims to the madness around them, unable or unwilling to cope in a way that isn't harmful to others. With the second half of the show's fifth season now in full swing and the survivors bound to keep crossing paths with other dangerous survivors, including a long-awaited, bat-wielding fan favourite from the comics, let's take a spoiler-filled look back at ten of the best antagonists the series has had to offer so far.

10. Ed Peletier

There are few people more pathetic in our society than those who derive their sense of self from their abuse of others; whether it's physically, sexually or emotionally, stories of abuse seem to permeate our everyday lives. To that end, Ed Peletier was an early representation of an abusive relationship seeping into a world where such acts and attitudes can no longer be swept under the rug and hidden with a lame excuse. Ed himself wasn't much of a three-dimensional character; in fact, no fan likely felt sorry for him when Shane beat him near death, let alone when the character actually died. But as a symbol of real-world horrors, he was a necessary evil. He may not have lasted long in the world of The Walking Dead due to his stubborn - and contemptible - machismo, but without him lurking around to keep Carol down early on, her journey from timid housewife to Rambo wouldn't have been as satisfying. Carol has long since moved on to deal with way more outwardly terrible things than Ed, but his existence as a lasting footnote in her arc continues to linger on, serving as a reminder of how far she's come.

9. Randall's Group

From the moment Dave and Tony walked into the bar where Rick and Glenn had found Hershel drowning his sorrows, viewers knew they were trouble. As the two groups moved past introductions and into territory concerning the farm, tensions quickly mounted, culminating in Rick shooting the duo in self-defence and ensuring they'd never see the farm (or even Nebraska, for that matter). Shortly after, several more men arrived looking for them, leading to a conflict that left their group fleeing, walkers alerted and the abandoned - and injured - Randall in the care of Rick, Glenn and Hershel. Randall's prisoner status at the farm would go on to cause conflict among the group that would pave the way for the rest of the season, with the moral debate over what to do with him ultimately sending Dale on his fateful final walk in the fields and bringing the long-brewing conflict between Rick and Shane to a head. Through Randall, viewers got the chance to hear and see what other survivors in the world outside of the farm were increasingly capable of, with the story of his group's rape of innocent girls being a sickening wake-up call that the farm wouldn't be a safe haven from others forever.

8. Inmates

Shortly after their arrival at the prison at the start of season 3, Hershel was bitten in the leg, leading Rick to perform an impromptu amputation of the limb in the prison's cafeteria. During this event, the survivors encountered five prisoners who had been locked inside the cafeteria since the outbreak had begun. Two of these survivors, Axel and Oscar, would later turn out to be decent guys, becoming a part of the group. Unfortunately for them, their de facto leader, Tomas, did a lot in a short amount of time to ensure that Rick had no reason to trust them, brutally murdering his own "friend" Big Tiny and blatantly attempting to kill Rick. Ultimately, Tomas would fall victim to a post-Shane, no-nonsense Rick, who buried his machete in the inmate's head. The fifth inmate, Andrew, took off running in response, escaping outside and directly into a group of walkers before being locked out and left to die by Rick. Unbeknownst to Rick, Andrew survived, luring walkers into the prison and causing chaos that would lead to the deaths of T-Dog and Lori before Oscar put a bullet in him. Despite finally having a new safe haven around them, the survivors had their worlds turned upside down, with Andrew's actions causing Rick to spiral out of control, casting a shadow over both the narrative drive of the season and the series as a whole.

7. Dawn

When Dawn was introduced in the first half of the fifth season, she brought with her a lot of mystery. Slap happy and frequently impossible to get a read on, the law enforcement official who put "the weak" into a form of indentured servitude stood in stark contrast to the recently deceased Hunters. Throughout her few appearances, her and her group's history at Grady Memorial was doled out almost exclusively through dialogue, letting attentive viewers put the pieces together. Obsessive and desperate to maintain her power in the face of those who would dissent, Dawn attempted to manipulate Beth to be on "her side" should anything go wrong. In the end, Dawn's desire to assert her strength during the trade-off of her people for Beth and Carol and her demand that Noah be handed over would lead to Beth stabbing her, Dawn instinctively shooting her and Daryl ending Dawn's life in return. Her time on the show may have been brief, but her final action served to rob the group of much-needed hope and will undoubtedly continue to have a lasting effect on characters like Maggie and Daryl.

6. The Marauders

Like Randall's group, Joe and the Marauders - or "Claimers" - served as a brutal reminder of what people can be capable of when given free reign in a world without rules. After deciding to hunt down Rick for murdering one of their own during his escape from the house they had invaded and ensnaring the listless Daryl in their group along the way, the Marauders finally caught up with Rick, Michonne and Carl in the season 4 finale, getting the drop on the trio and holding them at their mercy. With Daryl getting beaten to death in front of him for intervening, his son on the verge of getting raped and with Joe whispering promises of what he'd do to Michonne in his ear, cackling the whole time, Rick finally snapped, biting out Joe's jugular and distracting the rest of the Marauders long enough for his friends to take advantage. The entire sequence was at once captivating and distressing, standing out as one of the series' tensest moments. The Marauders may not have been fleshed out as individuals, but their existence and actions were a memorable and disturbing part of the show.

5. Lizzie

It would be too easy to label Lizzie as simply "crazy," but as a child growing up in the world of The Walking Dead with a warped worldview and a clear set of pre-existing developmental issues, she's representative of some of the worst things that can happen to people, particularly children, living in such an environment. Her mental problems untreated and swept aside in favour of characters telling her that she just needed to get used to the world, Lizzie's view of the walkers as people and skewed idea of right and wrong spiraled out of control over the course of the fourth season. After luring countless walkers to the prison fences with food, killing rabbits and nearly smothering Judith to death, Lizzie's issues finally came to a head in The Grove, with the character taking her own sister's life without remorse to prove to Carol and Tyreese that she'd come back still a person. In the end, Carol would take Lizzie out for a fateful look at the flowers, but the weight of the young girl's death continued to have a lasting impact on Carol and Tyreese going forward. Though she could never be labelled a villain, Lizzie's issues and outward insanity had proved time and again that she was a danger to herself and everyone else, providing the series' with one of its most complex antagonists.

4. Merle Dixon

When viewers got their first look at Merle Dixon on the rooftops of Atlanta way back in season one, they were treated to some fundamental 'white trash' stereotypes, elevated only by Michael Rooker's natural charisma. Despite that, the character's absence in the wake of the group finding his hand marked him as a particular point of fan interest, with the question of his potential return coming up time and again, until he finally reappeared in season 3. As a loyal servant to The Governor, Merle went on to hunt down and attempt to kill Michonne, kidnap Glenn and Maggie and brutally torture the former before being put on the outs by his leader under the belief that Merle had betrayed Woodbury. After escaping the town, Merle and Daryl split off on their own, with the much-changed Daryl acknowledging Merle for the scumbag he was shortly after and returning to the prison with his outcast brother in tow. Eventually, Merle sacrificed his life in a failed attempt to take out The Governor and give his brother a chance at living at the prison with the people he cared about without more conflict. Beforehand, the character was able to reflect upon his choices to Michonne, revealing that he remembered every life he had taken for The Governor and that it was far too late for him to turn back from the man he had become.

3. The Hunters

From the moment Terminus was mentioned, many viewers knew something was fishy. The sanctuary for all providing community for all seemed too good to be true and - big surprise - it proved to be a lie when Rick, Daryl, Michonne and Carl found themselves herded like cattle through the complex and into a train car at the end of the fourth season. The fifth season kicked off with the confirmation that the Termites were, in fact, cannibals, with several of the survivors nearly being added to the menu before Carol set the stage for an action movie. After slaughtering everyone they could and remaining intact, Rick's group reunited with Carol, Tyreese and Judith before moving on to their next adventure. Unfortunately, Tyreese had failed to kill a member he and Carol had subdued prior, Martin, who caught up with Terminus' leader, Gareth, along with a few other survivors of the destruction of their home. Becoming The Hunters, Gareth and his hungry band found out that Bob tasted even better than they thought he would, rattling the cages of the group, who lured The Hunters into a trap and brutally slaughtered them all inside Gabriel's church.

2. Shane Walsh

From hero to villain, Shane's time on the series was both entertaining and crucial in redefining the character of Rick. Essentially driven crazy by his love for Lori and belief that his best friend didn't have what it took to survive, Shane's decision to lure Rick out and end his life still feels as much an attempt to take his place as it does an effort to goad Rick into killing him instead. Jon Bernthal elevated every scene he was present in, finding ways to humanise Shane through simple expressions even as the show itself continued to dehumanise him. Between putting an unwitting Rick in his gun sights during season 1, attempting to drunkenly force himself on Lori at the CDC and sacrificing Otis at the high school, though, Shane's trajectory as an antagonist who would need to be dealt with was clear. In many ways, Shane coloured - and continues to colour - Rick's own character, with their public conflicts and knowledge of the truth behind the former's death also having shaped how the group saw Rick headed into the third season. To that end, Shane was undeniably one of the series' most engaging and important antagonists.

1. The Governor

Love him or hate him, no character has had the impact that The Governor had on the lives of Rick and his fellow survivors. While some fans may believe he overstayed his welcome after escaping season 3 alive, his ultimate war with the group changed the game, destroying the prison and scattering the survivors into the wind. Responsible for the deaths of characters like Axel, Milton, Andrea, Merle and Hershel, along with the slaughter of a number of his own people, The Governor's legacy is one that is still being felt by the survivors. As played by David Morrissey, who managed to effortlessly move the character between charming, ruthless and outright psychotic, the cycloptic antagonist's significance on the series can't be denied. Despite being a divisive character among fans of the series -- truly, this is one character who people either loved seeing on screen or hated wasting time with -- the damage he wrought upon the survivors as a group and as individuals is, so far, larger than anyone viewers have met yet has accomplished. Have we missed your favourite Walking Dead villain off the list? Let us know in the comments below.

Contributor
Contributor

Writer, film enthusiast, part-time gamer and watcher of (mostly) good television located on the fringe of Los Angeles, who now has his own website at www.highdefgeoff.com!